Fair warning: there are going to be a lot of spoilers in this review. Please don't read it unless you want to ruin your reading experience.
I began this book with high hopes. In the previous installment in this series, Agatha Raisin has been making steady progress at moving past her obsession with James Lacey, and is really coming into her own as a mature woman. Of course, like all of us, "Aggie" still has her insecurities, which make her a normal person. However, she is working on moving on with her life, and is growing as a character.
In [u]Agatha Raisin and the Fairies of Fryfam[/u], Agatha decides to take a trip to Norfolk where she is destined to meet her one true love, as per the prophecy of the Witch of Wyckhadden. Picking a place at random in Norfolk, Agatha lands up in the strange village of Fryfam. There, she meets a whole new cast of characters ranging from the gnarled and crabby Mrs. Jackson, to the smooth and always-well-put-together Rosie Wilden. More than that, Agatha discovers that there may be fairies living in the village, fairies that seem to steal small, everyday items whenever they appear. Soon, an invaluable Stubbs painting is stolen, and after that, Tolly Trumpington-James is found murdered in his manor.
Agatha, unable to decide whether to stay in Fryfam or return to Carsely, chooses to stay and try to see what she can discover of the thefts and murder. Sir Charles Fraith joins her, and they soon end up head over heels in alibis and a convoluted and seemingly untraceable mystery.
Let the spoilers begin.
As I have previously stated, I like Sir Charles Fraith as Agatha's lover/sidekick/partner much more than James Lacy, who I find to be a condescending jerk of a person. Sir Charles may have amoral tendencies and likes to enjoy himself sexually, but he is a funny, lighthearted person, and is the perfect foil for Agatha's vibrant personality! I very much enjoyed his role in the story.
However, at the end of the story, Agatha returns to Carsely to find that James Lacy has returned. Not only has he returned to Carsely, but he is also romantically linked to Melissa Sheppard, a new village resident. Agatha finds herself torn, but with her newfound dignity, refuses to make first contact with James. I can't tell you how much I loved seeing Agatha's struggle, and then witness her making a choice that is completely in tune with her new, mature personality!
Then, horror of all horrors, Ms. Beaton has James show up at Agatha's front door. After coming in and hearing about Agatha's newest adventure, James proposes marriage to Agatha. And what does Agatha do? She accepts his proposal.
What in the world?! I don't understand. I am so irritated by this plot twist, and it makes so LITTLE sense in the grand scheme of things, that it makes me want to give up on the entire series. Why, OH WHY, in the world did you do that, Ms. Chesney?!
Haven't we seen Agatha suffer enough, and learn more about her loneliness, and work hard to make new friends, and grow as a person to be rewarded with a LITTLE BIT of happiness for her?!
*Sigh*
I don't even know what to think any more. I was really happy with the direction the stories were taking. Agatha was becoming herself, and learning about who she is as a character. The stories were evolving, the characters were changing, the world was gaining more depth. And then this disaster.
I am very, very disappointed.
So now, I'm going to read the next book in the series to see if I should continue reading the rest of the series or not.
Wish me luck.