This book was converted from its physical edition to the digital format by a community of volunteers. You may find it for free on the web. Purchase of the Kindle edition includes wireless delivery.
Vladimir Ilyich Ulyanov, better known as Vladimir Lenin, was a Russian revolutionary, leader of the Russian Social Democratic Labour Party (Bolsheviks), statesman and political theorist. After the October Revolution he served as the first and founding head of government of Soviet Russia from 1917 until his death in 1924 and of the Soviet Union from 1922 until his death in 1924.
This pamphlet is a little hard to rate. It was written less than a year after the October Revolution, when the Bolsheviks were far from secure in power. Counterrevolutionaries of every stripe roamed freely, German, Austro-Hungarian and Ottoman troops occupied much of the country and the USA, France, Britain, and Japan were gearing up for a serious invasion of the country. Yet Lenin wrote with the certainty that the Communist revolution would not only prosper in Russia but spread to the rest of the world.
Neither the worst fears of the Bolsheviks nor their great hopes panned out. The Central Powers retreated with their defeat at the end of the Great War and were largely replaced with independent national governments in the Russian Empire's occupied provinces, the Allied invasion came and went and remains obscure and ignored in the Western narratives of the Soviet era and the counterrevolutionary forces were defeated with titanic effort in the Russian Civil War. Communist insurrections and short-lived governments swept many of the former combatant nations but were ultimately defeated by Liberals and Fascists.
Despite his failure to predict the immediate future and the eventual downfall of the government he founded Lenin's vision of an international revolution continues to inspire and inform revolutionaries throughout the world and particularly in the Global South. For this reason his writings remain essential reading to anyone trying to understand politics outside of the Liberal paradigm.
I studied economics, but focused on quantitative analysis, not theory or history of thought. I was, however, fortunate enough to study a course on the history of Soviet economic development & transformation. I am fascinated by the early days of the Soviet Union.
"Letter to American Workingmen" is illustrative of why early Soviet economics and politics are relevant even today. You do not have to agree with Socialism to appreciate the historic importance of this text. It is a short, easy read detailing Lenin's position on how the 99% of the day should address economic inequality and the nation's lopsided distribution of wealth.
It is also an interesting read if you are fascinated by the types of leaders and how they rise to power. I find this subject infinitely interesting, and this piece gives a peek into his passion and the rhetoric used.
One of my favorite essays from Lenin I've read in a long time. I had forgotten how detailed he is in stripping bare the contradictions of capitalism down to the studs, in exposing the lies and slander of the capitalist ruling class -- the parallels to the lies he debunks here, over 100 years ago, still rings true and relevant today; how many ruling class-backed "sources" tell us of the "horrors of socialism", conjured up by well-funded campaigns to make them look real, while the actual horrors of capitalism-imperialism in these nations continues to crush the working class and oppressed? Countless.
This is a must-read for any Communist in the u.s., or any leftist really. Especially if you doubt Lenin.
If you can look past Lenins atrocities and what you are told to think about Socialism and Communism, you will see that he makes some very spot-on observations towards American Capitalism and greed.
The biggest bummer for me is that while the IDEA of this sounds all fine and dandy, it is no different than any Pro-Capitalism propaganda/agenda and in that sense, hypocritical.
All in all, I believe it is something that everyone should read at least once to further educate themselves on world history and politics.
An excellent appeal to the American Proletariat. Lenin explores the hypocrisy surrounding the Western world's view of the October revolution along with the peace of Brest-litovsk. A good read!
This letter is most famous for Lenin’s remarks about the American War for Independence and Civil War, whose nature have become a point of controversy for the American left in recent years. Here, Lenin praises the two wars highly for their nature as a war of liberation and a war of democracy, respectively. Ultimately, I believe Lenin overlooked many details in his assessment, principally that of colonialism, which renders his comments a bit outdated in their analysis.
Despite that, what I find most intriguing is Lenin’s comments on revolution and revolutionary strategy, since he wrote this letter mere months after the triumph of the Great October Revolution of 1917. Among the highlights of these comments are Lenin’s explanation for why socialists may, in the broader interests of the international proletariat, be forced to make unlikely alliances with factions who would otherwise be their sworn enemies against another oppressing force, and the imperative for revolutionary violence against counterrevolution.
