What do you think?
Rate this book
Anne Boleyn & Elizabeth I: The Mother and Daughter Who Changed History
'(A)sensational book by one of our greatest and best-loved historians... Astoundingly good.' - Alison Weir
'Masterful, captivating, page-turning, this is solid gold history at its best.' - Nicola Tallis
'(A) thought-provoking, impeccably researched, and moving account uncovering how Anne's family, intellect, and tragedy shaped Elizabeth I's extraordinary career.' - Gareth Russell
'Her extensive research... reveals them as the most dazzling female double act in history.' - Sarah Gristwood
'Incredibly well-researched, elegantly written, and overall genuinely ground-breaking,' - Estelle Paranque
One of the most extraordinary mother and daughter stories of all time - Anne Boleyn, the most famous of Henry VIII's wives and her daughter Elizabeth, the 'Virgin Queen'.
Anne Boleyn is a subject of enduring fascination. By far the most famous of Henry VIII's six wives, she has inspired books, documentaries and films, and is the subject of intense debate even today, almost 500 years after her violent death. For the most part, she is considered in the context of her relationship with Tudor England's much-married monarch. Dramatic though this story is, of even greater interest - and significance - is the relationship between Anne and her daughter, the future Elizabeth I.
Elizabeth was less than three years old when her mother was executed. Given that she could have held precious few memories of Anne, it is often assumed that her mother exerted little influence over her.
But this is both inaccurate and misleading. Elizabeth knew that she had to be discreet about Anne, but there is compelling evidence that her mother exerted a profound influence on her character, beliefs and reign. Even during Henry's lifetime, Elizabeth dared to express her sympathy for her late mother by secretly wearing Anne's famous 'A' pendant when she sat for a painting with her father and siblings.
Piecing together evidence from original documents and artefacts, this book tells the story of Anne Boleyn's relationship with, and influence over her daughter Elizabeth. In so doing, it sheds new light on two of the most famous and influential women in history.
'Masterful, captivating, page-turning, this is solid gold history at its best.' - Nicola Tallis
'(A) thought-provoking, impeccably researched, and moving account uncovering how Anne's family, intellect, and tragedy shaped Elizabeth I's extraordinary career.' - Gareth Russell
'Her extensive research... reveals them as the most dazzling female double act in history.' - Sarah Gristwood
'Incredibly well-researched, elegantly written, and overall genuinely ground-breaking,' - Estelle Paranque
One of the most extraordinary mother and daughter stories of all time - Anne Boleyn, the most famous of Henry VIII's wives and her daughter Elizabeth, the 'Virgin Queen'.
Anne Boleyn is a subject of enduring fascination. By far the most famous of Henry VIII's six wives, she has inspired books, documentaries and films, and is the subject of intense debate even today, almost 500 years after her violent death. For the most part, she is considered in the context of her relationship with Tudor England's much-married monarch. Dramatic though this story is, of even greater interest - and significance - is the relationship between Anne and her daughter, the future Elizabeth I.
Elizabeth was less than three years old when her mother was executed. Given that she could have held precious few memories of Anne, it is often assumed that her mother exerted little influence over her.
But this is both inaccurate and misleading. Elizabeth knew that she had to be discreet about Anne, but there is compelling evidence that her mother exerted a profound influence on her character, beliefs and reign. Even during Henry's lifetime, Elizabeth dared to express her sympathy for her late mother by secretly wearing Anne's famous 'A' pendant when she sat for a painting with her father and siblings.
Piecing together evidence from original documents and artefacts, this book tells the story of Anne Boleyn's relationship with, and influence over her daughter Elizabeth. In so doing, it sheds new light on two of the most famous and influential women in history.
336 pages, Kindle Edition
First published May 18, 2023
388 people are currently reading
5513 people want to read
About the author
Tracy Borman
23 books851 followersTracy Borman, PhD, FRHistS, FSA is a historian and author from Scothern, United Kingdom. She is most widely known as the author of Elizabeth's Women.
Borman was born and brought up in the village of Scothern, England near Lincoln. She was educated at Scothern Primary School (now Ellison Boulters School), William Farr School, Welton, and Yarborough School, Lincoln. She taught history at the University of Hull, where she was awarded a Ph.D in 1997. Elizabeth's Women was serialized and became a BBC Radio 4 Book of the Week in September 2009. Tracy Borman appeared on BBC Radio 4's Woman's Hour, also in September 2009
Borman was born and brought up in the village of Scothern, England near Lincoln. She was educated at Scothern Primary School (now Ellison Boulters School), William Farr School, Welton, and Yarborough School, Lincoln. She taught history at the University of Hull, where she was awarded a Ph.D in 1997. Elizabeth's Women was serialized and became a BBC Radio 4 Book of the Week in September 2009. Tracy Borman appeared on BBC Radio 4's Woman's Hour, also in September 2009
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 329 reviews
May 9, 2023
Ms Borman wrote the non-fiction which brings the mother and the daughter together and focuses on the bond they forged despite being physically close for a short time. The role to preserve Queen Anne's memory fell onto her daughter and she did it in various ways, discreetly and always having in mind her changing status as a child to the king. Queen Elizabeth meandered masterfully between the love for her mother and the position of a monarch whose legal status may have been challenged by some of her subjects.
Ms Borman's writing is easy for anybody interested in the Tudors without any academic knowledge. It might seem nothing new should be there to write about but the Author manages to present Anne & Elizabeth from a perspective not that often presented.
*A big thank-you to Grove Atlantic, Tracy Borman, and NetGalley for arc in exchange for my honest review.*
Ms Borman's writing is easy for anybody interested in the Tudors without any academic knowledge. It might seem nothing new should be there to write about but the Author manages to present Anne & Elizabeth from a perspective not that often presented.
*A big thank-you to Grove Atlantic, Tracy Borman, and NetGalley for arc in exchange for my honest review.*
May 15, 2023
This non-fiction book takes a closer look at mother and daughter. Anne Boleyn was a strong woman and a courageous mother, who might have been a great queen if given a chance. “Her courage as she met her death was widely praised, even by her enemies.” During her brief tenure, less than three years, she sparked a religious and political revolution. And left a profound influence on her daughter, who became the most celebrated monarch.
