This is probably more of a 3.5 stars, but I decided to lean more toward 4 when posting.
First off, I love Greek Mythology. I just ate it up when I was in school and consumed it in big chunks. It rocked my world and I went beyond what the teacher assigned us to find out all I could about the subject. So I'm wired to like this book you could say. I'm also a big supporter of Indie Authors (since I started off Indie before my three book deal with Tor), and I know there are a slew of good authors out there waiting to be discovered (like J.L. Bryan).
The Things I Liked:
There was a nice sense of humor to the whole book. The idea of the Greek gods being reincarnated and are now all teenagers attending a high school called Olympia Heights is very tongue in cheek and fun. I liked how their archenemy football team was the Titans.
Zeus and Hera were very well fleshed out. I really felt bad for Hera, but Zeus does have his own particular charm. Their complex relationship was very well done.
Aphrodite, the goddess of Love, shows just how powerful and destructive she can be with her "love" and it was easy to hate and like her at the same time.
I really liked Poseidon's awakening to his power and how it came about. Dionysus also had a bit of a funny part about being constantly drunk once he discovered he could turn any liquid into alcohol.
It is clear the author knows a lot about Greek mythology and I enjoyed the quotes and flashback stories at the beginning of each chapter. In fact, the flashback stories were so beautifully written I would read a whole book just with that writing style.
Finally, the plot was good enough to keep me hooked and reading late into the night.
What I Didn't Like:
The head hopping in the begging of the book was horrible. The reader literally was hopping from person to person in some scenes. It felt really disjointed and was annoying. I almost gave up reading the book because of it. I don't mind a section being from one perspective and another section being from another character's point of view, but from paragraph to paragraph....UGH!!! Happily, this stopped being an issue deeper into the book when the author started alternating POV from chapter to chapter.
I honestly don't know any of the kids' names. I know which god they were supposed to be, but I didn't manage to hold onto their "human" name once I finished reading.
I liked that the author kept ALL the Pantheon gods in play, even Hestia, but it made the cast of character really unwieldy. I'm glad this is a series, because I felt a lot of the characters got the short-shrift, especially my favorite goddess Athena. Athena, Goddess of Wisdom, just ends up with a photographic memory and there's really no sign of the gray-eyed beauty from mythology in the teenager that is supposed to be her. Already Demeter, Persephone and Hades are dealing with the terrible things Hades did in the past,so I would like to see Zeus acknowledge his "children," even if they look the same age as him. Zeus and Athena had a close relationship, so I would like to see this fleshed out.
In the end, I really did enjoy the book. I even checked to see when the sequel will be out. This series has so much potential and I have high hopes for it. It was a very fun read.