What do you think?
Rate this book
Stealing Jake
When Livy O’Brien spies a young boy jostling a man walking along the boardwalk, she recognizes the act for what it is. After all, she used to be known as Light-fingered Livy. But that was before she put her past behind her and moved to the growing town of Chestnut, Illinois, where she’s helping to run an orphanage. Now she’ll do almost anything to protect the street kids like herself.
Sheriff’s deputy Jake Russell had no idea what he was in for when he ran into Livy—literally—while chasing down a pickpocket. With a rash of robberies and a growing number of street kids in town—as well as a loan on the family farm that needs to be paid off—Jake doesn’t have time to pursue a girl. Still, he can't seem to get Livy out of his mind. He wants to get to know her better . . . but Livy isn’t willing to trust any man, especially not a lawman.
Sheriff’s deputy Jake Russell had no idea what he was in for when he ran into Livy—literally—while chasing down a pickpocket. With a rash of robberies and a growing number of street kids in town—as well as a loan on the family farm that needs to be paid off—Jake doesn’t have time to pursue a girl. Still, he can't seem to get Livy out of his mind. He wants to get to know her better . . . but Livy isn’t willing to trust any man, especially not a lawman.
357 pages, Kindle Edition
First published June 24, 2011
104 people are currently reading
1406 people want to read
About the author
Pam Hillman
25 books648 followersCBA Bestselling author PAM HILLMAN was born and raised on a dairy farm in Mississippi and spent her teenage years perched on the seat of a tractor raking hay. In those days, her daddy couldn't afford two cab tractors with air conditioning and a radio, so Pam drove an Allis Chalmers 110. Even when her daddy asked her if she wanted to bale hay, she told him she didn't mind raking. Raking hay doesn't take much thought so Pam spent her time working on her tan and making up stories in her head. Now, that's the kind of life every girl should dream of. www.pamhillman.com
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 141 reviews
March 10, 2016
There are so many things I like about this novel- the western setting, the steadily building friendship and romance between Livy and Jake, but what really touched my heart was the abuse of child labor and street orphans. Livy's compassion for the orphans and Jake's duty as sheriff's deputy to investigate them as robbery suspects have them crossing paths and butting heads over how the situation should be handled. A few parts are told from the perspective of Luke, one of the boys living on the street, as he seeks to rescue his brother from captivity in a hidden sweatshop. It is astounding how little the lives of the orphans are valued not only by their abusers but defensive members of the growing town. With part of the mystery known to the reader and part of it revealed towards the end, there is an element of tension and suspense. The story includes other facets of frontier life that are woven in seamlessly, including the dangers of coal mining, a judgmental school teacher, and the dynamics of neighbors and friendships in a tight-knit community. I recommend this book to fans of Mary Connealy, Karen Witemeyer, and Regina Jennings.
(Thank you to the author for a copy of the book in exchange for my honest review)
(Thank you to the author for a copy of the book in exchange for my honest review)
September 15, 2022
About this book:
“When Livy O’Brien spies a young boy jostling a man walking along the boardwalk, she recognizes the act for what it is. After all, she used to be known as Light-Fingered Livy. But that was before she put her past behind her and moved to the growing town of Chestnut, Illinois, where she’s helping to run an orphanage. Now she’ll do almost anything to protect the street kids like herself.
Sheriff’s deputy Jake Russell had no idea what he was in for when he ran into Livy—literally while chasing down a pickpocket. With a rash of robberies and a growing number of street kids in town—as well as a loan on the family farm that needs to be paid off—Jake doesn’t have time to pursue a girl. Still, he can’t seem to get Livy out of his mind. He wants to get to know her better . . . but Livy isn’t willing to trust any man, especially not a lawman.”
Series: As of now, no.
Spiritual Content- Many Prayers & Blessings over food; Answered prayers; Talks about God, Jesus, sin & trusting Him; ‘H’s are capital when referring to God; A few Scriptures are mentioned; Church going; Mentions of those in the Bible.
Negative Content- Minor cussing including: a ‘drat’, a ‘stupid’, two ‘dumb’s, and three ‘shut up’s; Mentions of curses said but not written; Pain & Fighting (semi-detailed); Guns & Shooting; Holing someone’s neck & almost choking them (semi-detailed); Mentions of killing children, whipping & overworking them (up to semi-detailed); Mentions of killing; Mentions of starving; Mentions of drinking, drunks, saloons & whiskey; Mentions of gambling; Mentions of smoking and cigarettes; Many, many, many mentions of mines, blackness, death & the dying (barely-above-not-detailed);
Sexual Content- three head/forehead kisses, a cheek kiss, an almost kiss, three barely-above-not-detailed kisses, three semi-detailed kisses, a border-line detailed // very-detailed kiss; Remembering an almost kiss and a kiss (semi-detailed); Wanting to kiss; Mentions of stolen kisses; Touches & Hand-holding (semi-detailed); Blushes; Noticing (semi-detailed); a ‘strumpet’; Flirting & Teasing; Mentions of waking up in the morning with a woman; Mentions of men preying on young girls; Mentions of childbirth & those who died in it; Mentions of children born out of wedlock; Love, falling in love & the emotions
*Note: A cat gives birth (barely-above-not-detailed).
-Livy O’Brien
-Jake Russell
P.O.V. switches between them, Luke & Victor
Set in 1874
363 pages
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Pre Teens- One Star
New Teens- One Star
Early High School Teens- Two Stars
Older High School Teens- Three Stars
My personal Rating- Three Stars
Hmm. “Stealing Jake” had some parts I liked (caring for the orphans, prayers and Livy) and some parts I didn’t like (all the kisses & the mentions of killing children). At first, I was very confused with the different POVs, but I got it about fifteen chapters in. This book reminded me a bit of a Karen Witemeyer book. I wouldn’t be keeping this book, though, due to the boarder-line very-detailed kiss. :/
Link to review:
http://booksforchristiangirls.blogspo...
*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
*I received this book for free from the Publisher (Tyndale House Publishers) for this review.