Elizabeth, less than three, not knowing the fate of her mother, was deposed from succession and proclaimed a bastard. Young though she was, Elizabeth sensed that something was wrong with all the changes around her. Later, witnessing the succession of stepmothers. At ten, her mother’s cousin, Catherine Howard, was the second wife of Henry to be beheaded. Thus, Elizabeth at young age vowed never to marry.
During Mary’s turbulent reign, when Elizabeth was under house arrest, Elizabeth had a chance to connect with men from her mother’s past. It was a time when she started building her allies. At the same time, Mary earned a new name ‘Bloody Mary’ for burning Protestants at the stake.
Elizabeth learned a good lesson from her sister’s bloody reign not to force her subject to conform to the religion of her choice. She created a tightly knit court for most part related by ties of blood, marriage or friendship.
For most of the part, it’s the story of Elizabeth and her rise to power and how she had to be smart in securing her position not to be overthrown. Through her different traits, there are glimpses of Anne’s traits. Anne’s spark to religious reformation aligned with Elizabeth’s. Another trait that they shared was being patrons of learning. Both women refused to subordinate to men.
Elizabeth was a strong willed child and a courageous woman who pushed the boundaries. She wasn’t without flaws. She had some despotic traits. Above all, like her mother, she was hungry for knowledge. She thrived in intellectual atmosphere.
This is a very enlightening and enjoyable read that is not overwhelmed with historical details. It’s fascinating to have a closer look at two captivating women who stood tall in the world ruled by men.
Source: Book was provided by the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
Elizabeth, less than three, not knowing the fate of her mother, was deposed from succession and proclaimed a bastard. Young though she was, Elizabeth sensed that something was wrong with all the changes around her. Later, witnessing the succession of stepmothers. At ten, her mother’s cousin, Catherine Howard, was the second wife of Henry to be beheaded. Thus, Elizabeth at young age vowed never to marry.
During Mary’s turbulent reign, when Elizabeth was under house arrest, Elizabeth had a chance to connect with men from her mother’s past. It was a time when she started building her allies. At the same time, Mary earned a new name ‘Bloody Mary’ for burning Protestants at the stake.
Elizabeth learned a good lesson from her sister’s bloody reign not to force her subject to conform to the religion of her choice. She created a tightly knit court for most part related by ties of blood, marriage or friendship.
For most of the part, it’s the story of Elizabeth and her rise to power and how she had to be smart in securing her position not to be overthrown. Through her different traits, there are glimpses of Anne’s traits. Anne’s spark to religious reformation aligned with Elizabeth’s. Another trait that they shared was being patrons of learning. Both women refused to subordinate to men.
Elizabeth was a strong willed child and a courageous woman who pushed the boundaries. She wasn’t without flaws. She had some despotic traits. Above all, like her mother, she was hungry for knowledge. She thrived in intellectual atmosphere.
This is a very enlightening and enjoyable read that is not overwhelmed with historical details. It’s fascinating to have a closer look at two captivating women who stood tall in the world ruled by men.
Source: Book was provided by the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
May 26, 2023
FINALLY, A GREY REPRESENTATION OF ANNE BOLEYN
It might sound strange, but my favourite part of this book was actually how Borman didn't try to make Anne Boleyn a saint. For so long she had been seen as a pure villain. Then the pendulum swung too far in the other direction (in my opinion) and she was portrayed as a guiltless saint. But Borman puts the truth somewhere in the middle. And I feel like time is finally ripe for this view of Anne. For her to actually be a person, and not a caricature of one.
Of course, I also really liked how Borman portrayed Anne's everlasting effect on her daughter, who must not even have been able to actually remember her. Borman does an excellent job of connecting the two women and showing how Elizabeth incorporated lessons from her mothers life in her own.
ARC provided by the publisher through NetGalley in exchange for an honest review
Follow me for more book loving content!
Blog ✨ Facebook ✨ Instagram ✨ Twitter
Blog Post: Which Book Should you read next based on your favourite Jane Austen Heroine
It might sound strange, but my favourite part of this book was actually how Borman didn't try to make Anne Boleyn a saint. For so long she had been seen as a pure villain. Then the pendulum swung too far in the other direction (in my opinion) and she was portrayed as a guiltless saint. But Borman puts the truth somewhere in the middle. And I feel like time is finally ripe for this view of Anne. For her to actually be a person, and not a caricature of one.
Of course, I also really liked how Borman portrayed Anne's everlasting effect on her daughter, who must not even have been able to actually remember her. Borman does an excellent job of connecting the two women and showing how Elizabeth incorporated lessons from her mothers life in her own.
ARC provided by the publisher through NetGalley in exchange for an honest review
Follow me for more book loving content!
Blog ✨ Facebook ✨ Instagram ✨ Twitter
Blog Post: Which Book Should you read next based on your favourite Jane Austen Heroine
January 15, 2023
For centuries, we were told Elizabeth I never mentioned her disgraced mother. Tracy Borman explodes that myth in this thought-provoking and moving account uncovering how Anne’s family, intellect, and tragedy shaped Elizabeth I’s extraordinary career
ARC kindly sent to me by the author.
ARC kindly sent to me by the author.
May 27, 2023
This is a somewhat hostile biography of Anne Boleyn. The author chooses to use mostly Chapuys as a source for Anne and decides to present her in his view.
It's uncomfortable.
Anne is regularly referred to as a concubine after her marriage to Henry, and Elizabeth is often called the bastard during her parents' actual marriage.
It's bizarrely hostile.
Of what value is a biography of Anne Boleyn that stresses Katherine of Aragon & Mary Tudor's point of view???
This is beyond a balanced look.
The author passes the usual sexist nonsense about Anne Boleyn but packages it ludicrously as if Anne was a 'modern' feminist.
I find it weird that a modern view is that Anne simply should've given up her future as a wife to be a mistress to Henry VIII out of misplaced loyalty to Katherine of Aragon.
