Flawless, by Carrie Lofty, is pretty darn good. Great, even.
The premise is not terribly new: William Christie, millionaire tycoon, dies. His fortune is willed back to his businesses, with one exception: his four children are put in charge of various struggling companies in their father’s business empire, and then have 2 years to bring their respective company into the black. If they succeed, they will be the primary shareholder of the business, and get a million dollar bonus. If they don’t, they get nothing. (It was unclear to me why the bonuses were given in dollars, as I was under the impression that the father was Scots and lived in England; wouldn’t it be in pounds? But I digress.)
Vivienne Christie is placed in charge of the Christie diamond brokerage in Kimberley, Cape Colony (South Africa). At the reading of her father’s will, she is confronted with another disturbing incident: the return of her wastrel husband, Miles (that’s two romances in a row with heroes named “Miles”!), Viscount Bancroft, whom she had left a year before after he embarrassed her once too often. He is determined to reunite with his wayward wife and exact a measure of revenge on her for leaving him. Overwhelmed, Vivienne escapes him again, and doesn’t see him until months later when she arrives in Cape Town.
Miles has put his time to good use: having arrived earlier than his estranged wife, he has established a household in Kimberley, made some connections, and begun to learn the rudiments of the diamond trade. Vivienne notes that the Miles that greets her in Cape Town is not the Miles she remembers, but is suspicious of his having truly changed.
Flawless is a slow burn of a book: it has more to do with the growth of Miles and Vivienne’s trust and relationship together, and the growth of their business, than it does with their lust. Don’t mistake me, there is plenty of lust, but for two-thirds of the book it goes largely unquenched. I enjoyed seeing a damaged relationship heal slowly; it was very realistic considering their history together. I also enjoyed the growth of Miles and Vivienne’s characters into the people they always wanted to be, rather the roles they were forced to play in London society. The setting was also fantastic. The diamond mines of South Africa just after the Boer war constitute a setting that I don’t think I have ever come across in a historical romance novel, which was a very nice change. Ms. Lofty holds a Master’s degree in history, and it shows.
The only detractor for me was the ‘villain’, who was fine except for the fact that his “personal investigator” discovers facts about Vivienne that he attempts to blackmail them with. All well and good, but I couldn’t imagine that Miles’ family would not have also discovered this information prior to their marriage. That, and the fact that the many unsavory persons in Kimberley never really got any comeuppance. I know it’s unrealistic to see “villains” (or even rude people) punished, but it does rankle when it doesn’t happen.
I was undecided between four and five stars on Flawless – frankly, I’d give a 4 ½ – but I think I’m just being unfair to it as I think it’s suffering from being read simultaneously with Like No Other Lover, which was absolutely amazing. I would recommend this book to anyone who likes historical romance, especially if they’re tired of the same-old, same-old setting, and if they’re tired of cookie-cutter heroes and heroines falling in cookie-cutter love.