What do you think?
Rate this book
Aisling #2
Dream
To reveal the intricate machinations threatening them, two men must learn to trust each other. But how can they, when their hearts and minds—their realities—are subject to manipulation?
When he set out to escort the prisoner Wilfred Calder back to Putnam, Constable Dallin Brayden didn’t anticipate the political betrayal and malicious magic threatening their lives at every turn. To his surprise, he slips into the role of protector—and it’s more than duty compelling him to ensure Wil’s safety as they’re haunted by strange dreams. But does Wil dare put himself in the hands of a man he believes wants him dead?
Wil’s past weighs heavily on him, tainting his perceptions as he struggles his way through a tangle of lies. With both will and magic as his weapons, he fights desperately for survival—and his soul. For the Aisling is coveted by more than the Guild and the Brethren; ancient gods and soul-eating spirits also want what lives within him. His only chance might be Dallin and his goddess, the Mother, who Wil has been taught to despise above all others.
Second Edition.
First Edition published by Torquere/Prizm, 2011.
Cover Artist: Anne Cain
When he set out to escort the prisoner Wilfred Calder back to Putnam, Constable Dallin Brayden didn’t anticipate the political betrayal and malicious magic threatening their lives at every turn. To his surprise, he slips into the role of protector—and it’s more than duty compelling him to ensure Wil’s safety as they’re haunted by strange dreams. But does Wil dare put himself in the hands of a man he believes wants him dead?
Wil’s past weighs heavily on him, tainting his perceptions as he struggles his way through a tangle of lies. With both will and magic as his weapons, he fights desperately for survival—and his soul. For the Aisling is coveted by more than the Guild and the Brethren; ancient gods and soul-eating spirits also want what lives within him. His only chance might be Dallin and his goddess, the Mother, who Wil has been taught to despise above all others.
Second Edition.
First Edition published by Torquere/Prizm, 2011.
Cover Artist: Anne Cain
408 pages, ebook
First published June 15, 2011
9 people are currently reading
336 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 64 reviews
November 29, 2012
Finally, the world all comes together in this book! We learn who Wil truly is, while his connection to Dallin becomes more apparent. Through their journey, we learn more about their powers and their connection to the Gods, the Dominion, the Guild, the Brethren, and the Old Ones. The picture isn't completely clear but it has definitely taken shape. Of course there are still a ton of unanswered questions and the introduction of AEledfyres. In the end, can Wil actually choose himself over his Guardian? Can Dallin go through with Wil's request? I'm excited to learn how Wil's "name" fits into all of this. Not only a name, but a key. The key to his soul.
My only complaint is once again the book gets bogged down with too many details and drags a bit. I'm also getting a bit frustrated with how several key details of the story are not revealed to us. It's starting to feel like it's a brush off and not just part of the natural progression of the mystery/story. This is just something that keeps niggling at me. Half the time I feel the anticipation and the other half it feels like a big secret is being deliberately kept from the reader. Yes, this keeps us all interested and wanting to find out what happens next but I'm finding it's occurring far too often for my liking. HA, I guess I just can't deal with unknowns.
I'm glad I didn't have to wait for the third book!
My only complaint is once again the book gets bogged down with too many details and drags a bit. I'm also getting a bit frustrated with how several key details of the story are not revealed to us. It's starting to feel like it's a brush off and not just part of the natural progression of the mystery/story. This is just something that keeps niggling at me. Half the time I feel the anticipation and the other half it feels like a big secret is being deliberately kept from the reader. Yes, this keeps us all interested and wanting to find out what happens next but I'm finding it's occurring far too often for my liking. HA, I guess I just can't deal with unknowns.
I'm glad I didn't have to wait for the third book!
August 25, 2014
This book begins right at the point where things ended in Guardian and everything starts to make a bit more sense. Dallin and Wil learn to put their trust in each other and form a close bond and their relationship goes from strength to strength. Things have gone in a direction I wouldn't even have thought of at the beginning of the series and I am constantly amazed at the complexity of the world-building and thought put into the characters. Looking forward to Beloved Son
December 7, 2011
There are so many things that I enjoy in a fantasy book and this story covered them all for me. The first book in the series was a good book, but it didn't give me what I fully needed like book 2. The world building is so fully developed within this story that I easily am surrounded by the sites and sounds. The lore of the world easily becomes an intricate part of that world and makes it easier for the reader to understand how this can all be real.
The way that Carole Cummings uses words and unique situations to convey the pain and suffering of Wil is just beyond amazing .
Wil and Dallin, I absolutely love these characters and their journey of trust. Each of their actions provides such insight into their beliefs and history that you just eat up the personalities of these two and just hope with all your might that they get a HEA because they are so honest and real. This is such a full bodied relationship and story!
Can't wait for the last book in the series.
The way that Carole Cummings uses words and unique situations to convey the pain and suffering of Wil is just beyond amazing .
Wil and Dallin, I absolutely love these characters and their journey of trust. Each of their actions provides such insight into their beliefs and history that you just eat up the personalities of these two and just hope with all your might that they get a HEA because they are so honest and real. This is such a full bodied relationship and story!
Can't wait for the last book in the series.
June 15, 2011
Full review posted at Reviews by Jessewave.
In January I reviewed a book that I knew very little about by a new author that I had never read. I didn’t know anyone who had read the book, and taking the gamble, I ended up finding a story that was breathtaking in its scope and almost flawless in its characterizations. That novel, Aisling: Guardian (reviewed here) is the first book in the Aisling series by Carole Cummings, published by Prizm, the Young Adult division of Torquere. From the very first pages, I was hooked — deeply engaged in the story of Dallin Brayden, a no-nonsense and highly reasonable Constable for the city of Putnam in a world that resembles pre-industrial England, and the prisoner turned fugitive that deeply enthralls him, Wil Calder, a scrappy waif of a man who makes up for his physical inadequacies with wit, a skewed moral compass, and the vast need to survive at any cost. That book started a love affair for me with these two characters and I have since waited on tenterhooks for the next chapter in their sprawling story. Thankfully it is here, released today to buy from Prizm, and it is a beautiful continuation of their story, from the slow, piecemeal building of trust by a man that has suffered in the worst ways and betrayed by all those he ever believed loved him, to the seeking of knowledge they undertake together to understand just why they are the center of a maelstrom of political factions, religious zealots, and now newer, even larger foes.
Beginning immediately at the end of the first intstallment, Dallin wakes up from a dream where he has been Called by the Mother to take up his duty as Guardian and where he sees Wil for the first time in their shared dream, tending to the threads of man, plucking, twining, and weaving the world’s fates. Dallin finally believes. The forced exile from his homeland in Lind at the age of ten separated him from his birthright, the knowledge and training he would have had were it not for Siofra, or Wil’s jailor’s interference, and which without has turned him from a life of pious belief in the Mother and Her Gift of the Aisling into the factual Constable he is, ruled by strict reason and a logical, quick mind. The knowledge presents a dilemma for Dallin. Where once his logical mind considered the Aisling a myth studied in the cloisters of faraway religious sects, the evidence of its reality forces him to trust to faith, a new concept. This new belief means that he will have to appeal to a duty higher than the one he holds most dear, the justice and law he serves as a Constable, because if Wil is the Aisling and Dallin has indeed been Called by the Mother, then he is in fact the Guardian. No longer is Wil his prisoner to ferry back to Putnam for arraignment, but his charge to protect in his quest. Though, no matter the different groups hot on their heels, Wil and Dallin still have very little idea just what their quest is. Night after night, Wil plucks at the strings in what he believes is his duty, while only getting vague prophecies from the Father and subdued silence from the Mother. Wil feels more alone than ever with the growing burden of his duties, yet slowly Dallin’s kept promises, gentle encouragement, and almost reverent respect bloom into a slowly growing friendship, and ultimately begrudging trust.
