Captain Richard Martin Woodman was an English novelist and naval historian who retired in 1997 from a 37-year nautical career, mainly working for Trinity House, to write full-time.
I appreciated the passion this author has for his subject, as well as his indisputably deep and broad knowledge. Unfortunately, I was turned off by a passage about Henry Hudson on page 35:
“Although he had fathered three sons, there are dark and ambiguous hints about Hudson’s sexual orientation, and perhaps therein lies the mystery of Greene, of Ivet’s malign presence, and of the flaw in Hudson: he chose his ship’s company for reasons contrary to good sense.”
To lay Hudson’s flaws at the feet of his (speculated) homosexuality is, frankly, bigoted and lazy. A straight man can be as flawed as a gay man, and his sexual orientation is not the “dark” root of that flaw. It blows my mind that this attitude passes for acceptable in a book written in 2005. It is a moral tone I find flawed.
I did enjoy overall, the stories of the origins of various mutinies, and appreciated Woodman’s understanding of the local, political, national, and shipboard circumstances that led to them. However, I found his tone insular throughout.
The mutiny entry in a series of brief histories published by Constable & Robinson Ltd. It reads like the content filler that it is.
The author has specialized knowledge about the Royal Navy, so our brief history of mutiny focuses mainly on British vessels in the age of sail.
The approximate theme of the book is that most mutinies fail. The author backs this up with specifics of several (British) mutinies that quickly fail or result in death or imprisonment for the leaders of each mutiny.
If you find this to be an intriguing subject, then do yourself a favor and read a non-brief history of mutiny or a focused history on a specific mutiny.
How do you define mutiny versus a strike? So often we think of a mutiny as something bloody and barbaric; motivated by greed and carried out by savage men with no regard for human life. Yet when the "lower decks" refused to obey orders until their grievances are addressed, even though this was often done with utmost attempts for peace, the primary motivation was lack of suitable pay, which would seem to give credence to the fact that mutinies begin with greed. Discipline must prevail upon Navy ships, for they are isolated and away for months at a time. Mutiny cannot even be allowed to be hinted at. So where is the line to be drawn when there are real and serious grievances, but there is no way for the men who serve to make them known? Or, if they do, they are ignored? How do you reconcile the strikes that took place at Spithead and Ivengorn with the very mutiny that also took place? These are the questions Woodman leaves to be answered, especially in a post -9/11 world, where "mutiny" and "terrorism" will probably become synonymous, and as we also face an extraordinary rise in piracy.
This was not a well-written book. Woodman tends to gloss over details that would be interesting, or even just engaging, in favor of service level recounting of events and a barrage of names that mean nothing. He clearly has knowledge of ships and the roles of sailors on them, but he isn't able to convey this in a manner that sticks in your brain. The absence of details, instead choosing to bring up interesting things and then disregard them immediately, is very annoying. In theory, the history of different mutinies sound like a fun romp through naval history. However, the plodding pace of many of the tales and the constant allusions to better stories kept this from being a book I wanted to finish.
Richard Woodman's study of 'Mutiny', sub-titled as a 'Brief History' begins in the early sixteenth century and covers events almost to the present day. It has to be said that the majority of these insurgencies focuses on English/British or American warships and merchantmen. Which has me wondering why we do not hear more of other maritime nations, such as the Portuguese, Spanish, Dutch or French sailing into troubled waters. By far it is His/Her Majesties 'senior service' which is top of the poops. As early as Francis Drake's contretemps with Thomas Doughty at Puerto San Julian in 1578, rumblings from the lower decks have been a regular occurrence ever since. It was the notorious events in HMS Hermione, (see 'The Black Ship' for a fuller history) and not Captain Bligh's 'Bounty' that was the eighteenth century nadir. However, equally horrific was the mutiny on the American whaler 'Globe' in 1822, or the Canadian barque 'Veronica' in 1902, and the massacres by American crewmen aboard the 'Leicester Castle' also in 1902. Hollywood has ignored these events. Surprisingly the men were muttering in both British and American navies during and after WWII. Pay and conditions being the predominant grouse on both sides of the Atlantic, with the added problem of apartheid in U.S. ships. It is easy for me to relate to these problems of men upon the ocean wave. As a ship's officer in the 1970's I executed my own personal mutiny. Without taking the ship and disposing of the overbearing tyrant over the side, I knew there was more than one way to skin a cat o' nine. So I blew up the illegitimate skipper's radar, which forced the vessel into port for repairs and hit the old man below the waterline....in his pocket.
Richard Woodman's present several case studies of mutiny over the centuries from the 15th century to the begging of the 21st, focusing mostly on the Royal Navy and, to a lesser extent, the British Merchant Marine. Notable exceptions include the mutiny Magellan faced and the (in)famous uprising aboard the Battleship Potemkin.
Some interesting stories, well told (Woodman's background as a novelist serves him well), for the student of history this serves best as a look at the Royal Navy over the course of some 400 years give or take, and the problems it faced.
First published in 2005, 'A Brief History of Mutiny' gives an account of key mutinies over the period from the 16th century up to the late 20th century. The accounts make very interesting reading, but are marred by errors that must either be poetic licence on the authors part or questionable source information. In addition, this edition seems to have a huge amount of typos ranging from minor errors where you pause for a second or two before you work out what the word should, to seeming gibberish that had me baffled. A flawed but enjoyable read.
Clearly a competent historian and story-teller, but I feel like the author isn't very critical on the harsh crackdowns on mutinies, poor conditions experienced by the crew, and power imbalance between the skilled but poorly-treated sailors and the officers. For example, Sir Francis Drake lying to his crew to hide the fact that they were going to attempt a previously unthinkable voyage is portrayed as something smart and cunning, when it reality the crew is clearly being tricked from the start. Ships captains were for all intents and purposes dictators over tiny floating islands, with full powers to punish the crew (with the risk of mutiny if they were too harsh). The book is also rather scant on the intersections between mutiny and piracy, which is an oversight that I find rather regrettable.