What do you think?
Rate this book
Apple Ridge #4
The Scent of Cherry Blossoms: A Romance from the Heart of Amish Country
A star-crossed romance blossoms between an Old Order mennonite woman and an Old Order Amish man in this novel by New York Times bestselling author Cindy Woodsmall. Retreating from a contentious relationship with her mother, Annie Martin goes to live with her Daadi Moses in Apple Ridge. Annie loves the Plain ways of her Old Order Mennonite people, like those revered by her beloved grandfather. But as spring moves into Pennsylvania and Annie spends time amongst the cherry trees with the handsome Aden Zook, a follower of the Old Order Amish faith, she wishes she could forget how deeply the lines between the Old Order Amish and Old Order Mennonite are drawn. Facing estrangement from their families and friends because of their burgeoning romantic relationship regardless of their different backgrouds, can Annie and Aden find a place for their love to bloom in the midst of the brewing storm?
210 pages, Kindle Edition
First published February 21, 2012
81 people are currently reading
1084 people want to read
About the author
Cindy Woodsmall
68 books1,118 followersCINDY WOODSMALL is an award-winning, New York Times, and CBA best-selling author of twenty-five works of fiction and one nonfiction book. Coverage of Cindy’s Amish connections and her novels has been featured on ABC Nightline and the front page of the Wall Street Journal. She lives in the foothills of the North Georgia Mountains.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 187 reviews
September 11, 2024
I battled a raging snowstorm to get to the Christian bookstore before work on Saturday and was greeted by this beautiful cover the second I walked into the store. What a breath of spring! I had to buy it -- especially since it's written by Cindy Woodsmall. Need I say more? And bonus! It's a sequel to her Christmas novella, The Christmas Singing and we even get to catch up with Mattie and Gideon! Hoping that Woodsmall continues with the series because she has two seasons left to cover!
Even though this is a novella, Woodsmall has managed to pack it full of angst, romance and beautiful prose. She is such a gifted wordsmith! This is a Romeo/Juliet kind of love story with an Amish/Mennonite twist and I absolutely loved it. All the way through I kept fretting over how she could possibly turn this into a happily ever after. And I loved the fascinating details that explain the differences between the Amish and Old Order Mennonite faiths.
A sweet, satisfying read in that breathes the hope of spring into any season.
https://kavsbestreads.ca/2024/09/11/t...
Even though this is a novella, Woodsmall has managed to pack it full of angst, romance and beautiful prose. She is such a gifted wordsmith! This is a Romeo/Juliet kind of love story with an Amish/Mennonite twist and I absolutely loved it. All the way through I kept fretting over how she could possibly turn this into a happily ever after. And I loved the fascinating details that explain the differences between the Amish and Old Order Mennonite faiths.
A sweet, satisfying read in that breathes the hope of spring into any season.
https://kavsbestreads.ca/2024/09/11/t...
January 29, 2015
Good story of family, friendship, faith and love. Annie is the oldest of the kids in her family. She has a rocky relationship with her mother, thanks to their different outlooks on behavior. After one argument too many, Annie's mother sends her to stay with her grandfather in Pennsylvania. Annie loves her grandfather Moses and they have always gotten along well. While staying with Moses, Annie goes to help the Amish Zook family in their diner.
Aden is the cook at the diner while his handicapped brother works as server and his parents help out when they can. Aden is a handsome young man, and a very shy one. He stutters which makes it difficult for him to talk to other people, especially girls. His twin brother Roman is more outgoing, but is confined to a wheelchair, thanks to an accident several years earlier. Aden and Roman help each other, with Aden providing the muscle needed to help care for Roman, and Roman doing the talking for both of them.
With Annie spending more time at the diner, she and Aden get to know each other much better. Annie sees past the stutter to the sensitive and artistic young man that he is. Aden admires Annie's cheerfulness and the way she can talk to anyone she meets. Their friendship begins to deepen into something much stronger, but they can't see any future in it. Their individual faiths of Amish and Mennonite forbid a relationship between them and both are deeply committed to their beliefs. Even their families have pointed out the impossibility and continuing to spend time together threatens more than just their faith.
I felt really bad for Aden and Annie. In spite of the similarities between their religions, the differences are enough to keep them apart. It doesn't help that Annie's grandfather is especially against it, and as a partner in the Zook's diner can ruin the business if he pulls out. Aden's family also makes it clear that they don't approve. But neither Aden nor Annie want to give up what they have found together. I liked seeing them try to explain their feelings to various family members in an attempt to gain their support. I didn't know how they were going to make things work, but they did.
Aden's brother Roman is also a strong presence in the book. His accident and subsequent disability have made him rather bitter and also somewhat self-centered. He's not happy about Aden's interest in Annie, and it's not just because of the religious differences. He sees Aden as pulling away from him to spend time with Annie and doesn't want to lose his caretaker. He does a couple things that are pretty mean to try to split Aden and Annie apart. While he was away for a few days helping another family member he became reacquainted with a girl he would have pursued before his accident. She tends to call him on his attitude which is something he needs but doesn't necessarily appreciate. She does start to have an effect on him, and I hope to see more of them in a later book.
Aden is the cook at the diner while his handicapped brother works as server and his parents help out when they can. Aden is a handsome young man, and a very shy one. He stutters which makes it difficult for him to talk to other people, especially girls. His twin brother Roman is more outgoing, but is confined to a wheelchair, thanks to an accident several years earlier. Aden and Roman help each other, with Aden providing the muscle needed to help care for Roman, and Roman doing the talking for both of them.
With Annie spending more time at the diner, she and Aden get to know each other much better. Annie sees past the stutter to the sensitive and artistic young man that he is. Aden admires Annie's cheerfulness and the way she can talk to anyone she meets. Their friendship begins to deepen into something much stronger, but they can't see any future in it. Their individual faiths of Amish and Mennonite forbid a relationship between them and both are deeply committed to their beliefs. Even their families have pointed out the impossibility and continuing to spend time together threatens more than just their faith.
I felt really bad for Aden and Annie. In spite of the similarities between their religions, the differences are enough to keep them apart. It doesn't help that Annie's grandfather is especially against it, and as a partner in the Zook's diner can ruin the business if he pulls out. Aden's family also makes it clear that they don't approve. But neither Aden nor Annie want to give up what they have found together. I liked seeing them try to explain their feelings to various family members in an attempt to gain their support. I didn't know how they were going to make things work, but they did.
Aden's brother Roman is also a strong presence in the book. His accident and subsequent disability have made him rather bitter and also somewhat self-centered. He's not happy about Aden's interest in Annie, and it's not just because of the religious differences. He sees Aden as pulling away from him to spend time with Annie and doesn't want to lose his caretaker. He does a couple things that are pretty mean to try to split Aden and Annie apart. While he was away for a few days helping another family member he became reacquainted with a girl he would have pursued before his accident. She tends to call him on his attitude which is something he needs but doesn't necessarily appreciate. She does start to have an effect on him, and I hope to see more of them in a later book.