It's just a silly opinion.
Anne was within her rights to refuse to sleep with the same King who fucked her sister. It's just ridiculous to suggest otherwise.
People outside of a marriage do not need to prioritize or respect another couples marriage. They are free to make choices that benefit them solely. To suggest otherwise is just childish.
Anne had no power to tell Henry to leave her alone and the history agrees she wanted to marry Henry Percy.
She made lemonade out of the lemons Henry gave her.
Anne is blamed for Henry's own behavior towards and treatment of both Katherine of Aragon & Mary Tudor.
Which is bullshit. Henry was an ass to Mary after he murdered Anne. So clearly Anne wasn't influencing him from her grave.
Henry murdered Margaret Pole and her whole family in a fit of horrible pique. She was his mothers cousin and friend. She was involved in raising him. He murdered her children and grandchildren, tried to genocide her whole family.
He is sick as fuck and I hate that Anne has somehow more responsible for Henry being unfaithful than he's held accountable for.
It's basically told from Katherine & Mary's pov until Henry dies.
Then Mary is increasingly marginalized in favor of Elizabeth I's great rise.
Meh.
This is a biased and limited view of these dynamic women.
I found much of the ways Elizabeth carried her mother into her adult life touching.
At the same time this author is so biased I don't completely trust her narrative🤷🏾♀️
It's uncomfortable.
Anne is regularly referred to as a concubine after her marriage to Henry, and Elizabeth is often called the bastard during her parents' actual marriage.
It's bizarrely hostile.
Of what value is a biography of Anne Boleyn that stresses Katherine of Aragon & Mary Tudor's point of view???
This is beyond a balanced look.
The author passes the usual sexist nonsense about Anne Boleyn but packages it ludicrously as if Anne was a 'modern' feminist.
I find it weird that a modern view is that Anne simply should've given up her future as a wife to be a mistress to Henry VIII out of misplaced loyalty to Katherine of Aragon.
It's just a silly opinion.
Anne was within her rights to refuse to sleep with the same King who fucked her sister. It's just ridiculous to suggest otherwise.
People outside of a marriage do not need to prioritize or respect another couples marriage. They are free to make choices that benefit them solely. To suggest otherwise is just childish.
Anne had no power to tell Henry to leave her alone and the history agrees she wanted to marry Henry Percy.
She made lemonade out of the lemons Henry gave her.
Anne is blamed for Henry's own behavior towards and treatment of both Katherine of Aragon & Mary Tudor.
Which is bullshit. Henry was an ass to Mary after he murdered Anne. So clearly Anne wasn't influencing him from her grave.
Henry murdered Margaret Pole and her whole family in a fit of horrible pique. She was his mothers cousin and friend. She was involved in raising him. He murdered her children and grandchildren, tried to genocide her whole family.
He is sick as fuck and I hate that Anne has somehow more responsible for Henry being unfaithful than he's held accountable for.
It's basically told from Katherine & Mary's pov until Henry dies.
Then Mary is increasingly marginalized in favor of Elizabeth I's great rise.
Meh.
This is a biased and limited view of these dynamic women.
I found much of the ways Elizabeth carried her mother into her adult life touching.
At the same time this author is so biased I don't completely trust her narrative🤷🏾♀️
January 1, 2025
Let's face it, the Tudors are by far the most interesting characters in the history of Britain, mainly Henry VIII, and particularly his doomed second wife Anne Boleyn.
This book will not teach you any more about Anne, and little more about Queen Elizabeth I, her daughter. What it does do, however, is concentrate on the relationship between the two. If you already know that Elizabeth was not yet three years of age when her mother was executed, you may wonder what could fill a book? The brilliance of the author is to show how Elizabeth was shaped by her mother / her mother's death by referencing the many ways Elizabeth honours her mother, despite not having much first hand memory of her.
I found this approach rather touching, especially as I lost my own mother far too early. The consequences of the manner of Anne's death, however, would have been catastrophic to Elizabeth in so many ways, and certainly would have altered the normal course of her life, and the author gives credible examples of this throughout the book.
If you enjoy Tudor history, this is a different approach, and one which is a welcome addition to prior knowledge of the period - and highly readable for all.
This book will not teach you any more about Anne, and little more about Queen Elizabeth I, her daughter. What it does do, however, is concentrate on the relationship between the two. If you already know that Elizabeth was not yet three years of age when her mother was executed, you may wonder what could fill a book? The brilliance of the author is to show how Elizabeth was shaped by her mother / her mother's death by referencing the many ways Elizabeth honours her mother, despite not having much first hand memory of her.
I found this approach rather touching, especially as I lost my own mother far too early. The consequences of the manner of Anne's death, however, would have been catastrophic to Elizabeth in so many ways, and certainly would have altered the normal course of her life, and the author gives credible examples of this throughout the book.
If you enjoy Tudor history, this is a different approach, and one which is a welcome addition to prior knowledge of the period - and highly readable for all.
May 31, 2023
I really enjoy Borman's writing and I continue to go back to her works time and time again and this one was no exception.I don't really know if this was suppose to be a compare and contrast type book or just a book centering around what they would have most likely admired about each other.I tended to lean towards the latter though.Plus, there were random bits and bobs about the Boleyn family, favorites,their courts, religion, clothing,symbols and remaining household items.Some information was quite new to me which in my eyes made this absolutely worth the read.
Much thanks to Netgalley for sending me a copy in exchange for my honest review
Much thanks to Netgalley for sending me a copy in exchange for my honest review
September 23, 2023
One of the most famous mother/daughter duos in English history – or any history, for that matter – is that of Anne Boelyn (second wife of King Henry VIII) and the Great Gloriana, Queen Elizabeth I. Although they spent little time together (Elizabeth was a mere toddler when Anne was beheaded) and they are opposites as Anne was called a ‘whore’ while Elizabeth touted being a virgin; they are both a case study in feminism and powerful figures in their own rights and as a pair. Although there are countless biographies, texts, writings, films, plays, etc. circulating around these women; historian, author and the joint Chief Curator of Historic Royal Palaces Tracy Borman strives to take a different approach in reflection. Borman puts a new spin on history by observing the interplay between mother and daughter in, “Anne Boleyn & Elizabeth I: The Mother and Daughter Who Changed British History”.
