Up to chapter 6. It's very irritating that after chapter 4, there are no vocabulary lists provided, and you have to use the dictionary at the back! That's why I gave it 3 stars and not 4.
It's just after annoying verbs are introduced that add random vowels onto the front of certain tenses, so you look up an e- verb and find it isn't one at all! Grrr! Not helpful.
However there is a great sense of reward at working out a translation and realising you've got it right! Still going! It's oddly fascinating.
I've got a hold of a much older edition by F Kinchin Smith, and it's very curious that about half of that book used New Testament and biblical examples for translation and as a considerable help in developing the learner's vocabulary. Lots of contextual examples, like how the ancient Greek word Chrestos (good, useful) came to be used for Jesus, etc. it actually helps with learning vocabulary, (even though I'm not religiously inclined myself.)
I'm sure there are differences between the most Ancient Greek and Greek of the first couple of centuries AD, but to the interested amateur, they aren't hugely relevant. I am surprised at the total absence of anything biblical in this book though, as it's a legitimate development of the language.
(Later - apparently they brought out a different book purely concentrating on New Testament Greek. A pity really, because a variety of sources is interesting in itself, and a purely biblical book sounds dry)
If you do want a TY book to help with both biblical studies and ancient greek writers, try to get a hold of the older edition. I got mine at Amnesty books for 50p. Plus, it's miles better at developing your vocabulary and gentler on the pace of grammar.
Reached Chapter 9 and the new vocabulary count is over 600 so far! I'm still going, because it is fascinating stuff, despite being so dense I have to return to past sections often.
Good stuff- well finally there was a short New testament section to translate, and I love real Thucydides and Herodotus extracts. I actually feel I'm learning something. Maybe one day I'll be able to fulfil my ultimate goal of reading Theophrastus' botanical works in Greek!
Bad things - oh those aorist verbs with added prepositional prefixes. They are f-ing hard! Some of them I just cant untangle - like epephereto for example, which the key tells me means "it moves upon." No idea. Yet. Using an Ancient Greek dictionary app to supplement the aoristic inadequacies of the end of book dictionary.
Aargh! Had a look at my friend's more modern version and it has vocabulary lists for chapters 5 to 9, unlike my version! Unfair! I've had to construct my own, and it would have helped with those bloody aorist and irregular verbs! Just got book 1 of Athenaze. Maybe it'll be an improvement?
Chapter 10:- much better than the last couple of chapters. Less grammar and more practice. Quite enjoyed it and seemed to find fewer problems analysing word structure, though the significance of some words having an accent and others not wasn't made clear before this, and the example of the word "tis." A 13 line extract from Plato was a nice incentive at the end of the chapter. Huge new vocab of 88 words.
Chapter 11:- not bad. Root aorists, more on passives and future, and some odd nouns. Nice translation passages on Thucydides and Antiphon. I'm picking up more of the rhythms of the language, so translations improving. New vocab of 74
Chapter 12:- participles. Yuck. 12 more forms of the verb, all of which apparently decline like adjectives. We are told this but not shown, so I had to resort to the internet to look a couple up that appeared in the exercises. As ever, the author is bloody mean with the reference tables he provides at the back of the book. NOT at all comprehensive, damn it. More throwing of the book across the room. Might order myself the Oxford grammar. Euripedes, and extra reading of Epigrams to translate; keeping my translations in a notebook now for reference. New vocab of 93
Chapter 13 - odd and Attic nouns, use of genitive/dative. Some very interesting material on new particles and their use for emphasis. The standard set of sentences to work on was nice, but the extra Plato material from Lysias was very challenging. Still the odd word that is puzzling to interpret because the basic form doesn't appear in the dictionary at the back! I'm coming to the conclusion that some of the translations aren't as precise as they could be, for the sake of a smoother English sentence. New vocab 81, making a total of 1068 for the whole book so far. I probably remember about 20%!
Chapter 14 - subjunctive and optative moods of the verb, which is surprisingly not as hard as I expected; except for where endings occur in more than one tense, like long e for example. I made a one page table of endings for reference, though I expect it will take a while to appreciate their nuances. Extract of Xenophon provided to translate.
Chapter 15 - explanation of verb vowel changes (boring!), some interesting use of participles and special verbs of aspect. The best part of this nondescript chapter was the varied passages for translation:- John 19: The Crucifixion, Plutarch's Moralia, and Aeschylus' Prometheus Bound. The poetic structure of the latter was interesting.
Chapter 16 - one of the more frustrating and challenging chapters, because the author uses examples of the perfect and pluperfect and other tenses that don't fit the suffix ending patterns he gives, (E.g. Epiladeia = they needed. Where is "ia" given as a 3rd plural ending in any tense?) Several words in the Euripides extra reading don't appear in the end vocabulary, or indeed, in my excellent vocab app, leaving me scratching my head. There also seems to be a certain looseness, shall I say, in some of the answer-translations. I know translation is an art, but as a learner, I value precision more than beautiful prose (and some of the original Greek is very beautiful). Oh well. I persevere.
Chapter 17:- oh dear. Signs that my heavy use of the book is starting a process of disintegration. I selotaped the pages that were starting to loosen in the vocabulary section.
Commands and the comparison of adjectives. Okay I guess. Extra reading - Prometheus Bound (Euripedes)
Half a dozen words I couldn't work out in each translation section. Getting tougher! Still finding a few irregular endings that don't match the (admittedly incomplete) word patterns in the appendix. And the Greek habit of replacing some word endings with an apostrophe is hugely annoying!
Chapter 18 - -mi verbs - still absorbing these. Types of conditional sentences - very simple, so why is it frying my brain? I suspect because I'm expecting more complications?
Translation not bad - though one verb I translated as "you" singular ending -ES, the author translates as "they" (which doesn't have -ES endings under any circumstances). It's little things like this that bring the most frustration! Aargh! If you're allowed to paraphrase, say so!
Chapter 19 and the horrors of -mi verbs like istemi, eccentric mai words and perfect words that are actually present tense instead. Ew! First mention of words having poetical forms. The far more logical Latin is growing in appeal. Mind you, looking at my TY Latin book after months of Greek, I was amazed how logical and ordered it was in comparison. The endings stay very predictable, unlike those of Greek that seem to vary much more. Translation exercises on this chapter were far nicer, or perhaps I'm improving? Unlikely!