I am so far behind on writing reviews of books that I have read that I am working backwards from the most recently read titles.
This one I listened to as an audiobook. The narrator did an excellent job with the different voices. It's too bad that she couldn't control the characters' mundane dialogue.
The plot is based on a family gathering for Christmas at their ancestral home in the Blue Ridge Mountains. The family's three adult children all have problems. Bobby wants to study music, but feels pressured by his father to study law. Shane is recently divorced and is unhappy. Morwena is a successful ad executive, but her current lover decided to go to Cancun with an office rival. She also wants to draw more creatively than her career allows.
The preface of the book involves a fight between police officer Gabe and fleeing criminal Luke. Gabe is knocked unconscious and is found by the family, who take him into their cabin amid suspicion that he might be a criminal. He charms the family and then Luke shows up in the stolen uniform. So the family ties them both up and tries to figure out who the bad guy is.
Without going to the spoilers, one annoying aspect of this book is that the weather is used as a deus ex machina to wipe out all electronic communication with the outside world. No phones, TV, cable or Internet access provides a convenient way to delay the discovery of which is the bad guy. I found this to be trite.
The father comes off the worst in this book as he seems to have no redeeming features. He is portrayed as a paranoid grouch.
At one point, Morwena threatens to assault Luke if he keeps on talking. Then he keeps on talking and she doesn't follow through.
Luke repeats his same arguments against Gabe over and over to the point where one has to wonder if he is a broken robot repeating a recording. He always seems to be able to push these characters' buttons and make them suspicious of Gabe.
SPOILER ALERT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
When Luke finally attacks the family on the snowmobile, and Gabe saves them, the family does not feel penitent over how they treated Gabe. They are so wrapped up in their own survival that they do not feel the requisite shame for his treatment. Gabe had been nothing but nice to this family. Time and time again he proved himself. Even after he saves Genevieve when she predictably disobeys orders and puts herself into danger, the family still wonders about him.
The whole possession of Gabe and Luke by an angel and demon, respectively, was obvious to everyone but the characters in the book. There was a bizarre exchange toward the end of the book where Luke says that if he gets away, then he wins. Is his microcosmic struggle with Gabe supposed to affect all of mankind? This just makes God seem pettily arbitrary. It also is very American to assume that the final struggle would take place in the United States.
Another negative for me was that all of the characters were physically fit, good-looking and excellent at their chosen professions. The book went out of its way to recount their gym training and exercise routines. They were such archetypes that it reminded me of "The Happy Hollisters" children. Given their virtues and talents, they came off as spoiled rich kids much of the time.
The repetitive dialogue whenever the family criticized each other, whenever Gabe and Luke were making points, and whenever the family responded to Gabe and Luke was tiresome. I could have edited this book down if every repetitive thought and argument were removed from the book.
The coincidence that Shane's ex-wife would end up stranded in the snow on the edge of a cliff and that Shane "knew" where she was and that it was Cindy was over the top. Of course I am sure that Gabe used his angel powers to rig the TV so that Shane could see her, but even so it was unbelievable.
However, I cannot totally criticize this book as it had some very well-written scenes. These included one scene where Morwena tells a story through drawings and live actors. I honestly did not mind the religious aspects in the sense of the advice Gabe gave to the family. I found the prayer scene in the cemetery to be inspiring.
I was interested enough at times to see what would happen. But then the power would go off at just the right moment, postponing resolution, or the book would fly off into a tangent.