"The scenes of this story are laid in New York and at "Heatherleigh," the Argyle's summer home. The story is breezy, wholesome and sweet and gives one the pleasant sensation of feeling that with one girl, at least, riches and material wealth made little count against the friendship of true, loyal souls.
Some of the characters familiar to readers of the Sidney books re-appear: Sidney Stayre, Wade Winthrop and Jack Blanchard, and one feels a real thrill of welcome at mention of their names. Miss Ray's characters are genuine boys and girls, full of fun and humour, delicate feeling and courtesy, and not mere puppets made to voice the sentiment of the writer." -American Motherhood
Anna Chapin Ray was an American author. In 1881 she was one of the first three women to take the Yale University entrance exam. She studied at Smith College in Northampton, Massachusetts where she received a B.A. in 1885 and an M.A. in modern European history in 1888.
Beginning in 1889, Anna became a prolific author; her works included many children's books, but she also published adult novels. She wrote during the summer in New Haven, Connecticut, then spent the winter in Quebec. Most of her works were written using the pseudonym Sidney Howard.
Photo courtesy of Smith College Special Collections.
Third in the author's Sidney series, published in 1907. My review is spoilerific.
When this book opens, we find Day in the downtown office of her railway magnate father, complaining that she doesn't want her birthday celebrated as usual, with a party to which other rich girls just like her are invited. They will give her expensive presents, and then return the favor by inviting her to their parties, which Day sees as a problem. "I'm tired of doing all the same old things with the same old people," she says. "I'd like to give a rousing good time to someone who didn't expect it and who couldn't pay me back the very next day." However she's quick to clarify that she doesn't want to provide a spread for indigent newsboys or the like, but rather would like to invite someone to spend a weekend at the family's country estate: "somebody who would really enjoy Heatherleigh." Her brother Rob, who has walked in on the conversation, is quick to suggest his friend Sidney, whom Day has yet to meet. Sidney, as readers of the series already know, is not exactly poor, living in a comfortable, if shabby house, with her parents, six siblings, Wade, her 30 year-old cousin (who has joined the household just for the sake of being able to enjoy Sidney's company) and one maid of all work. Sidney also goes to a good school which will give her the foundation to go on to attend college. Day reluctantly agrees, and goes with Rob to call on Sidney. They are greeted at the door by "a tall lank girl of past fourteen, homely, awkward. Her thin brown hair was drawn tightly back from her freckled, spectacled face; her frock of dark blue muslin was half concealed beneath a great green-check apron, uncompromising of cut, but spotlessly neat." I wondered briefly if this was Sidney seen through Day's eyes, but the apparition is quickly revealed to be her next youngest sister, Phyllis, whom we've never heard of before. From the description above, one might think that that Phyllis is meant to be a good sort whose one fault is that she doesn't care about her appearance, but the author wastes no time in letting us know that Phyllis is Sidney's exact opposite: shrewish, mean-spirited, bad tempered, and -- Ray seems to imply this might be the worst of her sins -- unattractive. She also hates to sew, sets the table in a shockingly slap-dashed manner, and despite her apparent disregard for appearances, is a terrible snob. She heaps scorn on Jack Blanchard, who is a young man working for Day's father who'd previously been a porter on the Quebec sleeper (in my review of the previous book, Janet: Her Winter in Quebec, I neglected to mention how Rob and Jack are stuck on a train for over a day when it's halted by a snowstorm, after which, Rob, who's recognized Jack's worth, insists on his father taking Jack on in the office). Jack is good-looking, and his fine character is actually apparent to everyone (except Phyllis) on sight; as he walks down the street, we're told "elderly men stared at him with honest liking."
Naturally, the house party at Heatherleigh goes well, because everybody loves Sidney (no wonder Phyllis is so shrewish), and Day and Sidney quickly become fast friends, despite the difference in their social standings. Then Rob, Day, and Jack all get mumps and are quarantined together at Rob and Day's home, becoming more tightly knit then ever. It's decided that Jack might as well stay on as a permanent guest, as it's great for Day's dad to have his secretary always on call, plus they all like Jack so much. This gives Phyllis the chance to make caustic remarks about how Jack, as a former brakeman (she intentionally lowers his social status by calling him this instead of a former porter) shouldn't be able to use the front stairs, and that she's sure he "eats at second table," so everyone hates her more than ever. Matters aren't improved when the chums catch Phyllis ripping the lining out of Jack's coat when he comes to call.
I kind of hated the book for how spiteful Anna Chapin Ray is towards Phyllis, but it won't surprise anyone who's familiar with vintage series fiction that she does reform, at least somewhat. This is brought about because Wade, observing her with compassion, takes her under his wing. We're told that "later, he had his reward." I guess that means he's going to eventually marry Phyllis, which seems unfair, because, like everyone else, Wade likes Sidney best, and buys the more favored cousin an expensive dress so she can go to parties with Day's friends. But the real catalyst to Phyllis' reform is being saved by Jack from a suddenly blazing chaffing dish. Phyllis gets away with minor burns, Jack has severe ones. As Jack convalesces, his face swathed in bandages, Day realizes that what will fully cure him would be a reunion with his frail mother who lives in Quebec, and she goes off to fetch same, and at the end, rejoices that Jack's face is not too terribly scarred after all. As my readers might have surmised, one of the ways I entertain my bored brain while reading these books is wondering how Ray will pair everyone up at the end of the series. The odds are looking pretty good now for Day and Jack, but at the end of the last book, I would've put my money on Ronald, brother of Janet (who, like Janet doesn't appear in this book at all). However, as I noted in an earlier review, the brother-sister relationship appears to be in Ray's mind the closest one possible. Day snuggles under Rob's arm rather a lot.
So the plot is tiresome, but what really irritated me in this book is a particular tic in Ray's writing style. When she writes dialogue, her characters are always "Making [insert some sort of adjective] reply." Just flipping through this book, I found:
"And Sidney once more made tranquil answer-" "Wade made philosophic answer" "Then she made grim response" "she made prompt answer" "Jack made thoughtful reply" "Rob made generous offer" "Jack sent her a quick glance of understanding while Day made thoughtful answer-" "Rob made pitiful comment"
While paging through the book for these examples, I also came across this bit of dialogue in which Day is scolding her rich friends for snubbing Jack.
"How have we snubbed him?" [they ask] Day mounted her stilts. "How haven't you, you'd better ask"
I've never heard that particular expression before. The mental image it inspires amuses me.
The only reason why I didn't give this book one star is because Ray at least admits that part of what makes Phyllis so awful is that Sidney doesn't bother being nice to her. That Sidney isn't perfect is the greatest plot twist of all!
Well I'm halfway through the series now, and in the next one, Sidney will be at college. Janet, I'm pretty sure will be there too. Will Day? And (this is a bigger question) will Phyllis? There's no suggestion that Phyllis goes to the same college prep school Sidney attends, or that she goes to school at all. Hmm, now why on earth would Phyllis be jealous of her sister? Just her natural peevishness, I guess.