What do you think?
Rate this book
The MacDonnells #1
Under the Same Sky
The year is 1746. A young woman from South Carolina and a Scottish Highlander share an intimacy and devotion beyond their understanding. They have had visions of each other their entire lives. And yet they have never met.
Now, with their lives torn asunder, Maggie Johnson and Andrew MacDonnell's quest to find each other is guided only by their dreams— and by the belief in the true love they share.
On the Carolina frontier Maggie Johnson’s family struggles to survive. Maggie’s gift of “the sight” and her visions show her a presence she calls Wolf. She watches him grow from a boy her age to a man even as she goes from child to woman.
Andrew MacDonald has always wondered about the girl he sees in his dreams. He is able to talk to her through their thoughts and vows that even if he must cross an ocean he will find her.
They are thrust into different situations: Andrew fights for the doomed Jacobite cause and Maggie is captured by slavers, then rescued and brought into a kind, loving Native American tribe. They each believe in destiny and the power of the love they have shared forever.
Now, with their lives torn asunder, Maggie Johnson and Andrew MacDonnell's quest to find each other is guided only by their dreams— and by the belief in the true love they share.
On the Carolina frontier Maggie Johnson’s family struggles to survive. Maggie’s gift of “the sight” and her visions show her a presence she calls Wolf. She watches him grow from a boy her age to a man even as she goes from child to woman.
Andrew MacDonald has always wondered about the girl he sees in his dreams. He is able to talk to her through their thoughts and vows that even if he must cross an ocean he will find her.
They are thrust into different situations: Andrew fights for the doomed Jacobite cause and Maggie is captured by slavers, then rescued and brought into a kind, loving Native American tribe. They each believe in destiny and the power of the love they have shared forever.
319 pages, Paperback
First published January 3, 2012
14 people are currently reading
1960 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 129 reviews
January 3, 2017
This is my debut novel, so I hope it's not wrong of me to post on here about it, but I wanted to let potential readers know a bit about the book.
I began writing "Under the Same Sky" while I waited for Diana Gabaldon's next instalment, needing to fill those lonely places that opened up when I didn't have one of her books in front of me! So while "Under the Same Sky" is an adventure, and a historical romance, don't be fooled by the cover photo. There is nothing "Regency" or glamorous about my book. It is gritty, real, heartbreaking and thrilling.
The story is set in the 1740's and focuses on Maggie Johnson, a girl with "the Sight" who lives in the Carolinas with her very poor family. It also focuses on Scottish Highlander, Andrew MacDonnell. The two known each other as well as they know themselves, having dreamed of each other since childhood. They see each other's thoughts, channel their energies to one another, sometimes can even rescue each other from danger and death. When Andrew leaves Scotland after his country is devastated in the Battle of Culloden, he must journey across the Highlands, the Atlantic, and the vast colonies to find the woman he has always loved. Maggie survives a horrific trauma and is rescued from white slavers by the Cherokee, who take her in and encourage her Gift. But the 18th century was an unkind time, especially for women, and Maggie is forced to defend herself once again, this time with dire consequences. Will Andrew reach her in time? Will they ever touch beyond dreams?
I hope you enjoy "Under the Same Sky". It is being published in January 2012 by Berkley/Penguin US.
I began writing "Under the Same Sky" while I waited for Diana Gabaldon's next instalment, needing to fill those lonely places that opened up when I didn't have one of her books in front of me! So while "Under the Same Sky" is an adventure, and a historical romance, don't be fooled by the cover photo. There is nothing "Regency" or glamorous about my book. It is gritty, real, heartbreaking and thrilling.
The story is set in the 1740's and focuses on Maggie Johnson, a girl with "the Sight" who lives in the Carolinas with her very poor family. It also focuses on Scottish Highlander, Andrew MacDonnell. The two known each other as well as they know themselves, having dreamed of each other since childhood. They see each other's thoughts, channel their energies to one another, sometimes can even rescue each other from danger and death. When Andrew leaves Scotland after his country is devastated in the Battle of Culloden, he must journey across the Highlands, the Atlantic, and the vast colonies to find the woman he has always loved. Maggie survives a horrific trauma and is rescued from white slavers by the Cherokee, who take her in and encourage her Gift. But the 18th century was an unkind time, especially for women, and Maggie is forced to defend herself once again, this time with dire consequences. Will Andrew reach her in time? Will they ever touch beyond dreams?
I hope you enjoy "Under the Same Sky". It is being published in January 2012 by Berkley/Penguin US.
December 20, 2011
I almost feel as though I should do a jig because I have branched out from Outlander and read another romance with a highlander – Genevieve Graham’s debut novel Under The Same Sky. Under The Same Sky has similar elements to Outlander (paranormal elements, highlanders, Culloden) but Genevieve Graham’s book is NOT a doorstopper.
Read the rest of my review here
Read the rest of my review here
April 9, 2012
3-3.5 stars
OK, I'm sort of holding my breath as I type this review, because I'm concerned that it will be misunderstood. I *liked* this book, but I really wanted to love it, and I didn't.
The author truly focuses on the two main characters: Maggie our Heroine from South Carolina, and Andrew our Highland Hero. Maggie has "the Sight", a gift passed to her from her grandmother - it apparently skips a generation. Maggie sees visions of what will come, good or bad, but mostly bad. The only "vision" she has that is constant and "good" is of "the boy", whom she finds out later is Andrew. Maggie and Andrew have "seen" each other and dreamt of each other for as long as either can remember. As they've grown up together (even though an ocean apart), they've come to know one another and to love one another; neither has any doubt that some day, they'll be together.
In the meantime, tragedy after tragedy befalls each of them. Often, the other is able to provide some aid and comfort or even warning to the other. Knowing that the other is "there" is what keeps them both moving, living, going forward. It's wonderfully romantic.
But... as a reader, I felt confused at times, cheated at others. Time is relative in this book. We start in who-knows-what year with only a reference as to Maggie being born in 1730. After reading a bit and then getting to Andrew's part of the story, I had to go back and re-read everything I'd read to that point, trying to figure out what year it was and how old Maggie was supposed to be.
It seems that the author only wants to share specific events with us, and not the whole. We can literally leap from spring to autumn in the space of two sentences. And that's where my heart wept: it's what's in-between those sentences that could make this book so rich, so deep! It's those details, even mundane, that help us to really get the feel for the characters around Maggie and Andrew, and what's happening in their lives. It's what would make us care more... understand more... relate more... empathize more.
Because within this story is the germ of something really wonderful and magical. This gift that Maggie has and her connection with Andrew that is the reason for the story seems cheated by the miserly details within this book's framework. We learn a lot about the misery and horror of life; our only real comfort is from Maggie to Andrew and vice versa. There is a bit of comfort offered by others, but we never get the opportunity to really *know* them.
I still couldn't tell you much about Iain, except that he's a giant, he lost his family in the aftermath of Culloden, that he adopted 2 young kids, and that he traveled with Andrew to America.
I have pieces of who Andrew's family might be, but they seem lost in the sea of getting Andrew to Maggie, as if nothing but bringing these two together is what really matters. But since that event doesn't take place until at least 60% of the book, if that's the author's intent, it seems almost cruel. And I don't believe that *is* the author's intent.
It might sound cruel of me, but I view this book as a really good, really promising first draft of a story that is epic and wonderful and great. Perhaps it's my own sensibilities, but I have a hard time bearing all the tragedy and horrors of what happens (especially to Maggie) without wanting more of the good. Like when Maggie is with the Cherokee. I want *more* about her time with Waw-Li, since this is the turning point of her life - her acceptance of her gift, her ability to survive and heal from the horrors she's experienced. I want to know what happened to Kokili, since we rarely hear anything of her after Maggie meets Waw-Li. I want to know more about the Cherokee life - more than just mating rituals and Soquily's interest in Maggie.
I want to know more about those Andrew encounters, too. I want to know more about Iain, more about Janet's family - especially her brothers. I didn't even know that Geoffrey could play the bagpipes, until he shows up as they're leaving! Is this supposed to be a signal? A farewell? Something more meaningful than a man playing the bagpipes? I don't know, because while I've gotten the sense that Geoffrey is close to Janet and upset at her leaving, I only have a few sentences to understand that. And while I know that Geoffrey plays the violin, how was I to know that he was more musical than that?
Even the sea voyage that Andrew, Iain, the children, and Janet make from Scotland to America is vague... swept away within pages, without any real detail. We learn that Iain doesn't like the hammocks; Janet and the kids got a berth; Andrew & Iain worked harder than they ever had in their lives. And that's about it. There's so much of that story left out that could deepen the overall. And once they "land" in America, the group doesn't seem to have a bit of trouble with anything - the new life, the new people, and certainly not money. Yet somehow, I have a hard time believing that Andrew's parents had saved that much. It sounds like the only money they use is from the purse that Hector gave his daughter Janet; but if Hector had that kind of money put aside, why didn't he take his family to America before Culloden? Why bother to hide them? (And didn't anyone find that appalling and cowardly? I'd have thought that Iain, especially would have, even if Andrew could forgive.)
As for Seamus Murphy, I'm still not sure if he's a good guy or a bad guy. I've had my doubts about him, probably because he's smooth and charming, as most con men are. But I simply haven't enough information about him to know. And that really frustrates me.
I am also frustrated at Maggie's ability to "see" visions and not interpret them. I understand that she's resisted her gift most of her life. But after her time and training with Waw-Li, I'd think Maggie could clearly make out WHO the coyote in her dream is, especially since the author was so kind as to make sure to tell us about the distinctive scar on the coyote's face. Why doesn't Maggie even have an inkling of danger around this man until it's too late? Sure, it makes some sense as a plot device to get us to a particular cabin and a box, but it's hard to buy that Maggie has so little control or comprehension of her own gift at this point. Also, Waw-Li - surely she'd see more ahead of time? She was the one who wanted Maggie to make contact with the white settlers at the fort... surely that meant more than Maggie negotiating trade prices for the Cherokee?