“When Livy O’Brien spies a young boy jostling a man walking along the boardwalk, she recognizes the act for what it is. After all, she used to be known as Light-Fingered Livy. But that was before she put her past behind her and moved to the growing town of Chestnut, Illinois, where she’s helping to run an orphanage. Now she’ll do almost anything to protect the street kids like herself.
Sheriff’s deputy Jake Russell had no idea what he was in for when he ran into Livy—literally while chasing down a pickpocket. With a rash of robberies and a growing number of street kids in town—as well as a loan on the family farm that needs to be paid off—Jake doesn’t have time to pursue a girl. Still, he can’t seem to get Livy out of his mind. He wants to get to know her better . . . but Livy isn’t willing to trust any man, especially not a lawman.”
Series: As of now, no.
Spiritual Content- Many Prayers & Blessings over food; Answered prayers; Talks about God, Jesus, sin & trusting Him; ‘H’s are capital when referring to God; A few Scriptures are mentioned; Church going; Mentions of those in the Bible.
Negative Content- Minor cussing including: a ‘drat’, a ‘stupid’, two ‘dumb’s, and three ‘shut up’s; Mentions of curses said but not written; Pain & Fighting (semi-detailed); Guns & Shooting; Holing someone’s neck & almost choking them (semi-detailed); Mentions of killing children, whipping & overworking them (up to semi-detailed); Mentions of killing; Mentions of starving; Mentions of drinking, drunks, saloons & whiskey; Mentions of gambling; Mentions of smoking and cigarettes; Many, many, many mentions of mines, blackness, death & the dying (barely-above-not-detailed);
Sexual Content- three head/forehead kisses, a cheek kiss, an almost kiss, three barely-above-not-detailed kisses, three semi-detailed kisses, a border-line detailed // very-detailed kiss; Remembering an almost kiss and a kiss (semi-detailed); Wanting to kiss; Mentions of stolen kisses; Touches & Hand-holding (semi-detailed); Blushes; Noticing (semi-detailed); a ‘strumpet’; Flirting & Teasing; Mentions of waking up in the morning with a woman; Mentions of men preying on young girls; Mentions of childbirth & those who died in it; Mentions of children born out of wedlock; Love, falling in love & the emotions
*Note: A cat gives birth (barely-above-not-detailed).
-Livy O’Brien
-Jake Russell
P.O.V. switches between them, Luke & Victor
Set in 1874
363 pages
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Pre Teens- One Star
New Teens- One Star
Early High School Teens- Two Stars
Older High School Teens- Three Stars
My personal Rating- Three Stars
Hmm. “Stealing Jake” had some parts I liked (caring for the orphans, prayers and Livy) and some parts I didn’t like (all the kisses & the mentions of killing children). At first, I was very confused with the different POVs, but I got it about fifteen chapters in. This book reminded me a bit of a Karen Witemeyer book. I wouldn’t be keeping this book, though, due to the boarder-line very-detailed kiss. :/
Link to review:
http://booksforchristiangirls.blogspo...
*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
*I received this book for free from the Publisher (Tyndale House Publishers) for this review.
July 27, 2015
A plot so riddled with action and suspense that it'll give you itchy fingers (which means you want to find out what happens so badly that you're tempted to start turning pages faster than you can read.) Such a delicious dilemma for an avid reader!
Love that the romance is front and centre right from the start. The reader is in no doubt that chemistry exists between Jake and Livy and romance could blossom quickly under ideal circumstances. Alas, since the circumstances aren't ideal, there isn't a smooth path to matrimony -- but I sure enjoyed all the bumps and detours along the way!
Trust is a core issue that threads its way throughout this story. It's something Livy in particular really struggles with because of her past. But Jake harbors his own share of doubts which compound Livy's trust issues and it spirals into quite a quandary. Then there's young Luke, a mistrustful street kid who holds the key to a lot of questions that need answering...if only he could trust someone with the information.
The surprising suspense thread kept me riveted right to the very end....and then I mourned that it was all over. You know -- that black moment in a reader's life where you realize there is no more story but you're not ready to let it go? And the thought of starting another book leaves you feeling unsettled? That's how I felt when I reached the last page of Stealing Jake and what a wonderful (and disturbing) conundrum for an avid reader to be in. Definitely one for the keeper shelf.
My thanks to the author and publisher for providing me with a copy of this book.
Love that the romance is front and centre right from the start. The reader is in no doubt that chemistry exists between Jake and Livy and romance could blossom quickly under ideal circumstances. Alas, since the circumstances aren't ideal, there isn't a smooth path to matrimony -- but I sure enjoyed all the bumps and detours along the way!
Trust is a core issue that threads its way throughout this story. It's something Livy in particular really struggles with because of her past. But Jake harbors his own share of doubts which compound Livy's trust issues and it spirals into quite a quandary. Then there's young Luke, a mistrustful street kid who holds the key to a lot of questions that need answering...if only he could trust someone with the information.
The surprising suspense thread kept me riveted right to the very end....and then I mourned that it was all over. You know -- that black moment in a reader's life where you realize there is no more story but you're not ready to let it go? And the thought of starting another book leaves you feeling unsettled? That's how I felt when I reached the last page of Stealing Jake and what a wonderful (and disturbing) conundrum for an avid reader to be in. Definitely one for the keeper shelf.
My thanks to the author and publisher for providing me with a copy of this book.
August 2, 2011
This novel grabs your heart on page one and doesn’t let go ‘til the end.
Light-fingered Livy O’Brien grew up on the streets of Chicago. Raised on the cold and hunger of homelessness, friend to pain and the tragic death of her sister, hers is a story of God’s love shining in the most broken of hearts.
Jake Russell is Deputy Sheriff of Chestnut, Illinois. He doesn’t know what he’s getting in for the day he bumps (literally) into sweet little Miss O’Brien.
A romance that makes you smile, an intricate plot, and plenty of drama…but that’s not what gets you with this novel. Woven into the story of Jake and Livy is a cast of street kids. Arrested in Chicago and sold—by the police, nonetheless—as child labor, these kids find themselves alone and without hope in Chestnut.
