I've read this before, and in fact I've probably reviewed it before. I read it first as part of an anthology and I loved it. I was shocked to find myself crying at the end of it. I cry pretty easily, but over a romance novella? Never before, and possibly never since. I've read it at least 3 other times since then, and when I got a chance to get it as an audionovella, I took it. I do know that the impact of the story has faded for me a bit with time and re-readings. Or maybe I'm just not in whatever place I was in when I first read the story. Parts of it still really grab me. And some of it mildly annoys me. Mainly, I don't actually like Calin all that much. It's a funny thing because Roberts sticks to his POV through most of the story. We get bits and pieces of Brynna, but mostly we're in Calin's head. But where I connect emotionally to the story is through Brynna. I feel her pain and her longing. I understand her hurt and her pride and her decision to set the pride aside, and her decisions to pull it closely around her again. My tears at the end the first time I read it are because against all odds, without any expectations, Calin gives Brynna his love, which is her greatest desire. And I guess I was a bit surprised back then, just like she was. Now, I tend to listen to what Calin says to her and to how he thinks about her and understand why I might have been surprised back then, and also to wonder, just a bit, what she sees in him that makes him so special to her.
I have a high tolerance for audiobook narrators, apparently. I have some friends who cannot listen to a book at all if ther person sounds different than their mind's voice. I nearly always adjust, and this was no exception. But I did have to adjust. I wasn't crazy about Brynna's voice in the recording. I thought it sounded unnaturally high and light and found myself wishing the narrator had just read it in his own voice, adding the accent sure, but not trying so hard to create a woman's voice. I did like hearing the accents added in. This was probably a 3.5 star read/listen for me. I'm fairly sure I would have given this 5 stars my first time through it.