I'm also unsure of how we got from the fort, which is, I think in South Carolina near Charleston into North Carolina. In other words, how did Andrew and his group come across Maggie and her group? I didn't pull out a map, and I realize these states are close together, but still... it seemed like a very long way to go to escape. Why wouldn't the Cherokee head back into their own territory, where they'd be safer and have more numbers?
There are so many unanswered questions - answers to which were either barely touched on or not addressed at all. And that's what makes me feel as if this book is incomplete yet. A really great book lost inside something that was published while still in its infancy.
Perhaps if there weren't some similarities to the Outlander series, I could ignore some of it. (Although, because I still believe it's a great epic story yearning to be freed, I don't I could ignore it.) Character names are similar, although thank heavens, no Alexanders! But Sorcha is Gaelic for Claire. There's a Jamie. There's a Janet, even though she's referred to more often as Jenny in the Outlander series. There's an Iain, while his namesake in Outlander is Ian. There are Indians, Cherokee in this book. There are brutal men who rape, kidnap, pillage, and sell innocents into a white slave trade. There are lots of red coats and lots of Indians. The Outlander characters settled in North Carolina (northern part); it looks like Andrew's land is in North Carolina... and yet there are confusing references to Charleston (SC) - is it just where the Cherokee are? And then there's the author's own admission that Diana Gabaldon was an inspiration to the author, as she waits for the next Outlander novel.
So I end this review that seems more criticism than praise. If it's so, it's because I really believe there's so much MORE to this story that hasn't been allowed to be told... hasn't been explored. All those marvelous details and nuances that simply stand in the shadows and, like Maggie's visions, plead to be known and understood. That "more" would make this story and its characters breathtaking and spectacular, not just ordinary.
OK, I'm sort of holding my breath as I type this review, because I'm concerned that it will be misunderstood. I *liked* this book, but I really wanted to love it, and I didn't.
The author truly focuses on the two main characters: Maggie our Heroine from South Carolina, and Andrew our Highland Hero. Maggie has "the Sight", a gift passed to her from her grandmother - it apparently skips a generation. Maggie sees visions of what will come, good or bad, but mostly bad. The only "vision" she has that is constant and "good" is of "the boy", whom she finds out later is Andrew. Maggie and Andrew have "seen" each other and dreamt of each other for as long as either can remember. As they've grown up together (even though an ocean apart), they've come to know one another and to love one another; neither has any doubt that some day, they'll be together.
In the meantime, tragedy after tragedy befalls each of them. Often, the other is able to provide some aid and comfort or even warning to the other. Knowing that the other is "there" is what keeps them both moving, living, going forward. It's wonderfully romantic.
But... as a reader, I felt confused at times, cheated at others. Time is relative in this book. We start in who-knows-what year with only a reference as to Maggie being born in 1730. After reading a bit and then getting to Andrew's part of the story, I had to go back and re-read everything I'd read to that point, trying to figure out what year it was and how old Maggie was supposed to be.
It seems that the author only wants to share specific events with us, and not the whole. We can literally leap from spring to autumn in the space of two sentences. And that's where my heart wept: it's what's in-between those sentences that could make this book so rich, so deep! It's those details, even mundane, that help us to really get the feel for the characters around Maggie and Andrew, and what's happening in their lives. It's what would make us care more... understand more... relate more... empathize more.
Because within this story is the germ of something really wonderful and magical. This gift that Maggie has and her connection with Andrew that is the reason for the story seems cheated by the miserly details within this book's framework. We learn a lot about the misery and horror of life; our only real comfort is from Maggie to Andrew and vice versa. There is a bit of comfort offered by others, but we never get the opportunity to really *know* them.
I still couldn't tell you much about Iain, except that he's a giant, he lost his family in the aftermath of Culloden, that he adopted 2 young kids, and that he traveled with Andrew to America.
I have pieces of who Andrew's family might be, but they seem lost in the sea of getting Andrew to Maggie, as if nothing but bringing these two together is what really matters. But since that event doesn't take place until at least 60% of the book, if that's the author's intent, it seems almost cruel. And I don't believe that *is* the author's intent.
It might sound cruel of me, but I view this book as a really good, really promising first draft of a story that is epic and wonderful and great. Perhaps it's my own sensibilities, but I have a hard time bearing all the tragedy and horrors of what happens (especially to Maggie) without wanting more of the good. Like when Maggie is with the Cherokee. I want *more* about her time with Waw-Li, since this is the turning point of her life - her acceptance of her gift, her ability to survive and heal from the horrors she's experienced. I want to know what happened to Kokili, since we rarely hear anything of her after Maggie meets Waw-Li. I want to know more about the Cherokee life - more than just mating rituals and Soquily's interest in Maggie.
I want to know more about those Andrew encounters, too. I want to know more about Iain, more about Janet's family - especially her brothers. I didn't even know that Geoffrey could play the bagpipes, until he shows up as they're leaving! Is this supposed to be a signal? A farewell? Something more meaningful than a man playing the bagpipes? I don't know, because while I've gotten the sense that Geoffrey is close to Janet and upset at her leaving, I only have a few sentences to understand that. And while I know that Geoffrey plays the violin, how was I to know that he was more musical than that?
Even the sea voyage that Andrew, Iain, the children, and Janet make from Scotland to America is vague... swept away within pages, without any real detail. We learn that Iain doesn't like the hammocks; Janet and the kids got a berth; Andrew & Iain worked harder than they ever had in their lives. And that's about it. There's so much of that story left out that could deepen the overall. And once they "land" in America, the group doesn't seem to have a bit of trouble with anything - the new life, the new people, and certainly not money. Yet somehow, I have a hard time believing that Andrew's parents had saved that much. It sounds like the only money they use is from the purse that Hector gave his daughter Janet; but if Hector had that kind of money put aside, why didn't he take his family to America before Culloden? Why bother to hide them? (And didn't anyone find that appalling and cowardly? I'd have thought that Iain, especially would have, even if Andrew could forgive.)
As for Seamus Murphy, I'm still not sure if he's a good guy or a bad guy. I've had my doubts about him, probably because he's smooth and charming, as most con men are. But I simply haven't enough information about him to know. And that really frustrates me.
I am also frustrated at Maggie's ability to "see" visions and not interpret them. I understand that she's resisted her gift most of her life. But after her time and training with Waw-Li, I'd think Maggie could clearly make out WHO the coyote in her dream is, especially since the author was so kind as to make sure to tell us about the distinctive scar on the coyote's face. Why doesn't Maggie even have an inkling of danger around this man until it's too late? Sure, it makes some sense as a plot device to get us to a particular cabin and a box, but it's hard to buy that Maggie has so little control or comprehension of her own gift at this point. Also, Waw-Li - surely she'd see more ahead of time? She was the one who wanted Maggie to make contact with the white settlers at the fort... surely that meant more than Maggie negotiating trade prices for the Cherokee?
I'm also unsure of how we got from the fort, which is, I think in South Carolina near Charleston into North Carolina. In other words, how did Andrew and his group come across Maggie and her group? I didn't pull out a map, and I realize these states are close together, but still... it seemed like a very long way to go to escape. Why wouldn't the Cherokee head back into their own territory, where they'd be safer and have more numbers?
There are so many unanswered questions - answers to which were either barely touched on or not addressed at all. And that's what makes me feel as if this book is incomplete yet. A really great book lost inside something that was published while still in its infancy.
Perhaps if there weren't some similarities to the Outlander series, I could ignore some of it. (Although, because I still believe it's a great epic story yearning to be freed, I don't I could ignore it.) Character names are similar, although thank heavens, no Alexanders! But Sorcha is Gaelic for Claire. There's a Jamie. There's a Janet, even though she's referred to more often as Jenny in the Outlander series. There's an Iain, while his namesake in Outlander is Ian. There are Indians, Cherokee in this book. There are brutal men who rape, kidnap, pillage, and sell innocents into a white slave trade. There are lots of red coats and lots of Indians. The Outlander characters settled in North Carolina (northern part); it looks like Andrew's land is in North Carolina... and yet there are confusing references to Charleston (SC) - is it just where the Cherokee are? And then there's the author's own admission that Diana Gabaldon was an inspiration to the author, as she waits for the next Outlander novel.
So I end this review that seems more criticism than praise. If it's so, it's because I really believe there's so much MORE to this story that hasn't been allowed to be told... hasn't been explored. All those marvelous details and nuances that simply stand in the shadows and, like Maggie's visions, plead to be known and understood. That "more" would make this story and its characters breathtaking and spectacular, not just ordinary.
March 23, 2017
I think the reason I didn't like this more was because it was almost like 2 different stories. The majority of the book takes place from either Andrew or Maggie's POV with them only interacting in their dreams. It follows Maggie's early life in South Carolina, her kidnap and rape, and then building a life among the Cherokee. Andrew's covers his family and growing up in Scotland, fighting through the Battle of Culloden, and then journeying through Scotland to America. Just too very different stories with very little cross over between them. On their own they could have been developed into really good stories. I was interested in each as I read them, but every time the POV switched it was like picking up a different book. Again, well written, good characters, etc, but there either needed to be more crossover to make this a more cohesive story.
September 26, 2021
I was meaning to read another ancient Rome book after my hearty introduction to this era thanks to Kate Quinn’s novels, mentally debating between Steven Saylor and John Maddox Roberts and idly browsing my list of acquired e-books at the same time, when I accidentally loaded this book to my e-reader.
I’d say reading Under the Same Sky was sort of a “happy accident” for me, for it was an engaging short read. It gives us a somber picture of 1700s South Carolina and Scotland (specifically the aftermath of the Jacobite Rising of 1745), coupled with a supernatural plot twist and little romance. Two people, Maggie and Andrew, know they are destined to be together before they even met, and have since been using their dreams/visions to communicate with each other or keep one another from harm’s way. I like how the protagonists are drawn and believe they are also well-matched, having shared a bond deeper than most (both have lost their own families—Maggie from the slavers and Andrew from the ill-fated battle on Culloden Moor). But I think the novel is too short for character development (especially for a few minor characters that seem to come out of nowhere) and too fast-paced to fully take in the drama and historical context of the story. On the whole, I am content with this book and eager to continue with the next installment.
