I am giving this book 4-stars despite myself. I had some major issues with one of the main characters, but in the end it was a strong, interesting story with some rather fearless character moments.
Tracey and Garrett are grad students in Atlanta. He is in law school she is getting her MBA. He is from low-to-middle income good-ole-boy Southern white family, she is from a very wealthy and powerful black family. He is outgoing and friendly, everyone knows him. She is closed off and insular.
When they first meet she is wearing ratty overalls and has just taken a moment to lean against a janitor's closet. He thinks she works there and asks about a cleaning situation. Tracey takes umbrage at his "racist" assumption and give it to him with both barrels and leaves.
After that they manage to notice each other around campus quite frequently and Garrett tracks her down at her house and apologizes. This is when they start a friendship that turns into a rather clandestine relationship.
The conflict at the crux of this relationship is race. Or rather more accurately Tracey's conflict with race. Flipping the script a bit, it isn't the white guy who is trying to keep his relationship with a black girl on the down-low from friends and family, it is the other way around.
And this is my biggest frustration with the book. Ironically, it is also the most provocative part of the story as well.
Tracey is a very problematic character from a romance novel heroine standpoint. She is really rather unsympathetic. She is prickly, she is difficult, she is immature, she has a huge chip on her shoulder, and there was one instance when I flat out hated her. But I get the impression that these character flaws are very deliberate on the part of the writer. Unlike some romance novels where the author is writing what s/he believes is a great heroine but instead the heroine is an annoying twerp, I think Tracey is supposed to be all these things. We are supposed to notice her prickliness and her issues. As I said above, from a romance novel standpoint this is somewhat problematic, but from a pure character standpoint it works to create a dynamic picture of who she is.
Garrett goes along with her 'let's not acknowledge each other in public but retreat to my cozy house and indulge in private' at first. It suits him as well. For all that he isn't as conflicted about the race thing as Tracey, he is aware that he has family and friends who would have issues. But the strictures begin to weigh on him as they get more and more serious and he starts to force the issue, trying to 'out' the relationship.
You can't help but root for Garrett, the writing makes him completely sympathetic. Although as a character he doesn't get off scot-free either. There is this awesome conversation he has with his sister that I thought was really rather well done of the author. After Garrett tells his parents about his relationship with Tracey, his mother goes off on a 'welfare nigger' rant. This is of course completely ludicrous as Tracey's family could buy and sell Garrett entire extended family ten times over.
Afterward, Garrett's sister Angie and Garrett talk about the usage of the N-word. The two of them have a frank, uncomfortable and incisive conversation about it. I really liked where the author took the discussion. It felt in character for both of them.
Angie is a great character. I loved her. She felt like the black-sheep, straight shooter younger sister that she was. She and Tracey become friends early on. True to character, Tracey wants nothing to do with Garrett's sister but Angie steamrolls her way into her life. And in the process, she also gets to give Tracey a few come-to-jesus talks as well.
This is another reason why I think Tracey is supposed to be so problematic at first. In addition to Angie there are other characters who tell Tracey she is being a stupid, immature whiner. She gets called on her crap and each time she is you can see how she is being forced to examine her assumptions.
In the end Tracey does mature and change. Sure a lot of it is forced, but she does manage to come to some major self awareness which make for some really good character development for her.
There are a few other things about this book I really liked. I liked how a Grand Mis (one that Tracey allows to happen) in the middle of the book comes back to bite her on the ass in a big way (I cheered). People talk and communicate so stuff isn't allowed to fester. Garrett and Tracey's mother forge an alliance -- which I loved. Garrett's father Big, was a really good character and I liked his first meeting with Tracey -- it was awkward and sweet and felt realistic. Garrett's mother is a super minor, minor presence but her attitude really affects her kids. And i like how not all the problems get tied up in a pretty, neat bow.
But the ending was really good. I came to... not exactly like Tracey, but by the time I closed the book I liked where she had evolved to. And of course I frickin' loved Garrett.
So this book deserves it stars. It made me think and feel, which is what I like most of my books to do.