If you’re reading this review before reading Gee’s Flood, I recommend paying attention to the following: the social classes of the characters; the text’s attitude toward officials—academic and political in particular; biblical references; and gender-linked biases.
I also recommend keeping a running list of characters with brief descriptions. I was not very successful in getting such a list, even after hounding ChatGPT several times. It may, in fact, be a semi-futile endeavor, because the characters are grouped into stereotypical profiles: gender, class, age, and intellectual capacity.
When all hell breaks loose—and it does, several times, in different ways—it seems that what matters most is their position in society—certainly not their characters. Just as with pandemics, TSA shutdowns, and military drafts, the rich seem to get the better end of the deal every time. That said, the rich don’t seem particularly happy though.
But all is not bleak because the novel suggests, through Harold’s book and via the meteorologists’ studies, that life simply goes on. It is neither the future nor the past that we should worry about or pay attention to. It is simply the present, and this idea—that the present is universal for all of us—is a thread that pervades the book and offers its ultimate hope amid apocalypses.
The other hope offered is that the dead experience a greater understanding along a past-present-future continuum. This is not validated well in the novel, in my opinion.
There are also some huge stabs at religion, the religious, academics, and politics, which I found funny and poignant—but not particularly nuanced. There are a lot of digs at men, which I found rather nasty and small-minded. I was surprised that some of the characters I liked were the ones voicing them.
While I was looking for a moral compass in the story—among the narrator and the characters—I didn’t find one, likely, because the novel is not about ethics. Nor is it about logical consequences.
Rather, it seems to be about the ebb and flow of life’s joys and disasters—until death intercedes and affords us all a place of understanding.
Quotes:
Perhaps the dead can move through time if time is an endless unspooling ribbon, the living sea only the short bright section to which they cling, painting, struggling, peering out, blinded from the spotlit moment. Perhaps the dead see the whole of the road, stretching out forever, before, behind, 3000 human generations. Under the city, the dead travel onwards. Searching for something. Homing, homing. 6
May wasn't religious, but she knew there was something. There had to be; There was so much beauty. 10 her shyness, too, had quickly vanished as she learned to use the language of her lectures. Dolorice was afraid of nobody, now. Patricia forged onwards. “The Bottom line is, Emmer Dale makes a lot of money for us.” Sid, the sales manager, was frowning slightly. “Well, The figures for Lover in Clover weren't brilliant—” Patricia interrupted. “Thirty 1000 hardbacks of Farmyard Matters plus 300,000 paperbacks!” Dolorice tried again, more determinedly, “Look, it's hard to make sex in cancer boring, but this book does. Have you read a comma Patricia?” “Of course.” The older woman glared back. Dolorice knew at once that she hadn't. “Point is,” Brian said, rushing in to mollify anxious at the turn the conversation was taking, for people started asking if publishers read books, the game would be up for all of them.—“ Reckon we could shift half a mill of this one, if it's as raunchy as Farmyard Matters: “But,” Dolorice tried, one last time, “the public is going to see it's rubbish.” 29
“So what are you painting, can I just ask you?” “The end and the beginning of the world,” Ian said. 45
Then adolescence hit, with its souring knowledge. 47
Mysteriously, though, Gracie was home she couldn't bear her mother's carping, her predictable, puritanical opinions, her arguments with the television news—although Paula as a mother was faintly ridiculous, a potential source of public shame in tracksuit bottoms and turquoise anorak--mysteriously when Gracie was away from her, at times when she felt she was on the line, her mother's opinions leaped to her lips, her mother's worldview became her own. 47
Human beings were impossible, she decided: they wrote the words, a great flood of words that was meant to explain and record the whole world, then they fought the wars that destroyed the lot. Mind you, war was important period she wasn't against it. 54
The novelist’s flat was poor and small, allowing Moira to feel kindly towards her. 54
You tell me you haven't read Jude the Obscure, but how do I know you aren't unconsciously suppressing it? In any case, some texts are just in the air-to-put a lay-person’s gloss on it. 55
Once she had believed in all that. It was harder when you got rich and soft. (She wondered, briefly, if she still existed, somewhere, the sullen schoolgirl she had been?) 58