And yet God never leaves us that way, does He?
Because He brings Jake and Livy together at His perfect time, not only to discover a future together, but so they can intervene in the lives of kids who have no one to fight for them.
This novel is a promising debut for Pam Hillman, Romance Writers of America Golden Heart Award finalist and ACFW Genesis Contest winner. It’s a great read for fans of Tracie Peterson, Tamera Alexander and Diann Mills historical novels.
I’m looking forward to what she brings us next.
Light-fingered Livy O’Brien grew up on the streets of Chicago. Raised on the cold and hunger of homelessness, friend to pain and the tragic death of her sister, hers is a story of God’s love shining in the most broken of hearts.
Jake Russell is Deputy Sheriff of Chestnut, Illinois. He doesn’t know what he’s getting in for the day he bumps (literally) into sweet little Miss O’Brien.
A romance that makes you smile, an intricate plot, and plenty of drama…but that’s not what gets you with this novel. Woven into the story of Jake and Livy is a cast of street kids. Arrested in Chicago and sold—by the police, nonetheless—as child labor, these kids find themselves alone and without hope in Chestnut.
And yet God never leaves us that way, does He?
Because He brings Jake and Livy together at His perfect time, not only to discover a future together, but so they can intervene in the lives of kids who have no one to fight for them.
This novel is a promising debut for Pam Hillman, Romance Writers of America Golden Heart Award finalist and ACFW Genesis Contest winner. It’s a great read for fans of Tracie Peterson, Tamera Alexander and Diann Mills historical novels.
I’m looking forward to what she brings us next.
August 16, 2011
This book is amazing. I loved the story. Livy has lived on the streets and has a real heart for street kids. She remembers what its like to have to struggle for food, warmth and survival. Jake has no idea he thinks street kids are a problem that needs to be moved on. Jakes opinion is common of many people. Add a to this mix the fact the street kids are being brought to town by an unknown man. I love reading livy's story how her life has changed and she is now working in an orphanage helping look after orphans, she would like to help all the children but knows its hard for them to trust adults. Jake also has to deal with some of the issues of the children also when some robbery start to happen. We see themes like redemption, forgiveness, acceptance in this book. When I was reading this book I was thinking about children today we still have foster children who are still mistreated. There are also children in third world countries that are badly mistreated today. I love a book that makes me think about different issues. This is a great book and I cant wait to read more books by Pam.
May 3, 2016
Pam Hillman is an amazing author. I was captivated from the very beginning of this book. Livy, Jake, and Luke stole my interest from the beginning and didn't let go until the very end. I loved the plot. The plight of the street kids tugged at my heart strings. From all I've read, "street kids" and orphans were not treated very well back in those times (and you can't really say they are now), and Pam Hillman perfectly captured that fact in this nail-biting story. Read my full review: http://faithlovebooks.blogspot.com/20...
August 13, 2011
Pam Hillman’s debut novel, Stealing Jake, is a joy to read! From the very first scene we are caught up in Livy O’Brien’s world – a world where homeless street children are forced into a life of crime in order to survive, and if caught, are “sold” to unscrupulous men who use them for cheap labor in sweat shops. Although Livy has escaped that life by the grace of God, she refuses to leave it behind completely, knowing that she can be the instrument God uses to save others from that miserable existence.
Then she meets Jake Russell, the deputy of the small Illinois town where Livy and her mentor, Mrs. Brooks, have recently moved to start an orphanage. With Livy’s past, her first instinct is to avoid this lawman, but circumstances – and mutual attraction – continue to bring them together.
I thoroughly enjoyed the way Pam introduced and developed her characters. Both Livy and Jake have their demons, and Pam reveals them to the reader in a natural and compelling way. She allows her hero and heroine to face them, and then vanquish them before our eyes.
I am waiting impatiently for Pam’s next book!
I received a copy of this e-book as a free download from Netgalley for my review.
Then she meets Jake Russell, the deputy of the small Illinois town where Livy and her mentor, Mrs. Brooks, have recently moved to start an orphanage. With Livy’s past, her first instinct is to avoid this lawman, but circumstances – and mutual attraction – continue to bring them together.
I thoroughly enjoyed the way Pam introduced and developed her characters. Both Livy and Jake have their demons, and Pam reveals them to the reader in a natural and compelling way. She allows her hero and heroine to face them, and then vanquish them before our eyes.
I am waiting impatiently for Pam’s next book!
I received a copy of this e-book as a free download from Netgalley for my review.
July 29, 2011
I LOVED this book. It was such a good, fast, inspiring, romantic, sentimental, adventurous read. This is a book you DO NOT want to judge by it's cover or title (both are kinda ehhh). The book is written from the perspective of those 4 above characters, which really gives you the chance to know every angle of the story.
Yes, it's a Christian book... but I did not find it to be pushy or preachy at all. I thought that it portrayed the message well without over doing it. And, being that it's the mid-west in the late 1800's, it's appropriate. I feel like sometimes Christian books feel the need to rosy up the message or add 100 "God's" into it just because it's "Christian". And I AM a Christian... I still don't like it. Not the case with this book... it was perfect.
Seriously, go get it... now. Unfortunately, it's currently only available in e-book format, BUT for now it's FREE on Amazon. Woohoo!
5 stars
This book was given to me free of charge for the purpose of this review. This is my honest and unbiased opinion.
Yes, it's a Christian book... but I did not find it to be pushy or preachy at all. I thought that it portrayed the message well without over doing it. And, being that it's the mid-west in the late 1800's, it's appropriate. I feel like sometimes Christian books feel the need to rosy up the message or add 100 "God's" into it just because it's "Christian". And I AM a Christian... I still don't like it. Not the case with this book... it was perfect.
Seriously, go get it... now. Unfortunately, it's currently only available in e-book format, BUT for now it's FREE on Amazon. Woohoo!