In theory, Borman’s theme of “Anne Boleyn & Elizabeth I” is less of a dual-biography and more of a ‘compare and contrast’ Venn diagram of the mother and daughter pair and how they effected one another in their short co-habitation and posthumously after Anne’s death. The concept is inviting and invigorating with its revitalizing look at Anne and Elizabeth (and in effect, the Tudors, in general); but unfortunately, Borman misses her mark.
“Anne Boleyn & Elizabeth I” is indeed, for much of the text, the standard biographical history piece that Borman specifically maintained that it wouldn’t be and even that is somewhat vague and one-note. Borman is a leading authority/historian employed by the crème de la crème of historical organizations in England making her truly one of the go-to consultants on all things English history, especially the Tudors. Watching Borman on a video and/or listening to her on a podcast is often quite revelatory and intriguing; so why is it that she always holds back in her books? “Anne Boleyn & Elizabeth I” is a general history (similarly to Borman’s other books) and is best used as an introductory read for those new to the subject. Borman gives a background on Anne’s life without exploring anything new or unexpected. At this juncture, “Anne Boleyn & Elizabeth I” is simply a lightweight Anne Boleyn biography. Even though this stylistic method went against her initial intention with “Anne Boleyn & Elizabeth I”; even that could have been ignored if Borman had shed her restraints and really dove into the writing.
Also sparking an issue in “Anne Boleyn & Elizabeth I” is Borman’s propensity to mention certain areas as fact which have been disputed by other historians time-and-time, again (she does THIS in all of her books). Being that Borman does hold such a high professional position in the field means that readers are encouraged to believe her over her contemporaries. However, this would be an easier endeavor if Borman elaborated on these strands but she does not which makes the credibility questionable. Who do we believe?! Borman also sprinkles the text with occasional speculative statements further weakening her thesis.
That being said, there are SOME refreshing aspects in “Anne Boleyn & Elizabeth I” early on when Borman explores recently unearthed artifacts and antiquities related to Anne Boelyn and her daughter. These timely tie-ins make “Anne Boleyn & Elizabeth I” very “in the know” and updated with the current happenings on the subject.
Borman’s writing style is very accessible for the general audience meshing together academia with a pop-history format making for a quick read. There are, however, noticeable moments of repetition in this half which somehow seemed to escape her multiple editors (or it didn’t matter?).
“Anne Boleyn & Elizabeth I” hits a faster stride in the second half of the text when Borman shifts her focus onto Elizabeth. Although still enforcing the biography style; “Anne Boleyn & Elizabeth I” eases into a more literal and psychological comparative discourse on the two women such as how Anne’s death affected Elizabeth as an individual, woman and monarch. However, these arguments are still a bit too confined and sometimes “stretching it”. Once again, it seems like Borman held back thus preventing “Anne Boleyn & Elizabeth I” from reaching its full potential. Understandably, we don’t have a diary or other method of first-hand insight into Elizabeth’s psyche and her thoughts on the matter but this simply means that a veil still remains.
The final quarter of “Anne Boleyn & Elizabeth I” is when Borman FINALLY hits her crescendo and the text is an illuminating piece exploring the Boleyn family members that Elizabeth kept on staff and how it interplayed with the ways she ruled, Anne’s tangible goods inherited by Elizabeth and the psychological effects of her mother suffering a Queen’s beheading and how this bled onto Elizabeth’s reluctance to sign the death warrant for Mary, Queen of Scots among other meanderings. This portion of “Anne Boleyn & Elizabeth I” is quite illuminating and the text effectively lives ups to its title. It is simply a shame that it takes so long to get here and it can be argued that it is a little too late. This does help to conclude “Anne Boleyn & Elizabeth I” on a memorable and evocative note although not fully rehabilitating the entire piece.
“Anne Boleyn & Elizabeth I” is supplemented with an ample section of photo plates some of which have not been included in other books of the like. Borman also offers a section of notes (very lightly annotated) and a bibliography with an abundant use of both primary and secondary sources.
Borman has a very enticing propensity to seek out discussions that are unique and refreshing but something prevents her from fully expressing the subjects with “Anne Boleyn & Elizabeth I” being no exception. “Anne Boleyn & Elizabeth I” doesn’t fully engage readers and fails to entirely encompass what Borman sets out to do; but the final quarter does bring some gripping relief. It’s a wonder why I continue to read Borman’s output but it is for the sole reason that at least her subjects are diverse. “Anne Boleyn & Elizabeth I” is best suited for readers new to the history of Anne and Elizabeth or those readers (such as myself) who must read ALL books concerning the Tudors.
In theory, Borman’s theme of “Anne Boleyn & Elizabeth I” is less of a dual-biography and more of a ‘compare and contrast’ Venn diagram of the mother and daughter pair and how they effected one another in their short co-habitation and posthumously after Anne’s death. The concept is inviting and invigorating with its revitalizing look at Anne and Elizabeth (and in effect, the Tudors, in general); but unfortunately, Borman misses her mark.
“Anne Boleyn & Elizabeth I” is indeed, for much of the text, the standard biographical history piece that Borman specifically maintained that it wouldn’t be and even that is somewhat vague and one-note. Borman is a leading authority/historian employed by the crème de la crème of historical organizations in England making her truly one of the go-to consultants on all things English history, especially the Tudors. Watching Borman on a video and/or listening to her on a podcast is often quite revelatory and intriguing; so why is it that she always holds back in her books? “Anne Boleyn & Elizabeth I” is a general history (similarly to Borman’s other books) and is best used as an introductory read for those new to the subject. Borman gives a background on Anne’s life without exploring anything new or unexpected. At this juncture, “Anne Boleyn & Elizabeth I” is simply a lightweight Anne Boleyn biography. Even though this stylistic method went against her initial intention with “Anne Boleyn & Elizabeth I”; even that could have been ignored if Borman had shed her restraints and really dove into the writing.
