I would likely give three and a half stars to Mattimeo, but four is a distinct possibility.
This is, I believe, the most epically powerful adventure that Brian Jacques had to this point created.
I can only shake my head in wondrous awe at the almost ridiculously intricate and ingenious nuances that mark the text of this magnificent story from page one to page four hundred forty-six. There are enough gritty, determined, strong-willed heroes to fill a dozen super-novels, and enough dastardly, cold-blooded, wholly evil villains to keep them busy for an additional dozen books.
There truly is something magical and literally breathtaking about the luminous prose of Brian Jacques. I have never seen another author so adroitly able to spin fine fantasy literature like gold, and to retain that absurdly high standard for so long in the pages of one single heart-searing book.
I could trot out all of the masterful characters here, and talk about how wonderfully real they are while all the while they maintain a level of strength and dignified grace that sets them apart as the creations of an outstanding storyteller, but I could not do this with even a small fraction of the skill used by Brian Jacques. The same goes equally for the many formidable evil-doers.
Mattimeo is all at once a coming-of-age story, an epic fantasy, an epic adventure, a social commentary, a love story, a narrative about the strength of family ties and the determination that serves as a bedrock to the heart and soul of every human being, and much more that you will find upon reading it. It is a soul-stirring, thought-provoking journey that I must implore anyone and everyone not to miss.
"Weapons may be carried by creatures who are evil, dishonest, violent or lazy. The true warrior is good, gentle and honest. His bravery comes from within himself; he learns to conquer his own fears and misdeeds."
—Matthias, "Mattimeo", P. 30