5 stars
This book was given to me free of charge for the purpose of this review. This is my honest and unbiased opinion.
March 8, 2018
Uhgg...too preachy for my taste.
Read
June 7, 2019RTC
August 15, 2015
A sheriff and a former pick-pocket team up to rescue street kids and find unexpected love in Chestnut, Illinois. I like to break down my reviews into several elements...
The heroine: "Light-fingered" Livy is a wonderful heroine, feminine without being stiff, and gutsy without being overbearing. With her past, it is hard to see how things could ever work out between her and Jake, but that's what makes for great story conflict!
The hero: Jake is a down to earth, selfless hero that would make any lady's heart patter. He only has eyes for Livy, though, which makes him all the more swoon-worthy.
The romance: Sweet sorghum molasses! Jake does a handsome job of pursuing Livy against his better judgement. Shy, reticent girl that Livy is, Jake's attentions are of necessity determined, yet gentle and sweet. They melted this reader's heart more than once--okay, a lot.
The plot: This is a page-turner for sure. I was constantly guessing until the end, and the plight of the children really makes this story unique.
The setting: While reading this novel, I felt like I was living the scenes. The details immerse the reader into the snowy world of Illinois winter but never overwhelm or slow the pace too much. The effect feels effortless and is a mark of Pam's incredible talent.
The theme: Forgiving ourselves and overcoming secrets in our past is hard. Everyone can relate to making mistakes they'd rather no one else know. But through the blood of Jesus, we have forgiveness and He gives us victory over sin. The prejudices about street kids are also addressed along with our need to "be Jesus to the least of these." Matt. 25:40. This leads me to my final point...
The faith element: Pam Hillman writes her faith into her stories so gently and earnestly, the reader never feels preached to, but at the same time there's never a question this book was written to minister and encourage. Another mark of excellent fiction writing. I was happy to find a good read that speaks of Jesus' blood and His power to cleanse us from sin.
The audience: Because of the subplot with the desperate street kids, people of all ages will enjoy this story. I recommend this novel to anyone who loves good fiction.
The heroine: "Light-fingered" Livy is a wonderful heroine, feminine without being stiff, and gutsy without being overbearing. With her past, it is hard to see how things could ever work out between her and Jake, but that's what makes for great story conflict!
The hero: Jake is a down to earth, selfless hero that would make any lady's heart patter. He only has eyes for Livy, though, which makes him all the more swoon-worthy.
The romance: Sweet sorghum molasses! Jake does a handsome job of pursuing Livy against his better judgement. Shy, reticent girl that Livy is, Jake's attentions are of necessity determined, yet gentle and sweet. They melted this reader's heart more than once--okay, a lot.
The plot: This is a page-turner for sure. I was constantly guessing until the end, and the plight of the children really makes this story unique.
The setting: While reading this novel, I felt like I was living the scenes. The details immerse the reader into the snowy world of Illinois winter but never overwhelm or slow the pace too much. The effect feels effortless and is a mark of Pam's incredible talent.
The theme: Forgiving ourselves and overcoming secrets in our past is hard. Everyone can relate to making mistakes they'd rather no one else know. But through the blood of Jesus, we have forgiveness and He gives us victory over sin. The prejudices about street kids are also addressed along with our need to "be Jesus to the least of these." Matt. 25:40. This leads me to my final point...
The faith element: Pam Hillman writes her faith into her stories so gently and earnestly, the reader never feels preached to, but at the same time there's never a question this book was written to minister and encourage. Another mark of excellent fiction writing. I was happy to find a good read that speaks of Jesus' blood and His power to cleanse us from sin.
The audience: Because of the subplot with the desperate street kids, people of all ages will enjoy this story. I recommend this novel to anyone who loves good fiction.
July 27, 2011
Light fingered Livy who was an expert at pick pocketing has given up her old ways of living and has changed for the better! She is now a Christian and is helping run an orphanage in a small time to start a new life for herself. She is troubled though by all the street kids in her new small town that are getting a bad name because someone is stealing and everyone is blaming them. She is trying to help figure out who is the thief to clear the street-kids names and at the same time trying to convince them to come stay at the orphanage where they will be safe!
Livy meets Deputy Jake and instantly there are sparks a flying! The only problem is that she is afraid of falling in love, afraid of lawman, and afraid that once Jake knows her past he will abandon her!
Stealing Jake starts off with a bang and you are instantly involved in the lives of the street kids and the story of Livy! I was devouring the chapters as fast as I could and I finished the book in one night because I had no desire to wait until tomorrow to keep reading! I just had to know who the bad guys were and what would be the fate of the poor street kids!
I really enjoyed the character development of Livy! I felt like I knew a lot about her and could easily connect to who she was. I also felt this way about Jake, although at times I wish I knew a little bit more about what happened to him in the mine but I still really felt connected to him.
The spiritual aspect of this book was very refreshing and inviting! Hillman portrays a message that God can take anyone and restore them to beauty for God's glory and that when you seek God for help he will always provide for you! I was touched by the sweet way the Christians were portrayed in this story but I also never felt the Spiritual aspects were too pushy!
I very much enjoyed reading this debut novel and will be making sure I check out more of Pam Hillman's work. By the way - I got this novel free on Amazon, not sure how long the deal will last!
Content: Very clean, minor kissing!
Livy meets Deputy Jake and instantly there are sparks a flying! The only problem is that she is afraid of falling in love, afraid of lawman, and afraid that once Jake knows her past he will abandon her!
Stealing Jake starts off with a bang and you are instantly involved in the lives of the street kids and the story of Livy! I was devouring the chapters as fast as I could and I finished the book in one night because I had no desire to wait until tomorrow to keep reading! I just had to know who the bad guys were and what would be the fate of the poor street kids!
I really enjoyed the character development of Livy! I felt like I knew a lot about her and could easily connect to who she was. I also felt this way about Jake, although at times I wish I knew a little bit more about what happened to him in the mine but I still really felt connected to him.
