In this concise and balanced survey of heresy and inquisition in the Middle Ages, Jennifer Kolpacoff Deane explores the increasingly bitter encounters between piety, reform, dissent, and the institutional Church between 1100 and 1500. Although the loaded terms of 'heresy' and 'orthodoxy' employed by ecclesiastical officials suggest a clear division between right and wrong, that division was in fact vigorously contested by medieval people at all levels of society. Deane investigates key issues that sparked confrontations between Christians, including access to scripture, apostolic models of poverty and preaching, the Eucharist and sacramental power, and clerical corruption and wealth. She traces the means by which Church elites developed an increasingly complex set of inquisitorial procedures and resources to identify, label, and repress 'heresy,' examines the various regional eruptions of such confrontations across medieval Europe, and considers the judicial processes that brought many to the stake. The book ranges from the 'Good Christians' of Languedoc and Lombardy and the pan-European 'Poor,' to Spiritual Franciscans, lay religious women, anticlerical and vernacular movements in England and Bohemia, mysticism, magical practices, and witchcraft. Throughout, Deane considers how the new inquisitorial bureaucracies not only fueled anxiety over heresy, but actually generated fictional 'heresies' through their own texts and techniques. Incorporating recent research and debates in the field, her analysis brings to life a compelling issue that profoundly influenced the medieval world.
Deane investigates the complex social, religious and political history of the subject with thoroughness and clarity. I'm using as a reference/inspiration for some world-building in a fantasy novel, and found it much more illuminating than God's Jury.
I've assigned it maybe 4-5 times now in my Medieval Heresy/Inquisitions courses (planning to use it again Spring 2021). Deane's clear, engaging prose and deep knowledge of the issues make this an essential introduction to a complex topic. I assign it along with a couple of primary source collections as well as a few articles. Students tend to really like it. The chapters are good (in my experience) for sparking conversations and I think the presentation helps them get a good grasp on the complexity without being too overwhelmed. The bibliographies at the end of every chapter are really helpful for getting students into research projects, etc.
Just finished this for a class. As a new reader of Medieval history I was incredibly bored and overwhelmed by the somewhat scattered writing. The themes throughout were helpful but organizationally it was a very difficult book to follow, especially as someone new to the vocabulary and history.
A well-written general history of heresy and inquisition. One gains a far greater understanding of how deeply connected to daily life faith and official Church policies were during the middle ages, and how and why many groups sought their own path.
I thought this was going to be painful, as some readings for college are.. Thankfully I was pleasantly surprised. Her easy writing style made reading a breeze and I actually looked forward to turning the page! If this topic interests you I would definitely recommend this book! It takes a pretty non-biased approach, which is perfect when you're trying to learn both sides of an argument.
I ran across this title while reading a history of the King James Bible. It proved more interesting than I thought it might be, providing a broad overview of what medieval folk thought was heresy.