I decided to give this 4-stars in the end, though may only deserve 3 - I can understand some of the complaints about this book. For starters, it goes alphabetically as opposed to chronologically, which gets a bit confusing to follow. - Most of the players have only a few short paragraphs, which can be good or bad depending on the player. Some of them don't need more than a paragraph, but others certainly could've used a bit more detail. For instance, Joe Thorton had a whopping four sentences total, and one of them was about how he wore Scooby Doo underwear. - Many of the mentions were players who played one game, or a fraction of a game, while interesting to some degree, not always necessary to mention. There were also many mentionable names left out (Don Sweeney, among others).
All that said - I did enjoy the book as a quick fun read. It's more of a fun-fact / brush up on your trivia type of book. Entertaining enough to read from start to finish.