As they cross the country on their way to Lind, the Mother’s Cradle, where they hope to get some answers to anything and everything, they grow slowly closer and find a way to work together to find their own answers. It seems that not only does Wil have power as the Aisling, but so does Dallin as the Guardian. And it will take all of Wil’s belief and encouragement in Dallin for him to let go of his logical mind and embrace his birthright, just as it will take Dallin’s steady faith in Wil for him to let loose the power he is straining to hold back. Only with the other at their side will they be able to face the slowly gaining Siofra and the new knowledge of the origins of all their powers. Most of all, however, it will take everything Wil has to face his own demons — the guilt, the betrayal, and the lies that have shaped who he believes himself to be, and the matter of the fact that no one, not least himself, knows exactly who he really is.
If the strength of the first novel lay in it characterizations of Wil and Dallin, then the strength of the second is in the world-building. The first novel was rather cryptic with information, which served a purpose — not only in respect to the reader’s intelligence, which I really admired of Carole Cummings, but to outline the sea of intrigue and betrayal in which the two are cut adrift. They are almost clueless, basing their information on myth, lies, and their own intuition. Of their enemies, allies, and duty, just about everything is conjecture. But where the first novel sets out to pair up our two hapless allies and explain how they came into each other’s lives, the second sets out to seek answers. This is a book which, like the first, makes you work for the payoff. The factions at play are slow in realization — to the characters and to the reader, like slowly defining the shadows on the wall of Plato’s cave, on the cusp of a new level of perception, one in which the characters realize they are the dice in a much bigger game, along with bigger players.
While finally understanding the game in which they are playing is definitely satisfying, the heart of the story remains with Wil and Dallin, and how they react to it. I think that Carole Cummings made quite a smart choice in the slowly building relationship between the two. Wil is fragile, continually toeing the line between sanity and insanity, constantly changing his mind of which he would prefer — knowledge or ignorance. His capture at the age of six by Siofra and the decades long imprisonment and brainwashing under the influence of the “leaf” and subsequent forceful dreaming to Siofra’s wishes has nearly broken him. It has made Wil distrustful in everyone, but most of all the Mother and the Guardian, who Siofra constantly taught him were his enemies. No matter knowing the logic of Siofra being a kidnapping megalomaniac, he is also the only person to have shown Wil kindness for most of his life, and that kind of brainwashing is almost impossible to recover from. He takes pleasure in what seems to Dallin inconsequential things — the hoarding of apples for the horses Miri and Sunny, the finding of a pre-historic arrowhead. In Dallin’s words:
“Wil was—incredibly, implausibly and against all sense and reason—an idealist. With the widest, most contrary streak of fatalism Dallin had ever witnessed.”
With newfound trust comes a solidifying bond between the two, allowing them to change and grow, embrace themselves and each other, and also for romance to bloom.
The writing here is top-notch. It is beautiful and I often found myself going back paragraphs just to read it again. There were many times I cried (which is rare for me, trust me), not out of sadness but for the simple beauty of two characters who have only each other and are learning that it is a gift. In many ways this book is also a setup to the final showdown in the next and final novel of the series, no matter how much clearer the world is becoming. There is still quite a bit that we don’t know, which makes me all the more eager for the final installment in December. Perhaps what I admire most about this series is not the many different threads that Cummings is continually juggling (and subtly showing) for the reader, which I do greatly admire as it must take a great amount of skill, but instead the fact that at this two thirds point in the story, Wil and Dallin are almost completely different characters from when we first met them, and we’ve seen their evolution every step of the way.
Lastly, this is a series that I would recommend to everyone. The romance is slow, but the buildup is worth it, and almost more powerful for its abstinence. It takes a good amount of detective work to put the pieces of this story together, which is refreshing after reading so many stories in m/m where all the information is given to you up front. I appreciate that Cummings respects her readers enough to let them glean their own conclusions from what she has offered. I also reclaim the right to not yet rate this book as DIK (same as I did the first), no matter that if I actually were going to be stranded on a desert island and had time to choose which books to take I would definitely count these among them. I’m simply waiting on the final novel to see how two of my favorite characters of 2011 fare in their final battle.
In January I reviewed a book that I knew very little about by a new author that I had never read. I didn’t know anyone who had read the book, and taking the gamble, I ended up finding a story that was breathtaking in its scope and almost flawless in its characterizations. That novel, Aisling: Guardian (reviewed here) is the first book in the Aisling series by Carole Cummings, published by Prizm, the Young Adult division of Torquere. From the very first pages, I was hooked — deeply engaged in the story of Dallin Brayden, a no-nonsense and highly reasonable Constable for the city of Putnam in a world that resembles pre-industrial England, and the prisoner turned fugitive that deeply enthralls him, Wil Calder, a scrappy waif of a man who makes up for his physical inadequacies with wit, a skewed moral compass, and the vast need to survive at any cost. That book started a love affair for me with these two characters and I have since waited on tenterhooks for the next chapter in their sprawling story. Thankfully it is here, released today to buy from Prizm, and it is a beautiful continuation of their story, from the slow, piecemeal building of trust by a man that has suffered in the worst ways and betrayed by all those he ever believed loved him, to the seeking of knowledge they undertake together to understand just why they are the center of a maelstrom of political factions, religious zealots, and now newer, even larger foes.
Beginning immediately at the end of the first intstallment, Dallin wakes up from a dream where he has been Called by the Mother to take up his duty as Guardian and where he sees Wil for the first time in their shared dream, tending to the threads of man, plucking, twining, and weaving the world’s fates. Dallin finally believes. The forced exile from his homeland in Lind at the age of ten separated him from his birthright, the knowledge and training he would have had were it not for Siofra, or Wil’s jailor’s interference, and which without has turned him from a life of pious belief in the Mother and Her Gift of the Aisling into the factual Constable he is, ruled by strict reason and a logical, quick mind. The knowledge presents a dilemma for Dallin. Where once his logical mind considered the Aisling a myth studied in the cloisters of faraway religious sects, the evidence of its reality forces him to trust to faith, a new concept. This new belief means that he will have to appeal to a duty higher than the one he holds most dear, the justice and law he serves as a Constable, because if Wil is the Aisling and Dallin has indeed been Called by the Mother, then he is in fact the Guardian. No longer is Wil his prisoner to ferry back to Putnam for arraignment, but his charge to protect in his quest. Though, no matter the different groups hot on their heels, Wil and Dallin still have very little idea just what their quest is. Night after night, Wil plucks at the strings in what he believes is his duty, while only getting vague prophecies from the Father and subdued silence from the Mother. Wil feels more alone than ever with the growing burden of his duties, yet slowly Dallin’s kept promises, gentle encouragement, and almost reverent respect bloom into a slowly growing friendship, and ultimately begrudging trust.