The former was written with regards to his treating with French monarchists against German aggression to help bring an end to WWI, but has larger implications throughout proletarian history as seen most strikingly in the nonaggression pact of the USSR with Nazi Germany following the former’s failed attempts to secure an anti-fascist alliance with the western democracies in the face of growing German aggression and the tentative alliance of the Communist Party of China with the Kuomintang against Japanese imperialism following Japan’s invasion of China in the 30s. There is an important lesson here to be drawn and applied by all genuine revolutionaries which is admittedly very difficult, but thus all the more important.
The latter is very important in the face of the rising socialist left containing various elements that uphold Lenin and his teachings in words, but in practice reduce him to a common liberal, as well as abstract revolution as some glorified riot or protest instead of the very real violent surge of warring factions clashing continuously until the victory of one over the other. The latter sentiment is today particularly evident in various Marxist-Leninist circles, especially in response to the ongoing protracted people’s wars, as they collectively clutch their pearls at every act of violence, both toward people and property(!), committed by the people’s armies.
Here, Lenin speaks of the necessity for great revolutionary violence and repression of the bourgeois forces, and even laments not having been firmer in this repression sooner. He also talks about the positive aspects of mistakes in the waging of revolution and asserts that even if they’d committed 100,000 mistakes for every correct deed their revolution will still be justified and glorious. This is something modern day revisionists, opportunists, and moralists seem to forget, even as Lenin never faltered in his understanding.
100 years ago Lenin wrote this letter to American workers, outlining the justification for the Bolshevik revolution... many of his criticisms of the wealthy class resonate today. Even though the Russian revolution did not live up to its promises, his critiques still ring true today.
The letter is meant to address the international workers, specifically the American ones. In the letter does several things, he highlights the hypocrisy of the western nations, defends the actions of the new socialist republic and calls the workers of the world to action.
He explains that the western nations are flat out wrong to condemn the civil war because it causes destruction, they have been fighting world war one for four years and Lenin calls it out that they are hypocrites who only condemn this revolutionary war because it is a threat to the established capitalist order, otherwise they would be not as opposing to it.
He then goes on to explain that the new republic had to take several actions and “agreements” that are hurtful in the short term but save itself in the long term, such as the treaty of Brest litvosk, where they give up fighting in ww1 so that they can focus on defeating the counter revolutionary whites.
Lastly lenin calls up the rest of the workers in action and that they should not wait for a moment which is the easiest, as every revolution is going to be hard. But that he does not expect them to revolt anytime soon as russia was exceptionally backward which gave them the chance to revolt compared to other countries. He calls up the americans to look at their history such as the american revolutionary war and the american civil war and try to apply their lenses to the bolshevik revolution.
" ....even if we committed 10,000 mistakes for every 100 correct actions we performed, even in that case our revolution would be great and invincible, and so it will be in the eyes of world history, because, for the first time, not the minority, not the rich alone, not the educated alone, but the real people, the vast majority of the working people, are themselves building a new life, are by their own experience solving the most difficult problems of socialist organization."
We know with hindsight that the Soviet experiment didn't last. The world revolution didn't come. You can argue all day about how the Soviet Union turned out, but regardless of every single mistake, the proletariat ousted the oppressors from the state and made a noble attempt at a revolutionary new form of society. That means we can do it too, and take the lessons learned from our past comrades to lead us even further into a world were we are truly and finally free.
A rather speech-like letter, mostly hype moments and aura rather than a real theoretical analysis. It is very interesting to read a piece which is dedicated outwards towards one of the more stagnant proletarian populations from the head of one of the most dynamic (or one of the most dynamic) at the time. His perspective on American history is rather typical of earlier Marxists, including a baffling statement about the American Revolution not stealing anyone’s land. He is correct about the American civil war though — even specifying the 63-65 period as the proper one of revolution. He also advocates for playing bourgeoise factions against eachother, taking the time to be opportunistic. There’s an almost tragic optimism here. Lenin is quite enthused about the progress of the revolution in Russia, yet is not at all ready for the tragic reality which is about to befall the project. A better primary source than piece of theory.