The spiritual aspect of this book was very refreshing and inviting! Hillman portrays a message that God can take anyone and restore them to beauty for God's glory and that when you seek God for help he will always provide for you! I was touched by the sweet way the Christians were portrayed in this story but I also never felt the Spiritual aspects were too pushy!
I very much enjoyed reading this debut novel and will be making sure I check out more of Pam Hillman's work. By the way - I got this novel free on Amazon, not sure how long the deal will last!
Content: Very clean, minor kissing!
September 7, 2015
I've read slightly over 100 books this year and this is most certainly one of my favorites. It's so good that I actually woke up at 3 AM this morning and finished reading it through 5 AM. Fortunately, I'm off work today and was able to go back to sleep until 8 am.
The setting is in the 1870s in Chestnut, IL, a growing community just train ride away from Chicago. Characters include Livy O’Brien, a young lady working in the new orphanage in town. Livy grew up on the streets of Chicago and survived by picking pockets in order to keep from starving. She has changed her ways and is spending her life helping Mrs. Brooks, the lady who rescued Livy from street life, take care of orphans. Livy has a heart to protect and help the street children in Chestnut, as she attempts to convince the community that the children are only trying to survive in the world with the cruel hand they have been dealt.
Jake Russell is a farmer, shareholder in a coal mine, and sheriff’s deputy of Chestnut. He is working hard to make ends meet for his widowed mother and his younger siblings. He has a history of being one of the few survivors from a coal mine collapse and lives with survivor’s guilt. Of course, Jake finds himself very attracted to Livy and is unaware of her past life as a pick pocket living on the streets in Chicago.
Both Jake and Livy are very likeable characters. The author also does a great job developing the supporting characters in the book. Ms. Hillman has a way of making the reader feel as though they are in the community of Chestnut, IL. The story includes gripping action and mystery as well as a touch of romance. As previously stated, this is one of my favorite reads of the year and I highly recommend it. If you enjoy historical fiction, you will love this book.
I received a copy of this book from the publisher, through The Book Club Network (bookfun.org) in exchange for my honest review.
The setting is in the 1870s in Chestnut, IL, a growing community just train ride away from Chicago. Characters include Livy O’Brien, a young lady working in the new orphanage in town. Livy grew up on the streets of Chicago and survived by picking pockets in order to keep from starving. She has changed her ways and is spending her life helping Mrs. Brooks, the lady who rescued Livy from street life, take care of orphans. Livy has a heart to protect and help the street children in Chestnut, as she attempts to convince the community that the children are only trying to survive in the world with the cruel hand they have been dealt.
Jake Russell is a farmer, shareholder in a coal mine, and sheriff’s deputy of Chestnut. He is working hard to make ends meet for his widowed mother and his younger siblings. He has a history of being one of the few survivors from a coal mine collapse and lives with survivor’s guilt. Of course, Jake finds himself very attracted to Livy and is unaware of her past life as a pick pocket living on the streets in Chicago.
Both Jake and Livy are very likeable characters. The author also does a great job developing the supporting characters in the book. Ms. Hillman has a way of making the reader feel as though they are in the community of Chestnut, IL. The story includes gripping action and mystery as well as a touch of romance. As previously stated, this is one of my favorite reads of the year and I highly recommend it. If you enjoy historical fiction, you will love this book.
I received a copy of this book from the publisher, through The Book Club Network (bookfun.org) in exchange for my honest review.
July 22, 2015
When Livy O’Brien spies a young boy jostling a man walking along the boardwalk, she recognizes the act for what it is. After all, she used to be known as Light-fingered Livy. But that was before she put her past behind her and moved to the growing town of Chestnut, Illinois, where she’s helping to run an orphanage. Now she’ll do almost anything to protect the street kids like herself.
Sheriff’s deputy Jake Russell had no idea what he was in for when he ran into Livy—literally—while chasing down a pickpocket. With a rash of robberies and a growing number of street kids in town—as well as a loan on the family farm that needs to be paid off—Jake doesn’t have time to pursue a girl. Still, he can't seem to get Livy out of his mind. He wants to get to know her better . . . but Livy isn’t willing to trust any man, especially not a lawman.
I wasn't sure what I was going to think of this one. It sounded good but was she going to pull it off right? She did, by blending the different stories together and showing the real side of each character and making them individual. Some books told by different points of view are really hard to understand and see the contrast of them, like when I read Allegiant, I had the worst time trying to follow the story and be able to tell the voices apart. I also liked that she was able to mix the different voices, instead of switching views every other chapter and retelling things just from the other person's point of view. I thought the ending was easy to tell and the mystery part was figured out for me be page 50 or so. So that wasn't very surprising either. But for more of an easy reading chick lit, this one hit the spot.
I received this book for review through Tyndale's blogger review program.
Sheriff’s deputy Jake Russell had no idea what he was in for when he ran into Livy—literally—while chasing down a pickpocket. With a rash of robberies and a growing number of street kids in town—as well as a loan on the family farm that needs to be paid off—Jake doesn’t have time to pursue a girl. Still, he can't seem to get Livy out of his mind. He wants to get to know her better . . . but Livy isn’t willing to trust any man, especially not a lawman.
I wasn't sure what I was going to think of this one. It sounded good but was she going to pull it off right? She did, by blending the different stories together and showing the real side of each character and making them individual. Some books told by different points of view are really hard to understand and see the contrast of them, like when I read Allegiant, I had the worst time trying to follow the story and be able to tell the voices apart. I also liked that she was able to mix the different voices, instead of switching views every other chapter and retelling things just from the other person's point of view. I thought the ending was easy to tell and the mystery part was figured out for me be page 50 or so. So that wasn't very surprising either. But for more of an easy reading chick lit, this one hit the spot.
I received this book for review through Tyndale's blogger review program.
January 16, 2016
An incredible read!This book has so much within it. Excitement, love, redemption, trust, suspense for starters.
Jake Russell is working as a deputy in the town of Chestnut, Illinois. His father and 28 others were killed in a mine explosion some years earlier and he was trapped in the mine. He was not about to go back.
