Ok, I really struggled in terms of 'stars' on this one and finally decided to leave it without stars because I didn't feel qualified to pick. The reason I felt under-qualified is because this story is WAY outside my usual comfort zone (or genre, take your pick). I have read a little horror, mostly classics like King and Koontz, but I have mostly avoided this genre because I have a tendency toward developing truly mind-melting nightmares. This was particularly true when I was a child. They were so bad in fact, that I actually did learn a little dream control (yes, it is sometimes possible to realize one is dreaming and alter a dream). It didn't always work but it worked enough when I managed to change the endings to some repetitive nightmares (usually ending in my being flayed) that they abated...somewhat.
As an adult I guess my sensitivities have dulled because my nightmares are much more rare. When I began Inside the Outside, however, I worried about their return. But I digress. What did I think?
Firstly, the author is incredibly brave, in my opinion, to tackle this subject at all. If you read the synopsis then you know that this is a book about a cannibalistic cult living in the mountains above San Bernadino. If the words 'cannibalistic cult' frighten you in a bad way, I have to say this one is probably not for you. If they scare you in a good way, then this one is right in your wheelhouse. Let's just say in my case that I was intrigued as an author. How does one carry this off?
Well, Lestrapes does it amazingly well. He plunges you right into the heart of this sick society through the eyes of Timber Marlow, a child who has never known anything else. Even so, when she is called upon to take on some of the more disgusting duties in the group (preparing the 'sustenance'...if you know what I mean), even she finds herself questioning their ways. Her questions only grow as she notices the disparities in the way some members of the society are treated by 'Daddy Marlow', the man at the top. She is also disturbed by the rape of the women in the society. In some cases the women are willing, but not in all cases and Daddy even brings in Outsider men to take their women for money. Yuk. Without giving away any spoilers I can say that the details of the cult are really pretty interesting and well thought out, but they are very, very, very, very, very, very disturbing.
The book is divided into two parts. In the first it is all about the cult. In the second, it is all about the outside world and how those two paths collide through Timber's actions. I have to say that I enjoyed the first part a lot more myself...which does leave one to wonder what the heck is wrong with you. Maybe I need a head shrinker because i was more compelled by the disgusting, horrifying, creepy, shudder-worthy cult part than the outside world part. Interestingly this may be because although there are some disgusting, horrifying, creepy, shudder-worthy people and actions on the outside, they seem more 'normal' and don't provoke the same reaction? Hmmm, that is a thinker too.
I have to say that I found the tone of the second half (outside world) very different. It almost reminded me of Carl Hiassen (sorry, spelling? the guy that writes the funny murder mysteries set in Florida). I say that as a compliment because one thing Hiassen does that I love is really capture the soul of scumbags, petty thieves, sleazes, and their toadies. And there are plenty of these types in the 'outside' that Lastrapes manages to bring to life with vivid accuracy. Still, the feeling of the two sections was very different.
POV - I was fascinated that Lastrapes chose to use a narrator (whose identity is later revealed in a pretty good twist). I have been thinking about POVs a lot as I've done my own writing and this was also a brave choice. Narrators are rarely used anymore, for whatever reason, and I found the choice to be successful. It allows for a 3rd person omniscient sort of 'knowledge' of everyone without actually head-jumping. Very interesting approach.
The Details - Lastrapes really does give you the details in all his descriptions and I felt like I could picture (even when I didn't want to) everything that was happening and all the characters and environments very clearly.
Final Thought - If I could give it stars I would probably go '3' because I am not super into horror and a lot of this was beyond my grossness threshold. But I know that horror buffs probably LOVE that Lastrapes goes for the yuck-factor gusto so they would probably give it a '4' or '5'. Hence my choice not to use stars. Hopefully someone will read the full review and take it for what it is worth.
If you really like horror then I think you will love this book. It is truly horrifying in the best way. :)
But if cannibalism (and the associated food prep scenes) is something you can't stomach reading about...OR if you cannot handle VIVID sex scenes including sexual assaults, then this one may be a little much for you.