I’d say reading Under the Same Sky was sort of a “happy accident” for me, for it was an engaging short read. It gives us a somber picture of 1700s South Carolina and Scotland (specifically the aftermath of the Jacobite Rising of 1745), coupled with a supernatural plot twist and little romance. Two people, Maggie and Andrew, know they are destined to be together before they even met, and have since been using their dreams/visions to communicate with each other or keep one another from harm’s way. I like how the protagonists are drawn and believe they are also well-matched, having shared a bond deeper than most (both have lost their own families—Maggie from the slavers and Andrew from the ill-fated battle on Culloden Moor). But I think the novel is too short for character development (especially for a few minor characters that seem to come out of nowhere) and too fast-paced to fully take in the drama and historical context of the story. On the whole, I am content with this book and eager to continue with the next installment.
January 16, 2016
This book was not what I expected. It is so much more than a historical romance!
I read this book last year and wanted to include it on my Best Books of 2011 but since technically is wasn’t available until January 3, 2012 it couldn’t be included, but it will be in the running for 2012. This book is amazing. To think because it is not classified as a genre I usually read, I may have missed out on this story. This is the type of book my whole blog is about, a book you can escape into, a perfect escape, an adventure not to be missed. As soon as I finished this story and the snippet of the next I had to email Genevieve. I loved the story so much but my enthusiasm was so great I was having trouble putting it into words. Today I still feel like I am gushing but I really want to get across to all of you that you will enjoy this book, especially if you are like me, someone who has basically stepped away from the romance genre.
This story is beautifully written and captivating. There are places where it is purely poetic. Genevieve you are more than welcome in this pond. I am anxiously awaiting Sound of The Heart coming out in May.
January 19, 2012
*** originally posted to: Bookish as a part of the blog tour
Under the Same Sky by Genevieve Graham is a superb historical romance with a unique paranormal twist. From the outstandingly thorough development of characters and plot to the deliciously served historical details, it's a real treat to read. Fast paced, gracefully written and immensely enjoyable, it's a book to devour.
Maggie Johnson, a sixteen-year old girl from South Carolina, has been gifted with a special talent. Like her Grandmother before her, Maggie has "the Sight". She can see things that haven't yet happened, or are happening right now miles away. Her dreams reveal to her what will happen an hour, a day, a week, or even a year before it does. She can also find things that are lost or hidden.
In addition to her prophetic gift, Maggie can also see someone in her dreams. Andrew, a young Highlander, has been there (in her dreams) ever since she can remember. They basically grew up together and helped each other through difficult times. They are connected in a weird, magical way. Maggie calls Andrew "Wolf", as she doesn't know his real name. Worlds apart, not really knowing anything about each other and yet so madly in love with one another, these unlikely lovers will do anything it takes to finally be together for real. They'll embark on a dangerous journey across the treacherous lands and seas. A journey filled with many obstacles, with dreams as their only guide.
This book was wonderful. It offered so much more than I expected. Not only it has a great historical background, that is absolutely fascinating to read about (like the battle of Culloden (1746) or the conflict between British-American settlers and the Cheeroke), but also the romance part of the story is simply fantastic. Not in the least cheesy or overdone. In fact, the developing relationship between Maggie and Andrew is very pleasant to read about. Their attraction is genuine. Unlike in many other historical (or not) romances, where the attraction is instantaneous and often deprived of emotional depth, Genevieve's characters fell in love with each other over the course of many years.
There's a lot going on on the pages of Under the Same Sky. Surprisingly, only about 40-50% of the book focuses on the love-and-romance aspect of the story, which - if you'd ask me- is really great and refreshing! We actually get to know the main characters, instead of being bombarded with love scenes and constant oohs and aaahs. They truly love and care about each other, but they don't sit around pondering their feelings all the time. There's some real action in this book, most of it quite heart-breaking! Plus the paranormal aspect makes it so much more intriguing and compelling!
It's a character-driven story and I'm happy to tell you that the characters were really great. Genevieve does an excellent job drawing them. Her descriptions are detailed and rich in flavor, her writing enthralling. Maggie goes through so much! The story kicks-off with the tragic death of her father. Not long after that her mother gets killed by bandits who then kidnap her and her sisters. She's raped and abused, starved, beaten... She witnesses her sister's murder and is then forced to kill a man to defend her life. Correct me if I'm wrong, but that doesn't sound like a typical romance book to me! It was truly captivating, gut-wrenching and profoundly emotional. The story hes so much depth to it, so much meaning, it's breathtaking! It's not your typical, shallow romance. It's a fabulous and brilliant piece of literature, definitely worth reading! The best part? You don't need to be a romance fan to enjoy this book. I'm fairly confident that this fabulous book can be greatly enjoyed even by people who usually stay away from any sort of romance novels. I highly recommend it to everyone!
Genevieve Graham
Under the Same Sky by Genevieve Graham is a superb historical romance with a unique paranormal twist. From the outstandingly thorough development of characters and plot to the deliciously served historical details, it's a real treat to read. Fast paced, gracefully written and immensely enjoyable, it's a book to devour.
My dreams introduced me to people I had never seen, and took me places I could never have known existed.
Maggie Johnson, a sixteen-year old girl from South Carolina, has been gifted with a special talent. Like her Grandmother before her, Maggie has "the Sight". She can see things that haven't yet happened, or are happening right now miles away. Her dreams reveal to her what will happen an hour, a day, a week, or even a year before it does. She can also find things that are lost or hidden.
I first saw him when we were children: a young boy with eyes as dark as rain-soaked mud, staring at me from under a mane of chestnut hair. I kept him secret, invisible to everyone but me. He should have been invisible to me as well, because he was never really there, on the windblown land, under the same sky.
In addition to her prophetic gift, Maggie can also see someone in her dreams. Andrew, a young Highlander, has been there (in her dreams) ever since she can remember. They basically grew up together and helped each other through difficult times. They are connected in a weird, magical way. Maggie calls Andrew "Wolf", as she doesn't know his real name. Worlds apart, not really knowing anything about each other and yet so madly in love with one another, these unlikely lovers will do anything it takes to finally be together for real. They'll embark on a dangerous journey across the treacherous lands and seas. A journey filled with many obstacles, with dreams as their only guide.
This book was wonderful. It offered so much more than I expected. Not only it has a great historical background, that is absolutely fascinating to read about (like the battle of Culloden (1746) or the conflict between British-American settlers and the Cheeroke), but also the romance part of the story is simply fantastic. Not in the least cheesy or overdone. In fact, the developing relationship between Maggie and Andrew is very pleasant to read about. Their attraction is genuine. Unlike in many other historical (or not) romances, where the attraction is instantaneous and often deprived of emotional depth, Genevieve's characters fell in love with each other over the course of many years.
All the silent communication from our childhood had brought us to this point. I would never leave him. Wherever he needed me to be, if only if his thoughts. I would give him courage, strength and love. And he would give me the same whenever my mind called to him.
There's a lot going on on the pages of Under the Same Sky. Surprisingly, only about 40-50% of the book focuses on the love-and-romance aspect of the story, which - if you'd ask me- is really great and refreshing! We actually get to know the main characters, instead of being bombarded with love scenes and constant oohs and aaahs. They truly love and care about each other, but they don't sit around pondering their feelings all the time. There's some real action in this book, most of it quite heart-breaking! Plus the paranormal aspect makes it so much more intriguing and compelling!
It's a character-driven story and I'm happy to tell you that the characters were really great. Genevieve does an excellent job drawing them. Her descriptions are detailed and rich in flavor, her writing enthralling. Maggie goes through so much! The story kicks-off with the tragic death of her father. Not long after that her mother gets killed by bandits who then kidnap her and her sisters. She's raped and abused, starved, beaten... She witnesses her sister's murder and is then forced to kill a man to defend her life. Correct me if I'm wrong, but that doesn't sound like a typical romance book to me! It was truly captivating, gut-wrenching and profoundly emotional. The story hes so much depth to it, so much meaning, it's breathtaking! It's not your typical, shallow romance. It's a fabulous and brilliant piece of literature, definitely worth reading! The best part? You don't need to be a romance fan to enjoy this book. I'm fairly confident that this fabulous book can be greatly enjoyed even by people who usually stay away from any sort of romance novels. I highly recommend it to everyone!
Genevieve Graham
March 14, 2012
Absolutely fantastic and best written historical romance book I have ever read. This stoy had my emotions up and down and I loved it! I cried within the first three chapters of the book. That’s how great this is. If any book could get my emotions just wrung out like this, it has to get the highest recommendation I have ever put forth to a book. I have read hundreds of books, but this might be the first, in my memory, that I have ever cried from. That’s how touching and descriptive scenes from this book were. Genevieve has out done herself in this novel. I can’t wait for book two and there will even be more in this series.
We are taken through the life of Maggie, a girl from South Carolina that has dreamed of a boy since she was very young. Across miles and oceans. They don’t know each other. They have never met, yet in their dreams they do. Maggie has the gift of sight. She is able to see things that are going to happen or are happening. Yet, it doesn’t let her see everything. She can not read everything in her own future but she does get flashes of things that will happen and to the people around her. We are lead through some HORRIFIC occurrences in her life and her growing up and becoming a woman.
Then we watch as the man Maggie has dreamed about helps her in ways that are so surreal. She also helps him in his times of need. I loved how they did this for each other. Helping each of them give strength and love to one and other was just magical. I don’t even feel like I can give this book the justice it deserves. It’s just that great. It’s a wonderful and imaginative tale of strength, honor and above all else true love.
I HIGHLY recommend getting a copy of this book.