Livy O'Brien grew up on the streets of Chicago, literally. She only had her sister Katie but she died. When the town of Chestnut started having robberies they were blaming street kids. Livy knew they would not draw attention to themselves and tried to convince Jake of it.
It is heart wrenching to think of kids being on the streets and having to survive. This was fiction but that is a also a fact. This book definitely pulls on the heart strings.
They were taking these street kids from Chicago to work in a factory in Chestnut. You see some of the kids being separated from their siblings. A side story is Luke who was able to escape but he is still searching for his brother Mark.
There are many unique characters as well. Gus and his donkey Little bit, Emma who owns a cafe, Mary and Gracie. This is just an excellent story.
Mrs Brooks had taken Livy into her care in Chicago and told her about the Lord. They had an orphanage here in Chestnut but it is hard to get the street kids to trust enough to come in.
Jake Russell is working as a deputy in the town of Chestnut, Illinois. His father and 28 others were killed in a mine explosion some years earlier and he was trapped in the mine. He was not about to go back.
Livy O'Brien grew up on the streets of Chicago, literally. She only had her sister Katie but she died. When the town of Chestnut started having robberies they were blaming street kids. Livy knew they would not draw attention to themselves and tried to convince Jake of it.
It is heart wrenching to think of kids being on the streets and having to survive. This was fiction but that is a also a fact. This book definitely pulls on the heart strings.
They were taking these street kids from Chicago to work in a factory in Chestnut. You see some of the kids being separated from their siblings. A side story is Luke who was able to escape but he is still searching for his brother Mark.
There are many unique characters as well. Gus and his donkey Little bit, Emma who owns a cafe, Mary and Gracie. This is just an excellent story.
Mrs Brooks had taken Livy into her care in Chicago and told her about the Lord. They had an orphanage here in Chestnut but it is hard to get the street kids to trust enough to come in.
October 3, 2015
This book has been in my to-read shelf for quite some time now; I wish I'd pick it up sooner.
This has got all the elements of a feel-good story: wholesome romance, children, family, sense of community, and of course, it's got Jesus Christ at the center of it all.
Set in 1870s America, the story played out in the little town of Chestnut, Illinois. Livy is starting over in a new town, helping run an orphanage. Jake is the sheriff deputy hoping to catch the person responsible for a series of robberies. Aside from them, there is a whole cast of characters who played out their parts in an effort to save and protect their town from the undesirables.
Christian romance books often have uncomplicated plots and this is no exception. Their pull is from the simple and real-life situations. As well, reading a good one is like attending Sunday service sans the preachy homilies. They just give enough dosing of platitudes to get the reader ruminating about their lives.
As Christian romance books come, I'd say this is a good one.
This has got all the elements of a feel-good story: wholesome romance, children, family, sense of community, and of course, it's got Jesus Christ at the center of it all.
Set in 1870s America, the story played out in the little town of Chestnut, Illinois. Livy is starting over in a new town, helping run an orphanage. Jake is the sheriff deputy hoping to catch the person responsible for a series of robberies. Aside from them, there is a whole cast of characters who played out their parts in an effort to save and protect their town from the undesirables.
Christian romance books often have uncomplicated plots and this is no exception. Their pull is from the simple and real-life situations. As well, reading a good one is like attending Sunday service sans the preachy homilies. They just give enough dosing of platitudes to get the reader ruminating about their lives.
As Christian romance books come, I'd say this is a good one.
September 21, 2015
Pam Hillman made each character come alive in Stealing Jake. With each page, I couldn't figure out what to anticipate next, not because this was thriller, but because this book was a page turner that kept me going and had me thinking about the characters when I wasn't reading.
Livy O' Brien "just a pickpocket from Chicago" doubts God's provision for food and money. Jake Russell the town sheriff has his fair share of problems, but will do anything to protect Chestnut, Illinois. However, Jake cannot understand Livy's need to protect the children on the street. He knows Livy is putting herself in danger, which intrigues him as he has never met someone quite like her, but why would she put herself in danger at the risk of helping kids?
Will Livy end up in jail for all the mistakes she has made or will end up with Jake? Will this book turn out to be a happy ending like we want all books to be?
Livy O' Brien "just a pickpocket from Chicago" doubts God's provision for food and money. Jake Russell the town sheriff has his fair share of problems, but will do anything to protect Chestnut, Illinois. However, Jake cannot understand Livy's need to protect the children on the street. He knows Livy is putting herself in danger, which intrigues him as he has never met someone quite like her, but why would she put herself in danger at the risk of helping kids?
Will Livy end up in jail for all the mistakes she has made or will end up with Jake? Will this book turn out to be a happy ending like we want all books to be?
May 17, 2012
I’m not particularly fond of “romance” novels. However, I read this cannot-put-down book in one day, staying up until 2AM when my eyes clamped shut from fatigue.
At the end, when I read that this is her debut novel, I was shocked. I could not find one chapter, one paragraph, one word that I didn’t love about this book. It is definitely an exceptional, unforgettable book.
I loved the way the author interwove the romance part of the story through a touching and inspirational, yet suspenseful and adventurous story about real issues in real places.
The message of trust, hope, forgiveness and healing unfolded in a superb manner. I have already recommended this book to fellow readers, and will continue to do so.
At the end, when I read that this is her debut novel, I was shocked. I could not find one chapter, one paragraph, one word that I didn’t love about this book. It is definitely an exceptional, unforgettable book.
I loved the way the author interwove the romance part of the story through a touching and inspirational, yet suspenseful and adventurous story about real issues in real places.
The message of trust, hope, forgiveness and healing unfolded in a superb manner. I have already recommended this book to fellow readers, and will continue to do so.
June 22, 2013
I really liked the story premise and enjoyed reading this book. Livy is an intriguing character with a heart of gold. Her faith helps her overcome her difficult childhood. She has a genuine desire to help the orphans and street kids who have appeared in her small town. Livy is drawn to Jake, despite fearing he will discover the truth about her past.
