A quick read, this book shines both conceptually in its general argument and in its interweaving of some very different outlooks on the world. Where it fails a bit is in the more individual pieces strung together in service of this: the Having and Workplace chapters which feel more like a rant you'd hear on the subway than a carefully composed and reflectively endorsed chapter in a book on meaning, the lack of references for most claims throughout, the outdated references to "personal computers" that make one cringe a bit when reading in the 21st century. I think it had many nuggets of wisdom, and would gladly reread the Being, Personal Search, and Soul Crafting chapters as I feel there is certainly more to grasp there than I got on the first pass. But the book largely felt like I was mining, sifting through some straightforwardly useless bits, and some other neutral bits, in a more wisdom nugget rich environment than your average book, but still with much dirt.
I was recently at a financial planning conference, and one of the presenters recommended this book. Professors in economy, religion and psychology from Duke started a class called Search for Meaning, and that is what the book is based off of. They examine several states of being: meaninglessness, alienation, having and being. They also give advice on how to search for meaning (soul crafting) and finding meaning in work. I think it is a worthwhile read.
This is definately the most deliberate self-help book I've ever enjoyed reading. Enjoy reading is probably an understatement. I needed guidance and found it in this book. I won't say answers, but certainly clarification of where/how to go about getting them. I like that it's not philisophically heavy-handed. It sort of reads like a philisophical/spiritual workbook, which is great because one can draw guidance through it from oneself. You should read/do it.