I confess, I have no idea where these terrific reviews came from. I tried very, very hard to like this book. In the very beginning, I really did like it; it sucked me right in.
And then we get to the part where Gabriel drowns...which, BTW, is pretty much immediately. As you might surmise, he discovers that he's not dead and learns about his abilities. From that moment on, the book is one massive info-dump.
I tend to be more forgiving than the average reader, I think, with detailed exposition that explains The Rules. Don't get me wrong: I like rules. I've read many books that could've used more, IMO.
Not so here, though. This is just page after page of people answering questions, introducing themselves with far, far more information than a regular person would get in an introduction, and sometimes even anticipating the main character's confusion and responding before he even formulates a question. There's so much structure that the author doesn't really have any room left to flesh out the story, and the attempts to disguise these lectures were ham-fisted and transparent.
There are other problems, too...among them the fact that the main character is grossly overpowered. Just like games aren't nearly as much fun when you essentially have no chance of losing, books aren't fun to read when you know ahead of time that when something bad happens, the MC will spontaneously develop some amazing and rare power that'll save the day. Again.
The characters aren't terrific either. We have a caricature of a bad guy, who does everything we'd expect a villain to do short of tying some chick to the railroad tracks while he twirls his mustache. The good guys have suspiciously similar voices. Even the little stuff, like when he meets a teenager and an elegant older woman and the woman mutters "whatever"...rather like a teenager would have. When we're not getting lectured at, there's a great deal of banter between the characters, and unfortunately, much of it sounds like they're talking to themselves.
It's disappointing, because the plot itself is a pretty good one. More than once I found myself hoping I could get over my aggravation, because I wanted to see how the tale ends. (That's probably why I got considerably farther in this DNF than I usually do.) The world, too, would have been very interesting had I got to experience it rather than just learn about it. Maybe it's all the more disappointing because it had so much potential, I don't know.
You know, I have read lots of YA books without prejudice. Not because they're YA, but because the stories, while perhaps a bit simpler or less literary than your standard grownup books, are entertaining. Sorry, but I'm simply not entertained by never-ending seminars on magic and bad guys. I am, however, giving this two stars. If you're an adult, I'd recommend you move on (though maybe I'm just overly critical; this book does seem to be popular). If you're planning to get it for a kid, though – like middle school or early high school – I can see why a younger reader would find plenty to like.