Also sparking an issue in “Anne Boleyn & Elizabeth I” is Borman’s propensity to mention certain areas as fact which have been disputed by other historians time-and-time, again (she does THIS in all of her books). Being that Borman does hold such a high professional position in the field means that readers are encouraged to believe her over her contemporaries. However, this would be an easier endeavor if Borman elaborated on these strands but she does not which makes the credibility questionable. Who do we believe?! Borman also sprinkles the text with occasional speculative statements further weakening her thesis.
That being said, there are SOME refreshing aspects in “Anne Boleyn & Elizabeth I” early on when Borman explores recently unearthed artifacts and antiquities related to Anne Boelyn and her daughter. These timely tie-ins make “Anne Boleyn & Elizabeth I” very “in the know” and updated with the current happenings on the subject.
Borman’s writing style is very accessible for the general audience meshing together academia with a pop-history format making for a quick read. There are, however, noticeable moments of repetition in this half which somehow seemed to escape her multiple editors (or it didn’t matter?).
“Anne Boleyn & Elizabeth I” hits a faster stride in the second half of the text when Borman shifts her focus onto Elizabeth. Although still enforcing the biography style; “Anne Boleyn & Elizabeth I” eases into a more literal and psychological comparative discourse on the two women such as how Anne’s death affected Elizabeth as an individual, woman and monarch. However, these arguments are still a bit too confined and sometimes “stretching it”. Once again, it seems like Borman held back thus preventing “Anne Boleyn & Elizabeth I” from reaching its full potential. Understandably, we don’t have a diary or other method of first-hand insight into Elizabeth’s psyche and her thoughts on the matter but this simply means that a veil still remains.
The final quarter of “Anne Boleyn & Elizabeth I” is when Borman FINALLY hits her crescendo and the text is an illuminating piece exploring the Boleyn family members that Elizabeth kept on staff and how it interplayed with the ways she ruled, Anne’s tangible goods inherited by Elizabeth and the psychological effects of her mother suffering a Queen’s beheading and how this bled onto Elizabeth’s reluctance to sign the death warrant for Mary, Queen of Scots among other meanderings. This portion of “Anne Boleyn & Elizabeth I” is quite illuminating and the text effectively lives ups to its title. It is simply a shame that it takes so long to get here and it can be argued that it is a little too late. This does help to conclude “Anne Boleyn & Elizabeth I” on a memorable and evocative note although not fully rehabilitating the entire piece.
“Anne Boleyn & Elizabeth I” is supplemented with an ample section of photo plates some of which have not been included in other books of the like. Borman also offers a section of notes (very lightly annotated) and a bibliography with an abundant use of both primary and secondary sources.
Borman has a very enticing propensity to seek out discussions that are unique and refreshing but something prevents her from fully expressing the subjects with “Anne Boleyn & Elizabeth I” being no exception. “Anne Boleyn & Elizabeth I” doesn’t fully engage readers and fails to entirely encompass what Borman sets out to do; but the final quarter does bring some gripping relief. It’s a wonder why I continue to read Borman’s output but it is for the sole reason that at least her subjects are diverse. “Anne Boleyn & Elizabeth I” is best suited for readers new to the history of Anne and Elizabeth or those readers (such as myself) who must read ALL books concerning the Tudors.
February 14, 2023
I've been a fan of Anne Boleyn since I was a teen, but I've never gotten around to reading about Elizabeth I. I love the framework of this biography where it looks at Elizabeth's story through the lens of her mother, Anne. The first third of the book is focused on Anne and then it moves into Elizabeth's story. I really enjoyed the focus on Anne's intellectual and religious pursuits, beyond just her relationship with Henry VIII. Elizabeth's childhood was covered better than the rest of her life. Borman went into the psychological impacts caused by the death of Elizabeth's mother at the orders of her father. The author also highlights evidence of ways that Elizabeth paid tribute to her mother subtly throughout her reign. There was a certain point where I got bored reading lists of Boleyn relatives and how many times Elizabeth used a falcon as a symbol, but overall it was a solid biography and I'm glad it was my introduction to Elizabeth's biography. This is a must read for Tudor history fans.
*Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for an e-ARC in exchange for an honest review.
*Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for an e-ARC in exchange for an honest review.
May 15, 2023
I downloaded this book in digital format from Netgalley and read it on my Kindle e-reader. I'd like to thank the publisher for providing me with a copy.
Before reading this book, I was a huge fan of Queen Elizabeth I because the theater flourished during her reign. I knew relatively little about Elizabeth's mother, Anne Bolelyn, and I never thought about Anne's influence over her daughter.
The coronation of King Charles III recently took place. The author remarks that King Charles is descended from Mary Boleyn, Anne's sister, and that his son, the Prince of Wales, is descended from Mary Boleyn through both his parents. Elizabeth I, however, will always remain the only descendant of Anne Boleyn.
I enjoyed this book and learned a number of things that I hadn't known previously.
For my complete review see https://shomeretmasked.blogspot.com/2...
Before reading this book, I was a huge fan of Queen Elizabeth I because the theater flourished during her reign. I knew relatively little about Elizabeth's mother, Anne Bolelyn, and I never thought about Anne's influence over her daughter.
The coronation of King Charles III recently took place. The author remarks that King Charles is descended from Mary Boleyn, Anne's sister, and that his son, the Prince of Wales, is descended from Mary Boleyn through both his parents. Elizabeth I, however, will always remain the only descendant of Anne Boleyn.
I enjoyed this book and learned a number of things that I hadn't known previously.
For my complete review see https://shomeretmasked.blogspot.com/2...
November 15, 2024
Borman writes a compelling narrative of Anne Boleyn and her daughter Elizabeth. She illustrates just how fascinating Boleyn was as both a renaissance woman and reformer, respected by not only the French Court, scholars but those seeking change in England. She redirects the propaganda of Henry and Cromwell to reveal their strengths as women in a dangerous time. Elizabeth proved to be every inch Anne’s daughter outmaneuvering the patriarchy, and by avoiding marriage retaining her power to the very end. Borman’s ability to breathe life into the Tudor court is exceptional.