Jake struggles to understand why Livy has a soft spot for the street kids, who seem to be the source of trouble in the town. Explosive secrets are revealed that take Jake and Livy on a dangerous journey to seek the truth and bring justice to the town of Chestnut, Illinois. I highly recommend this book to those looking for a fast paced and beautifully plotted historical romance.
Jake struggles to understand why Livy has a soft spot for the street kids, who seem to be the source of trouble in the town. Explosive secrets are revealed that take Jake and Livy on a dangerous journey to seek the truth and bring justice to the town of Chestnut, Illinois. I highly recommend this book to those looking for a fast paced and beautifully plotted historical romance.
August 4, 2011
This was a good read. Fast paced, it kept my interest even though it was a little predictable.
October 25, 2011
Great! I cry at the ending every time! :-)
December 31, 2021
I picked up this book on clearance because it hit some of my favorite story elements for a fun read: a lawman, crime rings, a reformed criminal, and orphans. I wasn't familiar with Pam Hillman, but after reading this, I will definitely look into some of her other books and novellas. While I wouldn't say there were any unexpected plot twists, it was a fun and engaging story that I will likely reread in the future.
I loved the premise behind the criminal ring of street children being bought for use in sweatshops. I hadn't read a story that touched on that dark side of our history (and let's be honest, it is still going on today in a different format), and I really enjoyed seeing the town's opinion of those kids change over the course of the story. As a former street kid and current sweatshop escapee, Livy's and Luke's perspectives really added to the understanding of these kids' plight that garners compassion for a group that is easily written off. The tension between the romance was on the lighter side, but it was fun watching Livy and Jake fall in love and overcome the obstacles of prejudice and fear that stand between them.
Overall, I'd recommend this story for those looking for a light read, and those who enjoy criminal plots, lawmen heroes, sweet romances, and stories where communities learn to accept a previously rejected group of kids.
--
What I loved: I loved the plot with the street children and how the town's view of the kids changed throughout the book.
Favorite Character and Why: I really enjoyed all the street kids and orphan kids as a whole. Luke in particular was one who will live on in my memory for a while. He really struggled to help those still stuck in the sweatshop while trying to save his brother. Learning to trust was hard for him, but I loved how resourceful and determined he was. He'll make a great hero one day.
Who would like this? I'd recommend this story for those looking for a light read, and those who enjoy criminal plots, lawmen heroes, sweet romances, and stories where communities learn to accept a previously rejected group of kids.
Rating and Why: Four Stars. I enjoyed the storyline and characters and the character arcs were satisfactory. It was a good read that kept my attention but was easy to set down and pick back up when family interruptions occurred--even if those interruptions still annoyed me.
I loved the premise behind the criminal ring of street children being bought for use in sweatshops. I hadn't read a story that touched on that dark side of our history (and let's be honest, it is still going on today in a different format), and I really enjoyed seeing the town's opinion of those kids change over the course of the story. As a former street kid and current sweatshop escapee, Livy's and Luke's perspectives really added to the understanding of these kids' plight that garners compassion for a group that is easily written off. The tension between the romance was on the lighter side, but it was fun watching Livy and Jake fall in love and overcome the obstacles of prejudice and fear that stand between them.
Overall, I'd recommend this story for those looking for a light read, and those who enjoy criminal plots, lawmen heroes, sweet romances, and stories where communities learn to accept a previously rejected group of kids.
--
What I loved: I loved the plot with the street children and how the town's view of the kids changed throughout the book.
Favorite Character and Why: I really enjoyed all the street kids and orphan kids as a whole. Luke in particular was one who will live on in my memory for a while. He really struggled to help those still stuck in the sweatshop while trying to save his brother. Learning to trust was hard for him, but I loved how resourceful and determined he was. He'll make a great hero one day.
Who would like this? I'd recommend this story for those looking for a light read, and those who enjoy criminal plots, lawmen heroes, sweet romances, and stories where communities learn to accept a previously rejected group of kids.
Rating and Why: Four Stars. I enjoyed the storyline and characters and the character arcs were satisfactory. It was a good read that kept my attention but was easy to set down and pick back up when family interruptions occurred--even if those interruptions still annoyed me.
February 13, 2022
Wow. Great read. I loved almost everything about this book...from the plot to the the writing to the cover! I even loved the little decoration underlining each chapter (and echoed on the cover). Livy was strong and likeable. Jake was a man's man. The antagonists and all the supporting characters were perfectly written. The characters and story were well developed and the plot believable. There were only 2 things that irked me...
1 - This sentence from ch. 13: "He didn't want to rush her, but if he didn't put some distance between them soon, he'd give in and kiss her, and she'd as much as told him she wasn't ready for that, even though the look in the her eyes told him otherwise." Oh boy...this is so icky. Thankfully, the sentiments in this sentence are not found again or repeated in the book.
2 - Livy being so helpless near the end (inaction and despair while in the burning building, almost drowning and has to be saved, watches others clear the rock and debris from the mine). For such a strong, independent and decisive character, her actions (or lack thereof) seem inconsistent. I imagine she would do a lot more to help, fight and be effective in those situations.
Apart from those 2 items, this was a great read which I finished in less than 24 hours!! I would highly recommend this book. And, I would gladly read another Pam Hillman book again. 5 stars.
1 - This sentence from ch. 13: "He didn't want to rush her, but if he didn't put some distance between them soon, he'd give in and kiss her, and she'd as much as told him she wasn't ready for that, even though the look in the her eyes told him otherwise." Oh boy...this is so icky. Thankfully, the sentiments in this sentence are not found again or repeated in the book.
2 - Livy being so helpless near the end (inaction and despair while in the burning building, almost drowning and has to be saved, watches others clear the rock and debris from the mine). For such a strong, independent and decisive character, her actions (or lack thereof) seem inconsistent. I imagine she would do a lot more to help, fight and be effective in those situations.
Apart from those 2 items, this was a great read which I finished in less than 24 hours!! I would highly recommend this book. And, I would gladly read another Pam Hillman book again. 5 stars.
