The series about the lives and loves of the little town of St. Dennis continues where the previous novel left off, but this time with the siblings of the main characters of the previous novel. Stephanie is the younger sister of veterinarian Grant Wyler and, unlike her brother, she’s never left the urge to leave the town. Her dreams are informed by her childhood spent visiting a dear uncle who taught her to make ice cream, and her dreams of having a successful ice cream shop where she can sell her custom creations have been fulfilled. Despite her professional success, Steffie feels like an important piece of her life is missing, and this piece happens to roll into town in the form of Wade MacGregor.
Steffie has loved Wade for most of her life, but their timing always seems to be off: First she’s too young for the young mad four years her senior, and then he’s determined to start his microbrewery business in Texas, far from St. Dennis. Steffie laments his loss, but does her best to get on with her dreams…and then Wade shows up to the wedding of the town’s chief of police. Things get hot and heavy quickly but a phone call sends Wade fleeing and Steffie feeling confused and rejected.
Just when Steffie is getting on with her life, her peace is threatened by Wade’s return to town—this time with a toddler he says is his son. Now Steffie is left to wonder at the character of the man she loves: Why would he keep the baby’s mother a secret and lead her on during their previous encounter? Was he unfaithful to another woman with her? But in the small town on St. Dennis secrets are hard to keep, and the truth turns out to have as many challenges as the misunderstandings that came before.
The story is a little cheesy, but once I was hooked I wanted to find out what happened next and couldn't stop watching. The plot even moves with the slowness of a television serial: The reader gets to spend time with the inner thoughts of at least a half a dozen characters, and the shifting POV might have further detracted from the focus on what is supposed to be the primary couple except that the human interest of the story was handled so well. There are some big themes in this novel: Steffie’s commitment to her sister who died from cancer, and her attempts to honor this legacy; the connection of family with a small town, and how generations have an indelible impact on each other; what it means to be a parent, and the sacrifices this requires. I’ll even bashfully admit to having a good cry over a couple of scenes in the book, and I can cheerfully say that this is the best book so far in the series.
Stewart definitely seems to be improving her exploration of this community! Although some readers have complained that Steffie is rash, impulsive, and sometimes unlikeable, I find her to be more of a mouthy independent wench. I know women like this, who stand their ground with their hearts on their sleeves, and sometimes speak before they’ve thought things through. I really enjoyed Stewart’s exploration of how our teenage years stay with us—we don’t just ‘get over’ our youth, and it shapes us in permanent ways that are important. I also appreciated her measured introduction of characters: By the time another supporting character gets their book the reader has already had a chance to learn about them, and the novel can spend more time on plot development.
I will also add that I’m still not a fan of the diary aspect of the novel, as written by Grace Sinclair, an elderly character who has lived in St. Dennis all her life. The entries felt like a rehash of everything I had just read, and screamed "JUST IN CASE YOU WEREN'T PAYING ATENTION DURING THE LAST COUPLE OF CHAPTERS!" But this time these diary entries are much more interesting, and Stewart returns to an element she introduced in the first novel in this series with sometimes comedic results. I’m finally beginning to become interested in septuagenarian Gracie’s backstory, and what she has to offer with regards to the town’s older residents and the impact of their choices on the following generations.
Can I say how much I love food in romance novels? Steffie’s ice cream shop, “One Scoop, Two” has been important in the first two novels in this series, and the flavors she creates and how they reflect the people in the town has been an important part of the charm of this series; in this novel the ice cream shop is almost a character to itself as the place where Steffie wrestles with her questions and insecurities, and this helps give the novel a depth that I enjoyed, and reinforces my opinion that this is the strongest novel in the series. I like Mariah Stewart's writing style, and the characters she has created feel real; I am compelled to return to St. Dennis to find out how everybody else's story goes. It's a good story, set in an interesting community, and would be an entertaining read for a lazy weekend or beach read. I would recommend this series to those readers who like series romance with a strong sense of community.