August 15, 2023
Very much enjoyed the kindle version - but now I have to go buy the paperback! ;) So happy to see my theory confirmed that she dined at Gage’s table while she was in the Tower!
November 10, 2023
It was very informative and put the pieces of their lives together nicely. Some points were a little repetitive for filler, but overall it was an educated and informed book about their lives.
December 11, 2025
A great account of two great Queens.
Read
August 3, 2025Shocking: Mother’s decapitation impacts young daughter.
February 17, 2023
I went into this book thinking, Oh another retelling of all the same history purporting to have a new angle. It was not that at all. Borman never forgets her point, which is the effect that Anne and Elizabeth had on one another's lives despite their short time together. She has combed through records of Anne's queenship looking for not only ever scrap of information related to Elizabeth (clothing, staffing of her household, wishes for education...), as well as highlighting anything about Anne's life that could be put forward as having resonance in Elizabeth's. Then she similarly looked at records of Elizabeth's life and court and has turned up a positive wealth of indications that she had a high level of interest and trust in her relations on her mother's side - much greater than any connection on her father's (partly for the obvious reason that Tudor cousins were more likely to be interested in the throne). All kinds of jobs, titles, and highly demanding and responsible roles were assigned to members of the Howard family or relations through Anne's sister Mary or Anne's aunts and uncles. It is made very clear that not only did Elizabeth want to remember and promote her mother's memory, she also had a high regard for members of her mother's extended family.
The bizarre exception is Lettice Knollys, daughter of Mary Boleyn's daughter Katherine Carey. Lettice seemed to go out of her way to antagonize and provoke and compete with Elizabeth, which seems not only arrogant but really stupid.
The two most obvious ways that Anne's life shaped Elizabeth's, religion and positive horror of the idea of marriage, are given their due, but that's not all there is to the tale. It suggests that where Anne was undone by the dangers of still playing the courtly love game while married to a crazy king, Elizabeth won the game by remaining unmarried and unattached and making all the rules herself.
I can do without all the recent flood of suggestions that this or that person "changed history." Everyone changes history every minute that they are alive and taking actions. Don't let that grandiose title put you off this book, which is filled with interesting substance.
There are a few lingering errors that need correcting - for example, the reference to Catherine of Aragon's "coronation" in 1501 - that was the year she married Arthur, so coronation is not the word that was intended. Hopefully these will be caught in the final copyedit.
Thanks to NetGalley for letting me read an advance copy of this book.
The bizarre exception is Lettice Knollys, daughter of Mary Boleyn's daughter Katherine Carey. Lettice seemed to go out of her way to antagonize and provoke and compete with Elizabeth, which seems not only arrogant but really stupid.
The two most obvious ways that Anne's life shaped Elizabeth's, religion and positive horror of the idea of marriage, are given their due, but that's not all there is to the tale. It suggests that where Anne was undone by the dangers of still playing the courtly love game while married to a crazy king, Elizabeth won the game by remaining unmarried and unattached and making all the rules herself.
I can do without all the recent flood of suggestions that this or that person "changed history." Everyone changes history every minute that they are alive and taking actions. Don't let that grandiose title put you off this book, which is filled with interesting substance.
There are a few lingering errors that need correcting - for example, the reference to Catherine of Aragon's "coronation" in 1501 - that was the year she married Arthur, so coronation is not the word that was intended. Hopefully these will be caught in the final copyedit.
Thanks to NetGalley for letting me read an advance copy of this book.
March 5, 2023
Fab fab fab read. As someone who has read probably a few too many books about Tudors, this very notion fascinated me a ton. How did Elizabeth feel about her mother? Was there any Indication in her behavior that she admired and cared about her memory and legacy? I'm happy to say that Borman did a great job convincing me that in fact, Anne Boleyn was never far from her famous daughter's mind or body with ample evidence and exhaustive research. So this is for sure is a must read for any student of history or curious Anne Boleyn fanatic.
June 20, 2023
This is the thesis I’ve always dreamed of writing about my two favourite women
June 10, 2024
Annie B and Queen Lizzie 1!!! Both legends in my eyes👑 and pioneers for ALL women! 🙌🏽 GO GURLS!!
Anne was a fashionista, an intellect, a diva, passionate, a loving mother, and let’s not forget she somehow convinced a fat grumpy King Henry to create an entire new church so he could marry her??
Lizzie, well she was everything her mother was PLUS her reign has gone down as one of the best in English history - she brought about the compromise between Roman Catholicism and Protestantism, which previous to this point was proving to be a lil’ bit HECTIC! (To put it lightly) She leveraged off her femininity, and yes she also used her virginity. It’s fucked I know, but that was society back then - she used it to her advantage proclaiming the people of England her husband and children. Fucking genius.
I have read many books on both these icons, and the women who surround them during this time but this is definitely the most factual and historically accurate book so far. So a change in that respect. Loved it tho. Was like a very long podcast.
I never knew that Lizzie’s choices were so often based off her Mum’s - for example she favoured people who her Mum, Anne, favoured. Ultimately having these people around her to make decisions for the country led to a stronger England than even before… I mean how sick is that!!!!
Lastly, I just love that Henry tried so hard (six wives hard) to have a son to take over …. Little did he know that the red haired girl, who at times was claimed to be from incest (between Anne and her brother) and who’s mother he killed, took that crown and threw it in our fucking faces. YEAH THE GIRLS!!!
Anne was a fashionista, an intellect, a diva, passionate, a loving mother, and let’s not forget she somehow convinced a fat grumpy King Henry to create an entire new church so he could marry her??
Lizzie, well she was everything her mother was PLUS her reign has gone down as one of the best in English history - she brought about the compromise between Roman Catholicism and Protestantism, which previous to this point was proving to be a lil’ bit HECTIC! (To put it lightly) She leveraged off her femininity, and yes she also used her virginity. It’s fucked I know, but that was society back then - she used it to her advantage proclaiming the people of England her husband and children. Fucking genius.