February 10, 2012
MY REVIEW
Both Aden and Annie are very strong characters - strong i n their convictions, strong in their beliefs, loyal to their families and church. Both come from heartaches and trials. Aden from a family where both the father and two sons are physically handicapped, and Annie from a dysfunctional family. Cindy does a great job of bringing these into the story without condemnation, but with true heartfelt emotions and you ache with the characters as they struggle and rejoice with them as they overcome.
The scent of cherry blossoms has a very important position in the novella, and is a perfect title to draw the reader in. The whole novel is full of sensory details - obviously the smell, but also the vivid scenes in this Amish/Mennonite community.
i was wondering how Cindy would resolve this dilemma of bringing the two faiths together. I belong to what might be called a conservative Mennonite sect, and know how extremely hard it is for the older members to accept true friendship with those not of our faith, and yet, how little really separates us. For us, intermarriage is also not sanctioned by the church, and I love how Cindy delicately handles this fact.
This is a great novella, and am eager to recommend it to my friends. Cindy consistently brings us super reading material.
This book was sent to me free of monetary charge from Waterbrook Multnomah Publishers through their Blogging For Books program in exchange for an honest review, which i have done. The opinions stated in this article are my own.
September 8, 2012
This is my second Cindy Woodsmall novella and I absolutely loved it. The Scent of Cherry Blossoms has a similar setting to The Christmas Singing; some of the characters from the latter novella make appearances in the former and vice-versa.
I requested this book for review because the Mennonite "vs." Amish topic caught my attention. I was curious and wanted to find out whether the couple in love would remain in the Mennonite or Amish community. As I read, I fell in love with the story and characters.
Something that really stands out right from the beginning is the way Cindy does not sugarcoat disagreements the Mennonites and Amish have among themselves. Frequently, bonnet fiction depict Plain people as leading very peaceful lifestyles and having very submissive children. Thus, you could imagine my surprise when I read about the young characters having disagreements with their elders. It was shocking, really.
It was also eye-opening how the Mennonite and Amish cultures differ. Prior to reading The Scent of Cherry Blossoms, I did not know that there is such a group as the Old Order Mennonite. I had always assumed that Mennonites are way more modern than the Amish, judging by the Mennonites in one of the Plain forums in cyberspace.
The main characters are endearing. Whether it is Aden who stutters, kind-hearted Annie, or frustrated Roman, you can easily empathize with their struggles and feel disappointed when they make mistakes. My favorite character is Aden. He is this young guy who is struggling between the decision of being with the girl he loves and keeping the Amish rules he has been taught from young. His family opposes the idea of him being in a relationship with a girl not belonging to the Amish community. To summarize it all, he is between a rock and a hard place.
All in all, The Scent of Cherry Blossoms quickly became another favorite book for me. The complications in the story along with what we can learn about the Mennonites and Amish makes this book an enjoyable and hard-to-put-down read.
Disclosure of Material Connection: I received this book free from the publisher through their Blogging for Books program. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255: “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”
I requested this book for review because the Mennonite "vs." Amish topic caught my attention. I was curious and wanted to find out whether the couple in love would remain in the Mennonite or Amish community. As I read, I fell in love with the story and characters.
Something that really stands out right from the beginning is the way Cindy does not sugarcoat disagreements the Mennonites and Amish have among themselves. Frequently, bonnet fiction depict Plain people as leading very peaceful lifestyles and having very submissive children. Thus, you could imagine my surprise when I read about the young characters having disagreements with their elders. It was shocking, really.
It was also eye-opening how the Mennonite and Amish cultures differ. Prior to reading The Scent of Cherry Blossoms, I did not know that there is such a group as the Old Order Mennonite. I had always assumed that Mennonites are way more modern than the Amish, judging by the Mennonites in one of the Plain forums in cyberspace.
The main characters are endearing. Whether it is Aden who stutters, kind-hearted Annie, or frustrated Roman, you can easily empathize with their struggles and feel disappointed when they make mistakes. My favorite character is Aden. He is this young guy who is struggling between the decision of being with the girl he loves and keeping the Amish rules he has been taught from young. His family opposes the idea of him being in a relationship with a girl not belonging to the Amish community. To summarize it all, he is between a rock and a hard place.
All in all, The Scent of Cherry Blossoms quickly became another favorite book for me. The complications in the story along with what we can learn about the Mennonites and Amish makes this book an enjoyable and hard-to-put-down read.
Disclosure of Material Connection: I received this book free from the publisher through their Blogging for Books program. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255: “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”
August 23, 2014
I normally don't read romances. Especially not Amish romances. But I won a book in a giveaway (I didn't get to choose which book) and being the conscientious type, I felt obliged to read it and review it. I do not dislike romances because they're romances, but because in my experience, they are almost always poorly written. “Maybe I'm being prejudiced,” I thought. “Maybe it will turn out to be really good and convert me to reading romances.” I wasn't, and it didn't. It almost lost me on page 2 when they misspelled “navel”. Then they spelled it right. Then they spelled it wrong again. Then right again. Amish romances are cash cows for Christian publishers, you think they could afford to copy-edit them properly. It struck me as being rather contemptuous of the readers. They know they can get away with being shoddy, so they do. Fortunately things cleared up after that, for the most part.
It is a charming little story, but the prose was pedestrian. I was constantly told how people were feeling, instead of made to feel it myself. “Show, don't tell” is the first thing they tell new writers, but the lesson wasn't learned in this case. That's a shame. In a genre that is all about the emotion, you'd think they wouldn't use techniques that create emotional distance. I felt all too often that I was reading an essay about the characters instead of a story.
The main characters are way too perfect. Annie is so incredibly sweet, she has trouble getting along with her family. Or rather, they have trouble getting along with her. Think Cinderella, but it's her real family that picks on her. Aden is more deeply flawed – he stutters. Other than that they are beautiful, hard-working, full of integrity, truly wonderful. This is fairy tale country.
There was a lot of potential in the spiritual issues, but the author pulls her punches. They are explained a few times (Why does God let bad things happen to good people?) and then rather easily resolved with wise words from a mother or a friend. Okay, I'm exaggerating a bit, but not much. And it's much the same with the interpersonal conflict. We are told that their situation is heart-rending, impossible. And yet, like a gate with rusty hinges, all it takes is a little oil and a couple of good pushes, and the problem is resolved.
The set-up of the story was actually pretty good, and it could have been deeply moving, but it was determined to keep me at arm's length, and to keep things superficial.
It is a charming little story, but the prose was pedestrian. I was constantly told how people were feeling, instead of made to feel it myself. “Show, don't tell” is the first thing they tell new writers, but the lesson wasn't learned in this case. That's a shame. In a genre that is all about the emotion, you'd think they wouldn't use techniques that create emotional distance. I felt all too often that I was reading an essay about the characters instead of a story.
The main characters are way too perfect. Annie is so incredibly sweet, she has trouble getting along with her family. Or rather, they have trouble getting along with her. Think Cinderella, but it's her real family that picks on her. Aden is more deeply flawed – he stutters. Other than that they are beautiful, hard-working, full of integrity, truly wonderful. This is fairy tale country.