I give Under the Same Sky by Genevieve Graham 5 or 5 stars and is another of my 2012 favorites!
We are taken through the life of Maggie, a girl from South Carolina that has dreamed of a boy since she was very young. Across miles and oceans. They don’t know each other. They have never met, yet in their dreams they do. Maggie has the gift of sight. She is able to see things that are going to happen or are happening. Yet, it doesn’t let her see everything. She can not read everything in her own future but she does get flashes of things that will happen and to the people around her. We are lead through some HORRIFIC occurrences in her life and her growing up and becoming a woman.
Then we watch as the man Maggie has dreamed about helps her in ways that are so surreal. She also helps him in his times of need. I loved how they did this for each other. Helping each of them give strength and love to one and other was just magical. I don’t even feel like I can give this book the justice it deserves. It’s just that great. It’s a wonderful and imaginative tale of strength, honor and above all else true love.
I HIGHLY recommend getting a copy of this book.
I give Under the Same Sky by Genevieve Graham 5 or 5 stars and is another of my 2012 favorites!
August 23, 2014
I was actually quite surprised by this book. Having received the recommendation, I felt like a change and downloaded it whilst on sale at Amazon. After looking at the cover I was expecting a quick bit of fluff to read…..and was very happily surprised that it wasn’t. This book is a very well done historical read – a little supernatural, a little violent, and I was drawn into the story from the very first page. Born in South Carolina 1730, Maggie has the gift of the Sight. Andrew, born in the Highlands of Scotland has a deep connection with Maggie, across the seas. Both lives are turned upside down, Maggie kidnapped by slavers and rescued by an Native American Indian tribe and Andrew is trying to survive in the Jacobite Rebellion of 1746. I loved the detail the author brings into the story of Scottish and American historical fiction, as well, of course of the romance between Maggie and Andrew under the same sky. In the tradition of the Outlander series, this book is emotional, action-packed, and quite addictive. Having already devoured the 2nd book as well, I do wish the series continued with Maggie and Andrew's story - but the next two books follow other characters in the book, so it took me a little to leave Maggie and Andrew, but a little while into no 2 and I was just as hooked. If you like historical fiction with that little hint of paranormal, you will enjoy this book and the series.
March 19, 2015
I paid full price for this after I read the sample. It was lowered from 12.99 to 7.99, so I figured why not.
I have seen it recommended a while and I liked the premise reading the blurb. One of the few books I bought right from my Kindle after reading the sample and I love that it picks right up where I left off. Seamless. I usually order books from my computer, but I just couldn't wait and had to have it.
This was really good. Beautiful language. There is a lot of dark stuff in here though. I mean the Hero survives Culloden and the author doesn't sugarcoat the aftermath. So if one has certain triggers, maybe read some of the spoiler reviews. Violence is there, some of it towards children and women.
Its gritty and beautiful at the same time. The two souls connected across the continents.
Like the ultimate romance, really. What they have to endure to find each other makes you weep. Yet the hope in both is so strong and the believe never really wavers.
I don't know what else to put in here without spoiling too much. Its the journey that is gripping and full of despair and hope.
Its the kind of saga type historical romance I adore and not many of them are written anymore today.
I already have the 2nd on order. Can't wait to read it.
I have seen it recommended a while and I liked the premise reading the blurb. One of the few books I bought right from my Kindle after reading the sample and I love that it picks right up where I left off. Seamless. I usually order books from my computer, but I just couldn't wait and had to have it.
This was really good. Beautiful language. There is a lot of dark stuff in here though. I mean the Hero survives Culloden and the author doesn't sugarcoat the aftermath. So if one has certain triggers, maybe read some of the spoiler reviews. Violence is there, some of it towards children and women.
Its gritty and beautiful at the same time. The two souls connected across the continents.
Like the ultimate romance, really. What they have to endure to find each other makes you weep. Yet the hope in both is so strong and the believe never really wavers.
I don't know what else to put in here without spoiling too much. Its the journey that is gripping and full of despair and hope.
Its the kind of saga type historical romance I adore and not many of them are written anymore today.
I already have the 2nd on order. Can't wait to read it.
July 8, 2012
What an incredibly clever storyline! Soul mates with the gift of sight separated by thousands of miles who seek to find one another. Historically accurate, at times brutal, but thoroughly entrancing romance. Beautifully written, this is definitely a page turner. Despite their horrific circumstances and many travails, you can't help but fall in love with the main characters. What a fantastic find. Thanks for the recommendation, Nisha Mslvoe, my friend! I loved it!
This is the first book by this author for me and it won't be the last. :)
This is the first book by this author for me and it won't be the last. :)
April 10, 2015
Good, just not great.It would have been better had this been a lengthier story- the fascinating bits get skimmed over, we never know what happens to many of the characters. Felt a bit incomplete to me :/
January 11, 2012
3.5 stars
Genevieve Graham’s debut novel, set dually in Colonial America and Scotland, is a sweet, inspiring romance spiked with just enough action and mystery to keep the reader turning pages just as fast as she can.
Under the Same Sky follows the lives of two people destined to be lovers, though they are separated by a vast distance. Maggie is the eldest daughter of a poor farming family in the Carolinas, gifted with “the Sight,” the ability to dream the future, and sometimes the present as well. She is also able to summon up images of a boy her age living in an unknown place, and she and the dream-boy grow up together, constant companions who never the less have not yet met.
The dream boy is Andrew, a Scottish lad of the MacDonnell clan. As Andrew and Maggie grow to adulthood, he, his brothers, and father are swept into the war with England; meanwhile, Maggie’s family is devastated by the murder of their mother and the girls’ capture and attempted sale into sexual slavery. Unthinkable tragedies befall Maggie’s family and Andrew’s, and the two set out to build new lives for themselves, still maintaining their mystical connection and the comfort that their strange friendship brings.
Maggie’s path leads her to take up with the local Cherokee village, where she is allowed to hone her skill with the Sight without fear of being burned as a witch. Andrew, meanwhile, feels compelled to leave Scotland and head for the New World – partly to seek out Maggie, whom he can feel calling to him.
Graham’s prose at the beginning of the novel is absolutely rapturous, full of lush imagery and a quietly confident voice that had me hooked immediately. My one quibble with the book is that after a few chapters that lovely prose settled into a plainer, more straightforward storytelling style – not an authorial crime by any means, but I did find myself wishing for more of that delicious prose as I read to the novel’s final scene. In spite of that one complaint, Under the Same Sky is a well-paced book, switching deftly between the two point-of-view characters at just the right moments and never lagging too long between scenes of tension or action.
Ultimately, this is a novel about redemption – either Maggie or Andrew could have turned sour after the tragedies they’ve faced, but both choose to turn to the promise of love instead, and both take comfort and find purpose in caring for people in need. They are inspiring characters, and it is a delight to watch their romance develop. Genevieve Graham is one to watch for historical romance readers.
Note: An advance reading copy was provided to me in exchange for my honest review.
This review was cross-posted at Historical Novel Review, my blog, and Amazon.
Genevieve Graham’s debut novel, set dually in Colonial America and Scotland, is a sweet, inspiring romance spiked with just enough action and mystery to keep the reader turning pages just as fast as she can.
Under the Same Sky follows the lives of two people destined to be lovers, though they are separated by a vast distance. Maggie is the eldest daughter of a poor farming family in the Carolinas, gifted with “the Sight,” the ability to dream the future, and sometimes the present as well. She is also able to summon up images of a boy her age living in an unknown place, and she and the dream-boy grow up together, constant companions who never the less have not yet met.
The dream boy is Andrew, a Scottish lad of the MacDonnell clan. As Andrew and Maggie grow to adulthood, he, his brothers, and father are swept into the war with England; meanwhile, Maggie’s family is devastated by the murder of their mother and the girls’ capture and attempted sale into sexual slavery. Unthinkable tragedies befall Maggie’s family and Andrew’s, and the two set out to build new lives for themselves, still maintaining their mystical connection and the comfort that their strange friendship brings.
Maggie’s path leads her to take up with the local Cherokee village, where she is allowed to hone her skill with the Sight without fear of being burned as a witch. Andrew, meanwhile, feels compelled to leave Scotland and head for the New World – partly to seek out Maggie, whom he can feel calling to him.
Graham’s prose at the beginning of the novel is absolutely rapturous, full of lush imagery and a quietly confident voice that had me hooked immediately. My one quibble with the book is that after a few chapters that lovely prose settled into a plainer, more straightforward storytelling style – not an authorial crime by any means, but I did find myself wishing for more of that delicious prose as I read to the novel’s final scene. In spite of that one complaint, Under the Same Sky is a well-paced book, switching deftly between the two point-of-view characters at just the right moments and never lagging too long between scenes of tension or action.
Ultimately, this is a novel about redemption – either Maggie or Andrew could have turned sour after the tragedies they’ve faced, but both choose to turn to the promise of love instead, and both take comfort and find purpose in caring for people in need. They are inspiring characters, and it is a delight to watch their romance develop. Genevieve Graham is one to watch for historical romance readers.
Note: An advance reading copy was provided to me in exchange for my honest review.
This review was cross-posted at Historical Novel Review, my blog, and Amazon.
March 5, 2012
It is the 1700's and Maggie Johnson has grown up in the colony of South Carolina. Maggie has always had dreams that told her of the future. Her mother says that she has "The Sight" just as her grandmother did before she was burned as a witch. These dreams give Maggie glimpses of what is to come, but not always. Some of her dreams include a boy that is around her age and in these dreams they grow close to each other without speaking a word or sharing a touch. Maggie doesn't know his name, but she knows that one day they will find each other. On the other side of the ocean in Scotland, Andrew MacDonnell shares the same gift, the same dreams, and the same hope of finding the girl who has become a part of him. As Maggie and Andrew's lives are torn apart by greed, pride, and war, each step they take brings them closer together.