As they cross the country on their way to Lind, the Mother’s Cradle, where they hope to get some answers to anything and everything, they grow slowly closer and find a way to work together to find their own answers. It seems that not only does Wil have power as the Aisling, but so does Dallin as the Guardian. And it will take all of Wil’s belief and encouragement in Dallin for him to let go of his logical mind and embrace his birthright, just as it will take Dallin’s steady faith in Wil for him to let loose the power he is straining to hold back. Only with the other at their side will they be able to face the slowly gaining Siofra and the new knowledge of the origins of all their powers. Most of all, however, it will take everything Wil has to face his own demons — the guilt, the betrayal, and the lies that have shaped who he believes himself to be, and the matter of the fact that no one, not least himself, knows exactly who he really is.
If the strength of the first novel lay in it characterizations of Wil and Dallin, then the strength of the second is in the world-building. The first novel was rather cryptic with information, which served a purpose — not only in respect to the reader’s intelligence, which I really admired of Carole Cummings, but to outline the sea of intrigue and betrayal in which the two are cut adrift. They are almost clueless, basing their information on myth, lies, and their own intuition. Of their enemies, allies, and duty, just about everything is conjecture. But where the first novel sets out to pair up our two hapless allies and explain how they came into each other’s lives, the second sets out to seek answers. This is a book which, like the first, makes you work for the payoff. The factions at play are slow in realization — to the characters and to the reader, like slowly defining the shadows on the wall of Plato’s cave, on the cusp of a new level of perception, one in which the characters realize they are the dice in a much bigger game, along with bigger players.
While finally understanding the game in which they are playing is definitely satisfying, the heart of the story remains with Wil and Dallin, and how they react to it. I think that Carole Cummings made quite a smart choice in the slowly building relationship between the two. Wil is fragile, continually toeing the line between sanity and insanity, constantly changing his mind of which he would prefer — knowledge or ignorance. His capture at the age of six by Siofra and the decades long imprisonment and brainwashing under the influence of the “leaf” and subsequent forceful dreaming to Siofra’s wishes has nearly broken him. It has made Wil distrustful in everyone, but most of all the Mother and the Guardian, who Siofra constantly taught him were his enemies. No matter knowing the logic of Siofra being a kidnapping megalomaniac, he is also the only person to have shown Wil kindness for most of his life, and that kind of brainwashing is almost impossible to recover from. He takes pleasure in what seems to Dallin inconsequential things — the hoarding of apples for the horses Miri and Sunny, the finding of a pre-historic arrowhead. In Dallin’s words:
“Wil was—incredibly, implausibly and against all sense and reason—an idealist. With the widest, most contrary streak of fatalism Dallin had ever witnessed.”
With newfound trust comes a solidifying bond between the two, allowing them to change and grow, embrace themselves and each other, and also for romance to bloom.
The writing here is top-notch. It is beautiful and I often found myself going back paragraphs just to read it again. There were many times I cried (which is rare for me, trust me), not out of sadness but for the simple beauty of two characters who have only each other and are learning that it is a gift. In many ways this book is also a setup to the final showdown in the next and final novel of the series, no matter how much clearer the world is becoming. There is still quite a bit that we don’t know, which makes me all the more eager for the final installment in December. Perhaps what I admire most about this series is not the many different threads that Cummings is continually juggling (and subtly showing) for the reader, which I do greatly admire as it must take a great amount of skill, but instead the fact that at this two thirds point in the story, Wil and Dallin are almost completely different characters from when we first met them, and we’ve seen their evolution every step of the way.
Lastly, this is a series that I would recommend to everyone. The romance is slow, but the buildup is worth it, and almost more powerful for its abstinence. It takes a good amount of detective work to put the pieces of this story together, which is refreshing after reading so many stories in m/m where all the information is given to you up front. I appreciate that Cummings respects her readers enough to let them glean their own conclusions from what she has offered. I also reclaim the right to not yet rate this book as DIK (same as I did the first), no matter that if I actually were going to be stranded on a desert island and had time to choose which books to take I would definitely count these among them. I’m simply waiting on the final novel to see how two of my favorite characters of 2011 fare in their final battle.
November 18, 2011
I'm going to explain something because I really want to drive home how much I love this series. I rarely read fantasy. The names usually annoy me because they tend to have too many letters, mostly consonants, and multiple apostrophes. I end up spending most of my reading time trying to figure out how to pronounce names like J'lkhrutphne. Also books that marry up fantasy and romance usually end up being uneven; one aspect of the story is built up and the other gets left behind. Plot holes and weak world building...if I read something that is in direct opposition to the world the author has created it ruins the book for me. So, me and fantasy usually don't mix.
Now, the first book in this series was brilliant. It was pure fantasy and everything about it was perfect. Aisling Book One did not have any romance though, or rather it had a hint of it but that was all. I knew the second book in the series would probably incorporate romance and I was prepared for Book Two to be a little uneven and not shine quite as brightly as Book One. I had nothing to fear.
Aisling Book Two was beyond amazing. Anyone who is thinking about writing a fantasy/romance novel needs to read this book because Aisling Book Two is a perfect example of how things should be done.
Book Two picks up right where Book One left off. In this book Dallin and Wil new challenges, both internal and external, and many of the questions from Book One are answered in the second installment of the series. There is alot of character growth that happens in this book and as Wil and Dallin grow as individuals their relationship also evolves. It was wonderful to see Wil and Dallin solidify their bond. The romance was there in this book but at no point did it overshadow the rest of the story. The plot in this book was just as strong as it was in the first book but Carole Cummings managed to use certain events to show just how much Dallin and Wil complimented and cared for each other. By doing that Cummings kept the romance from being pushed to the background. Bravo!
It's hard to review this book without giving any spoilers, so I'm going to end with this: Read. This. Series. Carole Cummings is an author whose work will bowl you over, dazzle you and leave you begging for more.
Now, the first book in this series was brilliant. It was pure fantasy and everything about it was perfect. Aisling Book One did not have any romance though, or rather it had a hint of it but that was all. I knew the second book in the series would probably incorporate romance and I was prepared for Book Two to be a little uneven and not shine quite as brightly as Book One. I had nothing to fear.
Aisling Book Two was beyond amazing. Anyone who is thinking about writing a fantasy/romance novel needs to read this book because Aisling Book Two is a perfect example of how things should be done.
Book Two picks up right where Book One left off. In this book Dallin and Wil new challenges, both internal and external, and many of the questions from Book One are answered in the second installment of the series. There is alot of character growth that happens in this book and as Wil and Dallin grow as individuals their relationship also evolves. It was wonderful to see Wil and Dallin solidify their bond. The romance was there in this book but at no point did it overshadow the rest of the story. The plot in this book was just as strong as it was in the first book but Carole Cummings managed to use certain events to show just how much Dallin and Wil complimented and cared for each other. By doing that Cummings kept the romance from being pushed to the background. Bravo!
It's hard to review this book without giving any spoilers, so I'm going to end with this: Read. This. Series. Carole Cummings is an author whose work will bowl you over, dazzle you and leave you begging for more.
August 3, 2016
Things I loved...
Dallin's acceptance of who he was and what he was meant to do, what he could do. Even more, the way he saw Wil.
"...You take hold of every single thing in your grasp and value it, things I’ve taken for granted my whole life and never had the first clue were precious...You’re not odd—you’re just who you are and I think you’ve done bloody well, for all you’ve been through."
Wil's growing trust in Dallin, and his ability to adjust to a new reality. Also, his love of food.
And…” Wil squirmed a little. “Well… He made me skillet cakes,” was all he offered by way of excuse, perhaps even slightly accusatory
The bits of humor were a welcome relief from the darker elements of the story.
I had some issues with the writing...
