What do you think?
Rate this book


880 pages, Hardcover
First published January 10, 2012
This book is a long hard slog, but a rewarding one for Brautigan fans. The result of over two decades of research on Hjortsberg's part, the book presents Brautigan's life in minute detail over the course of some 812 pages. It does seem slightly ironic that Hjortsberg goes to such lengths and covers so much detail in discussing the life of an author who valued smallness, brevity, and the beauty of the mundane.
The book's strengths are manifold. We are given insight into Brautigan's writing methods, everything he wrote whether published or unpublished, how he developed those beautiful book covers for his works pre-Hawkline Monster, and how his art developed over the course of his career. For Brautigan scholars there is more than enough detail about Brautigan's thinking and his relationships with other people, but most importantly to this reader, Hjortsberg uses his own novelistic skills to provide a visceral understanding of Brautigan's motives for committing suicide. The book's conclusion is heart-rendingly perfect.
As detailed as this tome is, I found it did not do a very good job of some basic things most of us Brautignists want to see, such as showing just how witty and jovial Brautigan could be. To get that, one must read Greg Keeler's Waltzing with the Captain or even Keith Abbott's Downstream from Trout Fishing in America (though it is less well written than is either Keeler's or Hjortsberg's works). Further, Hjortsberg does very little to explain or even to dramatize how such a humane writer, such a searcher for TRUTH as Brautigan was could be such a womanizer and then be so devastated when either first wife Ginny or second wife Akiko strayed off the reservation. Even worse, perhaps, we are given no hint of an explanation as to why Brautigan's star faded in the early eighties. What caused the voice of the generation to lose his audience?
These concerns aside, this book is major work showing great dedication and devotion to its subject. If it had only been edited more closely. There are numerous dittographies, missing words, dangling modifiers,and misspellings that indicate that the book was edited on screen, perhaps even scanned from typed pages (see Becky Forida for Becky Fonda on p. 708).