Inside Transracial Adoption

by Gail Steinberg, Beth Hall

A resource guide for families considering transracial adoption. This book is the result of two families' experiences adoption multicultural children. Somewhat limited in scope and attitude. The section on Black hair care is well done. Gail Steinberg and Beth Hall. Adult. Hardcover. Perspectives Press, 2000. 405 pp. A resource guide for families considering transracial adoption. This book is the result of two families' experiences adoption multicultural children. Somewhat limited in scope and attitude. We recommend this as one of several articles/publications on transracial adioption. The section on Black hair care is well done. Does not talk about how to address the children's cultural needs or the issues relevant to living in more urban communities.

Genres: Adoption, Parenting, Nonfiction, Family, Race

405 pages, Hardcover

First published November 1, 2000

Reviews

[Robert Beveridge · Rating 1 out of 5]

Gail Steinberg and Beth Hall, Inside Transracial Adoption (Perspectives Press, 2000)

The more books I encounter from Perspectives Press (and as my wife and I are in the process of adopting a child, I've been seeing a lot of them over the past six months or so), the more I wonder if it's not a vertical-market vanity press. Inside Transracial Adoption is just the latest link in the chain. The editing and proofreading, if any were done, were shoddy, making the book even tougher to read than its subject matter would dictate, which is a vanity press hallmark. That, and I can't remember the last time I said this about bad proofreading, is the least of the book's problems.

While the title and cover photos might lead you to believe that the book is a general primer for anyone adopting a child of a different race, once you actually start reading, it becomes obvious that the book was written specifically for white people adopting non-white people. It's pretty dangerous territory if the authors have any sort of ulterior agenda, and that they do also becomes obvious pretty quickly. Where there is an agenda, a fertile breeding ground, and a lack of editorial input, logical fallacies are sure to sprout. And here we get to the heart of the problem. There are enough straw men in this book to scare away every crow presently living on the planet. “White is right, Asians are the model minority (almost like white.) [sic] If you're brown, get down, if you're black, step back.” (44) is not the type of verbiage one expects to find in a manual about adoption, and the idea that it's promoting-- institutionalized racism in “popular culture and music”-- is simply ludicrous. Take a quick look at Billboard's top 20 albums and singles for any of the last twenty years or so and we'll talk about white privilege. (Since I happen to have 2007 to hand, we find Akon, Fergie [who also landed the top-selling single], Beyonce, Kanye West, and Jay-Z riding the stratosphere. White privilege, indeed!)

Need it be said that assuming all whites are racist is a form of racism in itself? Do yourself a favor and look for something a little more balanced. (zero)

[Alina Borger · Rating 4 out of 5]

This book is the major heavyweight title in transracial adoption. The authors themselves have adopted transracially, and include interviews with families (parents and kids) in all the various ages and stages. I think the single most helpful thing in this book is actually a comparison section, where the authors separate "issues all adoptive kids face" from "issues transracially adopted kids face." I found it SUPER helpful, because I realized that a lot of my fears, worries and other "dark scenarios" were actually adoption-related and not necessarily race-related. There are also sections in the book that discuss issues faced by adopted kids from specific cultural groups, including Latinos, Asians and Africans.

Note: the star system is a bit awkward here. To say I "really liked" a book like this is not exactly true. It's more like I found this book "really important" in my journey to and through interracial adoption.

[Marnie · Rating 2 out of 5]

There was some good information in this book but it's full of typos making it hard to read, & some of the advice & opinions I disagreed with. I thought the idea that all whites are automatically racists because they benefit from racism was ridiculous, & I thought the authors (who are both white & seem to think they're experts on how blacks, Hispanics, & Asians think) put way too much importance on race. They say basically that all members of a race think the same, which is obviously not true, & that whites alone are responsible for stopping racism because they're the ones (or their ancestors) who create it. There's even a page where it talks about how we associate different colors with different things, like white is associated with goodness & purity, & brown is associated with poop. Yes, it actually says that & I cant figure out what it has to do with adoption. My opinion is the best way to raise a child of a different color is to treat them as an individual & a member of your family, not to assume they'll be a certain way or have certain issues because of their skin color or nationality. You also have to recognize that racism exists, but dont make it the center of your life or think it's behind everything: if your child gets a bad grade or doesnt get invited to a birthday party it's possible that they earned the grade or just arent that good friends with the kid having the party, you cant automatically assume it's because of racism like some of the people in this book. Looking for racism in every little situation would probably also trivialize real racism or race-related incidents that you really should get angry about. You also have to teach your child that they are beautiful & loved, & that their race has many people who are beautiful & successful, & acknowledge that they're a different color from you & that they're adopted & that those are good things that make the child special, as well as the child's personality & talents that have nothing to do with race. Me & my husband are white & we hope to adopt a black girl soon & we've been reading a lot about adoption, race, & parenting. This is not one of the best books & I wonder if one of its goals is really to discourage people from adopting transracially.