-Some abrupt/confusing scene transitions
-One or two internal reflections that dragged a bit
-Word choices in Wil's narration that didn't always fit his character
...that kept this from being 5 stars, but the characters and their story made this so worth the read.
On to the next!
Dallin's acceptance of who he was and what he was meant to do, what he could do. Even more, the way he saw Wil.
"...You take hold of every single thing in your grasp and value it, things I’ve taken for granted my whole life and never had the first clue were precious...You’re not odd—you’re just who you are and I think you’ve done bloody well, for all you’ve been through."
Wil's growing trust in Dallin, and his ability to adjust to a new reality. Also, his love of food.
And…” Wil squirmed a little. “Well… He made me skillet cakes,” was all he offered by way of excuse, perhaps even slightly accusatory
The bits of humor were a welcome relief from the darker elements of the story.
I had some issues with the writing...
-Some abrupt/confusing scene transitions
-One or two internal reflections that dragged a bit
-Word choices in Wil's narration that didn't always fit his character
...that kept this from being 5 stars, but the characters and their story made this so worth the read.
On to the next!
June 19, 2011
Confession time. I have Aisling Book 1: Guardian in print (signed copy occupying a place of honor on my bookshelf), so decided to get a print copy of this sequel. All well and good until its actual release. Impatient to read the next chapters in Wil and Dallin's lives, I also bought it in ebook. And finished it. I will re-read when my print copy arrives.
Oh, my! What an exquisitely written book! Carole Cummings takes words I'd never think to put together and weaves them into a riveting tale that I couldn't put down. The characters are as real as they come, with world building so intense you can almost smell the campfire and peer at the two protagonists across its glow.
How is it possible for someone to write interaction between two characters in which they're simply crossing a wood, stretch it out for pages, and hold the reader's rapt attention to every little twig-snap or horse nicker? As this novel is classified as young adult, the intimate details are kept mostly off-page, and yet what we see is as hot as it gets. Wil and Dallin's first kiss had me IMing a friend who's already read this just to share my joy.
The writing is starkly beautiful through and through, and I couldn't recommend Aisling 2: Dream any higher. Bravo Carole Cummings, for creating a book that reminds me why I was such an avid reader in my teens.
My only disappointment is that now I have to wait until December to read the conclusion. Oh well, I'll have re-read books one and two several times by then, I'm sure.
Oh, my! What an exquisitely written book! Carole Cummings takes words I'd never think to put together and weaves them into a riveting tale that I couldn't put down. The characters are as real as they come, with world building so intense you can almost smell the campfire and peer at the two protagonists across its glow.
How is it possible for someone to write interaction between two characters in which they're simply crossing a wood, stretch it out for pages, and hold the reader's rapt attention to every little twig-snap or horse nicker? As this novel is classified as young adult, the intimate details are kept mostly off-page, and yet what we see is as hot as it gets. Wil and Dallin's first kiss had me IMing a friend who's already read this just to share my joy.
The writing is starkly beautiful through and through, and I couldn't recommend Aisling 2: Dream any higher. Bravo Carole Cummings, for creating a book that reminds me why I was such an avid reader in my teens.
My only disappointment is that now I have to wait until December to read the conclusion. Oh well, I'll have re-read books one and two several times by then, I'm sure.
November 30, 2011
This book is the second in the series, but unlike some middle books, it steps up both the adventure and the romance. Dallin and Wil move together in a way that is teeth-grindingly slow and yet exactly right. And watching Wil lean on Dallin now and then is sweet and satisfying. The tension is mounting, the ending is still not an ending, I'm completely hooked, and the next one had better be out soon!
September 6, 2016
*HERE THERE BE SPOILERS*
"Aisling: Dream" is the second part of marvelous epic story about a fascinating world and the engaging and complex characters, and deities, which populate that world. "Dream", being the second book in a trilogy, doesn't suffer from it, but stands, if not alone, then firmly in its place, satisfying completely and yet keeping the reader wishing for the last book, due out in December.
We get a good deal more here of world-building than we had in the first book, Carole holding back a lot of details there in order to show these two fabulous characters – Dallin and Wil – coping with exactly that same situation – not knowing enough either about each other or about their own predicament until circumstance and dawning respect gradually brought growing trust and eventually – friendship.
In the second book, delightfully, we also get even more of the developing relationship between Dallin and Wil. What I really love about Carole's writing is the way that she weaves humor into what could be a very dark story. Wil, especially, with his tormented past, is an old soul with the heart of a child and his humor reveals that childlike quality. For example, when upset with Dallin, Wil thinks of him as "Stupid-picky-bossy Constable Brayden" and when trying to cope with his own physical weakness after a devastating, and nearly fatal, incident thinks of himself as "Swooning. Swooning. Like a…like a…swooning…thing."
Watching their relationship gradually build as they make their way cross country and hide out in the cellars of the Temple, is delightful. This exchange is a good example of the banter between these two:
"I thought I was a vicious little shit," he muttered.
"You are," Brayden said simply …"But you say it like it's a bad thing."
Carole keeps the physical side of their relationship "off camera", other than a gorgeous, sensual kiss or two, but that doesn't keep the characters from thinking about what went on "off camera" in language that is sensuous and hot and has nothing to do with sex and everything to do with Carole's superb use of words.
The plot is fascinating and involved and very much reflects the real life intrigues and machinations which would surround a spiritual and political prize like the Aisling. There are moments in the plot that have you standing and cheering and then almost immediately gasping with dismay. And Carole pulls no punches when she skillfully leads you to understand that the most creepy, slimy, downright evil bad guy you can think of (and you have been hating for who knows how many pages) is NOT the ultimate foe here, which makes you shudder to think what, or who, could be more evil than that.
Carole's writing is amazing. Just as some artists take paints and create Campbell soup cans and call it art and some take paints and create masterpieces that take your breath away, Carole is definitely up there with the masters in the way she uses words to paint gorgeous, intricate pictures – works of art that have layers and layers of meaning and make you come back again and again to study them.
It is exciting to know we have one more book in this series to look forward to and, if you visit Carole's website, to find that we have an entire new series called "Wolf's-own" to look forward to as well (as soon as a savvy publisher snatches it up!)
Bravo Carole!
"Aisling: Dream" is the second part of marvelous epic story about a fascinating world and the engaging and complex characters, and deities, which populate that world. "Dream", being the second book in a trilogy, doesn't suffer from it, but stands, if not alone, then firmly in its place, satisfying completely and yet keeping the reader wishing for the last book, due out in December.
We get a good deal more here of world-building than we had in the first book, Carole holding back a lot of details there in order to show these two fabulous characters – Dallin and Wil – coping with exactly that same situation – not knowing enough either about each other or about their own predicament until circumstance and dawning respect gradually brought growing trust and eventually – friendship.
In the second book, delightfully, we also get even more of the developing relationship between Dallin and Wil. What I really love about Carole's writing is the way that she weaves humor into what could be a very dark story. Wil, especially, with his tormented past, is an old soul with the heart of a child and his humor reveals that childlike quality. For example, when upset with Dallin, Wil thinks of him as "Stupid-picky-bossy Constable Brayden" and when trying to cope with his own physical weakness after a devastating, and nearly fatal, incident thinks of himself as "Swooning. Swooning. Like a…like a…swooning…thing."
Watching their relationship gradually build as they make their way cross country and hide out in the cellars of the Temple, is delightful. This exchange is a good example of the banter between these two:
"I thought I was a vicious little shit," he muttered.
