But you say, why does this get a review when Omnivore's Dilemma doesn't? Well because I pretty much agreed with Pollan who did his homework, Omnivore's Dilemma is great, and you should read it, but it's not nearly as fun to interact with as this.
So I came for the recipes (Those look good, I'll have to mix up my daily smoothie recipes), but stayed for the pseudo-scinece and raw food hype.
There's just so much I lost track, but as sample:
"Why doesn't everyone know what Ph is?" - Well I do and pretty sure you're using it wrong, but hey.
There's also the bizzare claim that soil yeast can turn sodium into potassium, so stop the presses apparently we have tiny nuclear reactors everywhere!
For context, I grow ever increasingly more of my own veg in a no-till organic system driven by local compost, but there's only 2 ways to increase the mineral content of the soil, 1. Wait for bacteria and weather to liberate from the bedrock and subsoil 2. Apply it from a source; either directly via rock dust, or from minerals already collected by previous generations of plants, compost (plant wastes) or kelp (ocean collected).
Chimps and humans share 98% of their DNA so our diets should be 98% the same!
Well you also share 30% of you DNA with coral, so maybe 30% of your diet should be by hosting algae in our cells!
That being said, we should eat more fruits and veggies so I guess whatever gets that ball rolling.
I consider smoothies very useful to this end as I have a strict [not really I'm just lazy] 1 salad a day max policy (unless it's winter lettuce or winter spinach) so that means finding more ways to work greens in.
I still don't get the whole raw food ideal, the calorie density of fruits and vegetables is so low that you'd have to just eat pounds of food, and you better have a blender or spend all day chewing like gorillas. Plus there's the whole cooking made us human, renders plant toxins harmless, etc.
Also from an ecological standpoint, I'm not sure how it makes sense to eat fruit all year long given it would have to be shipped in most of the year and very few humans live in an environment where that is possible/desirable?.
A positive point where I do agree with the author is the division of vegetables into categories. Non-sweet fruits (cukes, tomatoes, squashes), flowers (broccoli), roots (beet, radish), and greens (any leaf). This a much more informative way to talk about food and nutrition even if it leaves leeks in a odd spot.
Oh, and for those of you in the Midwest, sweet corn is still not a vegetable.