[Serena · Rating 3 out of 5]

If you are a white parent adopting a child of a different race or ethnic background, you should definitely take a look at this book. If you are a parent who thinks "love will conquer all" or "I don't see skin color," you need to check out this book quickly. I generally consider myself well educated on adoption issues and a pretty progressive person, but this book still gave me a lot to think about. My favorite parts of the book were the personal stories from the authors (both white adoptive mothers) and the quotes from transracial adoptees. While I believe the information in the book is vital, I had to take away two stars for the sheer amount of editing errors present. If this book had been reviewed more thoroughly before publication, it would be worthy of five stars.

[Angela Perry · Rating 4 out of 5]

For white people who have not explored the inherent racism the world is built around I am sure will have many issues with this book.

While not perfect, it shares the authors experience and what they have learned while raising their own transracial children.

For adoptive parents considering adopting across racial lines it is an excellent book to expand knowledge on the subject but it should only be a starting point at examining the world they live in and how different it will be from their child.

[Andrew Wolgemuth · Rating 4 out of 5]

The list of "Things to Keep in Mind as an Adoptive Parent" is long to begin with; "transracial" matters lengthen the list a bit more. We learn so much from those who have gone before us during our adoption adventure, and that's the case with this book. Hall and Steinberg are candid about what they've learned, where they've failed, and what other families can do to avoid their mistakes (and they've done a lot right too!).

[Kari Bruce · Rating 4 out of 5]

Such a GREAT resource for anyone who is going to adopt or has adopted transracially (a child who is a difference race than your own). The negative reviews refer a lot to terrible grammar which definitely show up in all of the personal stories they write, which is strange. But if you can just ignore that and focus on content, it's a super great book to have in your library! I loved reading all of the first hand accounts. It's given me things to think about and tips for our own adopted child.

[Shawna · Rating 4 out of 5]

Great beginning knowledge about transracial adoption.

[Becky · Rating 5 out of 5]

A ton of wisdom here.

[Ebookwormy1 · Rating 2 out of 5]

I confess, I didn't get very far in this book... I got stuck in the second section on "Racial Identity".

On the good side, this book did help me to understand racism better. The idea that because I'm white I am given advantages and considerations without asking for them was a eye opener to me. The concept that children of color we would adopt wouldn't be granted such consideration when they are not with my husband and I was helpful to understand. In addition, there are extensive annotated bibliographies by section and at the end of the book.

I wanted to like the book. But, the negatives are it is incredibly difficult to read. Too long. Bizillion words per page. The style and lack of editing make the book feel like it is a fanatic treatise. The authors tend to focus more on problems, failures (their own and others), and challenges. There are MANY things to disagree with here. The author's approach seems very divisive and, if possible, overemphasizes race as the primary source of identity (maybe this would be rectified by perseverance further in the book). But, in the end, the more I thought about it, it wasn't really WHAT was said, but HOW it was said that is the problem.

This was my first attempt/ exposure to researching our dream of transracial adoption. It was a discouraging one. I may go back to this book because of the positives, but in the meantime it is due back at the library and I think I'd rather start the process with a different perspective.

[Gemma Alexander · Rating 2 out of 5]

Seriously, did this book even have an editor? Garbled sentences, random font changes, typos and spelling errors seriously detracted from the authors' thesis, however valid it may be. Their primary point is that race matters (kind of preaching to the choir- if adoptive parents didn't already believe it, they wouldn't read the book in the first place) and that while race is not everything, it is a factor in everything. Unfortunately, this meant that instead of a well structured, logically organized book, what you get is a mish mash grab bag of topics and how race may relate to each one. So it took them 386 pages to say, "Race matters. It is an element of every aspect of your child's life. Once your child leaves your side, they are no longer the recipient of white privilege, and if they are not prepared handle the treatment members of their own race are subject to, you have not properly prepared them to survive on their own in our society. If you are white, you cannot provide them with this preparation directly, because you do not have the skills yourself. Your only choice is to enlist allies from within your child's race to help you educate your children about their birth culture and how members of their race survive in America." A good message, but I think they could have said it more impactfully in hundreds fewer pages. I was hoping for something more, maybe fewer "you shoulds" and more "how tos".

[Clay]

Inside Transracial Adoption should be required reading for anyone considering transracial adoption.