I have read many books on both these icons, and the women who surround them during this time but this is definitely the most factual and historically accurate book so far. So a change in that respect. Loved it tho. Was like a very long podcast.
I never knew that Lizzie’s choices were so often based off her Mum’s - for example she favoured people who her Mum, Anne, favoured. Ultimately having these people around her to make decisions for the country led to a stronger England than even before… I mean how sick is that!!!!
Lastly, I just love that Henry tried so hard (six wives hard) to have a son to take over …. Little did he know that the red haired girl, who at times was claimed to be from incest (between Anne and her brother) and who’s mother he killed, took that crown and threw it in our fucking faces. YEAH THE GIRLS!!!
July 2, 2024
Super interesting read! I learned a ton, and feel like I may actually remember this period of history better than I've been able to before. I made my wife listen to me telling her so many Anne facts and Elizabeth facts every day. The book is very open about its speculative nature; there were so many instances of "It's tempting to believe..." that I grew a little impatient with the disclaimers, even though they're obviously necessary. There was one chapter I could have done without, which basically listed all the Boleyn relatives/associates whom Elizabeth interacted with as Queen. It seemed like the author had done an incredible amount of research and wanted to include the detail, but the amount of content didn't really strengthen the argument for me. But I'm sure other readers or researchers would fee differently! On the whole, I recommend this to anyone who's interested in women's history, especially in this period. I think I took Elizabeth I for granted and didn't realize how groundbreaking she was and how hard she had to work PR to do what she did. And I certainly underestimated the extent to which she was continuing work started by her mother!
October 1, 2024
A non-fiction read addressing the largely ignored connection between mother and daughter and in particular Boleyn’s influence on Elizabeth. As Anne died when her daughter was just three I had always assumed her influence was fairly minimal. This book disproves that thoroughly. Elizabeth was able to draw from her mother’s strengths: as a linguist, a religious reformer, a forthright speaker but balance them against Anne’s flaws that fundamentally led to her downfall. I always think that Anne’s daughter becoming queen is one of the biggest ‘revenge served cold’ events in history. However the text did feel pretty repetitive. The same issues could have been covered probably in an extended essay to the same effect.
November 18, 2024
Another fabulous book from Tracy Borman!
I have been a huge fan of Tracy's work for many years and this new book exploring the relationship between mother and daughter, Anne Boleyn and Elizabeth I is hugely engaging and superbly researched. It dives deep into the affect of Anne Boleyn's death on her young daughter and Elizabeth's determination to honour her mother through public reminders of the woman she truly was rather than the one painted during the reign of her father, Henry VIII.
Highly recommended!
I have been a huge fan of Tracy's work for many years and this new book exploring the relationship between mother and daughter, Anne Boleyn and Elizabeth I is hugely engaging and superbly researched. It dives deep into the affect of Anne Boleyn's death on her young daughter and Elizabeth's determination to honour her mother through public reminders of the woman she truly was rather than the one painted during the reign of her father, Henry VIII.
Highly recommended!
Read
February 21, 2024Compellingly narrated by the author— I am rarely so captivated by a history book.
September 17, 2024
First Tracy Borman book and oh my god, it's love.
July 24, 2025
4.5 stars.
I binge listened to this and found it excellent. A biography linking Anne Boleyn and Elizabeth I is a niche approach and it worked. It charts the rise and fall of both women, their limited mother/daughter relationship and the influence that Anne Boleyn had on Elizabeth I life.
Tracy Borman is my absolute favourite Tudor historian and she makes an informative narrator as well.
I binge listened to this and found it excellent. A biography linking Anne Boleyn and Elizabeth I is a niche approach and it worked. It charts the rise and fall of both women, their limited mother/daughter relationship and the influence that Anne Boleyn had on Elizabeth I life.
Tracy Borman is my absolute favourite Tudor historian and she makes an informative narrator as well.
July 2, 2025
I would say closer to 3.5 stars but oh well, I’ve read another one of Borman’s books on Elizabeth and at times this was a little bit too similar, nonetheless it was still interesting and an enjoyable read.
June 29, 2023
No book has ever made me dream about its central characters. Until this one! What's more I was in the dream too. In a fitting session with one of the queens! Ha. It's hilarious.
As you might have surmised with my experience above, I found much of the book pretty fascinating and engrossing. Tracy Borman writes really well, and her knowledge and research shines through.
Learned a lot of new things about these two iconic queens.
4 and a half stars from me.
As you might have surmised with my experience above, I found much of the book pretty fascinating and engrossing. Tracy Borman writes really well, and her knowledge and research shines through.
Learned a lot of new things about these two iconic queens.
4 and a half stars from me.
January 4, 2023
I would like to thank Netgalley and Atlantic Monthly Press for the uncorrected proof of this book.
Synopsis: How interconnected are Anne Boleyn and Elizabeth Tudor's lives? We know that they are mother and daughter and that they had to navigate a deadly time that did not value women for their intellect or tenacity. However, how did these women influence each other's lives? Rather than a joint biography of these women, Borman weaves together the historical evidence to show how mother and daughter influenced decisions, purchases, and other relationships.
Thoughts: I love the Tudors and Borman's work so when I heard she was writing this book I knew I had to read it. When the opportunity came to review this book came up on NetGalley I smashed the "request" button so hard. I have been an avid reader of Tudor history since I was a child and in EVERY chapter of this book, I learned a new detail not only about Anne and Elizabeth but about their relationship. Given the premise of the book you would think that there would not be so much source material given that Anne died when Elizabeth was so young, but the way that Borman weaves the facts of Anne throughout Elizabeth's life is fascinating.
My favourite things that Borman highlights in this book are the material possessions that were passed from mother to daughter and the way that Elizabeth honoured her mother throughout her reign.
It was super interesting to learn what items Elizabeth had in her possession even before she became Queen that could be traced back to her mother. Given Henry's desire to wipe Anne's memory off the face of the planet, I was surprised to see that he did not exert more power to keep Anne's memory from her daughter. I think the tapestries Borman mentioned were my favourite item discussed.