“Let the corrupt bourgeois press shout to the whole world about every mistake our revolution makes. We are not daunted by our mistakes. People have not become saints because the revolution has begun. The toiling classes who for centuries have been oppressed, downtrodden and forcibly held in the vice of poverty, brutality and ignorance cannot avoid mistakes when making a revolution. And, as I pointed out once before, the corpse of bourgeois society cannot be nailed in a coffin and buried. The corpse of capitalism is decaying and disintegrating in our midst, polluting the air and poisoning our lives, enmeshing that which is new, fresh, young and virile in thousands of threads and bonds of that which is old, moribund and decaying.”
An interesting read, a valuable historical resource introducing a perspective of the War years generally alien to the jingoistic interpretations of most early primary accounts before the misery and horrors of the war start to bite.
So much of theory is unbearably dry, looking at you capital, but Lenin makes it interesting so I give him props for that. An interesting read. I appreciate the love for my fellow Hoosier Eugene v debs
4 stars for the style in which its written, but 3 stars for the overall contents. I feel like Lenin would've been better off responding to more Western arguments than spending half the book calling the Western powers scoundrels and thieves.
Short and enjoyable. A few punchy lines here and there. Interesting piece of historical writing which situates the Bolsheviks’ internal reasoning for negotiating the treaty of brest-litovsk.
those comments on 1776 are probably some of the worst paragraphs that Lenin has ever penned, unfortunately. Combined with the IWA’s obsequious letter to Lincoln and Mao’s downright ignorant apologia for the white masses, this is the starter pack of settler marxist quote-mining.
This is by no means a comprehensive analysis of the US working class and their material conditions, however, it is several pages wherein Lenin outlines his hopes for the US and his perspective from the Soviet Socialist Republics, their respective failures, and his keen advice.
"In spite of this, we are firmly convinced that we are invincible, because the spirit of mankind will not be broken by the imperialist slaughter. Mankind will vanquish it."
A comment by Aldous Huxley in an essay on Centralization and Decentralization prompted my interest. As I grow older and wiser, I hope, I see that unbridled capitalism isn't the answer. The problem in greed. Enough is never enough. Marx and Lenin must have had some good ideas. Mussolini, Stalin, and Hitler corrupted them. I'm searching for the socialist/capitalist balance where everyone has work to do, food to eat, clothes, shelter, education, etc. What's the saying? To each according to his need, from each according to his talents? Something like that. As we move into an age of increasing automation and artificial intelligence, we should be able to eliminate poverty. But how?
"The great law of capitalism in all wars; that he who is richest and mightiest profits the most, takes the greatest share of the spoils while he who is weakest is exploited, martyred, oppressed and outraged to the most." This is what Lenin appealed to the American workingmen for a revolution after the four years long of World War I. Lenin asked: shall we place the integrity and safety of this fatherland (he was referring to U.S.) created by the bourgeoisie over the interests of the international socialist revolution?
Lenin's usual no nonsense style of writing is motivational, straightforward, and incitant. His speech called for revolution in America to end the "capitalist wage slavery", just like their forefathers in the Civil War to end the slavery, and to overthrow the rule of the bourgeoisie, in a classical Marxist class struggle analysis.
To the oppressed, Lenin's encouragement was gospel-like that brought hope to the new world. For example, "the greater the bitterness and brutality they (the proleteriat) sow, the nearer is the day of the victorious proletarian revolution."; "that a successful revolution is inconceivable unless it breaks the resistance of the exploiting class...it became our duty to quell the resistance of the exploiting class. We are proud that we have done it, that we are doing it."
There are more statements like this in this pamphlet that readers nowadays might be awed. But if you considered the degree of suffering that the average workingmen were under at the time, that they echoed what Lenin said, you might be horrified by the history of the struggle of mankind. Nonetheless, history was not written the way Lenin conceived. Overall, a great little pamphlet.
Right now, in the twenty century, this is the great time for the whole world to unit toghether to fight against the hipocrisy and the worst interest. The whole world must work to establish the greatest equality betwen them: equality for each people to live in the respect and dignity, same education, same health, same priority for all kind of people, ... This is that we need in the world for greater life, because we are one, either black or white people, biologicaly and scientificly, we play the same function.
Good brief read highlighting socialistic thought. It is particularly relevant now with the socialistic ideas being highlighted by political candidates.