What do you think?
Rate this book
Un treno pieno di vento
Agli inizi del Novecento intere folle di bambini vivevano di carità, piccoli furti e altri espedienti per le strade di New York. Nacquero in quegli anni, per iniziativa di un giovane pastore protestante, i cosiddetti Treni degli orfani: decine di migliaia di bambini - abbandonati, senzatetto, vittime della povertà o della negligenza dei genitori - salirono sui treni diretti a ovest, per essere adottati da nuove famiglie cristiane dell'America rurale. Nessuno di loro conosceva la propria destinazione. Ogni possibile provvedimento fu preso affinché le famiglie d'origine non potessero mai più rintracciarli. "Un treno pieno di vento prende" le mosse da un capitolo drammatico della storia americana per raccontare le vite intrecciate di tre donne.
263 pages, Hardcover
First published January 1, 2011
23 people are currently reading
720 people want to read
About the author
Rae Meadows
11 books446 followersRae Meadows is the author of the forthcoming WINTERLAND and four previous novels: Calling Out, No One Tells Everything, Mercy Train (in hardcover as Mothers and Daughters), and most recently, I Will Send Rain, which was an Indie Next pick, and received starred reviews from Publishers Weekly, Library Journal, and Booklist. She is the recipient of the Goldenberg Prize for Fiction, the Hackney Literary Award for the novel, and the Utah Book Award, and her work has been published widely. Meadows lives with her family in Brooklyn, New York.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 104 reviews
June 6, 2012
Three generations of mothers and daughter are featured in this novel. Samantha, with a young daughter of her own, is dealing with her own personal crisis, when she is sent a mystery box that contains her grandmothers history. She can use this history and learn from it, gain strength and find a way through her own life. In 1854 through 1929, may children including Samantha's grandmother roamed the streets of New York, forging their own families with other children and trying to survive on their own. Mercy or orphan trains actually transported 150,000 to 200,000 children to the countryside of the Midwest. What I never knew was that they made it virtually impossible for these children's parents to ever find them again. Really heartbreaking for those who just had parents who could not temporarily take care of them but hoped to reclaim them one day. Poignant read.
July 14, 2015
I can only give the book "Mercy Train" a three and barely at that. I wanted to read this book because it mentioned that one of the characters Violet rode the orphan train when she was 11 years old in 1900. The parts with Violet were good and interesting. I liked her plot line. Instead it goes between three characters' point of view. Violets, Iris, daughter of Violet, and Samantha daughter of Iris. I was disappointed that Samantha knew almost nothing of her grandmother. and neither Iris or Samantha knew about Violet and how she rode the orphan train.{Samantha found out only after Iris died and found a box of items from Violet}the readers know when they read Violet's story.I would have liked it if the ONLY CHARACTER that had most of the storyline would have been Violet. I could have cared less about Iris or Samantha. Both of these characters were boring and not fleshed out very much to be of interest. Very disappointed in this book.Even the cover of this book is confusing who the heck are the two kids on the cover?this could have been so much better if the author had stuck with the Violet plot line.
December 12, 2012
I wanted to know more about the orphan trains . Also wanted to know more about violet when she left the train. Found this book to be disappointing
May 3, 2012
Samantha finds herself on a precipice, her role as mother has been her end all but now it’s time to return to her work, but her potter’s wheel remains dust covered as she instead breaks open a seal to mementos discovered from her mother who died two years prior. As she goes through the items both foreign and familiar, she finds things from both her mother Iris and her grandmother Violet which opens a new path of discovery for Sam, a discovery of two women who she should have known deeper, a discovery that could lead to answers of how she copes with life, love and loss, a discovery of why her relationship with her mother was like it was, a discovery of how all of these things could have been molded even before she was born and a mystery she now finds she needs to solve.
