Let me start this review by saying a couple of things: I love Lois Lowry. She has long been one of my favorite children's authors, from the time that I was a kid myself falling in love with THE GIVER and the Anastasia books and laughing until I cried at the Sam series. I read NUMBER THE STARS over and over again as a preteen. In college, I went to see Lois Lowry speak and was so impressed buy her as a human, as well as by her work. As far as I'm concerned, Lois Lowry is one of the founding mothers of modern children's literature, and has a depth and breadth to her body of work that few authors can boast.
I also want to start by saying that it has genuinely been years since I have given a book one star and left a scathing review. It's something that I categorically don't do anymore, as an author myself. But when we finish this book last night, I was so angry, that I felt like it was a rare moment to break my rule.
Earlier this month, we read the first Gooney Bird book with Kate at bedtime, and it was so charming and enjoyable to all three of us that I immediately put the second and third book on hold at the library. From the beginning of GOONEY BIRD AND THE ROOM MOTHER, I was a little bit nervous, as the story centers on a second grade Thanksgiving pageant and definitely offers a fairly sanitized version of history. For the most part, though, it didn't get very far into the history of Thanksgiving, and the part that I felt most uncomfortable with was the repeated references to children dressing up like Native Americans with feathered headbands.
Toward the end of the book, though, this story went from uncomfortable territory to downright inappropriate. During the performance of the Thanksgiving pageant, the class tells the story of Squanto/Tisquantum. The story mostly centers on what a "very, very helpful guy" Squanto was, and how much he loves to help British settlers of North America. That was uncomfortable enough, but then the story took a detour into discussing how Squanto had to come to learn English. Not only does the story make only brief references to slavery and the fact that the rest of his tribe was wiped out, it outright states that Squanto went to England with his dear friends, the English settlers, and that he came back because he grew bored of British society. It does briefly reference the fact that he was forcibly taken to Spain and sold as a slave, but the general narrative is that Squanto, because he was such a "very helpful guy," traveled to most of the places he visited and associated with most of the people he associated with purely by choice.
In general, and as much as I loved the first book and plan to read the last, this particular Gooney Bird episode is one I feel like I categorically can't recommend. I can't even imagine how hurtful reading this book would be to an indigenous person.