There was a lot of potential in the spiritual issues, but the author pulls her punches. They are explained a few times (Why does God let bad things happen to good people?) and then rather easily resolved with wise words from a mother or a friend. Okay, I'm exaggerating a bit, but not much. And it's much the same with the interpersonal conflict. We are told that their situation is heart-rending, impossible. And yet, like a gate with rusty hinges, all it takes is a little oil and a couple of good pushes, and the problem is resolved.
The set-up of the story was actually pretty good, and it could have been deeply moving, but it was determined to keep me at arm's length, and to keep things superficial.
March 7, 2014
After a falling out with her mother Annie Martin is sent for an extended stay with her beloved Daadi Moses in Apple Ridge. Her return to this special place brings her back into contact with Aden Zook, an Amish neighbor who runs the diner of which her grandfather is part owner. However it seems that things have changed between them and she begins to look at Aden in a whole new light, but as she is a Mennonite the two can never be together.
Aden Zook has had to grow up quickly after the accident that crippled his twin brother and left his father with chronic pain. He has not only had to run the family diner, along with his brother, but he has had to become his brother's legs. A stutter that has plagued him since childhood has always made him shy, preventing him from ever developing a relationship with a woman. That and memories of the only girl to ever catch his attention, Annie Martin.
Annie and Aden have a forbidden love to rival that of Romeo and Juliet (without the tragedy I promise), held apart not by a family feud but by their vows to God. When their secret relationship is discovered what will their choice be?
There is also a side story involving Aden's brother Roman and his accepting his injuries, along with a special young girl who seems to see past his useless legs.
I thought this was a really sweet and happy romance, I actually particularly liked Roman's part of the story. The characters were interesting and believable and the setting was beautiful.
****SPOILER ALERT****
There was one thing that bothered me, the idea that one of the characters was willing to break their vow. However this character did very carefully analyze their relationship with God and made certain they were putting it first in their life. It also did seem that this vow was to the church and not to God.
Well to close I will say that, particularly if you love Amish romances, this is a sweet and relaxing read.
I received this book from Waterbrook Multnomah's blogging for books program in exchange for my review. http://classycassies.blogspot.com/201...
Aden Zook has had to grow up quickly after the accident that crippled his twin brother and left his father with chronic pain. He has not only had to run the family diner, along with his brother, but he has had to become his brother's legs. A stutter that has plagued him since childhood has always made him shy, preventing him from ever developing a relationship with a woman. That and memories of the only girl to ever catch his attention, Annie Martin.
Annie and Aden have a forbidden love to rival that of Romeo and Juliet (without the tragedy I promise), held apart not by a family feud but by their vows to God. When their secret relationship is discovered what will their choice be?
There is also a side story involving Aden's brother Roman and his accepting his injuries, along with a special young girl who seems to see past his useless legs.
I thought this was a really sweet and happy romance, I actually particularly liked Roman's part of the story. The characters were interesting and believable and the setting was beautiful.
****SPOILER ALERT****
There was one thing that bothered me, the idea that one of the characters was willing to break their vow. However this character did very carefully analyze their relationship with God and made certain they were putting it first in their life. It also did seem that this vow was to the church and not to God.
Well to close I will say that, particularly if you love Amish romances, this is a sweet and relaxing read.
I received this book from Waterbrook Multnomah's blogging for books program in exchange for my review. http://classycassies.blogspot.com/201...
February 17, 2012
Cindy Woodsmall is by far my favorite Amish fiction writer hands down. She has this ability to create descriptive details and deep meaningful characters that just draw you in to the story. Even though The Scent of Cherry Blossoms is just a small novella there is nothing small about the story line or characters.
We have two strong devoted young people. Annie, who belongs to the Older Order Mennonite people and lives with her mother and siblings in a dysfunctional family setting. Then there is Aden who lives next door to Annie's Daadi Moses and is an Old Order Amish man but struggles with a stuttering problem and a paralyzed brother. Cindy does a superb job of bringing together these two different stories in one unique way. There are so many heartfelt moments and tender scenes throughout the story.
Both Aden and Annie begin an interest in each other even though it is highly against their religions to court those in different faiths. They are drawn together but are struggling to do what is right. You will be guessing as to how and if these two will be able to be together by the end of the book.
There are two things that stick out to me that were wonderful about this story. One is the way the other weaves the scent of cherry blossoms in to the story. I could just picture the orchards and blooms as described throughout the story that just added a lovely touch to this sweet story. The other thing that amazed me about this story is how deep and entertaining it was despite its short length. I never thought I'd get as invested in the story as I did!
If you haven't had a chance to read any of Cindy Woodsmall's Amish Fiction, you need to get right on that. She is superb in creating dynamic characters and interesting stories!! The Scent of Cherry Blossoms is a great way to begin your journey of discovering Cindy Woodsmall.
This book was sent to me free from Waterbrook Multnomah Publishers in exchange for an honest and personal review. All opinions are my own.
We have two strong devoted young people. Annie, who belongs to the Older Order Mennonite people and lives with her mother and siblings in a dysfunctional family setting. Then there is Aden who lives next door to Annie's Daadi Moses and is an Old Order Amish man but struggles with a stuttering problem and a paralyzed brother. Cindy does a superb job of bringing together these two different stories in one unique way. There are so many heartfelt moments and tender scenes throughout the story.
Both Aden and Annie begin an interest in each other even though it is highly against their religions to court those in different faiths. They are drawn together but are struggling to do what is right. You will be guessing as to how and if these two will be able to be together by the end of the book.
There are two things that stick out to me that were wonderful about this story. One is the way the other weaves the scent of cherry blossoms in to the story. I could just picture the orchards and blooms as described throughout the story that just added a lovely touch to this sweet story. The other thing that amazed me about this story is how deep and entertaining it was despite its short length. I never thought I'd get as invested in the story as I did!
If you haven't had a chance to read any of Cindy Woodsmall's Amish Fiction, you need to get right on that. She is superb in creating dynamic characters and interesting stories!! The Scent of Cherry Blossoms is a great way to begin your journey of discovering Cindy Woodsmall.
This book was sent to me free from Waterbrook Multnomah Publishers in exchange for an honest and personal review. All opinions are my own.
