As you might guess from the title, the theme of this installment in the Cape Light series is the idea of starting anew—turning over a new leaf, as the old cliché has it. It’s a nicely supported theme—as much worth a read as any of the other books in the series.
This is the book where you experience the privilege of becoming acquainted with Molly Willoughby. She was Molly Morgan growing up, but that was before she turned the ever-so-mature age of 15 and got the hots for the fast-talking handsome Phil Willoughby, who married her, promptly impregnated her, and almost as promptly cheated on her numerous times. Worse yet, after the divorce he paid little child support and even less attention to the couple’s two daughters, Lauren and Jill. He would do well for a while, but then he would build their expectations only to disappoint them by not showing up when he was supposed to, etc.
As this book opens, Molly, who has a reputation for being rather quick witted and sharp tongued, is cleaning a house which is to be inhabited the next morning by the town’s new doctor, a friend of the old retired one. Because of Phil’s conduct over the years, Molly has given up on men generally and on ever again really being in love. But as you might predict, the new doctor isn’t the old ho-hum guy Molly expected, and when he shows up unexpectedly the night before he is to move in, catching her with a vacuum hose in her hand, the two begin a relationship which will grow in intensity throughout the book despite her doubts.
Even old fast-talking Phil makes what turns out to be genuine changes in his life. He gets a real job that pays real money, and he’s once again in the child support payment business. The thing is, this time he doesn’t mind so much. He’s even picking up his girls on time and keeping every promise to them. Naturally, the book reveals a good bit of tension between old fast-talking Phil and the good doctor, with poor Molly in the midst of it all.
There are other instances in this book where the local residents think and act anew, to paraphrase President Lincoln. In the hands of lesser-skilled writers, all these changes would be dizzying and difficult to keep track of, to say the least. But these authors manage to keep you moving through without character confusion. This book also starts getting a bit more into the Christmas spirit, which is of course the perfect time for anyone to start anew, as most of us have discovered.
Again, I’m impressed with the realism found in the lives of these characters. None of these reforms made by town residents happens artificially. In one plot line, you meet Carl Tucker, an ex-con homeless drunk whose brother, Tulley, is one of Cape Light’s policemen. When Carl shows up in town, Tulley is naturally scandalized, and things get worse when he has to make room for his brother at the house—something his wife doesn’t even want despite her generalized efforts at charity during the Christmas season. Carl’s return even brings Tulley’s lifelong friendship with Charlie down at the eatery to the brink of collapse. In short, reform does happen in this book, but it is realistic reform complete with events that grind the sharp edges off of everyone in town.
You see, that’s what I like about this series. It takes a hard look at ordinary people who think they’re doing enough by vaguely helping others while neglecting the bigger kind of charity they ought to be committed to at home. If you fervently believe that it’s possible to become an instant Christian, you might struggle a bit with these books. They seem to stress the idea that discipleship is a process—an idea I wholeheartedly endorse. As a result, and to my pleasant surprise, none of these characters puts me off. Even Reverend Ben is a whole person in these books—someone you can come to respect and cheer for.