From previous readings, I knew that Elizabeth favoured her mother's family more during her reign because they did not have a strong blood claim to the through like her father's family did. However, I was unaware of just how influential Anne was in forming Elizabeth's court. The way Borman outlines how these individuals went from Anne's patronage to Elizabeth's service was so easy to follow and really gave me a new perspective on Elizabeth's reign. Most sources cite Elizabeth's reign as the Golden Age of England that had lasting repercussions through to today, to think of how much of a role Anne played in that is as heartwarming as it is interesting.
I only had two minor complaints about this book and given that it's not necessarily the final copy of the book I am not sure if they are even relevant. Some images or sketches of the items that were discussed even if they were not contemporary would have been really helpful in visualizing things. For instance, the pageantry of the coronations. Also, I wish that there were a family tree for the Boleyns I fully might have missed this as being part of the book, but when we were discussing the Boleyn courtiers in Elizabeth's court I got confused by who was whose daughter and which Katherine was which. This however is a fault of most discussions of the Tudor era as Katherine, Mary, and Elizabeth were all popular names.
If you love the history that centers on female stories, the Tudors, material history, or just want to try something new I highly recommend this book.
Synopsis: How interconnected are Anne Boleyn and Elizabeth Tudor's lives? We know that they are mother and daughter and that they had to navigate a deadly time that did not value women for their intellect or tenacity. However, how did these women influence each other's lives? Rather than a joint biography of these women, Borman weaves together the historical evidence to show how mother and daughter influenced decisions, purchases, and other relationships.
Thoughts: I love the Tudors and Borman's work so when I heard she was writing this book I knew I had to read it. When the opportunity came to review this book came up on NetGalley I smashed the "request" button so hard. I have been an avid reader of Tudor history since I was a child and in EVERY chapter of this book, I learned a new detail not only about Anne and Elizabeth but about their relationship. Given the premise of the book you would think that there would not be so much source material given that Anne died when Elizabeth was so young, but the way that Borman weaves the facts of Anne throughout Elizabeth's life is fascinating.
My favourite things that Borman highlights in this book are the material possessions that were passed from mother to daughter and the way that Elizabeth honoured her mother throughout her reign.
It was super interesting to learn what items Elizabeth had in her possession even before she became Queen that could be traced back to her mother. Given Henry's desire to wipe Anne's memory off the face of the planet, I was surprised to see that he did not exert more power to keep Anne's memory from her daughter. I think the tapestries Borman mentioned were my favourite item discussed.
From previous readings, I knew that Elizabeth favoured her mother's family more during her reign because they did not have a strong blood claim to the through like her father's family did. However, I was unaware of just how influential Anne was in forming Elizabeth's court. The way Borman outlines how these individuals went from Anne's patronage to Elizabeth's service was so easy to follow and really gave me a new perspective on Elizabeth's reign. Most sources cite Elizabeth's reign as the Golden Age of England that had lasting repercussions through to today, to think of how much of a role Anne played in that is as heartwarming as it is interesting.
I only had two minor complaints about this book and given that it's not necessarily the final copy of the book I am not sure if they are even relevant. Some images or sketches of the items that were discussed even if they were not contemporary would have been really helpful in visualizing things. For instance, the pageantry of the coronations. Also, I wish that there were a family tree for the Boleyns I fully might have missed this as being part of the book, but when we were discussing the Boleyn courtiers in Elizabeth's court I got confused by who was whose daughter and which Katherine was which. This however is a fault of most discussions of the Tudor era as Katherine, Mary, and Elizabeth were all popular names.
If you love the history that centers on female stories, the Tudors, material history, or just want to try something new I highly recommend this book.
December 27, 2022
4/5 stars
I received this book as an ARC from NetGalley and the publisher
This book was a deep dive into Anne Boleyn and her daugther Elizabeth I: Their stories, their similarities and the love that connected them through their mother daughter bond. I found it very comprehensive, the author did their research and it shows. The writing was understandable and it had a nice rhythm.
I personally enjoyed the first third or so of the book that was centered around Anne Boleyn's life. It was fascinating to the point that I was sad to see how short it was though I understand that she didn't live long enough to really explore her life, unlike Elizabeth and her long reign which is more than enough to fill a whole book.
What I found most compelling about this book was the relationship beetween the two of them and all the little hints of Elizabeth's appreciation for a mother that she didn't have the pleasure to really know and cherish. The events decribed both delighted me and upset me, I think the author did a great job at portraying the court intrigue and all the political issues. Definitely give this a read.
I received this book as an ARC from NetGalley and the publisher
This book was a deep dive into Anne Boleyn and her daugther Elizabeth I: Their stories, their similarities and the love that connected them through their mother daughter bond. I found it very comprehensive, the author did their research and it shows. The writing was understandable and it had a nice rhythm.
I personally enjoyed the first third or so of the book that was centered around Anne Boleyn's life. It was fascinating to the point that I was sad to see how short it was though I understand that she didn't live long enough to really explore her life, unlike Elizabeth and her long reign which is more than enough to fill a whole book.
What I found most compelling about this book was the relationship beetween the two of them and all the little hints of Elizabeth's appreciation for a mother that she didn't have the pleasure to really know and cherish. The events decribed both delighted me and upset me, I think the author did a great job at portraying the court intrigue and all the political issues. Definitely give this a read.
May 28, 2023
This stunning book charts the previously unexplored emotional landscape of Queen Anne Boleyn and her daughter, Queen Elizabeth I. Thick with primary research, and typically astute analysis, Borman’s groundbreaking study sheds new light on the extraordinary relationship between mother and daughter, overturning the long-held assumption that Elizabeth rarely acknowledged her mother in public. With abundant, lucid examples of Elizabeth drawing upon her mother’s memory and keeping those connected to Anne close to her, this thrilling account gets to the heart of how important Anne’s memory really was to Elizabeth. Elizabeth may have been a Lion’s cub, but she was heart and stomach a Boleyn. This is Borman’s finest work to date. Highly recommended!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 329 reviews