August 3, 2016
Cindy Woodsmall's books are always beautifully characterized, with humanity as much a part of each man and woman as is their spirituality. The emotions and passions so deeply felt in "The Scent of Cherry Blossoms" are as exquisite and memorable as the blossoms themselves. Annie Martin's difficult relationship with her mother leads her to live with her beloved grandfather, Daadi Moses, in Apple Ridge, PA. She loves the ways of her Old Order Mennonite people, and her heart is conflicted when she renews a friendship with Aden Zook, who is Old Order Amish. There are deeply drawn lines between the two orders, but the inappropriateness of the friendship cannot stop her growing feelings for Aden. He has become a fine young man, talented and artistic, but he is dominated by his wheelchair-bound twin brother, Roman. Aden has long thought of Annie as more than a friend, and he struggles with his love for her and his loving commitment to his family and his faith. Annie dares to dream of a life with Aden without the boundaries set by the two orders. While the Amish and the Mennonite at times seem to be in close agreement, they both are strict in their beliefs that the two orders should not mix and mingle, especially in the matter of marriage. Annie and Aden are both aware of the dictates of their separate communities. Their feelings run strong, but the consequences of pursuing their relationship could have lasting harmful effects for all. Can a love as pure and sweet as the scent of cherry blossoms create a new life path for faithful hearts to follow? Once again, Cindy Woodsmall will touch your emotions, stir your thoughts, and leave you feeling very blessed to read the words of a very special storyteller. A recommended read.
Review Copy Gratis WaterBrook Press
Review Copy Gratis WaterBrook Press
May 21, 2012
In her newest novella, The Scent of Cherry Blossoms, Cindy Woodsmall treats the reader to a glimpse into differences between two communities – the Old Order Amish and the Old Order Mennonites. But these two communities only seem identical to the outsiders. Cindy Woodsmall dares to plumb the depths of the differences between these theological “cousins” that date back to the 17th century.
Annie Martin is an Old Order Mennonite girl who loves her heritage and her grandfather. To escape a difficult situation at home, Annie goes to live with him in Apple Ridge, Pennsylvania just as spring begins to show its face. While there, she becomes reacquainted with a childhood friend, Aden Zook. But Aden is Old Order Amish, and as their friendship grows into love, their families forbid the relationship, revealing just how deeply the boundaries between the two sects run.
Even though novellas are traditionally shorter and less complex than a novel, Cindy Woodsmall has also given the reader fully developed secondary characters, including a look at Aden’s twin brother, Roman, as he tries to regain his identity after being confined to a wheel chair due to a farming accident. Roman’s journey and his steps toward love with an outgoing, vivacious Amish girl are a delightful background to Annie and Aden’s story.
I have enjoyed all of Cindy Woodsmall’s books that I’ve read, and this one is no exception. In the growing sub-genre of Amish fiction, Cindy gives the reader a sweet, authentic story every time.
I received a free copy of this book from the publisher for my unbiased review.
Annie Martin is an Old Order Mennonite girl who loves her heritage and her grandfather. To escape a difficult situation at home, Annie goes to live with him in Apple Ridge, Pennsylvania just as spring begins to show its face. While there, she becomes reacquainted with a childhood friend, Aden Zook. But Aden is Old Order Amish, and as their friendship grows into love, their families forbid the relationship, revealing just how deeply the boundaries between the two sects run.
Even though novellas are traditionally shorter and less complex than a novel, Cindy Woodsmall has also given the reader fully developed secondary characters, including a look at Aden’s twin brother, Roman, as he tries to regain his identity after being confined to a wheel chair due to a farming accident. Roman’s journey and his steps toward love with an outgoing, vivacious Amish girl are a delightful background to Annie and Aden’s story.
I have enjoyed all of Cindy Woodsmall’s books that I’ve read, and this one is no exception. In the growing sub-genre of Amish fiction, Cindy gives the reader a sweet, authentic story every time.
I received a free copy of this book from the publisher for my unbiased review.
February 24, 2012
I'm pretty sure I can summarize this book in these two words: utterly fantastic! This is now among my favorites, and definitely one of the most enjoyable books I've read...ever. Both Annie and Aden are fantastic, unique characters with a whole lot of personality.
Aden and Annie are two young adults belonging to two different yet very similar religious communities, communities which forbid marriage outside of their own community. Despite this rule, the two take a liking to each other, falling a little more for the other each time their paths cross. Finally, after being driven to her grandfather's farm due to problems at home, Annie realizes her feelings for Aden have deepened a great deal. The two teeter on the fence line of going their separate ways in favor of their community and family peace, or committing to a relationship that could quite possibly hurt everyone they love and rip their communities apart.
I'm really at a loss for how to convey the awesomeness of this book, so I'm just going to stop here. Basically, this is a great read for anyone who loves romance - from the mushy kind to realistic to practical romance. Get it. Read it. I received this book for free from the publisher. I was not require to write a review, nor a positive one. I was not compensated for this review.
Aden and Annie are two young adults belonging to two different yet very similar religious communities, communities which forbid marriage outside of their own community. Despite this rule, the two take a liking to each other, falling a little more for the other each time their paths cross. Finally, after being driven to her grandfather's farm due to problems at home, Annie realizes her feelings for Aden have deepened a great deal. The two teeter on the fence line of going their separate ways in favor of their community and family peace, or committing to a relationship that could quite possibly hurt everyone they love and rip their communities apart.
I'm really at a loss for how to convey the awesomeness of this book, so I'm just going to stop here. Basically, this is a great read for anyone who loves romance - from the mushy kind to realistic to practical romance. Get it. Read it. I received this book for free from the publisher. I was not require to write a review, nor a positive one. I was not compensated for this review.
March 31, 2012
I loved this book! Well, I love anything by Cindy Woodsmall but this book was really a good one.
Two brothers, twins, one haunted by tragedy and the other by a disability. Aden and Roman Zook are as close as twins are supposed to be and ever since the accident that rendered Roman wheelchair bound, Aden has looked after his brother and Roman has become dependent on Aden to be there for him. So what happens when matters of the heart interfere?
Annie Martin has had a crush on Aden Zook ever since she was 15 and now that she has come to stay with her grandfather and help out in the Zook's diner, she realizes they both have grown and matured and look at each other in a different way. Yes, Aden still stutters but if he puts things in a singsong way the words just flow and Annie loves listening to him talk. One big problem. Aden is Old Order Amish and Annie is Old Order Mennonite. Can these two overcome the hurdles to become more than friends?
Marian is the only person who looks beyond Roman's disability to see the person inside and she makes him feel wonderful when they talk. But will his self pity destroy what they might be beginning? We will have to wait and see.
I highly recommend this book. It will leave you wanting more. Guaranteed.
Two brothers, twins, one haunted by tragedy and the other by a disability. Aden and Roman Zook are as close as twins are supposed to be and ever since the accident that rendered Roman wheelchair bound, Aden has looked after his brother and Roman has become dependent on Aden to be there for him. So what happens when matters of the heart interfere?
Annie Martin has had a crush on Aden Zook ever since she was 15 and now that she has come to stay with her grandfather and help out in the Zook's diner, she realizes they both have grown and matured and look at each other in a different way. Yes, Aden still stutters but if he puts things in a singsong way the words just flow and Annie loves listening to him talk. One big problem. Aden is Old Order Amish and Annie is Old Order Mennonite. Can these two overcome the hurdles to become more than friends?
Marian is the only person who looks beyond Roman's disability to see the person inside and she makes him feel wonderful when they talk. But will his self pity destroy what they might be beginning? We will have to wait and see.
I highly recommend this book. It will leave you wanting more. Guaranteed.
