What is going on? Seriously, this is the second mystery I've read this month that has suffered from an acute identity crisis! Love Lies Bleeding just does not know what it wants to be. Oh, it's a mystery. Oh, it's a psychological thriller, no wait, it's a haunted house story. Now, I don't mind genre-bending when it's done right, but I didn't think it was in Love Lies Bleeding. The certain aspects of the genres she used just didn't...mesh well together. That made it seem like the author wanted to take the book in three different directions, but didn't know which direction to take...so she took all of them.
Another thing that bothered me was Samantha's behavior. I get that she's paranoid, bitter, depressed, and a whole lot of other things due to her attack, but I found her written very inconsistenly. She was okay one minute and then bratty the next. I don't mean justifiably bratty (because some brattiness would be justified after what she went through), but more like teenager bratty. Seriously, she said "Whatever" and rolled her eyes like fifteen times in Love Lies Bleeding. At first, I was like "Man, this chick must be pretty young", because with her behavior I had assumed that she was in her early to mid twenties. Then I found out towards the middle of the novel that she's actually THIRTY-FIVE! I was in shock. No thirty-five year old would act like that. It's not even only her constant overuse of the word "Whatever".
Samantha was constantly bitching about wanting more control, she NEEDS more control over her life, but everytime she gets control, she acts immature and stupid, and that really just proves the point that she can't be trusted with control. Another thing that bothered me was how much she wanted control over her situation when it came to her father. That part right there didn't bother me. What bothered me was that she had no qualms whatsoever in relinquishing control to her controlling fiance. And I just remembered something else...in one part of Love Lies Bleeding, she actually tells another character "You're supposed to be MY friend! I thought you were on MY side!" Seriously? Seriously?! Does that sound like the actions of a thirty-five year old to you?
So, Love Lies Bleeding gets two stars for an intriguing premise that allowed me to read the book in one sitting. But the inconsistency of the main character, the genre-bending, and the somewhat predictable whodunit aspect of the novel left me feeling cold. But I will definitely check out Jess Mcconkey's future work as I do think she can write one hell of a page-turner.