Iris is dying of cancer and she’s ready to go. Knowing her daughter is coming to see her off on her final journey is both troubling and comforting because there are things that she’s never revealed, things that she knows she should have told Sam, but then the relationship between she and her own mother was always full of things left unsaid.
Violet finds herself a mostly motherless child on the wild streets of New York City at the turn of the 20th century. Her mother unable to cope with Violet or life itself sends Violet on a train that will change her life. From that ride on the Mercy Train Violet will discover things about herself and the world that both please and worry her, the ride will shape her life and her relationships with others even those who should be closest to her, that ride will shape not only her life but the lives of future generations.
Rae Meadows brought me a poignant look at how the past shapes the future, how nature as well as nurture have as much to do with how we live and look at life as anything does. She brings me a story of three women daughter, mother and grandmother who’s lives reflect that beautifully, she shows how the cycle of secrets change lives and not always for the better and how that cycle can be altered by love and enlightening and looking inside one’s own heart. How one woman can learn from the accomplishments as well as the failures of generations past to better not only her own future but the relationship that will evolve between she and her own daughter. She discloses things historically accurate about the Orphan Trains that traveled with unsuspecting yet hopeful children from NYC to our heartlands.
Mercy Train is a mix of historical and contemporary, literary and women’s fiction with a narrative that took me right inside the pages to the scenes created by the imaginative mind of the author, she acquaints me intimately with her characters and kept me reading through chores and bedtime because I couldn’t not know what happens next. However if you’re looking for that read that answers your every question I’m afraid you won’t get that here as Ms. Meadows leaves certain possibilities open to her audience which of
Please check out the Q&A with the author http://bookclubs.barnesandnoble.com/t...
Iris is dying of cancer and she’s ready to go. Knowing her daughter is coming to see her off on her final journey is both troubling and comforting because there are things that she’s never revealed, things that she knows she should have told Sam, but then the relationship between she and her own mother was always full of things left unsaid.
Violet finds herself a mostly motherless child on the wild streets of New York City at the turn of the 20th century. Her mother unable to cope with Violet or life itself sends Violet on a train that will change her life. From that ride on the Mercy Train Violet will discover things about herself and the world that both please and worry her, the ride will shape her life and her relationships with others even those who should be closest to her, that ride will shape not only her life but the lives of future generations.
Rae Meadows brought me a poignant look at how the past shapes the future, how nature as well as nurture have as much to do with how we live and look at life as anything does. She brings me a story of three women daughter, mother and grandmother who’s lives reflect that beautifully, she shows how the cycle of secrets change lives and not always for the better and how that cycle can be altered by love and enlightening and looking inside one’s own heart. How one woman can learn from the accomplishments as well as the failures of generations past to better not only her own future but the relationship that will evolve between she and her own daughter. She discloses things historically accurate about the Orphan Trains that traveled with unsuspecting yet hopeful children from NYC to our heartlands.
Mercy Train is a mix of historical and contemporary, literary and women’s fiction with a narrative that took me right inside the pages to the scenes created by the imaginative mind of the author, she acquaints me intimately with her characters and kept me reading through chores and bedtime because I couldn’t not know what happens next. However if you’re looking for that read that answers your every question I’m afraid you won’t get that here as Ms. Meadows leaves certain possibilities open to her audience which of
Please check out the Q&A with the author http://bookclubs.barnesandnoble.com/t...
December 16, 2016
Wonderful generational story of women. Because I've read several books on the orphan trains, I was glad it wasn't all about that again. I note that others perhaps who hadn't read books on the orphan trains, wanted more though!
This is a story more about the grandmother, mother and daughter and the secrets that are/were kept, and how they impacted all of them. Beautifully written book with wonderful character development.
I heard Rae Meadows speak at the Wisconsin Book Festival, and she was a gracious humble speaker who engaged quickly with her audience. I recently read her latest book first and truly enjoyed it as well. I look forward to anything she will write in the future!
This is a story more about the grandmother, mother and daughter and the secrets that are/were kept, and how they impacted all of them. Beautifully written book with wonderful character development.