August 24, 2014
I like this book because, unlike a lot of Amish fiction, it gave more insight into the differences between Old-Order Mennonite and the Amish. It was well written and had a very sweet story. I always enjoy Cindy Woodsmall's books. In today's world, her books are refreshing reads.
The characters were endearing and well-developed. The story was light, flowed well and was easy to understand.
The characters were endearing and well-developed. The story was light, flowed well and was easy to understand.
September 2, 2016
Good book. But I personally don't think that God wants us to set up religious rules that limit who we can fall in love with.
August 1, 2018
A sweet love story. The beginning was a little slow.
August 10, 2022
Sweet clean romance read!
October 1, 2021
I'm not sure that words can truly even express how much I adored this beautiful story from one of the genre's very best. I've read a lot of Amish fiction titles over the years, but very rarely have I read one that focuses around a forbidden relationship between two different religious sects.
Annie is old order Mennonite, and has been good friends with the son of her grandfather's business partner since they were young kids. When a falling out with her own family leads to her leaving to spend some more time with her grandfather, her and Aden quickly come to realize that their childhood friendship has grown into something more. How could a relationship between the two of them ever truly work out when they have so much working against them, and both of them having taken their vows to their own churches?
The Scent of Cherry Blossoms is a breathtakingly beautiful romance story that speaks of sacrifice, the importance of familial bonds, and most importantly, learning to trust and follow our Lord even when He doesn't seem to be leading us in the direction we were hoping for. Annie and Aden's love story story is heartwarming and authentic, and I adored the fact that their romance barely contains any physical components, and yet their bond is so strong and speaks to them wanting to be together for the right reasons, and not just because of physical attraction or lust.
I appreciate the fact that every time I pick up a novel from Cindy Woodsmall, I end up learning something new about Amish culture, and I always love how she's not afraid to tackle tougher subjects in her heartfelt stories. In this particular title on top of the forbidden romance, the reader also encounters the struggles that Aden's brother encounters being in a wheelchair, and the fact that Aden himself has suffered from speech impediments for as long as he can remember.
I truly adored this one from start to finish, and I almost read the entire story in one sitting. I'm so sad to be finished with the Apple Ridge series, and I know I'm going to have to reread these in the very near future.
Final Rating: 5/5.
Annie is old order Mennonite, and has been good friends with the son of her grandfather's business partner since they were young kids. When a falling out with her own family leads to her leaving to spend some more time with her grandfather, her and Aden quickly come to realize that their childhood friendship has grown into something more. How could a relationship between the two of them ever truly work out when they have so much working against them, and both of them having taken their vows to their own churches?
The Scent of Cherry Blossoms is a breathtakingly beautiful romance story that speaks of sacrifice, the importance of familial bonds, and most importantly, learning to trust and follow our Lord even when He doesn't seem to be leading us in the direction we were hoping for. Annie and Aden's love story story is heartwarming and authentic, and I adored the fact that their romance barely contains any physical components, and yet their bond is so strong and speaks to them wanting to be together for the right reasons, and not just because of physical attraction or lust.
I appreciate the fact that every time I pick up a novel from Cindy Woodsmall, I end up learning something new about Amish culture, and I always love how she's not afraid to tackle tougher subjects in her heartfelt stories. In this particular title on top of the forbidden romance, the reader also encounters the struggles that Aden's brother encounters being in a wheelchair, and the fact that Aden himself has suffered from speech impediments for as long as he can remember.
I truly adored this one from start to finish, and I almost read the entire story in one sitting. I'm so sad to be finished with the Apple Ridge series, and I know I'm going to have to reread these in the very near future.
Final Rating: 5/5.
March 23, 2012
Description:
Annie Martin, an old order Mennonite, has always been faithful to the Plain ways of her ancestors, but when a mother-daughter spat sends her to live with her grandfather, a new "distraction" begins to test her faith. Aden Zook is Old Order Amish, and has stolen Annie's heart. Can Annie and Aden find a way to be together even though their faiths' prohibit it? Or will their love only last as long as the cherry blossoms are in season?
Review:
I live near Lancaster, Pennsylvania so I am no stranger to horse-and-buggy travel in the area, but besides what I have seen and read about the Amish population, I don't really know much about their beliefs or daily life. So when Doubleday Publishing Group offered me a copy of The Scent of Cherry Blossoms, I was excited to learn more about Amish culture. The book is short, but I found out that it is part of a "seasonal" series of novellas by Cindy Woodsmall, (so I know I will be heading to the library soon to find the other ones). I loved the characters, especially Annie, Aden, and Roman; their thoughts as well as their dialogue were detailed and full of emotion. Their relationships and interactions with the community were fun to read about - as was the book as a whole. The plot was good, and I enjoyed the innocent romance as well as the back-story. My only qualm was that it was so short, but that was intended; I will definitely be reading more books by Cindy Woodsmall now that I have discovered her craft for words. I was amazed by the amount of information and feeling that she managed to fit into this tiny book! Highly recommended for fans of Christian and Amish/Mennonite fiction. Off to the library I go to find more in the series!
Rating: On the Run (4/5)
*** I received this book from the author (The Doubleday Religious Publishing Group) in exchange for an honest and unbiased review.
Annie Martin, an old order Mennonite, has always been faithful to the Plain ways of her ancestors, but when a mother-daughter spat sends her to live with her grandfather, a new "distraction" begins to test her faith. Aden Zook is Old Order Amish, and has stolen Annie's heart. Can Annie and Aden find a way to be together even though their faiths' prohibit it? Or will their love only last as long as the cherry blossoms are in season?
Review:
I live near Lancaster, Pennsylvania so I am no stranger to horse-and-buggy travel in the area, but besides what I have seen and read about the Amish population, I don't really know much about their beliefs or daily life. So when Doubleday Publishing Group offered me a copy of The Scent of Cherry Blossoms, I was excited to learn more about Amish culture. The book is short, but I found out that it is part of a "seasonal" series of novellas by Cindy Woodsmall, (so I know I will be heading to the library soon to find the other ones). I loved the characters, especially Annie, Aden, and Roman; their thoughts as well as their dialogue were detailed and full of emotion. Their relationships and interactions with the community were fun to read about - as was the book as a whole. The plot was good, and I enjoyed the innocent romance as well as the back-story. My only qualm was that it was so short, but that was intended; I will definitely be reading more books by Cindy Woodsmall now that I have discovered her craft for words. I was amazed by the amount of information and feeling that she managed to fit into this tiny book! Highly recommended for fans of Christian and Amish/Mennonite fiction. Off to the library I go to find more in the series!
Rating: On the Run (4/5)
*** I received this book from the author (The Doubleday Religious Publishing Group) in exchange for an honest and unbiased review.
March 12, 2012
Amish and Cindy Woodsmall go together like milk and cookies – they are just that good and this newest book is no different and I’m so glad that I had the chance to read it! I was somewhat worried that this would be same ol’ girl wants boy, boy has issues, girl tries to forget boy, boy gets over issues then they both get married – but while it was a boy gets girl, it wasn’t the typical story. There are many intricacies that dictate dating and marriage between different groups of Plain people – so when Annie comes back and helps out and falls in love with Aden – we get to learn what some of those issues that keep the two groups separate.
