If the baseball book club chose to read a book featuring the Red Sox, we had to counter with one about the Yankees, right. Excited about the two teams’ first meeting of the year, I picked up our midseason book (for the all star break) in advance. New York journalist Jack Curry sets the parameters as to why he believes the 1998 Yankees are the best team ever. He matches them against other great Yankees and other teams from the past and over the course of this book attempts to convince readers that the 1998 version of the bombers was indeed the best.
Jack Curry is a lifelong Yankees fan and employed by the Yankees television network YES. He has constant access to most of principal players from the 1998 team as well as video footage, his former newspaper articles, and is in the know to all the players even if they are not currently employed by the Yankees. Because of his employment alongside two of the key members of the team, current Yankees broadcasters David Cone and Paul O’Neill, Curry’s task at hand was an easy one. He already carried bias and didn’t have to look far to find information to fill a book. Hence, the book read easy and quickly and the majority of the sound bites came from those who are currently employed by the Yankees or their tv network. For stories relating to players not currently in Yankees employ, all Curry had to do was call them and invite them back to the stadium where they are always regaled as kings. As a result I question how much researching went into this book although it presents a quality argument nonetheless.
The 1998 Yankees were reeling from a playoff defeat to the Cleveland Indians the year before. Owner, the esteemed and ruthless George Steinbrenner, said even before the tears dried at the close of 1997, that next year the Yankees would win it all. That is not a tall order but with 27 world championships at present day, in New York if a team doesn’t win the World Series, then that season is deemed a failure. At the peak of his powerful years, Steinbrenner assembled a powerhouse team full of selfless players. It was compromised of three future hall of farmers and another twenty two quality ball players. All of them bought into the idea that the team came first before themselves and a few unlikely players had career years. These elements are what generally the great teams about from merely the good ones, the ones who win the World Series and those remembered as coming up short.
What many might not remember is that the 1998 Yankees started 1-3 and the media of course questioned if manager Joe Torre’s job was safe. The team had been spooked by a bus accident that wasn’t en route to opening day in Anaheim. Somehow after that 1-3 start, the team finished 114-48. I had to do the math because even I couldn’t fathom this. And to be honest, as a Cubs fan, in 1998 I was rooting for Sammy Sosa during his home run chase, which does get a cameo in the book. The Yankees did not have a player approach 60 home runs although ten players hit at least ten and rookie Shane Spencer hit three grand slams in September. The pitching was lights out and featured Cuban refugee Orlando Hernandez who very well might have been the missing piece to the championship puzzle. While the Cubs during the summer of slam managed to make the playoffs as a wild card team, the Yankees dominated, and dominated in the post season as well. Their final record: 125-50.
Were the 1998 Yankees the best team ever? Curry runs numbers and through his criteria believes this to be true. They might not have had the most future hall of famers but as a team they were selfless, devoid of egos. He does admit that most fans are going to make an argument that their favorite team is the best ever. At least he kept it honest. What he coincidentally does not mention is that this dominating team went on to win the World Series in the next two seasons and lost in the series in two of the next three seasons after that. This fear has yet to be replicated during this century, the sustained success of a baseball dynasty, and should fault the Yankees of that era into the best team ever discussion. Whether you love the Yankees or love to hate, this was a fast paced read that brought one back to the last era when the Yankees dominated baseball and knew that they should win every game they played in.
3.5 stars