I heard Rae Meadows speak at the Wisconsin Book Festival, and she was a gracious humble speaker who engaged quickly with her audience. I recently read her latest book first and truly enjoyed it as well. I look forward to anything she will write in the future!
August 9, 2017
Un bel romanzo, non posso nascondere che mi abbia coinvolto e che sia scritto molto bene. Purtroppo però me lo aspettavo più profondo e mi immaginavo un libro che si fermasse ai primi del Novecento e che descrivesse più a fondo la povertà di famiglie costrette (o no) ad abbandonare dei figli su quei "Treni" con i conseguenti destini. Avrei apprezzato di più un romanzo sulle vite che ad essi erano collegate.
June 10, 2018
Another great read by this author, told through the eyes of three generations of women in one family. Another look into orphan trains and the over run rampant children of New York.
September 29, 2020
La storia di tre generazioni di donne, ciascuna in lotta con la propria realtà e le sue difficoltà. ⠀
L’arco temporale abbraccia l’intero ultimo secolo, a partire dai primi anni del 1900, dove incontriamo la prima protagonista: Violet, bambina di 11 anni nata nel Kentucky e trasferitasi, insieme alla madre, a New York.⠀
Povertà e miseria spingeranno la madre a scegliere di far adottare la piccola Violet rivolgendosi alla Children’s Aid Society. Insieme a Violet, migliaia di bambini - orfani, senzatetto o provenienti da famiglie estremamente povere - si ritrovano a bordo dei “treni degli orfani”, con la prospettiva di essere adottati da nuove famiglie cristiane dell’America rurale. Non mancarono ovviamente i casi in cui gli orfani dei treni si ritrovarono vittime di abusi o sfruttamento.⠀
⠀
Dalla sua vicenda è tratto il titolo italiano che però non rispecchia il contenuto del romanzo. Molto più giusto, secondo me, sarebbe stato tradurre il titolo originale di “Mothers and daughters”.⠀
⠀
Perché il romanzo procede poi su diversi piani temporali, abilmente intersecati, lasciando la narrazione sempre limpida e scorrevole. I temi invece sono tanti, tutti ugualmente dolorosi e che non lasciano indifferenti: oltre alla drammatica vicenda dei treni degli orfani, si parla anche di maternità (non sempre desiderata), aborto, malattia, rimpianti e delusioni.⠀
⠀
Insomma non un libro felice, come lo sono tutti quelli che parlano della realtà.
L’arco temporale abbraccia l’intero ultimo secolo, a partire dai primi anni del 1900, dove incontriamo la prima protagonista: Violet, bambina di 11 anni nata nel Kentucky e trasferitasi, insieme alla madre, a New York.⠀
Povertà e miseria spingeranno la madre a scegliere di far adottare la piccola Violet rivolgendosi alla Children’s Aid Society. Insieme a Violet, migliaia di bambini - orfani, senzatetto o provenienti da famiglie estremamente povere - si ritrovano a bordo dei “treni degli orfani”, con la prospettiva di essere adottati da nuove famiglie cristiane dell’America rurale. Non mancarono ovviamente i casi in cui gli orfani dei treni si ritrovarono vittime di abusi o sfruttamento.⠀
⠀
Dalla sua vicenda è tratto il titolo italiano che però non rispecchia il contenuto del romanzo. Molto più giusto, secondo me, sarebbe stato tradurre il titolo originale di “Mothers and daughters”.⠀
⠀
Perché il romanzo procede poi su diversi piani temporali, abilmente intersecati, lasciando la narrazione sempre limpida e scorrevole. I temi invece sono tanti, tutti ugualmente dolorosi e che non lasciano indifferenti: oltre alla drammatica vicenda dei treni degli orfani, si parla anche di maternità (non sempre desiderata), aborto, malattia, rimpianti e delusioni.⠀
⠀
Insomma non un libro felice, come lo sono tutti quelli che parlano della realtà.
