This was a very quick read - and honestly, it was a solid story, but it didn't catch my interest as "Haunted Violet" did. I'm not sure if I'm faerie'd out (if that could ever happen to me, I'm not even sure), or if this particular faerie story just wasn't for me. It didn't keep my interest, and it felt like a lot of the other faerie stories out there that have already been written, and quite frankly, written better than this one was.
But this isn't to say that Alyxandra Harvey isn't a good writer or that "Stolen Away" isn't a good story - it's more that I feel that "Haunting Violet" is her best, and is a pretty hard act to follow. This story is solid, but just not as well-developed as "Violet" was. "Violet" was gorgeous, and I'd love to see more books in that Victorian world that Harvey captured so well. "Stolen Away" felt more like Harvey was phoning it in, and maybe writing it because the fae are big right now, I'm not even sure (even if that does sound cruel, an author has to eat, and I completely understand why she might have done that if that were the case). I wish I could say better, but I just can't. My interest wavered and attention wandered throughout so many parts of this book that I feel like I had to crawl to the end of the book on my belly.
The characters didn't feel very solid, or very filled out, and the pace was far too fast. I can see where maybe this might be a good book for the very young YA crowd just getting into the world of faerie and all of its complications, but so many authors have done it better. I have to agree with a lot of the other reviewers in that the dialogue felt stilted and cliched at times, and the romance left me completely unmoved. However, I did like Lucas' character, because he felt the most solid and detailed of them all. Even if at times he sounded totally ridiculous with his otherworldly/outdated speech, but I dig things like that.
However, one of Harvey's more strong points (sensory/descriptive language) really shone in this one. I think this one saved the book for me, even if I just couldn't finish it. The sensory language was at its best, and reminded me of "Violet". The words there flowed the most, but got stopped up with dialogue and word choice in that dialogue. The sensory language really saved the book. I really just wished everything else had worked as well for me as it did for other readers.
I think what the main problem was was the execution of the plot. The plot was excellent and that's what drew me in in the first place. But I think the faulty execution was a lack of development with the most important/main cast of characters, and the words they spoke. The rest of it flowed pretty well when you take out those two major elements. Had the arc and sub-arcs been different, I think I might have enjoyed this more.
I really hate giving reviews like this, especially since I had some high expectations after finishing "Violet" and getting excited over the synopsis blurb for this book. However, I stress that this is probably just me, and you should definitely give "Stolen Away" a try since it is a very solid story. I guess my idea of faerie is just more than Harvey could give me, and that's okay. It hits shelves on January 17th, so be sure to pick it up at your local store or library and give it a browse, and tell me what you think.
(posted to goodreads, shelfari, and witchoftheatregoing.wordpress.com)