When I first saw the cover of the book, I wasn't quite sure about it. Under the Same Sky looked like a romance novel, and while I have nothing against them, they just aren't what I typically read. However, I put my worries aside and read the first chapter. And then the second. And before I knew it, half the day and half the book had passed without my moving. I was completely sucked in and literally could not force myself to put the book down. I loved Maggie's character. She was so likable and strong, but had her character flaws that made her believable. Andrew was just as fantastic and I truly enjoyed seeing where their paths would take them and what it would take for them to be together. Aside from the wonderful characters, the writing was really well done and I find it very hard to believe that this is a debut novel. The plot moves along quickly and is steeped in historical detail. Not only does it share tidbits about living in the colonies and life in Scotland after Culloden, readers also get a glimpse of life in a Cherokee settlement, which was one of my favorite parts of the book. My only complaint is that it ended too quickly because I didn't want it to end. However, I was really excited to see a chapter from Graham's next novel at the end of the book and cannot wait until it comes out. Overall, it was a fantastic debut novel that had me completely captivated.
*Please note, I received a copy of this novel from the author in exchange for an honest review.
When I first saw the cover of the book, I wasn't quite sure about it. Under the Same Sky looked like a romance novel, and while I have nothing against them, they just aren't what I typically read. However, I put my worries aside and read the first chapter. And then the second. And before I knew it, half the day and half the book had passed without my moving. I was completely sucked in and literally could not force myself to put the book down. I loved Maggie's character. She was so likable and strong, but had her character flaws that made her believable. Andrew was just as fantastic and I truly enjoyed seeing where their paths would take them and what it would take for them to be together. Aside from the wonderful characters, the writing was really well done and I find it very hard to believe that this is a debut novel. The plot moves along quickly and is steeped in historical detail. Not only does it share tidbits about living in the colonies and life in Scotland after Culloden, readers also get a glimpse of life in a Cherokee settlement, which was one of my favorite parts of the book. My only complaint is that it ended too quickly because I didn't want it to end. However, I was really excited to see a chapter from Graham's next novel at the end of the book and cannot wait until it comes out. Overall, it was a fantastic debut novel that had me completely captivated.
*Please note, I received a copy of this novel from the author in exchange for an honest review.
March 1, 2012
Oh, I really liked this book! It's a historical fiction mixed with some mystery and paranormal with some romance or in other words, a truly delicious combination and the type of book that you can get lost in. And lost I got. This book found me lazing on the couch for the entire afternoon because I couldn't bear to put it down. I really liked how the author wove the paranormal details with the historical details. It really made the book come to life for me!
This is also a tale of how you shouldn't judge a book by its cover. I saw the cover before reading the synopsis and said "oh, this is a bodice ripper." And I like bodice rippers sometimes but this book is not a bodice ripper at all. There is romance but not the... uh... sort that you would be expecting from the cover.
This book explores the idea of soulmates, an idea that I really like. I loved Maggie and Andrew as soulmates. I loved that both of them seemed to know each other even though they were literally an ocean apart (Maggie is in the Carolinas and Andrew is a Scottish Highlander).
I really wish that we would have gotten to see more about them once they finally meet in real life. I'm still holding out hope for a sequel that features more of Andrew and Maggie together (Graham has another book coming out later this spring that features Andrew's brother back in Scotland; there's a sneak peek in the back of Under the Same Sky). I think one of the signs of a good book is when you aren't ready to let go of the characters at the end of the book and I was so not ready to let go!
Bottom line: This is a story that will hold on to you until the last page (and beyond).
This is also a tale of how you shouldn't judge a book by its cover. I saw the cover before reading the synopsis and said "oh, this is a bodice ripper." And I like bodice rippers sometimes but this book is not a bodice ripper at all. There is romance but not the... uh... sort that you would be expecting from the cover.
This book explores the idea of soulmates, an idea that I really like. I loved Maggie and Andrew as soulmates. I loved that both of them seemed to know each other even though they were literally an ocean apart (Maggie is in the Carolinas and Andrew is a Scottish Highlander).
I really wish that we would have gotten to see more about them once they finally meet in real life. I'm still holding out hope for a sequel that features more of Andrew and Maggie together (Graham has another book coming out later this spring that features Andrew's brother back in Scotland; there's a sneak peek in the back of Under the Same Sky). I think one of the signs of a good book is when you aren't ready to let go of the characters at the end of the book and I was so not ready to let go!
Bottom line: This is a story that will hold on to you until the last page (and beyond).
April 8, 2012
4.5 Stars
The love story in this book was written in that all consuming true love style that I love so much. Yes, there were parts of the book that I personally didn't enjoy because they were too gritty and violent. But I am happy that I kept on truckin' through those parts because the love story really was fantastic.
In order to really get into the love story, you have to be willing to have an open mind. This pair has seen each other in visions and dreams for their whole lives but they have never met. I think it's very interesting that Andrew never wavers in his devotion to Maggie, even though he's never met her. Maggie does have a flirtation with one of the members of the Native American tribe that she lives with. Of course, he is so sweet, and who can blame her for being unsure about Andrew, so this worked in the story for me.
My favorite part of the book is the time that Maggie spends with the Native American tribe. All of the people are so kind and teach her to heal her wounds with love and support.
I do want to warn readers that the violence in this book is very unpleasant, and I didn't care for it. But I am very glad that I read the rest book instead of letting that scare me away.
Overall, an all-encompassing love story that transcends time and space.
book sent by publisher and author in exchange for honest review
reviewed for http://inthehammockblog.blogspot.com
January 23, 2012
Young Maggie has always had the gift of 'sight', she has always been able to see future events and places she's never been. Since she was a child a young boy has always been present in her dreams and visions. When her her life is suddenly turned upside down after the death of her father she hopes that he'll be there to rescue her. Maggie goes through so much in this book, she is kidnapped by slavers and rescued by a Native American tribe.
Born thousands of miles apart, both Maggie and Andrew have a deep connection. Each has glimpses into the others lives; both tragedy or joy. Life is Scotland for Andrew is harsh and violent; he fights with his family against the English troops. When the war is over, he finds himself alone. He decides to go and find Maggie who desperately needs his help.
This was such a unique book, I very rarely find a historical romance based on a young woman who isn't from the Aristocracy. I really enjoyed the glimpse into Maggie and Andrew's lives, they are so unlike anything I've read before. The story is so filled with history and a touch of paranormal, I was drawn into the story and couldn't put it down.
I can easily say this is one of the best debut's I've ever read and easily topped my list of books read in 2011. I can't wait to see what Genevieve comes up with for her next book "Song of the Heart" coming out in May 2012.
Born thousands of miles apart, both Maggie and Andrew have a deep connection. Each has glimpses into the others lives; both tragedy or joy. Life is Scotland for Andrew is harsh and violent; he fights with his family against the English troops. When the war is over, he finds himself alone. He decides to go and find Maggie who desperately needs his help.
This was such a unique book, I very rarely find a historical romance based on a young woman who isn't from the Aristocracy. I really enjoyed the glimpse into Maggie and Andrew's lives, they are so unlike anything I've read before. The story is so filled with history and a touch of paranormal, I was drawn into the story and couldn't put it down.
I can easily say this is one of the best debut's I've ever read and easily topped my list of books read in 2011. I can't wait to see what Genevieve comes up with for her next book "Song of the Heart" coming out in May 2012.
July 28, 2013
Being a fan of Outlander and knowing that the author of this book is also a fan, I had higher hopes for this one. Hopes that weren't exactly met. That's not to say it's bad. Not at all, I enjoyed reading it and found quite a bit to like. However, the entire story felt somewhat rushed. Ms. Graham wanted to pack a lot into the story, but only gave herself roughly 300 pages to do so. The result is that, while readers are almost certainly never bored, they're also never quite allowed any room to recover from the myriad horrible things that happen to Maggie and Andrew. The events in the first quarter of the book alone are quite draining emotionally, and at times it felt like being struck over the head with a large, heavy object.
I didn't like how the POV changed from first to third between Maggie and Andrew. It made it harder to focus when it was Andrew's turn in the story.
I also kind of resented the fact that it ended so quickly. After pining for each other for nearly two decades, I had hoped I'd be treated to a bit more face-to-face interaction between the protagonists. Alas, it was not to be.
Despite all that, I enjoyed it. It's probably not a book I'd pick up and reread, but it made its mark.
I didn't like how the POV changed from first to third between Maggie and Andrew. It made it harder to focus when it was Andrew's turn in the story.
I also kind of resented the fact that it ended so quickly. After pining for each other for nearly two decades, I had hoped I'd be treated to a bit more face-to-face interaction between the protagonists. Alas, it was not to be.
Despite all that, I enjoyed it. It's probably not a book I'd pick up and reread, but it made its mark.
April 27, 2017
4.5/5 stars. A very good book. Yet, I can tell that Outlander was a major influence (not that there's anything wrong with that). The author used the standing stones for the two characters to communicate, the witch trial scene was when Maggie killed Captain Quinn (who was Black Jack Randall). The author, Genevieve Graham, even stated she wrote this waiting for the Next Outlander book to be released. I loved the plot, writing, setting, and the characters. But I felt like the connection between Maggie and Andrew was missing, it didn't have the spark that often made me fall in love with two characters being together. Also, it was interesting to learn more about the Cherokee (how they lived, what they used to hunt, ect). Some scenes in this book did include rape m, which weren't overly graphic (Thank god), but still were hard to read. Overall, a very enjoyable book but too similar to Outlander, I would recommend it and will be picking up books by this author in the future.
September 19, 2013
I shelved this book under fantasy as well as historical romance because the focus was on the supernatural way that the hero/heroine communicated and "knew" each other. However, it was historical because it was set around the time of the Jacobite Rebellion in 1746. I like the organization of the book - the author changes the point of view in each section of the book from Maggie's to Andrew's which keeps things nice and neat. When I read the first few chapters I wasn't sure I was going to like the book, but it was an easy read that I finished in just 3 days - it was worth that much time. One of the things I didn't care for was the way their lives paralleled each other's so conveniently (for example, they both reject the affections of people who fall in love with them because they are not "Maggie/Andrew") and how loose ends just got wrapped up into a nice, neat bow at the end after so much tragedy in both of their lives. It's a happily ever after, for sure. I was expecting more of what I call a "bodice ripper," but there were not any steamy sex scenes at all. A sweet romance.