This was a short book, but even though it was short I felt connected to the characters and could feel the tension that was going on between Annie and Aden as they decide how to proceed. How those steeped in Old Order tradition have to open their eyes and hearts to new ways of thinking, even if it means leaving behind some prejudices about the other group. I really hope to read more about the people in this book and take a look into their life later to see how things are going in the future. Yes the girl gets the boy, but it’s with a new twist that I appreciate.
Please rate my review here: http://waterbrookmultnomah.com/bloggi...
**I was provided a copy of this book from Waterbrook Multnomah Publishing through Blogging for Books in exchange for my honest opinion, no other compensation was given.
This was a short book, but even though it was short I felt connected to the characters and could feel the tension that was going on between Annie and Aden as they decide how to proceed. How those steeped in Old Order tradition have to open their eyes and hearts to new ways of thinking, even if it means leaving behind some prejudices about the other group. I really hope to read more about the people in this book and take a look into their life later to see how things are going in the future. Yes the girl gets the boy, but it’s with a new twist that I appreciate.
Please rate my review here: http://waterbrookmultnomah.com/bloggi...
**I was provided a copy of this book from Waterbrook Multnomah Publishing through Blogging for Books in exchange for my honest opinion, no other compensation was given.
February 22, 2012
'The Scent of Cherry Blossoms' by Cindy Woodsmall was a fantastic
read! The story revisits a couple of characters from previous
Woodsmall books, Roman and Aden Zook, as well as introduces us to
Annie Martin, a 'horse and buggy' Mennonite. One thing I simply love
about Woodsmall is that while her books are a series they can also be
read as standalone novels. If you're an avid reader, you start to get
a feel for the characters in her community and it's really nice to
revisit them when new novels hit the shelves.
I truly enjoyed the characters in this book. My own daughter suffered
from a speech impediment, luckily, therapy has worked for her.
Because of the extensive therapy we've been through with her, I felt a
closeness to Aden and was pleased with how his character was written.
So many times people look at someone with a speech difficulty as
"slow" and Woodsmall respectfully showed that many times that is not
the case. I was glad he was able to find someone who could love him
for who he was, regardless of his speech problem!
I anticipate seeing a future installment that explores more of Roman's
story. I felt his part of the story was tied up a little too soon, but
hope that in doing so it will mean a new story to read in the future!
A fantastic book, and a lovely little romance!
read! The story revisits a couple of characters from previous
Woodsmall books, Roman and Aden Zook, as well as introduces us to
Annie Martin, a 'horse and buggy' Mennonite. One thing I simply love
about Woodsmall is that while her books are a series they can also be
read as standalone novels. If you're an avid reader, you start to get
a feel for the characters in her community and it's really nice to
revisit them when new novels hit the shelves.
I truly enjoyed the characters in this book. My own daughter suffered
from a speech impediment, luckily, therapy has worked for her.
Because of the extensive therapy we've been through with her, I felt a
closeness to Aden and was pleased with how his character was written.
So many times people look at someone with a speech difficulty as
"slow" and Woodsmall respectfully showed that many times that is not
the case. I was glad he was able to find someone who could love him
for who he was, regardless of his speech problem!
I anticipate seeing a future installment that explores more of Roman's
story. I felt his part of the story was tied up a little too soon, but
hope that in doing so it will mean a new story to read in the future!
A fantastic book, and a lovely little romance!
February 20, 2012
I found "The Scent of Cherry Blossoms", by Cindy Woodsmall captivating.
Cindy Woodsmall’s writes so artistically that you become intimately familiar with her graphic descriptions and landscapes, so much so that you can sense the smell the cherry blossoms and you feel as though you are standing in the orchards.
As you read Cindy is able to guide you so that you become familiar with the customs and beliefs of the Amish. She will lead you in a way that you feel you are in this community and understand the differences in the Old Order Amish/Older Order Mennonite community and how they are able to blend their different beliefs.
The characters seem to walk off the pages into your mind; you will be amazed at how well you visualize these characters interacting and how much you feel their challenges.
I cannot help but hope that we will be hearing more about the characters Annie and Aden and the possibility of a series.
Thanks Goodreads, this book is a winner!
Cindy Woodsmall’s writes so artistically that you become intimately familiar with her graphic descriptions and landscapes, so much so that you can sense the smell the cherry blossoms and you feel as though you are standing in the orchards.
As you read Cindy is able to guide you so that you become familiar with the customs and beliefs of the Amish. She will lead you in a way that you feel you are in this community and understand the differences in the Old Order Amish/Older Order Mennonite community and how they are able to blend their different beliefs.
The characters seem to walk off the pages into your mind; you will be amazed at how well you visualize these characters interacting and how much you feel their challenges.
I cannot help but hope that we will be hearing more about the characters Annie and Aden and the possibility of a series.
Thanks Goodreads, this book is a winner!
October 9, 2012
Excellent! This has to be one of my all-time favorites. I'm a fan of Cindy Woodsmall's writing!
March 9, 2017
Sweet story of family, love and commitment to church and those we care about. The story dragged a little and could have been finished in half the content. Book #4 in the Apple Ridge series.
March 18, 2012
Things have been tense in the Martin household. Nineteen-year-old Annie tries to ignore her brothers' antics, but there's no denying that their drinking and swearing and gambling is a far cry from appropriate behavior for Old Order Mennonites. When her mother sends her off to stay with her grandfather in Apple Ridge, Pennsylvania, she's relieved to get away from all the fighting. But Apple Ridge brings its own challenges, as Annie is reminded of her affection for quiet, stuttering Aden Zook. As a young girl, she'd admired him; as a grown woman, she realizes he's everything she's looking for in a man. And Aden seems equally taken with her. There's only one problem: he's Old Order Amish, and the two are forbidden to intermarry, or even court. With Annie's grandfather threatening to put the Zook family diner out of business, and Aden's crippled brother doing everything he can to tear them apart, will Annie and Aden ever find a way to be together? Can they overcome the obstacles in their way? Should they?
This books marks my first foray into the growing genre of Amish fiction. And I have to say, I suspect it may not be the genre for me.
Everyone in the book is sort of . . . vaguely nice and good-intentioned (with the possible exception of Annie's boorish brothers). When they disagree, they do so quietly and respectfully--even when the heroine berates herself for being 'disrespectful' of her elders, her behavior is far from rude or impertinent. I realize this may be a realistic portrayal of the communities involved, and it sounds like the author did her research, but that doesn't exactly make for scintillating reading. The whole book was kind of a snooze, really. Granted, I read a lot of sci fi and horror fiction, so I may not be the best judge. But I also have a fondness for the 19th century comedy of manners, and nobody gets eaten or kidnapped by pirates in those either.