Though by now there was only a morsel or so left, Moira suddenly plunged on it like a Heron, stabbing the cube off Angela’s plate and snapping it down, her throat briefly bulging. This was something new in the scale of hostility. 59
By the time she finished Moira well shrieking, a long metal ribbon of screaming sound, one arm lifted to the fluorescent ceiling, the other gesturing toward the red window, and all the faces, the eager, the indolent, city worn faces, tired clever faces, innocent, Arden faces of the young, were fixed, startled, on the old woman prophesizing. 61
It wasn't really burgling, since it was for God. Father Bruno had explained all that. 65
And it wasn't perfect--dad could be a bastard, and look at mom now, so slight, so tiny, as if she only half exists, without him. 69
Mr bliss was banging the war drum Again. We must have war, or there will never be peace. 71
Although she was young, or because she was young, she understood dreams, and the pain of surrendering them, here in the city that gorged on dreams. 75
“It’s capitalism, isn't it? Exploiting nature. You're really lucky to deal with the stars,” she said. “I mean there isn't any capitalism, up there. There's nothing Helsperican [American?] up there. Just beauty, I guess.” 79
Lola is being, you know, a bit blaming. Teenagers are hot on blame. 81
Harold's physics allowed for no past or future, only a single infinite structure. A hall of time from which the moments open, a mansion of many sunlit rooms. Davey imagined an unending honeycomb. 83
One of the awful things about children was that they expected you to be consistent. 91
It’s about time, and simultaneity. The way everyone's moment happens at once, wherever they are, however different, and every atom is interconnected. 121
“No one ever dies,” said Harold, suddenly emptying another glass, and smiling transformed from the usual shy, ironic herald who led his wife take center stage. “In my book, I say no one ever dies. Good moments, like this one, go on forever. It's just that our bodies leave them behind. Our minds don't have to. We can choose to be happy.” 131
Lottie beamed upon him, proud but baffled. “That’s Awfully clever, Harold. But is it true?” “In my bucket is,” he smiled back at her. “The Eternal return, the eternal moment." 131
While May was alive, their old life would go on, his slippers in the cardboard, the daily paper. That way she would carry him onward. Alfred, love, I won't let go. 164
Life goes on, but now, beautiful; The swimming pool breathes in and out; The life it supports takes its rhythm for granted; Every day, peaceful, miraculous life in a city reclaimed from the edge of disaster. 198
They were a close family, full of passionate loyalty, but ravaged by the past, and the deeper past, by the shadows of the shadows of unspeakable crimes. 203
(But she has a slightly absent air, she is in a different world, a maternal worry.) 205
But every so often, the pattern fractures. Maybe the Galaxy is bored with balance. Maybe it gets tired of a life forms persistence period perhaps it wants to make room for something different comma something less myopic than the city-dwellers. 243
Yet all her kids had turned into believers. Shirley was always in church with the kids, Darren had his Marxism, which was like religion, because he held on to it no matter what, even though he was so wealthy, and never seemed to share it… 246
Yes, that was the word, “fundamentalist.” A word that had no light and shade. 247
Alfred believed in things like Justice, with a capital “J”, and Standards, with a capital “S”. May had more sense, because she was a woman… 247
She was over 70, yes, but she wasn't useless. She fell asleep with hope in her heart. 247
Religion, May thought. It could turn your brain. She imagined a giant lamb on a mountain, surrounded by the thousands of normal-sized people. You couldn't take it seriously, could you? Though she'd have to be careful not to laugh at Dirk. It wasn't a good idea to laugh at men. 248
The hissing whisper is “flood sickness”. No one is worried about astral bodies. On the long strings of space-time, events are gathering. 265
But now, slowly, under the surface, in the depths of their hearts where there is no argument, where knowledge never reaches, beyond logic, they start to hate, because they start to fear. 274
“I’m sorry,” she said. “I didn't know what to do. I didn't know anything. I never did.” It Was there again, that sinking feeling. Her whole life as a mother, her whole life as a wife, she had never known anything, she'd just reacted, just on the next thing is the next day came, and mostly it was wrong. Her whole hurrying life. It was only afterwards you understood things. 278
The rich believed they can always leave, that money will always get them away. 283
Frightening the people who do not leave. The poor believed they can never leave. There is no escape;
Life simply happens, the wheels roll forward, crushing them or sparing them. 284
Safe in the grass, the bodies lie, stunned by the arc of the sun through the sky. 304
Dreaming themselves, they are as they wish. All that they ever hoped to be. 304