"You are," Brayden said simply …"But you say it like it's a bad thing."
Carole keeps the physical side of their relationship "off camera", other than a gorgeous, sensual kiss or two, but that doesn't keep the characters from thinking about what went on "off camera" in language that is sensuous and hot and has nothing to do with sex and everything to do with Carole's superb use of words.
The plot is fascinating and involved and very much reflects the real life intrigues and machinations which would surround a spiritual and political prize like the Aisling. There are moments in the plot that have you standing and cheering and then almost immediately gasping with dismay. And Carole pulls no punches when she skillfully leads you to understand that the most creepy, slimy, downright evil bad guy you can think of (and you have been hating for who knows how many pages) is NOT the ultimate foe here, which makes you shudder to think what, or who, could be more evil than that.
Carole's writing is amazing. Just as some artists take paints and create Campbell soup cans and call it art and some take paints and create masterpieces that take your breath away, Carole is definitely up there with the masters in the way she uses words to paint gorgeous, intricate pictures – works of art that have layers and layers of meaning and make you come back again and again to study them.
It is exciting to know we have one more book in this series to look forward to and, if you visit Carole's website, to find that we have an entire new series called "Wolf's-own" to look forward to as well (as soon as a savvy publisher snatches it up!)
Bravo Carole!
June 17, 2011
I have to wait six months for the final part? To borrow the language of Wil and Dallin, BLOODY HELL!
The world-building is one of the pillars of good fantasy and, usually, one of the first things that should be addressed when reviewing the fantasy book. But, I'll tell you this: I would read any book in which Wil and Dallin are protagonists, whether it was contemporary, historical, horror or - fantasy novel. Because, they are embodiment of what well-written, three-dimensional characters should be. They are original and unique and, yet, carry the universal truths with them. Wil is that face of humanity that overcomes the direst of circumstances (of birth, one's social standing, strength, etc.), that goes against all odds and triumphs over inhumanly strong opposition without loosing the human soul. Dallin is that part of us that protects the good and right and weak against the world set to destroy them without any thought for personal well-being or consequences. At the same time, they are hardly infallible, because, yes, Wil is a vicious little shit and Dallin can be an arrogant ass. Do I need to say that I adore them?
This book - exploded. The cryptic prophecies, half-information, half-forgotten personal histories from the first book broke open to show us what lies behind them. The world finally got its (almost) complete shape and Wil and Dallin are coming into their own. They are embracing their new powers, tentative trust and - each other. It was beautiful to read how they changed from one page to the next, while still remaining Wil and Dallin.
The writing is simply beautiful and it's admirable how Ms. Cummings holds all the threads of the story. Seeing how some of them from the first book found their fruition in this one, I can't wait to see what else she has prepared for us, not to mention for Wil and Dallin. The gentle humor counterbalanced more difficult parts of the book and we were introduced to the secondary characters that could play important part in the final book. I was hesitant to give the first book five stars because I felt that the world-building was incomplete. It still isn't entirely complete, but that simply isn't good enough reason to lower the rating of this book. I don't know why this book isn't in the hands of some mainstream publisher, but - respect for Prizm/Torquere for embracing this gem. Five stars!
December?! BLOODY HELL!
The world-building is one of the pillars of good fantasy and, usually, one of the first things that should be addressed when reviewing the fantasy book. But, I'll tell you this: I would read any book in which Wil and Dallin are protagonists, whether it was contemporary, historical, horror or - fantasy novel. Because, they are embodiment of what well-written, three-dimensional characters should be. They are original and unique and, yet, carry the universal truths with them. Wil is that face of humanity that overcomes the direst of circumstances (of birth, one's social standing, strength, etc.), that goes against all odds and triumphs over inhumanly strong opposition without loosing the human soul. Dallin is that part of us that protects the good and right and weak against the world set to destroy them without any thought for personal well-being or consequences. At the same time, they are hardly infallible, because, yes, Wil is a vicious little shit and Dallin can be an arrogant ass. Do I need to say that I adore them?
This book - exploded. The cryptic prophecies, half-information, half-forgotten personal histories from the first book broke open to show us what lies behind them. The world finally got its (almost) complete shape and Wil and Dallin are coming into their own. They are embracing their new powers, tentative trust and - each other. It was beautiful to read how they changed from one page to the next, while still remaining Wil and Dallin.
The writing is simply beautiful and it's admirable how Ms. Cummings holds all the threads of the story. Seeing how some of them from the first book found their fruition in this one, I can't wait to see what else she has prepared for us, not to mention for Wil and Dallin. The gentle humor counterbalanced more difficult parts of the book and we were introduced to the secondary characters that could play important part in the final book. I was hesitant to give the first book five stars because I felt that the world-building was incomplete. It still isn't entirely complete, but that simply isn't good enough reason to lower the rating of this book. I don't know why this book isn't in the hands of some mainstream publisher, but - respect for Prizm/Torquere for embracing this gem. Five stars!
December?! BLOODY HELL!
December 5, 2011
Re-read time
This book is still utterly amazing, even the second time around. Usually when I re-read I skip over some of the background because I have been there done that. Not with this book. I just read every word again. There is nothing to skip, it is all great and honestly, this one is better than the first one. How the story progresses is fascinating, the characters growth is amazing (and lets face it Dallin and Will are just too cute for words) and the story just makes you want to pounce on the third book. Cannot wait!!!
This book is still utterly amazing, even the second time around. Usually when I re-read I skip over some of the background because I have been there done that. Not with this book. I just read every word again. There is nothing to skip, it is all great and honestly, this one is better than the first one. How the story progresses is fascinating, the characters growth is amazing (and lets face it Dallin and Will are just too cute for words) and the story just makes you want to pounce on the third book. Cannot wait!!!
July 27, 2011
Oh, man I loved this. In this second part of the trilogy, characters are deepened and evolved,trust is made and broken, and relationships between people,and between people and deities delved into. The external action speeds up -- something that I've been chanting for since the middle of Book 1 happens, and all in all, I was more than happy to read the entire book a second time, and probably will again when Book 3 comes out, just to have it fresh in mind for the climax of the story.
October 19, 2017
A Joyfully Jay review.
4.75 stars
Dream is the direct sequel to Guardian and the second in the Aisling series. These books MUST be read in order. Dream picks up only moments after we leave Wil and Dallin in Guardian. The two have come to a tentative understanding and acceptance of one another but it’s a fragile thing. Their relationship evolves dramatically over the course of the book and it’s really the driving pulse behind the plot. Wil and Dallin each have to confront their purpose and embrace it. As readers we know that something big is coming and that time is running out. The author does an excellent job of building tension without ratcheting it up to ridiculous proportions. Wil really comes into his own with Dream. He’s still confused and a bit wild and always on the verge of a breakdown, but his strength is more evident and his ability to move beyond his past makes him admirable. Dallin has accepted his place as Wil’s Guardian, but without training he’s fumbling in the dark. His devotion to Wil is endearing and one of my favorite aspects of the book.
There is a chaos to this series that a reader has to accept before they can understand and enjoy the story. And that’s easier said than done. But our confusion mirrors Wil’s and as he comes to understand the truth of himself, so do we. There are long dream sequences that end up impacting later scenes and as a reader you have to pay attention. That seems like a silly thing to say, but sometimes we just want to read and relax and let our minds wander. There are lots of great books that allow that, but Dream and the Aisling series demand more. And it is more than worth the effort.