December 22, 2012
A beautifully written book. Though an ocean apart, Maggie and Andrew both blessed with the gift of the sight are keenly aware of each other. In Scotland, Andrew fights for Prince Charlie on Culloden Field.
With his family killed, he finds friends to go with him to the colonies where he knows Maggie is.
in South Carolina, Maggie raised in poverty finds herself and her sisters in great danger. Able to take refuge with the Cherokee, she knows Andrew is coming for her but will he be in time?
When it came to choosing my recommendation for the month of June, 2012, I was torn between this book and Elswyth Thane's Yankee Stranger. Although this book really appealed to my heart and I still highly recommend it, Yankee Stranger was such a compelling read, I decided on it as my 2012 recommendation.
Still this one is highly recommended too!
With his family killed, he finds friends to go with him to the colonies where he knows Maggie is.
in South Carolina, Maggie raised in poverty finds herself and her sisters in great danger. Able to take refuge with the Cherokee, she knows Andrew is coming for her but will he be in time?
When it came to choosing my recommendation for the month of June, 2012, I was torn between this book and Elswyth Thane's Yankee Stranger. Although this book really appealed to my heart and I still highly recommend it, Yankee Stranger was such a compelling read, I decided on it as my 2012 recommendation.
Still this one is highly recommended too!
May 5, 2013
I am highly recommending this book to all Outlander fans. This is one of my favorite reads of the year so far. I loved the blend of Scottish and American historical fiction, as well as the romance building between Maggie and Andrew under the same sky. The book is emotional, action-packed, and just sweet enough. I only wish the series were going to continue following Maggie and Andrew's story - but it looks like we get to hear about other characters in the next book.
February 1, 2012
Not quite sure how to rate this one. I loved the author's writing style, her characterization and the pace of the story but I really did not like the paranormal and mystical aspects of the storyline. I hope her next book will not have any paranormal plot lines. I give her writing and style a 5 and the storyline a 2 so I guess that averages out to a 3.5.
October 4, 2013
what a pleasantly nice surprise to find a new author and a great first story. Gritty at times but hard to put down. What drew me in was the connection that Maggie and Andrew had with one another. They met in their dreams since they were young but never met. I liked seeing both of their stories being told in parts and a good conclusion to the story. I look forward to more of her books.
August 22, 2012
This book included some rough material to wrap your mind around. the storyline, however, was new and interesting - keeping the hero and heroine physically removed from each other for over three quarters of the book. It was beautifully written. I finished it in a day and a half.
March 17, 2012
Loved it cannot wait for the next book
March 14, 2012
(a similar version of this review can be found here at Into the Hall of Books: http://www.intothehallofbooks.com/201...)
I love to read books that are rich in characters and setting. I completely lucked out with UNDER THE SAME SKY. Not only are ALL of the characters absolutely amazing, but the setting - well, both of the settings - are lush and perfect. To top it off, half of the book is set in the Carolinas, and I'm a Carolina girl myself. When I heard about this one, I had to read it and you guys, before I even get started I'm gonna just recommend it to you ALL.
1. The Characters. There are two different settings with two different plot lines for much of the book, which means there are a bunch of characters. But the main characters are Maggie and Andrew.
Every character that Maggie and Andrew come across in this book - be it a good guy or a bad guy - is believable and developed. Oh, how I despised the bad guys and how I loved the good ones! This complete cast is superbly written, and Maggie and Andrew are to-die-for lovable. I couldn't get enough of them.
2. The Story. Maggie and Andrew can see each other in their dreams while they're sleeping or sometimes in visions while they're awake. They communicate wordlessly at first. Over time, it seems like this gift becomes stronger - over the years they are able to talk to one another and eventually, they can touch briefly. Maggie and Andrew are good for one another in that they encourage each other when they're both discouraged or sad. They also help each other out by seeing things or predicting things that will happen to the other one and giving warnings. Their gift is unique and awesome to read about. It's a really fun take on a book in this genre.
3. The Genre. Historical Fiction/Romance with some unique and awesome Paranormal. Loved it.
4. The Setting. In my opinion, this is one of the best things about this book. Maggie's story is told in America - South Carolina to be exact. She goes from her meager farm in the beginning and moves to live with the Cherokee Native Americans. These settings are described so well and perfectly - particularly for this time in history, as I am pretty familiar with it - and I loved reading about an area that is so close to home for me.
Andrew's story begins in Scotland, as he is a kilt and plaid-wearing Highlander. Have mercy! I am not very familiar with this area or this time in Scottish history, but clearly the author has done her research. It is well laid-out and I feel like not only did I read a book that was immensely enjoyable, I learned a little bit about some Scottish history and geography as well. I love that. The descriptions of the Scottish countryside were breathtaking, from the colors to the terrain, and I loved even the descriptions of the battle scenes and war-torn countryside.
The setting in this book is amazing and if you are a reader that enjoys that sort of thing - like I am - you will love this part of UNDER THE SAME SKY. The setting alone was a sensory experience.
5. The Writing. The story is told in multiple points-of-view between Maggie and Andrew, although this is not done with alternating chapters. There are several chapters of Maggie, then several chapters of Andrew, and so on. This was wonderful in terms of story flow and pacing, and it kept me engaged from page one until I closed the book.
Genevieve Graham's writing is luscious and descriptive. It is beautiful. There were several times that I actually stopped to re-read passages that I thought sounded particularly, well, pretty. The author's language and imagery practically dropped me into Scotland with Andrew, and it allowed me to be side-by-side with Maggie as she traveled the Carolinas. Loved it.
6. The Romance. Oh, this romance, you guys! See, here's the thing: it is a slowly-developing thing between these two young people in the beginning. They start out having visions of each other as children and the visions just carry on throughout their lives until the two realize as adults that they need each other. *sigh* The problem is they're an ocean apart. It can't get much more romantic than that...
The romance can't help but be slowly-developing because of the dual settings, which is really nice. Readers are assured that this relationship is authentic because the two bond without words for years before they even can speak to each other, and then it is another couple of years before they even lay eyes on each other. Also, there is no love triangle whatsoever because these two have eyes for no one else. This is one of my favorite romances ever because they fell in love in their dreams!
Friends, I am thrilled and excited to have read UNDER THE SAME SKY. It is truly spectacular and I enjoyed every word of it. It is a wonderfully character-driven story with excellent pacing and a unique spin on historical romance. I loved the weave of paranormal and magic into the story and I was excited over both of the settings used in the book.
I would love to know more about Maggie and Andrew. But...I'm also eager to read the next book in this series - out in May - titled SOUND OF THE HEART. Honestly, if it is anything at all like this one, I'm pretty certain that I'll love it. Genevieve Graham is one to look out for, readers, and I highly suggest picking up UNDER THE SAME SKY if you are a fan of historical fiction or romance with a bit of paranormal.
**I received a review copy from the author/publisher in exchange for an honest opinion and review. I received no compensation for my thoughts. Thank you SO MUCH Genevieve and Berkley Trade!
I love to read books that are rich in characters and setting. I completely lucked out with UNDER THE SAME SKY. Not only are ALL of the characters absolutely amazing, but the setting - well, both of the settings - are lush and perfect. To top it off, half of the book is set in the Carolinas, and I'm a Carolina girl myself. When I heard about this one, I had to read it and you guys, before I even get started I'm gonna just recommend it to you ALL.
Why you need to read UNDER THE SAME SKY right now:
1. The Characters. There are two different settings with two different plot lines for much of the book, which means there are a bunch of characters. But the main characters are Maggie and Andrew.
**Maggie Johnson. Maggie has "the Sight" which means she can see the future. She can also find things that are hidden or out of sight. Maggie has seen a boy in her dreams and visions for years, a boy that she communicates with wordlessly. He comforts her and makes her laugh, and she considers him a friend. When she is 17, Maggie's father dies and soon after her mother is murdered. She and her sisters are taken away, raped, and mistreated - one sister dies. Malnourished and injured, Maggie manages to escape and the boy comes to her in a vision - he wordlessly points out a weapon lying closeby and Maggie uses it to kill her kidnapper. She and her sister are then picked up, taken to the Cherokee Nation, and healed by the healers of this Native American tribe. She continues to live with them for the vast remainder of the book, learning their language and customs.
**Andrew McDonnell. Andrew is one of three sons in his loving family. He too has "the Sight" and has always had visions of a girl that he communicates with wordlessly. He thinks of her almost constantly and dreams of the day when he can meet her face-to-face. However, when war comes to the area, he - along with his father and brothers - goes to fight for what he feels is right. Unfortunately, Andrew is the only survivor in his family. He makes it back to his home to find that his mother has been killed and the farm has been destroyed. Depressed and saddened, Andrew vows to leave Scotland and find the girl in his visions. He learns that he'll have to cross the Atlantic Ocean to get to her - and it'll take a long time - but that is okay. He will do anything, anything to find her.
Every character that Maggie and Andrew come across in this book - be it a good guy or a bad guy - is believable and developed. Oh, how I despised the bad guys and how I loved the good ones! This complete cast is superbly written, and Maggie and Andrew are to-die-for lovable. I couldn't get enough of them.
2. The Story. Maggie and Andrew can see each other in their dreams while they're sleeping or sometimes in visions while they're awake. They communicate wordlessly at first. Over time, it seems like this gift becomes stronger - over the years they are able to talk to one another and eventually, they can touch briefly. Maggie and Andrew are good for one another in that they encourage each other when they're both discouraged or sad. They also help each other out by seeing things or predicting things that will happen to the other one and giving warnings. Their gift is unique and awesome to read about. It's a really fun take on a book in this genre.
