This is a collection of interviews, and I’m okay with it being written partly in dialect — it sounds like listening to some of my family members. There’s always a risk with that, though, of unintentionally parodying your subject. Hard to say whether that happened here, although it is pretty heehaw. What I enjoyed less was the jumble: there’s an attempt at categorization, but gets replaced by another method halfway through, like the project got passed to another editor. Even the dialect transcription stops, and the rest of the stories are in plain English.
The stories themselves are … fine. Some are much better than others, but a majority are along the lines of “One night I was walking home and saw a man, but when I looked again he was gone!” That’s it. That’s the story. Or, “One time I heard there was a lady who set her baby down for a minute and a panther ate it.” There’s a whole section of “stories” (debatable) about mountain lions, for some reason. Which is fine, it just feels a little like padding.