October 23, 2014
The idea for this book is fascinating. I was mislead by the summary, which portrays a story of a young mother sifting through her mother's belongings and discovering a family history no one but her Grandmother knew about. It takes more than 1/2 the book for her to open the box of her Mother's belongings, and the rest of the book too look through them. She finds clues, which are great, but at no point does she actually discover anything about her family. We, as readers, know the backstory, because Mrs. Meadows told us what really happened. There was also a lot of filler, such as Samantha following the prostitute, that doesn't add any significance to the story whatsoever. I do like the differing perspectives we get from Violet, Iris, and Samantha.
May 1, 2018
Carino, ma non era quello che mi aspettavo. Credevo fosse totalmente incentrato sulle vicende di questi bambini sfortunati che venivano portati ad ovest per essere adottati. Invece qui si parla solo della storia di una di queste bambine e della sua discendenza.
I capitoli alternano la storia di Violet, Iris e Sam. A dire il vero mi è piaciuta solo la storia di Violet, mentre le altre due mi sono sembrate incomplete perché in entrambi i casi mi sono mancati dei dettagli che avrei voluto conoscere.
Bella la ricostruzione dell'atmosfera che si respirava nei quartieri poveri della New York dei primi del Novecento. L'autrice ha descritto con effetto lo squallore di vite miserabili che vi si trascinavano arrangiandosi come potevano per sopravvivere.
I capitoli alternano la storia di Violet, Iris e Sam. A dire il vero mi è piaciuta solo la storia di Violet, mentre le altre due mi sono sembrate incomplete perché in entrambi i casi mi sono mancati dei dettagli che avrei voluto conoscere.
Bella la ricostruzione dell'atmosfera che si respirava nei quartieri poveri della New York dei primi del Novecento. L'autrice ha descritto con effetto lo squallore di vite miserabili che vi si trascinavano arrangiandosi come potevano per sopravvivere.
June 24, 2012
The book is the story of a woman who was put on a "mercy" or orphan train byt her mother who could not care for her. These trains took poor children from the city and gave them to families in the Midwest. Sometimes this was a success, but not always. The plot deals with Violet, the child put on the train; her daughter Iris, who tries to understand her mother's idiosyncracies; and Samantha, Iris's daughter. Obviously, a story or mothers and daughters and how they relate.
I was only briefly aware of the use of these "orphan trains" and found it an interesting subject. I also found the characters in the book likeable and believeable. I enjoyed the book and would recommend it.
I was only briefly aware of the use of these "orphan trains" and found it an interesting subject. I also found the characters in the book likeable and believeable. I enjoyed the book and would recommend it.
November 6, 2012
Having coincidentally just finished The Chaperone, which happens to be about the same subject matter, I could not help but compare the two. I found this book a bit undeveloped...the characters and story lines for each one just seemed to be lacking. In fact, when I got to the last page, I was left with a sense of "that's it?". It was as if the author was given a word limit and hadn't thought the story out so had to wrap it up in 2 pages. Lots of unanswered questions...
December 7, 2012
This book seemed incomplete to me...when I reached the end I felt I had only read one fourth of it...there was no tying up of loose ends at all...no closure of the characters...it was very poorly written...
