Kathleen Fuller's Maple Falls series has been kind of hit or miss for me, as while I didn't end up enjoying the first two titles in the series as much I'd expected to, I thought the third title was a wonderful romance, which ended up being a pleasant surprise. I was hopeful this one would end up being another lovely addition to the series, especially since the synopsis sounded sweet and charming.
I usually love titles that have a "bookish" element, so the fact that Olivia was the town's librarian already had this one moving in the right direction. Unfortunately, her character wasn't exactly what I was expecting or hoping for, and she was kind of hard to relate to, and slightly unlikeable. Kingston wasn't a character I ended up enjoying either, especially since he often seemed scatterbrained, and completely out of touch with reality. While the romance could have been swoon worthy and adorable, instead it reads as insta-love, and even more precisely, insta-lust, and I had a hard time believing their feelings developed as fast as they did. Without giving spoilers away, I also felt a lot of the drama that existed between the two of them over the issues in their relationship seemed blown out of proportion, and all could have been resolved if they'd simply taken the time to truly talk things out. However, this book also includes a wonderful romance between two of the older residents of Maple Falls, and that one I wholeheartedly enjoyed, and was more than happy with how it wrapped up.
All in all, it was nice to get one last visit to the (fictional) town of Maple Falls, but I have to say that this series overall has been a miss for me. While the setting is lovely, many of the characters are a hoot, and they all have a really great plot set up, the execution generally ends up feeling to me like something is missing by the end of the story, and that was the case again here. Also, I really wish that books marketed as "Christian" fiction would actually have a faith element included, instead of just a few superficial mentions of attending church.
Final Rating: 3/5.
A cute romance that stays fairly clean, but with a disjointed plotline and characters that were unlikeable and unrelatable, I don't foresee myself rereading this one again in the future.
Thanks so much to Thomas Nelson for allowing me to read and review this one!
I voluntarily read and reviewed a complimentary advance reader copy of this novel from the publisher (Thomas Nelson) via NetGalley. I was not required to give a positive review. All thoughts and opinions are my own, and this is my honest review.