3. The Genre. Historical Fiction/Romance with some unique and awesome Paranormal. Loved it.
4. The Setting. In my opinion, this is one of the best things about this book. Maggie's story is told in America - South Carolina to be exact. She goes from her meager farm in the beginning and moves to live with the Cherokee Native Americans. These settings are described so well and perfectly - particularly for this time in history, as I am pretty familiar with it - and I loved reading about an area that is so close to home for me.
Andrew's story begins in Scotland, as he is a kilt and plaid-wearing Highlander. Have mercy! I am not very familiar with this area or this time in Scottish history, but clearly the author has done her research. It is well laid-out and I feel like not only did I read a book that was immensely enjoyable, I learned a little bit about some Scottish history and geography as well. I love that. The descriptions of the Scottish countryside were breathtaking, from the colors to the terrain, and I loved even the descriptions of the battle scenes and war-torn countryside.
The setting in this book is amazing and if you are a reader that enjoys that sort of thing - like I am - you will love this part of UNDER THE SAME SKY. The setting alone was a sensory experience.
5. The Writing. The story is told in multiple points-of-view between Maggie and Andrew, although this is not done with alternating chapters. There are several chapters of Maggie, then several chapters of Andrew, and so on. This was wonderful in terms of story flow and pacing, and it kept me engaged from page one until I closed the book.
Genevieve Graham's writing is luscious and descriptive. It is beautiful. There were several times that I actually stopped to re-read passages that I thought sounded particularly, well, pretty. The author's language and imagery practically dropped me into Scotland with Andrew, and it allowed me to be side-by-side with Maggie as she traveled the Carolinas. Loved it.
6. The Romance. Oh, this romance, you guys! See, here's the thing: it is a slowly-developing thing between these two young people in the beginning. They start out having visions of each other as children and the visions just carry on throughout their lives until the two realize as adults that they need each other. *sigh* The problem is they're an ocean apart. It can't get much more romantic than that...
The romance can't help but be slowly-developing because of the dual settings, which is really nice. Readers are assured that this relationship is authentic because the two bond without words for years before they even can speak to each other, and then it is another couple of years before they even lay eyes on each other. Also, there is no love triangle whatsoever because these two have eyes for no one else. This is one of my favorite romances ever because they fell in love in their dreams!
Friends, I am thrilled and excited to have read UNDER THE SAME SKY. It is truly spectacular and I enjoyed every word of it. It is a wonderfully character-driven story with excellent pacing and a unique spin on historical romance. I loved the weave of paranormal and magic into the story and I was excited over both of the settings used in the book.
I would love to know more about Maggie and Andrew. But...I'm also eager to read the next book in this series - out in May - titled SOUND OF THE HEART. Honestly, if it is anything at all like this one, I'm pretty certain that I'll love it. Genevieve Graham is one to look out for, readers, and I highly suggest picking up UNDER THE SAME SKY if you are a fan of historical fiction or romance with a bit of paranormal.
UNDER THE SAME SKY will appeal to fans of:
Historical Fiction/Historical Romance
with Paranormal/Magic
Slowly-Developing Romance with No Love Triangle
Multiple POV
Rich Setting: Scottish Highlands, America/South Carolina
UNDER THE SAME SKY by Genevieve Graham
is currently available for purchase.
**I received a review copy from the author/publisher in exchange for an honest opinion and review. I received no compensation for my thoughts. Thank you SO MUCH Genevieve and Berkley Trade!
January 16, 2012
This book poses a huge dilemma for a reader. It’s one you can’t put down. It’s that good. But it’s also one that you have to put down. Just to exhale that breath you’ve been holding, to then inhale and take on a calmness so you can continue on. It’s not that easy, however. The story is that heart-wrenching, so full of tragedy for these courageous, honorable, and so very likable characters.
Maggie Johnson has always had “the Sight.” Whatever she dreams come true. Whatever she sees will come to pass. Among all the horrible dreams there’s been one constant, the boy whose smile and eyes are with her always. They’ve grown up together, seeing one another but never speaking or touching but understanding a look across the span of thousands of miles. As they grow older, Maggie calls this warrior her Wolf, bringing to mind those graceful predators. For Andrew, Maggie is the prettiest woman he’s ever seen and he knows they belong together, that some day they will find a way to each other. He also is able to see events before they occur, and his dreams are as full of Maggie as hers are of Andrew. The way the book is set up, several chapters are devoted to Maggie, written in first person, then several chapters are given to Andrew from his POV, and this continues throughout the book.
Tragedy strikes Maggie and her family after her father has died. She, her mother, and sisters have been surviving the best they can, without letting townsfolk know about the lack of a male presence on the homestead. But that only lasts for so long, and the day comes when men ride up with evil intentions on their minds. One shot is all it takes to leave the girls on their own, at the mercy of these men, their intent to sell them as slaves – after they deliver their own brand of evilness. These are such heart-breaking scenes, especially when it comes to Maggie’s youngest sister, ten-year-old Ruth. Though her scene is not described in detail as Maggie’s, you know what’s happening to the child in the woods, and that fear is confirmed when the men return without her. As man after man has his way with these girls, you want to reach through the pages and choke the ever-lovin’ life out of each of them. Maggie and Adelaide do their best to hold on, knowing the horror has to be over soon and escape is still a possibility.
War is the tragedy in Andrew’s life – he loses everything and everyone he loves as a result of the battle at Culloden in 1746, fighting with his father, brothers, and other Highland clans. Of course, we all know the outcome of this particular battle, the massacre that is a significant part of the downfall of the clans of Scotland. At first, surviving such an onslaught is not the gift it should be for Andrew. Then finding his home, along with his mother, destroyed, coming in contact with no other person – Highlander or Sassenach – for days on end, he’s more than tired enough to lie down and let this nightmare end, but he fights on. Finally he discovers the friends that will become his family as they all rebuild their lives. Feeling disconnected from everything to do with his country, wanting to get as far away as possible from the violence, Andrew decides to leave his homeland for good, along with others who feel the same.
Maggie and Adelaide are rescued by a tribe of Cherokee, who take them in and help them heal. The sisters learn the Indians are not the savages they’d always heard about, and they carve out a place for themselves, learning the language and way of life of these people who don’t frighten them as the white man now does. Eventually Maggie is allowed to accompany the men to the closest fort to trade furs and skins, and she does well for them, understanding how the tribe has always been cheated. But meeting Captain Quinn, a respected man about town, once again ends with Maggie bearing the brunt of men and their superior attitudes. She’s accused of and tried for – railroaded, actually – murder.
I kept thinking to myself throughout this book, “When are these two going to catch a break??” I was exhausted after reading these scenes and just had to put the book down to take a deep breath. But then I had to immediately pick it up again to see what happens to them, how they react, how they recover, how they move on. And, because of the era, they, of course, resolutely move on just because they have to, that’s how people of the time lived and died. I haven’t been this emotionally wiped out reading a romance in a long time.
Andrew finally makes landfall in America, receives land given to immigrants willing to work hard, and makes his way toward Maggie. Even that journey is fraught with danger and delays. But all along they’ve had each other in their dreams, and for a while now those dreams have been very real. They now touch, they feel, they talk, and they remember it all with clarity afterward. Though these scenes of them together are nice and frequent enough so that hero and heroine are together at various intervals throughout the book, I wish there’d been either more of those dreams or more of Andrew and Maggie together at the end of the book. After everything each of them have been through, have helped the other through with comfort and strength, even knowing that happily ever after would be upon them soon, I wanted to see more of that happiness instead of being told about it because it’s now time for the story to end. That’s my only nitpick. For me, there’s just not enough. We’re given just enough to let us know their life together is good and gets better as the years will go on, but I wanted to feel it more, to see it happening, to experience a bit more with them after such a harrowing time has been had to get them to this point.
I’m quite impressed with Ms. Graham’s debut novel. She takes a reader on an epic journey that thoroughly engages the heart and gives them characters who defy horrific odds and who never give up. I look forward to her future work.
See my complete review at http://www.goodbadandunread.com
Maggie Johnson has always had “the Sight.” Whatever she dreams come true. Whatever she sees will come to pass. Among all the horrible dreams there’s been one constant, the boy whose smile and eyes are with her always. They’ve grown up together, seeing one another but never speaking or touching but understanding a look across the span of thousands of miles. As they grow older, Maggie calls this warrior her Wolf, bringing to mind those graceful predators. For Andrew, Maggie is the prettiest woman he’s ever seen and he knows they belong together, that some day they will find a way to each other. He also is able to see events before they occur, and his dreams are as full of Maggie as hers are of Andrew. The way the book is set up, several chapters are devoted to Maggie, written in first person, then several chapters are given to Andrew from his POV, and this continues throughout the book.
Tragedy strikes Maggie and her family after her father has died. She, her mother, and sisters have been surviving the best they can, without letting townsfolk know about the lack of a male presence on the homestead. But that only lasts for so long, and the day comes when men ride up with evil intentions on their minds. One shot is all it takes to leave the girls on their own, at the mercy of these men, their intent to sell them as slaves – after they deliver their own brand of evilness. These are such heart-breaking scenes, especially when it comes to Maggie’s youngest sister, ten-year-old Ruth. Though her scene is not described in detail as Maggie’s, you know what’s happening to the child in the woods, and that fear is confirmed when the men return without her. As man after man has his way with these girls, you want to reach through the pages and choke the ever-lovin’ life out of each of them. Maggie and Adelaide do their best to hold on, knowing the horror has to be over soon and escape is still a possibility.