And anyway, the extreme deference and obedience seems to come and go at the author's whim--for all her talk of submission, Annie does not hesitate to sneak out of the house in the dead of night to meet Aden in the cherry orchard. For two people raised in such a rule-driven culture, they are surprisingly quick to abandon the rules that have governed their lives and to conduct a clandestine courtship. Nothing untoward happens--they never even kiss--but the mere fact of their 'relationship' is a violation of the standards of both their communities.
Annie and Aden's inconsistency is mirrored by the community at large (or at least their families). This inter-order courtship starts out as, essentially, anathema and betrayal of a vow before God that will destroy Annie's chaste reputation. Then the author seems to change her mind, and it becomes more of an old fashioned idea of Annie's grandfather (and thus more of a practical obstacle, given his power over the Zooks). By the end of the book, it's just a minor detail that everyone will get over in practically no time at all.
This sort of 'forbidden romance' is always troubling to me. On the one hand, it can be reminiscent of baseless and immoral anti-miscegenation laws, where the law preventing the hero from marrying the heroine is plainly wrong, even evil, and should be ignored. But here, the conclusion is not that the law is bad. Neither of them decides to abandon their community (though of course one will have to join the other's community once they marry). Annie and Aden still want to be a part of their respective churches. They just think they should be an exception, because they're destined for one another. Love conquers all, as they say. But should it?
Annie and Aden are troubled not just about the community standard, but about God's. They have both vowed before God to be faithful members of their communities, and that means not marrying anyone outside the community. Period. Therefore, their courtship violates not just community rules, but their own promises. They both eventually decide this shouldn't keep them apart, and Aden even decides that he is 'free in Christ' to break his vow and that God will forgive him. Which may be true, in a way, but hardly makes for good theology or good decision making. This 'forbidden love' starts to look a bit more like a married man who claims he is 'allowed' to break his vow to his wife in order to be with the woman he loves.
Then, too, there is the inevitable effect on the community. Annie's grandfather, as part owner of the Zook family diner, has the ability to put them out of business, and threatens to do just that if Aden doesn't stop courting Annie. By continuing their relationship, Annie and Aden know that they are upsetting not just their community in general, but their family. Without the diner, the Zooks may not be able to feed themselves--Aden's brother is crippled and can no longer do manual labor. His father also has severe physical limitations, and the other siblings are too young to be much help. Annie and Aden ultimately decide that their choice to be together is, essentially, not about anyone else. In other words, once again, love conquers all, even if it means your family starves. Or something.
Aside from the moral implications of this ostensibly moral genre, the writing itself is not that impressive. The supporting characters bordered on caricatures, but Annie and Aden, though mind-numbingly nice and not all that interesting, were decently drawn. It goes without saying that an Amish romance is going to be cheesy, and there were definitely some eye-roll-worthy lines in this one. But for some reason, they weren't as fun. I think a lot of cheesy writers know they're being cheesy and over the top. Here, the tone is serious, even sincere. And that makes me feel kind of bad about the above-mentioned eye-rolling. Because everyone in this book is so nice, and I'm sure the author is terribly nice as well, and I just . . . I feel bad for thinking the book was . . . kind of dumb.
There. I said it.
Bottom line: This may be a perfectly serviceable Amish romance novel (and the reviews on Goodreads and Amazon seem to indicate that it is). But if you're looking for something with a bit more zing--something to make you laugh, or even cry, or something to scare or excite or entertain or . . . anything you, for that matter--you might be better off looking elsewhere.
I received this book for free from WaterBrook Multnomah Publishing Group for this review.
This books marks my first foray into the growing genre of Amish fiction. And I have to say, I suspect it may not be the genre for me.
Everyone in the book is sort of . . . vaguely nice and good-intentioned (with the possible exception of Annie's boorish brothers). When they disagree, they do so quietly and respectfully--even when the heroine berates herself for being 'disrespectful' of her elders, her behavior is far from rude or impertinent. I realize this may be a realistic portrayal of the communities involved, and it sounds like the author did her research, but that doesn't exactly make for scintillating reading. The whole book was kind of a snooze, really. Granted, I read a lot of sci fi and horror fiction, so I may not be the best judge. But I also have a fondness for the 19th century comedy of manners, and nobody gets eaten or kidnapped by pirates in those either.
And anyway, the extreme deference and obedience seems to come and go at the author's whim--for all her talk of submission, Annie does not hesitate to sneak out of the house in the dead of night to meet Aden in the cherry orchard. For two people raised in such a rule-driven culture, they are surprisingly quick to abandon the rules that have governed their lives and to conduct a clandestine courtship. Nothing untoward happens--they never even kiss--but the mere fact of their 'relationship' is a violation of the standards of both their communities.
Annie and Aden's inconsistency is mirrored by the community at large (or at least their families). This inter-order courtship starts out as, essentially, anathema and betrayal of a vow before God that will destroy Annie's chaste reputation. Then the author seems to change her mind, and it becomes more of an old fashioned idea of Annie's grandfather (and thus more of a practical obstacle, given his power over the Zooks). By the end of the book, it's just a minor detail that everyone will get over in practically no time at all.
This sort of 'forbidden romance' is always troubling to me. On the one hand, it can be reminiscent of baseless and immoral anti-miscegenation laws, where the law preventing the hero from marrying the heroine is plainly wrong, even evil, and should be ignored. But here, the conclusion is not that the law is bad. Neither of them decides to abandon their community (though of course one will have to join the other's community once they marry). Annie and Aden still want to be a part of their respective churches. They just think they should be an exception, because they're destined for one another. Love conquers all, as they say. But should it?
Annie and Aden are troubled not just about the community standard, but about God's. They have both vowed before God to be faithful members of their communities, and that means not marrying anyone outside the community. Period. Therefore, their courtship violates not just community rules, but their own promises. They both eventually decide this shouldn't keep them apart, and Aden even decides that he is 'free in Christ' to break his vow and that God will forgive him. Which may be true, in a way, but hardly makes for good theology or good decision making. This 'forbidden love' starts to look a bit more like a married man who claims he is 'allowed' to break his vow to his wife in order to be with the woman he loves.
Then, too, there is the inevitable effect on the community. Annie's grandfather, as part owner of the Zook family diner, has the ability to put them out of business, and threatens to do just that if Aden doesn't stop courting Annie. By continuing their relationship, Annie and Aden know that they are upsetting not just their community in general, but their family. Without the diner, the Zooks may not be able to feed themselves--Aden's brother is crippled and can no longer do manual labor. His father also has severe physical limitations, and the other siblings are too young to be much help. Annie and Aden ultimately decide that their choice to be together is, essentially, not about anyone else. In other words, once again, love conquers all, even if it means your family starves. Or something.
Aside from the moral implications of this ostensibly moral genre, the writing itself is not that impressive. The supporting characters bordered on caricatures, but Annie and Aden, though mind-numbingly nice and not all that interesting, were decently drawn. It goes without saying that an Amish romance is going to be cheesy, and there were definitely some eye-roll-worthy lines in this one. But for some reason, they weren't as fun. I think a lot of cheesy writers know they're being cheesy and over the top. Here, the tone is serious, even sincere. And that makes me feel kind of bad about the above-mentioned eye-rolling. Because everyone in this book is so nice, and I'm sure the author is terribly nice as well, and I just . . . I feel bad for thinking the book was . . . kind of dumb.