Read Sue’s review in its entirety here.
4.75 stars
Dream is the direct sequel to Guardian and the second in the Aisling series. These books MUST be read in order. Dream picks up only moments after we leave Wil and Dallin in Guardian. The two have come to a tentative understanding and acceptance of one another but it’s a fragile thing. Their relationship evolves dramatically over the course of the book and it’s really the driving pulse behind the plot. Wil and Dallin each have to confront their purpose and embrace it. As readers we know that something big is coming and that time is running out. The author does an excellent job of building tension without ratcheting it up to ridiculous proportions. Wil really comes into his own with Dream. He’s still confused and a bit wild and always on the verge of a breakdown, but his strength is more evident and his ability to move beyond his past makes him admirable. Dallin has accepted his place as Wil’s Guardian, but without training he’s fumbling in the dark. His devotion to Wil is endearing and one of my favorite aspects of the book.
There is a chaos to this series that a reader has to accept before they can understand and enjoy the story. And that’s easier said than done. But our confusion mirrors Wil’s and as he comes to understand the truth of himself, so do we. There are long dream sequences that end up impacting later scenes and as a reader you have to pay attention. That seems like a silly thing to say, but sometimes we just want to read and relax and let our minds wander. There are lots of great books that allow that, but Dream and the Aisling series demand more. And it is more than worth the effort.
Read Sue’s review in its entirety here.
November 1, 2017
It Just Gets Better and Better
I am enjoying this series tremendously. The world-building is getting more comprehensive, questions are being answered, relationships are developing, and the guys are learning more about themselves and each other every day. This is kind of a feudal/historical/fantasy world Cummings is building here with some paranormal elements to it and not in your genre-typical vamps and shifters kind of way, but inasmuch as magic is a part of the everyday world. Even if a vast majority of the 'common folk' in the diverse societies don't get to see it much, powerful forces are at work. The Dreamer is Dreaming and the Watcher is Watching.
The Aisling (Wil) and his Guardian (Dallin Brayden) are at the top of that particular heap of magical shit, which is what it is as the situation currently sits. Politics, fanatics, abuse and forced unwarranted imprisonment, murder and mayhem, conspiracy, mystery, and mysticism ... events have thus far conspired against the pair. They're largely having to figure out everything for themselves since they can't trust anyone around them not to have their own agenda. It is a stewpot of intrigue and likely to get worse before it gets better. What sacrifices will be made along the way and will they both come out on the other side? Who knows? But I want to be there for the rest of the ride.
Other reviews by NeRdyWYRM can be read here.
Images (if present) may be subject to copyright
Galley copy of Dream (Aisling Trilogy, #2) provided by Dreamspinner Press in exchange of an honest review.
I am enjoying this series tremendously. The world-building is getting more comprehensive, questions are being answered, relationships are developing, and the guys are learning more about themselves and each other every day. This is kind of a feudal/historical/fantasy world Cummings is building here with some paranormal elements to it and not in your genre-typical vamps and shifters kind of way, but inasmuch as magic is a part of the everyday world. Even if a vast majority of the 'common folk' in the diverse societies don't get to see it much, powerful forces are at work. The Dreamer is Dreaming and the Watcher is Watching.
The Aisling (Wil) and his Guardian (Dallin Brayden) are at the top of that particular heap of magical shit, which is what it is as the situation currently sits. Politics, fanatics, abuse and forced unwarranted imprisonment, murder and mayhem, conspiracy, mystery, and mysticism ... events have thus far conspired against the pair. They're largely having to figure out everything for themselves since they can't trust anyone around them not to have their own agenda. It is a stewpot of intrigue and likely to get worse before it gets better. What sacrifices will be made along the way and will they both come out on the other side? Who knows? But I want to be there for the rest of the ride.
Other reviews by NeRdyWYRM can be read here.
Images (if present) may be subject to copyright
Galley copy of Dream (Aisling Trilogy, #2) provided by Dreamspinner Press in exchange of an honest review.
August 3, 2011
It's been worth the wait – the second installment of Carole Cummings' Aisling trilogy is out, at last. I've been going nuts waiting to find out what's happened to Wil and Dallin since I finished Part 1. Aisling Book One: Guardian was a 5 star read and Part Two: Dream is every bit as good.
This is definitely a continuation of the story – the narrative picks up where it left off, and you'll be confused for a while without the advantage (pleasure) of reading Guardian. Wil and Dallin have reached a place of tenuous safety and have a breath or two to assess what they have been through, but hardly more than that, and then dangers start again. Since Wil and Dallin are coming only slowly to an understanding of one another, small things could escalate to grave danger with no trouble at all. A few secondary characters come to add to this, and the sick edge of distrust taints every small advance to truth.
Dream is a book of reversals – what was a flight and pursuit becomes a pilgrimage of sorts, what were enemies become something both more and less than friends and lovers, fear becomes trust, and yes, trust does become doubt. By the end of the book, very little is as it started, and the changes are perfectly plotted and in character.
Dallin and Wil themselves come to a better accord and a somewhat better understanding – this is an evolving relationship. They do come together sexually in a scene that is a brilliant "fuzz to dark gray" that manages to be one of the all time sexiest scenes I've ever read. Of course, after that, Wil needs a good sharp slap, but rethinks things before I can give it to him. Love Wil, poor scarred man/boy who holds keys he doesn't understand. Love Dallin, too, and want Wil to find the wholeness to love him as much as I do, and yet... this adventure is not over.
The language is at turns poignant and pointed – we yearn for Wil to see a river as much as Dallin yearns to show it to him, and somehow a river becomes a wider world much safer than any they've lived in so far. Simple actions and wishes become astonishing in her descriptions – the words are the words of English but the stringing together is – magic.
This segment climaxes in a moment that brought me to tears; Wil extracts a promise so heartbreaking in its trust, love, and horror that I'm fogging up again just typing. I want Part Three so bad I can taste it, and the publisher is making me wait for months yet. December, I am told; that's so far away.
This is definitely a continuation of the story – the narrative picks up where it left off, and you'll be confused for a while without the advantage (pleasure) of reading Guardian. Wil and Dallin have reached a place of tenuous safety and have a breath or two to assess what they have been through, but hardly more than that, and then dangers start again. Since Wil and Dallin are coming only slowly to an understanding of one another, small things could escalate to grave danger with no trouble at all. A few secondary characters come to add to this, and the sick edge of distrust taints every small advance to truth.
Dream is a book of reversals – what was a flight and pursuit becomes a pilgrimage of sorts, what were enemies become something both more and less than friends and lovers, fear becomes trust, and yes, trust does become doubt. By the end of the book, very little is as it started, and the changes are perfectly plotted and in character.
Dallin and Wil themselves come to a better accord and a somewhat better understanding – this is an evolving relationship. They do come together sexually in a scene that is a brilliant "fuzz to dark gray" that manages to be one of the all time sexiest scenes I've ever read. Of course, after that, Wil needs a good sharp slap, but rethinks things before I can give it to him. Love Wil, poor scarred man/boy who holds keys he doesn't understand. Love Dallin, too, and want Wil to find the wholeness to love him as much as I do, and yet... this adventure is not over.
The language is at turns poignant and pointed – we yearn for Wil to see a river as much as Dallin yearns to show it to him, and somehow a river becomes a wider world much safer than any they've lived in so far. Simple actions and wishes become astonishing in her descriptions – the words are the words of English but the stringing together is – magic.