Love is essential, but love alone does not erase racial realities, cultural identity, or the responsibility adoptive parents have to prepare their children for the world they live in.

This book challenged me in necessary ways and forced me to think more deeply about what it truly means to support my children—not just emotionally, but culturally and socially.

It helped me better understand how to listen instead of assume.

It reminded me that parenting requires humility.

My job as a parent is not to make my children fit neatly into my worldview. My job is to help them fully become themselves.

I’m grateful I read this early in my parenting journey.

I’ll continue reading.

[Betsy Dion · Rating 4 out of 5]

There is a lot of information packed into this book. I found it difficult to read straight through, so I just read it in shorter sections over a long period of time. Definitely worth reading for anyone considering adopting a child of a different race. I didn't agree with every single conclusion, but it brought up a lot of relevant issues that should be considered. It helps that both authors have been through the process themselves. Reading this book can give a parent some preparation for what their child might experience, rather than having to deal with everything in the moment without the chance to think through the situation.

[Dayspring · Rating 4 out of 5]

Written by two transracial adoptive mothers for transracial adoptive parents. Like any book, particularly books about parenting and families, I don't agree with all of the author's suggestions and perspectives. The strategies and suggestions are mostly based on the authors' experiences, not research, but still good thought-provoking ideas. Overall, this is one of the better books I have read on transracial adoption, and because it is often referred to in other adoption literature and by some adoption agencies, I would recommend it to anyone planning to adopt transracially.

[Meg · Rating 3 out of 5]

Super disorganized. And yet, I learned a lot from the authors' experiences. Some of the child development stuff I valued and other theory I ignored. Like all advice, you take what makes sense to you and you leave the rest. I appreciated some of their advice about how to approach conversations with family. Sort of a mixed bag of a book, but in a world where there are so few sources on transracial adoption, I appreciated just hearing people's stories and experiences. And I appreciate that they regard children who have been transracially adopted as the experts.

[Kate · Rating 3 out of 5]

I found this to be a book with some excellent points and some dated, irritating perspectives. It is also quite repetitive at times, and the authors sometimes come off as more than a little pleased with themselves. Inside Transracial Adoption is one to be read with an open and critical mind. I certainly wouldn't take it as a primary text for learning about transracial adoption. This is one of those books that I used to give myself time to think about issues of transracial adoption rather than one I would turn to for advice or guidance.

[Jennifer · Rating 2 out of 5]

I disagreed with the authors' conclusions and point of view most of the time. It was interesting and made me think but I think the perspective in "I"m Chocolate, You're Vanilla" is more accurate and helpful.

[shanamadele · Rating 4 out of 5]

A must-read for anyone considering transracial adoption -- chock full of stories and questions that will help you think through the issues surrounding this decision.

[Amber · Rating 3 out of 5]

Good information...only some is applicable at this point in our journey, I think this will be a book I revisit as issues arise. I can see it becoming extremely helpful as she gets older.

[Kara · Rating 4 out of 5]

Many sections of this book I found insightful and seemed to speak to my experience.

[Hannah]

really good info, but need to remember that Jesus is bigger than 'doing it right'

[Hannah]

great book, challenging in many ways, just have to remember that ultimately Jesus is putting this child in your family and is sufficient despite your failings

[Tami · Rating 3 out of 5]

Some good things to think about.

[Polly · Rating 2 out of 5]

2.5 Stars.

It was lengthy and disorganized, still I found their personal experiences to be beneficial. I'm glad they included excerpts from "experts" (most of whom were adoptees).

[Jane Hinton]

This book was very basic, a 101 to building a multi-cultural family through adoption.

[Mary · Rating 4 out of 5]

This book has terrible editing errors all throughout, but it is worth the distraction.

[Tom Panning · Rating 4 out of 5]

A very good 150 page book in 400 pages.

[Rebecca · Rating 3 out of 5]

While this book is very US oriented, there were useful ideas in it. Still, I was hoping to get more inside the adopted/fostered child's mind and understanding what might be driving them to play up. For example, deliberate rule-breaking. Also, although I know adopted black South Africans who faced the same challenges of not connecting with their culture, it's fairly easy here to ensure that happens. however, the issue for me was that her 'culture' is poverty, her friends from before we adopted her live nearby ... but the neighbourhood is dangerous (gangsterism etc) so how to incorporate some of township culture (e.g. music, food, clothing, language) is easy to deal with. Other aspects are more tricky ... a culture of hopelessness, drugs, school dropouts, and teen pregnancy ... I think we've finally got the balance right, but this was not part of the assumptions of the book ...

[Tara]

Written by PACT cofounders (get 2nd edition)