This is not a review, but an observation and a question.
Something I don't really understand so I would enjoy hearing people's views on is how people buy books for children from the point of view of the gender of the book's main subject as illustrated on the cover.
At the moment Geronimo Stilton is the hot book for 8-10 year olds. Both boys and girls rush up to the display and look for the ones they haven't read. Mothers, on their own, will buy Geronimo Stilton's for both their sons and daughters. In my experience, fathers rarely buy books for their daughters unless they are with the little girl who will then choose her own book.
However, when it comes to the companion range of books about
Geronimo's sister, Thea, it is a completely different story. The girls will equally select a Thea Stilton book. They show no preference for Geronimo or Thea, they are just looking for one they haven't read and that has an appealing cover and title. But little boys will not buy a Thea Stilton book. They don't even want to look at them and if I show them, they are almost uniformly disgusted because it is a 'girl's book'.
It isn't the subject matter, Geronimo is a journalist and editor, Thea is a detective, both are action stories. It is enough that the protagonist is a female to cause disgust among the boys and make the mothers reject Thea Stilton for their sons.
This gender bias runs across the entire age range of books. If the cover has a boy on it, both sexes will read it. If it has a girl, only girls. Tom Sawyer, the Jungle Book and Alfie are bought for both sexes. The Madeleine books, Pippi Longstocking and Heidi only for girls.
There are exceptions. Boys will not select Roald Dahl's Matilda but mothers might buy it for them if they like Roald Dahl books. The Secret Garden gets bought for boys only if it is on a school reading list. Harriet the Spy and the Ramona books are for girls. If a book is about a fairy tale and has not been made into a cartoon (yet) by Disney, like Little Red Riding Hood, it will be bought for both. Once it has become Disneyfied, it acquires the same gender bias.
There is absolute horror at the idea that a boy would be bought Nancy Drew books, but the Hardy books are read by both boys and girls.
Would Harry Potter have been so succesful if the protagonist had been Holly Potter?
A note to authors of children's books: no matter what the story is about, if it is directed at both boys and girls, then make sure the title and the cover do not contain any girlie elements otherwise you're dead in the water!