There. I said it.
Bottom line: This may be a perfectly serviceable Amish romance novel (and the reviews on Goodreads and Amazon seem to indicate that it is). But if you're looking for something with a bit more zing--something to make you laugh, or even cry, or something to scare or excite or entertain or . . . anything you, for that matter--you might be better off looking elsewhere.
I received this book for free from WaterBrook Multnomah Publishing Group for this review.
August 14, 2017
Annie & her mother don't get along well. In the midst of an argument, her mother tells her to move out & go live with her Daadi---Grandfather Moses. While there, Annie works in a diner to help a Plain family. Working alongside Zook, the two begi'sin meeting after work in Daadi's cherry orchard.
Annie & Aden have bee raised with different religious beliefs. One is Old Order Amish, the other is Old Order Mennonite. The two are forbidden to date because of their religious differences.
When Daadi finds out about their rendezvous, they won't stop seeing each other--sneaking around
behind his back & that of Annie's mother.
Daadi threatens to take Annie & move away to break them up. If he does, it would also put the
diner in jeopardy--it would lose it's right to use electricity--eliminating the Zook family's
livelihood. Amish were not allowed to use electricity, only Mennonites could & they needed
Daadi's partnership in the diner to keep it open.
Annie & Aden are madly in love. But is it worth the financial ruin of the Zook family & the shunning by Annie's family?
Annie & Aden have bee raised with different religious beliefs. One is Old Order Amish, the other is Old Order Mennonite. The two are forbidden to date because of their religious differences.
When Daadi finds out about their rendezvous, they won't stop seeing each other--sneaking around
behind his back & that of Annie's mother.
Daadi threatens to take Annie & move away to break them up. If he does, it would also put the
diner in jeopardy--it would lose it's right to use electricity--eliminating the Zook family's
livelihood. Amish were not allowed to use electricity, only Mennonites could & they needed
Daadi's partnership in the diner to keep it open.
Annie & Aden are madly in love. But is it worth the financial ruin of the Zook family & the shunning by Annie's family?
July 24, 2019
4.6. :)
Oh wow, that was sweet, and an ending that my spirit delighted in. This book was my first Amish fiction that I've completed...ha! I know there's good Amish fiction out there, but like any genre, I think it's about finding your authors you like. Cindy Woodsmall definitely is on my list to follow now. What I liked was that it was light, but not fluffy. Complex, but not not too much. I liked that the author presented old order in a way that, as a Christian who doesn't put stock into man-made religious rules, I could get to know she characters and see their humanness and like them as my friends, while also having the space to conclude whatever I think about the religiosity of old order that, I believe, isn't always biblical. I came away from the story happy for the outcome, although curious as if this type of conclusion happens.
My favorite character: Aden's Mamm. The author portrayed her maternal thought process so well.
Crushing? Yes! Aden's gentle seriousness has him on this list for me. I loved how much he respected Annie. He showed patience and discernment, yet was honest, open, and vulnerable. Good man.
Quicker read. But refreshing and engaging for me.
Oh wow, that was sweet, and an ending that my spirit delighted in. This book was my first Amish fiction that I've completed...ha! I know there's good Amish fiction out there, but like any genre, I think it's about finding your authors you like. Cindy Woodsmall definitely is on my list to follow now. What I liked was that it was light, but not fluffy. Complex, but not not too much. I liked that the author presented old order in a way that, as a Christian who doesn't put stock into man-made religious rules, I could get to know she characters and see their humanness and like them as my friends, while also having the space to conclude whatever I think about the religiosity of old order that, I believe, isn't always biblical. I came away from the story happy for the outcome, although curious as if this type of conclusion happens.
My favorite character: Aden's Mamm. The author portrayed her maternal thought process so well.
Crushing? Yes! Aden's gentle seriousness has him on this list for me. I loved how much he respected Annie. He showed patience and discernment, yet was honest, open, and vulnerable. Good man.
Quicker read. But refreshing and engaging for me.
January 6, 2019
This novella is listed as book 4 in the Apple Ridge series, and is a little bit different. Annie Martin is a member of the Old Order Mennonites, but she is more faithful to the old ways than the rest of her family. After her father left the family, her mother and siblings have struggled, and the old ways have suffered as a result, putting Annie at odds with her family. One evening, an argument with her mother results in her being sent to her Grandfather Moses' house in Apple Ridge. Annie and her grandfather have always been close. When she arrives, Annie agrees to help an Amish family (old friends of her grandfather's) in their diner. While there, she gets reacquainted with their son Aden Zook. Yet, when they get too close - and seem to be falling in love - both families will do whatever it takes to prevent one of them from walking away from their own faith's vows.
An excellent story of love, faith, and family.
An excellent story of love, faith, and family.
December 26, 2018
This is the fourth novel in Woodsmall's Apple Ridge series, and this one as you might guess is set in the spring rather than at Christmas. In the timing of the series, these events actually take place between The Christmas Singing and the Dawn of Christmas, the second and the third books, but I guess that since this is a full novel and not a novella, it is called number 4 rather than 3.5. Anyhow, like the three preceding books of the series, this Amish romance novel is well written and has good character development. I really felt for Aden and Annie and the unique struggles they faced, and I really enjoyed their story and am glad I decided to read this series.
May 7, 2020
I loved this book. It is an Amish retelling of Romeo and Juliet. A girl from the old order Amish Mennonite and a boy from the old order Amish are forbidden from dating. They see each other anyway in her grandfathers cheery orchard. They work side by side in a diner. Her grandfather threatens to shut the diner down if Annie and Aden don’t keep seeing each other. Somehow they make it work. Annie decides to become old order Amish so she and Aden can be together. Her grandfather gives his blessing to Aden if he prays to god and think about what if would mean to her and her grandfather would agree to it.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
February 27, 2023
Annie and Seth are two characters struggling with familial relationships and loneliness when they’re placed in close proximity while running his family restaurant. Annie has been exiled from her home as a punishment and is staying with her grandfather and Seth is shy, lonely and worried about his twin brother Roman who is handicapped and despondent. Their growing affection is sweet and charming but absolutely forbidden since she’s Old Order Mennonite, he’s Old Order Amish and a relationship between them is scandalous. This wonderful story explores religious differences, sibling jealousy and familial expectations while continuing the story of previous couples in this series and I enjoyed it very much.
March 19, 2017
Mennonite and amish romance
When they were growing up they were close friends. Now as adults they find resistance from their communities for their romance. She is Amish and he is Mennonite. Will they be able to marry when they will be make so much disappointment from their families?
When they were growing up they were close friends. Now as adults they find resistance from their communities for their romance. She is Amish and he is Mennonite. Will they be able to marry when they will be make so much disappointment from their families?
Displaying 1 - 30 of 187 reviews