August 12, 2017
This was a book club choice. I had no previous knowledge about the orphan trains of the past and would have liked to have read more about this topic. The original publishing title was Mothers and Daughters and I think that it makes a better title to go with the subject matter. Although we do get to read about some of Violets experiences in the streets of NYC and why her mother could not keep her, it does not go into much detail about the background of the orphan trains and what happened to Violet once she found a place. I feel as though there should be a sequel so we can learn more about this feisty, willful child who just wanted to be loved. What I did find interesting was the relationship between the mothers and daughters. How much do we think we know our mothers when in reality they have lived and felt so many things that we can not fathom until we become mothers ourselves. Even their past experiences and upbringing color their personalties, likes and dislikes, and the way they approach life in ways we cannot understand. It was difficult to read about Iris and her illness because I have lost my mother recently and have experienced so many of the same situations and feelings. It was difficult to see this independent, proud woman wasting away and needing so much assistance from those around her. It was an honor to be with her as she drew her last breath and it was the last thing I could have done for her as a dutiful daughter. Sam just had one box of things to go through. We had a whole houseful of things that must have meant something to her but have little value to us. Things that have a story that we can no longer ask about. Photos of people we do not know but who were once special to her. It's somewhat sad as Sam pointed out that a life can be reduced to a box of clippings and photos. Many memories, stories and family history were lost with my mom's passing in the same way that Violet's and Iris' death sealed a chapter that her daughter and grandchildren will not know about.
"Motherhood has it's own universe and it's own nonlinear timeline, it's own indefinable pain and reward."
"Motherhood has it's own universe and it's own nonlinear timeline, it's own indefinable pain and reward."
September 12, 2018
I had read The Orphan Train earlier and was glad that this one was a different approach.
This highlighted a very poignant chapter in U.S. history. It is hard to imagine that happening in our culture today. We don't know poor!
I enjoyed Rae's writing but found the activities of each member in their chapters some what hard to follow. Ex.: I couldn't always tell the stage of Iris's health and is Ella born at this stage of Samantha's life. It was cleared up eventually but caused unnecessary confusion.
This highlighted a very poignant chapter in U.S. history. It is hard to imagine that happening in our culture today. We don't know poor!
I enjoyed Rae's writing but found the activities of each member in their chapters some what hard to follow. Ex.: I couldn't always tell the stage of Iris's health and is Ella born at this stage of Samantha's life. It was cleared up eventually but caused unnecessary confusion.
June 23, 2021
Ii liked the parts of the story about Violet. This character was well developed and we knew quite a bit about her. Iris and Samantha were not very well rounded and a lot of information about them was lacking. I felt that the story just stopped instead of ending. We know that Iris died, but we don't know anything about Samantha's continuing story.
March 13, 2021
(2.5). Don't know what it was, but it was difficult for me to connect with the characters. There were times in the book I was thinking 'just get on with it'. Not all of the book was this way, but certainly enough parts that it was hard to feel inspired to keep reading.
December 24, 2025
I liked the concept of the book more than the story itself. Three generations of women all with their own struggles and secrets. Something felt disjointed and disconnected but overall not the worst read ever.
November 10, 2017
I had high hopes for this story, but ended up disappointed.
December 1, 2017
Another book about the orphan trains. I learned that even though they were Christian charity work, the program was a predecessor to our current foster care system.
August 26, 2018
Liked Orphan Train a bit more, but each showed a totally plausible narative... I really like reading history as fiction in this manner. Has Author notes and questions... I like that in a book.
January 6, 2020
I didn't think the blurb on the book cover was really accurate as to what this book was about. I expected more of a discovery of family secrets. I was somewhat disappointed.
July 14, 2020
3.5. I read a few pages in November and stopped. Started reading again a few days ago. The book follows 3 generations. I think there was more to say about Sam.
I am not a big fan of the format.
I am not a big fan of the format.
September 23, 2020
Not as good as Orphan Train/ but interesting.
Read
November 12, 2020not bad, not fond of books that jump around so much
July 13, 2022
An amazing novel about three generations of struggle, loss and love.
August 1, 2022
Good. I felt that the ending could have been better. It failed to come together.
November 2, 2022
Excellent read for book club!
January 28, 2024
Very disjointed. Jumping from one woman’s story to another but never really getting you invested in any of them.
March 8, 2024
I like the overall themes of motherhood and feminity however it was a very slowly paced book and I found myself loosing interest pretty quickly
Displaying 1 - 30 of 104 reviews