War is the tragedy in Andrew’s life – he loses everything and everyone he loves as a result of the battle at Culloden in 1746, fighting with his father, brothers, and other Highland clans. Of course, we all know the outcome of this particular battle, the massacre that is a significant part of the downfall of the clans of Scotland. At first, surviving such an onslaught is not the gift it should be for Andrew. Then finding his home, along with his mother, destroyed, coming in contact with no other person – Highlander or Sassenach – for days on end, he’s more than tired enough to lie down and let this nightmare end, but he fights on. Finally he discovers the friends that will become his family as they all rebuild their lives. Feeling disconnected from everything to do with his country, wanting to get as far away as possible from the violence, Andrew decides to leave his homeland for good, along with others who feel the same.
Maggie and Adelaide are rescued by a tribe of Cherokee, who take them in and help them heal. The sisters learn the Indians are not the savages they’d always heard about, and they carve out a place for themselves, learning the language and way of life of these people who don’t frighten them as the white man now does. Eventually Maggie is allowed to accompany the men to the closest fort to trade furs and skins, and she does well for them, understanding how the tribe has always been cheated. But meeting Captain Quinn, a respected man about town, once again ends with Maggie bearing the brunt of men and their superior attitudes. She’s accused of and tried for – railroaded, actually – murder.
I kept thinking to myself throughout this book, “When are these two going to catch a break??” I was exhausted after reading these scenes and just had to put the book down to take a deep breath. But then I had to immediately pick it up again to see what happens to them, how they react, how they recover, how they move on. And, because of the era, they, of course, resolutely move on just because they have to, that’s how people of the time lived and died. I haven’t been this emotionally wiped out reading a romance in a long time.
Andrew finally makes landfall in America, receives land given to immigrants willing to work hard, and makes his way toward Maggie. Even that journey is fraught with danger and delays. But all along they’ve had each other in their dreams, and for a while now those dreams have been very real. They now touch, they feel, they talk, and they remember it all with clarity afterward. Though these scenes of them together are nice and frequent enough so that hero and heroine are together at various intervals throughout the book, I wish there’d been either more of those dreams or more of Andrew and Maggie together at the end of the book. After everything each of them have been through, have helped the other through with comfort and strength, even knowing that happily ever after would be upon them soon, I wanted to see more of that happiness instead of being told about it because it’s now time for the story to end. That’s my only nitpick. For me, there’s just not enough. We’re given just enough to let us know their life together is good and gets better as the years will go on, but I wanted to feel it more, to see it happening, to experience a bit more with them after such a harrowing time has been had to get them to this point.
I’m quite impressed with Ms. Graham’s debut novel. She takes a reader on an epic journey that thoroughly engages the heart and gives them characters who defy horrific odds and who never give up. I look forward to her future work.
See my complete review at http://www.goodbadandunread.com
August 18, 2020
I have it 2-stars because it’s not my favorite Genevieve Graham book; she has better ones out there. But it is a decent book in its own right and definitely a quick read.
January 20, 2012
Soulmates--some people go their whole lives without finding that special someone. Others are more fortunate...
'He has always been there....When I was little, I thought of him as just another child. One with a slow smile and gentle thoughts that soothed me, as if he held my hand. When he didn't fade with my childhood years, I began to wonder if he were a spirit, communicating through my dreams. In my heart I knew he was more...'
Maggie Johnson and Andrew MacDonnell have known each other their whole lives yet have never actually met. They interact within their dreams in a silent communication which needs no words. They knew each other like they knew themselves--two halves of a whole, but had no clue who or where the other lived. Through the years they've given each other comfort and strength through their bond. In the midst of tragedy and war, the magical bond between the two will grow and they will realize no other will do. When at last they are able to speak with each other through their dreams, Andrew vows, "I will find ye."
This is a romance which attempts to weave some of the harshness and history of the time into its story. Maggie and Andrew live in a time when life wasn't easy. In Scotland, where Andrew is from, the country is in the midst of the Jacobite uprising. Maggie lives in the yet untamed area of South Carolina where there are issues with the Cherokee and woman aren't always safe if they aren't under the protection of a man.
Maggie is strong, smart, and the eldest of 3 sisters. When the story begins, she lives with her family. When she turns 17 things take a turn for the worse as their father dies.
Andrew lives with his family in Scotland. When the call for war sounds he, his father, and his brothers hear it. Not everyone will come out of the fighting alive. He will travel around the world to find her.
I liked how Graham bonded the two main characters through magic. At times they could lend each other strength and stamina through their bond. On occasion, they could help each other by predict something that is or will happen which effects the other. When Maggie meets the Cherokee she learns more about her gift. The powers that she and Andrew share are similar to those of the tribe's Seer, Waw-Lai. I enjoyed the interaction Maggie had with the tribe and how Graham incorporated animal totems into the story to represent some of the characters. Andrew had a wolf totem whereas Maggie had a raven.
The trials, tribulations, and drama in the story made for a great read. Although I normally don't care for violence in a novel Graham expertly incorporated it for a reason which added depth to the story. It also left my emotions flaring which bonded me more to Maggie. Plus, when Andrew and Maggie finally came together his handling of her was swoon worthy.
The song dancing through my head as I read was 'Somewhere Out There' from the movie 'Fievel':
"Somewhere out there if love can see us through
Then we'll be together somewhere out there
Out where dreams come true
And even though I know how very far apart we are
It helps to think we might be wishing on the same bright star
And when the night wind starts to sing a lonesome lullaby
It helps to think we're sleeping underneath the same big sky"
Could there be a more appropriate song?
Overall, I gave this one 4 1/2 out 5 roses. On the Lisarenee Romance Rating Scale, this one rates a BLUSH - at the beginning stages of romance where something is just starting to be stirred. This romance didn't get all hot and heavy like some, but I liked the way Graham handled it. As I said before it was swoon worthy none the less. I felt this was a great debut for author Genevieve Graham and look forward to reading more of her books in the future.
Notes to keep you in the know:
I found a wonderful list of Animal Totem and their meanings at http://www.legendsofamerica.com/na-to... which had the following information on some of the animal totems used in the story:
Wolf - Loyalty, perseverance, success, intuition, and spirit
Raven - Introspection, courage, self-knowledge, magic
Hawk - Messenger, intuition, victory, healing, nobility, recollection, cleansing, visionary power, and guardianship.
Coyote - Trickster, intelligence, stealth, wisdom and folly, guile and innocence
Also, if you're interested in finding out more information on the Cherokee in South Carolina I found this wonderful website: http://www.cherokeesofsouthcarolina.com/
If you'd like to see more of my reviews please visit my blog at www.seducedbyabook.com
'He has always been there....When I was little, I thought of him as just another child. One with a slow smile and gentle thoughts that soothed me, as if he held my hand. When he didn't fade with my childhood years, I began to wonder if he were a spirit, communicating through my dreams. In my heart I knew he was more...'
Maggie Johnson and Andrew MacDonnell have known each other their whole lives yet have never actually met. They interact within their dreams in a silent communication which needs no words. They knew each other like they knew themselves--two halves of a whole, but had no clue who or where the other lived. Through the years they've given each other comfort and strength through their bond. In the midst of tragedy and war, the magical bond between the two will grow and they will realize no other will do. When at last they are able to speak with each other through their dreams, Andrew vows, "I will find ye."
This is a romance which attempts to weave some of the harshness and history of the time into its story. Maggie and Andrew live in a time when life wasn't easy. In Scotland, where Andrew is from, the country is in the midst of the Jacobite uprising. Maggie lives in the yet untamed area of South Carolina where there are issues with the Cherokee and woman aren't always safe if they aren't under the protection of a man.
Maggie is strong, smart, and the eldest of 3 sisters. When the story begins, she lives with her family. When she turns 17 things take a turn for the worse as their father dies.
Andrew lives with his family in Scotland. When the call for war sounds he, his father, and his brothers hear it. Not everyone will come out of the fighting alive. He will travel around the world to find her.
I liked how Graham bonded the two main characters through magic. At times they could lend each other strength and stamina through their bond. On occasion, they could help each other by predict something that is or will happen which effects the other. When Maggie meets the Cherokee she learns more about her gift. The powers that she and Andrew share are similar to those of the tribe's Seer, Waw-Lai. I enjoyed the interaction Maggie had with the tribe and how Graham incorporated animal totems into the story to represent some of the characters. Andrew had a wolf totem whereas Maggie had a raven.
The trials, tribulations, and drama in the story made for a great read. Although I normally don't care for violence in a novel Graham expertly incorporated it for a reason which added depth to the story. It also left my emotions flaring which bonded me more to Maggie. Plus, when Andrew and Maggie finally came together his handling of her was swoon worthy.
The song dancing through my head as I read was 'Somewhere Out There' from the movie 'Fievel':
"Somewhere out there if love can see us through
Then we'll be together somewhere out there
Out where dreams come true
And even though I know how very far apart we are
It helps to think we might be wishing on the same bright star
And when the night wind starts to sing a lonesome lullaby
It helps to think we're sleeping underneath the same big sky"
Could there be a more appropriate song?
Overall, I gave this one 4 1/2 out 5 roses. On the Lisarenee Romance Rating Scale, this one rates a BLUSH - at the beginning stages of romance where something is just starting to be stirred. This romance didn't get all hot and heavy like some, but I liked the way Graham handled it. As I said before it was swoon worthy none the less. I felt this was a great debut for author Genevieve Graham and look forward to reading more of her books in the future.
Notes to keep you in the know:
I found a wonderful list of Animal Totem and their meanings at http://www.legendsofamerica.com/na-to... which had the following information on some of the animal totems used in the story:
Wolf - Loyalty, perseverance, success, intuition, and spirit
Raven - Introspection, courage, self-knowledge, magic
Hawk - Messenger, intuition, victory, healing, nobility, recollection, cleansing, visionary power, and guardianship.
Coyote - Trickster, intelligence, stealth, wisdom and folly, guile and innocence
Also, if you're interested in finding out more information on the Cherokee in South Carolina I found this wonderful website: http://www.cherokeesofsouthcarolina.com/
If you'd like to see more of my reviews please visit my blog at www.seducedbyabook.com
Displaying 1 - 30 of 129 reviews