When two friends like a guy, it doesn't end very well most of the time. Usually they end up assuming the guy likes them when in reality, he hardly knows them. They almost always try to make a move on him just to realize he doesn't like them at all. "The Sweetest Thing" is just like this. Two girls named Judith and Meredith like the same guy, and since this same incident happened years ago, they both promise to not let another boy get in between them. As always, they seem to forget about their promise. As their feelings for Adam increase, they both try to make a move on him.
Judith and Meredith are Flan’s new best friends. Since they start liking Adam, she is scared of letting him ruin Meredith and Judith’s friendship. While they fawn over Adam She can't see what they see in him. To her he is just a dumb football player who doesn’t care about anyone. However, when he and Flan talk to each other she realizes how easy it is to fall for him. Even though she starts to like Adam, she feels guilty about it because she has a boyfriend. Plus her friends both like him.
The setting takes place in New York City, Flan's freshman year.
The theme is don't let anyone get in the way of friendships, especially guys. In the end, It is best friends who will stick around. Throughout this book, Judith and Meredith have been struggling with not letting a guy get in the way of their friendship.
I would recommend this book to anyone who has read the first book. Although it's not too hard to read without getting confused, it may be helpful to read the first book.