This segment climaxes in a moment that brought me to tears; Wil extracts a promise so heartbreaking in its trust, love, and horror that I'm fogging up again just typing. I want Part Three so bad I can taste it, and the publisher is making me wait for months yet. December, I am told; that's so far away.
Read
April 1, 2012It’s a slow placed travel that we are doing with this series by Carole Cummings. And not really since the main characters are actually doing a real and self-discovering travel, but also since, book after book, Carole Cummings is also building their relationship, but she is doing that by little steps, not rushing it, taking and giving time to the readers to adapt to this evolution. In this points you really realize this is a Young Adult novel, it’s like the author is telling to this young mind, guys, you have time, don’t rush into anything you are not ready for.
Said that, where, if I remember well, in the first book there was really no romantic relationship between Wil and Dallin, or at least nothing that was open and fully acknowledge, in book two they shared some intimate moments that make it clear they are heading towards a love story.
As always, I’m concentrating on the “romance” more than on other aspects of the story, but truth be told, this is really a Coming of Age story, with Wil doing his own travel, from being a boy to being a man, but also from being barely aware of his power and destiny to little by little taking his own destiny in hand (and right in the last sentence I think there is a good metaphor on this point). Also Dallin is doing his own travel, but it’s more a self-discovery travel, all inside himself: Will is moving from one step to another, Dallin is more trying to understand the step in which he is already on.
The Aisling series is a quite complex world building, but it’s not heavy setting; the author is playing more with the characters and their evolution than the world around them. It’s not a big bum bang plot, and that is probably why, even if mainly aimed to a YA target, also an adult reader will appreciate it, actually I think they will find something that a teenager will probably not focus on. This novel is like some of those eye trick paintings that, according to who is looking at them, will communicate different perceptions.
http://www.amazon.com/dp/1610402413/?...
Said that, where, if I remember well, in the first book there was really no romantic relationship between Wil and Dallin, or at least nothing that was open and fully acknowledge, in book two they shared some intimate moments that make it clear they are heading towards a love story.
As always, I’m concentrating on the “romance” more than on other aspects of the story, but truth be told, this is really a Coming of Age story, with Wil doing his own travel, from being a boy to being a man, but also from being barely aware of his power and destiny to little by little taking his own destiny in hand (and right in the last sentence I think there is a good metaphor on this point). Also Dallin is doing his own travel, but it’s more a self-discovery travel, all inside himself: Will is moving from one step to another, Dallin is more trying to understand the step in which he is already on.
The Aisling series is a quite complex world building, but it’s not heavy setting; the author is playing more with the characters and their evolution than the world around them. It’s not a big bum bang plot, and that is probably why, even if mainly aimed to a YA target, also an adult reader will appreciate it, actually I think they will find something that a teenager will probably not focus on. This novel is like some of those eye trick paintings that, according to who is looking at them, will communicate different perceptions.
http://www.amazon.com/dp/1610402413/?...
January 13, 2018
(Originally reviewed for Love Bytes Reviews.)
Here we are with the second of three installments in this series. The blurb on this one tells you a lot about the story, so I’m not going to give you much on that end. I’ll start by saying that I’m really enjoying this story, and the development of both Dallin’s and Wil’s characters, as well as the new characters we meet along the way in this installment. I liked how the author brought the characters into contact with the real Wilfred Calder’s family members, and I can’t wait to see where that will all lead.
Both Dallin and Wil are developing their powers, and things are really heating up. There is still a lot to be revealed, and I’m really curious to see where the author is going from here. I would recommend this one, but caution that you have to read the first book before you read this one. They flow directly into each other, as will book three.
I’ve got to keep it honest and tell you that while I’m really enjoying the books, I do have a minor peeve. I really didn’t like the sudden cut off in this particular one. It seemed to end almost mid-sentence. Now I’m going to have to wait for the next one to come out…in December!
Rant complete. I’ll forgive the author the cliffhanger. As I said above, I’m enjoying the series and look forward to the third and final chapter in the series.
Here we are with the second of three installments in this series. The blurb on this one tells you a lot about the story, so I’m not going to give you much on that end. I’ll start by saying that I’m really enjoying this story, and the development of both Dallin’s and Wil’s characters, as well as the new characters we meet along the way in this installment. I liked how the author brought the characters into contact with the real Wilfred Calder’s family members, and I can’t wait to see where that will all lead.
Both Dallin and Wil are developing their powers, and things are really heating up. There is still a lot to be revealed, and I’m really curious to see where the author is going from here. I would recommend this one, but caution that you have to read the first book before you read this one. They flow directly into each other, as will book three.
I’ve got to keep it honest and tell you that while I’m really enjoying the books, I do have a minor peeve. I really didn’t like the sudden cut off in this particular one. It seemed to end almost mid-sentence. Now I’m going to have to wait for the next one to come out…in December!
Rant complete. I’ll forgive the author the cliffhanger. As I said above, I’m enjoying the series and look forward to the third and final chapter in the series.
November 20, 2012
I am really very fond of Carole Cummings' intensely character-focused style. It and I are muy simpatico. :-) I am not as invested in this plot or this world as I was with her Wolf's-Own series, and I am still intensely irritated at the way she fails to include a complete story arc in any one of her book installments -- these are really three fragments of one serialized novel rather than three novels in a series -- but I can forgive a lot of gripes for the sake of her character work.
I also find the extensive similarities between Wil and Jacin (from Wolf's-Own) to be very very interesting. Cummings obviously has a lot invested in this type of character, and I just wonder if her next book will include another of the same type. It's okay with me if it does -- I've enjoyed reading both characters -- but it's interesting to see such a distinct character type repeated across two series.
I also find the extensive similarities between Wil and Jacin (from Wolf's-Own) to be very very interesting. Cummings obviously has a lot invested in this type of character, and I just wonder if her next book will include another of the same type. It's okay with me if it does -- I've enjoyed reading both characters -- but it's interesting to see such a distinct character type repeated across two series.
June 18, 2016
This book could've been so good if it wasn't bogged down in useless narrative all the bloody time. The first 10% or so of this is pretty much just Dallin's thoughts, and Dallin suddenly doing a 180 and telling Wil about how amazing etc it is. He just starts believing in all the dream/myth stuff so quickly and so fervently, it doesn't come across as legit.
This book is so big on telling and not showing. There were SO MANY words spent on how awesome Wil is, it just got ridiculous. It's so annoying how much I loved 'Blue on Black' by this same author, yet the two other books I've tried from her have been duds.
Sadly, I just don't have the patience to continue with this, and I would've really liked to have seen the romance actually start!
This book is so big on telling and not showing. There were SO MANY words spent on how awesome Wil is, it just got ridiculous. It's so annoying how much I loved 'Blue on Black' by this same author, yet the two other books I've tried from her have been duds.
Sadly, I just don't have the patience to continue with this, and I would've really liked to have seen the romance actually start!
July 28, 2011
This second part of interesting story, was way better for my piece of mind, but then it was mostly because Dallin and Wilfred started to work with each other and for each other. I liked the atmosphere and their verbal interaction. It was fun! The story ends in middle of action, which is a bit annoying, but I will gladly wait for more. Thanks for interesting read!!
September 4, 2011
I found this second book weaker than the first one. At some stages even a bit boring. There was too much internal dialogue of the MCs, and not all of it rang believable. The long dreams, in part with explanation, were... too long. To say that the end is abrupt is an euphemism.
I'm not yet sure if I'm going to read the third part.