April 15, 2025
Stealing Jake by Pam Hillman is an exceptional read.
Livy O' Brian, a former street kid known as Light-Fingered Livy, moves to the town of Chestnut where she puts her past behind her and assists in running the local orphanage in town with Mrs Brooks. When she spots a boy discreetly pickpocketing a man, she steps in and returns his belongings without him being any wiser. Understanding the desperation street kids face, Livy strives to protect them from both the law and the greedy businessmen running sweatshops.
Jake Russel, a farmer, steps into the role of a sheriff's deputy to pay off a loan against the farm and care for his family. While apprehending a pickpocket, he meets Livy and finds her intriguing. Despite all his responsibilities, he finds himself forming a friendship with her. When robberies occur and everything seems to point at the street kids who seem to be increasing by the day, their friendship is tested. Will they discover who is really behind the robberies?
A wonderful novel woven with bits of romance, mystery and suspense while depicting the real challenges Christians face such as holding on to faith in spite of the desperate circumstances we face and making a conscious decision to let go of past mistakes, not allowing it to define us.
Livy O' Brian, a former street kid known as Light-Fingered Livy, moves to the town of Chestnut where she puts her past behind her and assists in running the local orphanage in town with Mrs Brooks. When she spots a boy discreetly pickpocketing a man, she steps in and returns his belongings without him being any wiser. Understanding the desperation street kids face, Livy strives to protect them from both the law and the greedy businessmen running sweatshops.
Jake Russel, a farmer, steps into the role of a sheriff's deputy to pay off a loan against the farm and care for his family. While apprehending a pickpocket, he meets Livy and finds her intriguing. Despite all his responsibilities, he finds himself forming a friendship with her. When robberies occur and everything seems to point at the street kids who seem to be increasing by the day, their friendship is tested. Will they discover who is really behind the robberies?
A wonderful novel woven with bits of romance, mystery and suspense while depicting the real challenges Christians face such as holding on to faith in spite of the desperate circumstances we face and making a conscious decision to let go of past mistakes, not allowing it to define us.
August 27, 2022
This was a really good story. I don't know much about orphans being used in sweatshops except that modern Child Labor laws came about because of it, but reading stories like this (despite being fiction) makes me incredibly thankful for those laws and equally devastated by the knowledge that so many children suffered and died from such brutality before human decency recognized the evil of the practice. Even though this story is set in Illinois outside Chicago in 1874, it very much has a western frontier feel to it. I also appreciated the added suspense of the coal mining, the dangers of it, and the bravery of the men willing to risk their lives every day to go into the pits of Hell and work. The plight of the orphans, the messages of anti-discrimination, trust, and forgiveness, and the blossoming romance between Jake and Livy made for a wonderful adventure that I thoroughly enjoyed escaping in to. This was a great read! Bravo Pam Hillman Bravo!!
June 3, 2017
If you love children, Chicago, or just a good love story, you'll be hard pressed to out this book down.
Starting over in a new town, Livy, once herself a street urchin, now helps the woman who resced her from the streets run an orphanige in Illinois. Jake, the young deputy soon finds her intriguing but can she overcome her own fears from her past to trust a man, much less a police officer after her horrible experiences on the streets of Chicago? And will he still have any interest in her if he finds out just exactly how she had feed herself back beforecoming to Chestnut? When children who where sold to work in a sweatshop need help, Livy jumps in to help them, putting herself and Jake in danger. Pam Hillman writes a heartstopping, tear-provoking good romance.
Starting over in a new town, Livy, once herself a street urchin, now helps the woman who resced her from the streets run an orphanige in Illinois. Jake, the young deputy soon finds her intriguing but can she overcome her own fears from her past to trust a man, much less a police officer after her horrible experiences on the streets of Chicago? And will he still have any interest in her if he finds out just exactly how she had feed herself back beforecoming to Chestnut? When children who where sold to work in a sweatshop need help, Livy jumps in to help them, putting herself and Jake in danger. Pam Hillman writes a heartstopping, tear-provoking good romance.
July 4, 2017
Livy was rescued from the streets of Chicago and given a home. When the people of her town begin to blame street children for crimes being committed, Livy looks for ways to help the children and gain their trust. The deputy takes a special interest in Livy, but how can she ever love a lawman. He will certainly reject her once he finds out about her past.
The author did a great job with writing a believable story. There were many characters, but it was never confusing. The book held my attention from beginning to end. The love story was sweet.
The author did a great job with writing a believable story. There were many characters, but it was never confusing. The book held my attention from beginning to end. The love story was sweet.
February 2, 2022
Stealing Jake was a delightful story of Livy O'Brien who has left behind her life on the streets of Chicago as a child and is now reaching out to other homeless young people. I admired Livy and Mrs Brooks who first told Livy about Christ and gave her a home. Jake Russell, sheriff's deputy, doesn't have much sympathy for the homeless kids from Chicago until Livy persuades him to take a closer look. There are bigger problems happening in Chestnut, Illinois! I recommend Stealing Jake by Pam Hillman.
June 2, 2023
I’m a sucker for western romance lol! This was a bit darker than I was expecting but I liked it because it touched on some things you don’t normally hear about in these stories. I didn’t like the ending because I didn’t feel like there was an ending. It kinda ended like a hallmark movie but i felt like there was a lot of loose ends that needed to be tied up especially regarding the main characters conflicting emotions about having a baby herself.
November 1, 2017
Rating 3.5. This is not clearly a 3 but not clearly a 4, either. Where are the half stars at a time like this?!
There was a lot going on in this story and a lot of interesting characters. I am rounding this up to 4 stars.
I normally avoid books about cruelty to children but chose this by accident. Despite that being a main theme for the book, it was presented in a way I could tolerate.
There was a lot going on in this story and a lot of interesting characters. I am rounding this up to 4 stars.
I normally avoid books about cruelty to children but chose this by accident. Despite that being a main theme for the book, it was presented in a way I could tolerate.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 141 reviews