"The Leslies have come down in the world, and with them come to board the Argyles, a wealthy family from New York. Miss Ray tells of the friendships between Day and Rob Argyll and Ronald and Janet Leslie - friendships clouded by misunderstandings, which in the end only make them the firmer." -The Publishers' Circular
Anna Chapin Ray was an American author. In 1881 she was one of the first three women to take the Yale University entrance exam. She studied at Smith College in Northampton, Massachusetts where she received a B.A. in 1885 and an M.A. in modern European history in 1888.
Beginning in 1889, Anna became a prolific author; her works included many children's books, but she also published adult novels. She wrote during the summer in New Haven, Connecticut, then spent the winter in Quebec. Most of her works were written using the pseudonym Sidney Howard.
Photo courtesy of Smith College Special Collections.
In this second volume of the Sidney series, only a few weeks have passed since the close of the first book, but things have changed dramatically for secondary characters Janet Leslie and her "abnormally tall" older brother, Ronald (fortunately he's also "abnormally good looking"). Their wealthy father has died suddenly, and since fictional fathers rarely have their affairs in good order, there has been a dramatic reversal of fortune for the already grief-stricken family. Ronald must forgo his senior year at McGill, and take a dreary underpaid office job, while their mother takes in boarders who now have the best rooms in the old family home in the city of Quebec.
The boarders are an American family, Mr. and Mrs. Argyle and their sprightly daughter Day, who strikes up a friendship with Ronald, and teases out from him the reasons for his low spirits, while 14 year-old Janet holds herself aloof. Then Day's older brother Rob, who's recovering from a terrible football injury, shows up and strikes up an alliance with Janet. This state of affairs continues as Winter sets in, until Janet takes umbrage at a comment Day makes about the quality of the stores in Quebec, then gets insulted when Day apologizes that she didn't know the Leslie family was in trade. Janet runs off to the library to find Rob, meets teasing instead of consolation, and in a rage tells him she can't stand Americans. Anna Chapin Ray has a regrettable tendency to explain at great length the precise ways characters misunderstand each other, misinterpret each other's tone, and take things the wrong way etc. etc. with such painstaking elaborateness that the result is singularly unconvincing. Howsomever, we now have a feud between the young people of the two families, which takes up the bulk of the book. One happy side effect of the estrangement is that Day, who barely knew her brother before his arrival, becomes close to Rob. In fact both pairs adore their siblings with a fervor that makes me suspect Ray herself didn't actually have a brother.
While all this keenly observed moodiness is going on, the young people, with or without each other, explore the wintry city and its historical sites, and continually bump into a doltish young member of the British aristocracy named Sir George Porteous, who is attempting in a vague and ineffectual way to get a taste of life in the colonies before taking up the mantle of his estate. If this seems random and out of nowhere, that's because it is, but Sir George has a role to play in this story...
At some point Rob goes down to New York to see his doctors, which gives him the chance to meet Sidney, who lives there, because it's important for every character in this series to meet Sidney so they can like her best.
In conclusion, Anna Chapin Ray is a pretty bad novelist. However, I liked this book better than the first. The depiction of Quebec in Winter was atmospheric and not uninteresting, and Sir George is really bemusing in his oddness, which I think was intentional, so good job there, Anna Chapin Ray. I'll need a 3-4 book palate cleanse before taking on Book 3, but I look forward to Day: Her Year in New York with interest/trepidation. My prediction is that she'll decide she likes Sidney better than Janet.