July 4, 2011
I started this book, and "Dream" didn't dissapoint. The characters feel alive, and the storyline continues to surprise in a really good way. We know a little more about the world of Aisling. In a word, brilliant.
July 27, 2011
This story continues to enthrall me and hold me in the palm of its hand. I am in love with the setting, the mythology, the politics, and especially the characters. The only downside to this book is that it ended. An absolute great read.
November 28, 2011
I am sooo glad I decided to read the second book in this series right away, rather than let the first book bring me down a little. SO MUCH BETTER. Consider me another convert to Wil and Dallin. Bring on Book 3!
January 26, 2013
This one didn't quite reach the excellence of the first, but it got really close.
More drama + more action = a little less focus on the development of the relationship between Dallin and Wil, but a whole lot of entertainment! =D
More drama + more action = a little less focus on the development of the relationship between Dallin and Wil, but a whole lot of entertainment! =D
August 19, 2011
Awesome book. Loved the well drawn characters particularly Will's nature and Brayden's sturdiness. I can't wait for the third book to see how the the story will play out.
May 23, 2019
4.5 stars, but I might bump this up to 5 in the future. This was SO GOOD. Basically everything I was hoping for romance-wise after the set-up in the first book. The development between Wil and Dallin was just perfect. I loved them starting off with Wil beginning to learn to trust Dallin, and Dallin still learning how to deal with Wil, and how they slowly come to work together and be on each other's side and support one another. I adored the moment early on when Wil was like, "Listen, if it comes down to it, I'm going to choose me over you. I will save myself," and Dallin's like, "Yeah, of course, I understand that," because the second he says that, you KNOW it's going to end up not being true. I am a total sucker for that trope, so it made me happy to see it here, and of course later on I also loved Dallin overhearing Wil talking about starting to trust him and how he recognizes what a big deal that is. Anyways, besides the romance stuff, I also adored Wil being like, "Horses are annoying, I don't like them for all these reasons," and Dallin being like, "Everything you're saying about them just means they love you," and then Wil ending up getting attached and NAMING them and not wanting to leave/sell them. Everything with the horses was great. Also I guess there was some plot in this, but I will admit that that wasn't really my focus here. I mean, it was interesting, just… not my main interest.
March 3, 2018
Review can be read at It's About The Book
This felt like a middle book to a trilogy. We learn a lot in this book but there’s obviously so much more to come. Some things come full circle and then new paths are set. We finally learn what Dallin and Wil truly are. There’s much more to figure out though so don’t think it ends here. The ending feels very much like a cliffhanger. They do battle one of their foes in this book but the journey and fight are far from over. We’ve yet to realize just what’s waiting for them. Wil and Dallin know they have to face much more before the end.
The good thing is they have each other now which is more than Wil has ever had. The guys are on the run for the entirety of this book. This forces their friendship, trust and feelings to escalate. Wil is still working on letting his defenses down. He also has to let go of lies he’s been brainwashed into believing are real. Dallin is a rock. He’s pledged to give his life if needed for Wil. He hopes it doesn’t come to either of their deaths but the danger is real and around every corner. Together they both are forced to face their destinies and embrace the gifts or burdens depending how you look at it.
We meet some interesting characters in this book. Wil and Dallin are backed into a corner and have to try and accept help at times. I found myself skeptical of everyone just as Wil would be. Although the guys are in constant danger this book was a bit slower paced IMO. There’s a lot of conversations between Wil and Dallin which are necessary. There is quite a bit of action at times also. I’m really looking forward to the next book. I can’t say I completely understand what’s happening but I have a pretty good idea. I’m looking forward to all the pieces coming together.
This felt like a middle book to a trilogy. We learn a lot in this book but there’s obviously so much more to come. Some things come full circle and then new paths are set. We finally learn what Dallin and Wil truly are. There’s much more to figure out though so don’t think it ends here. The ending feels very much like a cliffhanger. They do battle one of their foes in this book but the journey and fight are far from over. We’ve yet to realize just what’s waiting for them. Wil and Dallin know they have to face much more before the end.
The good thing is they have each other now which is more than Wil has ever had. The guys are on the run for the entirety of this book. This forces their friendship, trust and feelings to escalate. Wil is still working on letting his defenses down. He also has to let go of lies he’s been brainwashed into believing are real. Dallin is a rock. He’s pledged to give his life if needed for Wil. He hopes it doesn’t come to either of their deaths but the danger is real and around every corner. Together they both are forced to face their destinies and embrace the gifts or burdens depending how you look at it.
We meet some interesting characters in this book. Wil and Dallin are backed into a corner and have to try and accept help at times. I found myself skeptical of everyone just as Wil would be. Although the guys are in constant danger this book was a bit slower paced IMO. There’s a lot of conversations between Wil and Dallin which are necessary. There is quite a bit of action at times also. I’m really looking forward to the next book. I can’t say I completely understand what’s happening but I have a pretty good idea. I’m looking forward to all the pieces coming together.
July 28, 2021
How does one even describe this book? Wil and Dallin finally grow closer, their adversarial relationship turning to friendship and more. Both of them begin to trust the other and even learn to lean on the other one.
Looking for answers, they get caught up in the intrigue and danger following Wil. More and more of the myths around the Aisling and Guardian come out in this book. Both of them discover power that they didn't know they had. There were parts I had to reread to understand the myths and their impact on Wil and Dallin through mythical imagery. The action was intense and had me breathless at times.
The book is definitely a continuation of Guardian and Beloved Son will pick up where this one leaves off. So glad I have that one ready to go.
Looking for answers, they get caught up in the intrigue and danger following Wil. More and more of the myths around the Aisling and Guardian come out in this book. Both of them discover power that they didn't know they had. There were parts I had to reread to understand the myths and their impact on Wil and Dallin through mythical imagery. The action was intense and had me breathless at times.
The book is definitely a continuation of Guardian and Beloved Son will pick up where this one leaves off. So glad I have that one ready to go.
October 17, 2017
A Scattered Thoughts and Rogue Words Review
Rating: 5 stars out of 5
For the full review, visit http://wp.me/p220KL-bU8
From that review: " The world building Cummings starting in Guardian (Aisling, #1) becomes even more complex and wide ranging, crossing lands and picking up cultures and peoples we had only heard about in the first novel. Mirroring the complexity of the world building is the relationship and personal dynamics between Wil and Dallin. From enemies to friends and now the slow move into a romantic relationship, Cummings has been careful to establish the necessary trust and communication that let's this happen between them. I love the slow courtship between the men. Considering all Wil has been through, the slow emotional involvement that the physical one also implies makes perfect sense..."
For all our reviews, author interviews and such, visit us at http://scatteredthoughtsandroguewords...
Rating: 5 stars out of 5
For the full review, visit http://wp.me/p220KL-bU8
From that review: " The world building Cummings starting in Guardian (Aisling, #1) becomes even more complex and wide ranging, crossing lands and picking up cultures and peoples we had only heard about in the first novel. Mirroring the complexity of the world building is the relationship and personal dynamics between Wil and Dallin. From enemies to friends and now the slow move into a romantic relationship, Cummings has been careful to establish the necessary trust and communication that let's this happen between them. I love the slow courtship between the men. Considering all Wil has been through, the slow emotional involvement that the physical one also implies makes perfect sense..."
For all our reviews, author interviews and such, visit us at http://scatteredthoughtsandroguewords...
Displaying 1 - 30 of 64 reviews