THE GIRLS HE ADORED [2001] By Jonathan Nasaw
My Review Four Stars****
I just finished reading the book that most readers would agree is the crown jewel amidst this author's colorful and captivating arsenal of serial killer thrillers featuring veteran FBI Agent E.L. Pender. It is certainly his most well known novel of psychological suspense, and it did foster a host of devotees who heaped lavish praise on this original and intriguing journey into the mind of a most definitely novel serial killer.
THE GIRLS HE ADORED was originally published nearly two decades ago, and when released in 2001 the novel was inevitably compared against the perhaps unreachable high bar set by the genius of Thomas Harris, first with RED DRAGON in 1981 and then with its sequel SILENCE OF THE LAMBS in 1988. Perhaps unfairly, I personally believe that critics will always use the works of Thomas Harris noted above as a yardstick to measure all the serial killer thrillers that would follow.
That said, I became acquainted with the works of Nasaw (notably his E.L Pender book series) after reading an article on Britain's Crime Fiction Lover that had been carried in their newsletter back in 2013 (SERIAL KILLER NOVELS TEN OF THE BEST). WHEN SHE WAS BAD [2007] the sequel to the more popular THE GIRLS HE ADORED was listed as a recommended read. I subsequently read the book at the time I ran across the article in 2017 and simply LOVED it.
I reviewed the book on Amazon November 30, 2017 and I was flattered that it is listed as a Top Review. To quote a section of said review:
I INVESTIGATED THIS CHOICE PRIOR TO PURCHASE, SINCE JONATHAN NASAW WAS A "NEW AUTHOR" TO ME. THE FIRST THING I LEARNED WAS THAT THERE IS DOGGONE NEAR A CULT FOLLOWING ASSOCIATED WITH HIS FIRST NAIL-BITING THRILLER FEATURING FORMER FBI AGENT E. L. PENDER, NAMELY THE GIRLS HE ADORED. IN FACT, ITS SEQUEL (WHEN SHE WAS BAD) WAS GENERALLY SPEAKING A HUGE DISAPPOINTMENT TO THE LOYAL FANS OF THE FIRST BOOK. REVIEWS INCLUDED READERS THAT HAD LOVED THE FIRST ONE SO MUCH THAT IT HAD BEEN RE-READ OVER THE YEARS.
ARMED WITH THE ABOVE INSIGHTS I PURCHASED THE RECOMMENDED NOVEL (THE SEQUEL WHEN SHE WAS BAD)---REASONING THAT I COULD NOT BE DISAPPOINTED OR LET DOWN BECAUSE I HAD NOT READ THE FIRST BOOK. THIS WOULD PERMIT ME TO EXAMINE MY FEELINGS ABOUT THE READING EXPERIENCE WITHOUT UNDUE NEGATIVE INFLUENCES. SO, HERE GOES---
I LOVED it. In 2018 I read all of the E.L. Pender books with the exception of the first one. Generally speaking, all of them were worthwhile reads, albeit like the strength of a storm the force and excellence of the series petered out significantly toward the end. But I have a habit of "saving the best for last" (and not just relative to reading book series), so I didn't read the cult classic that started all the fuss until March of 2019. This maiden voyage of Nasaw's new protagonist E.L. Pender sets itself apart from its contemporary competition in a number of ways. First, Pender is perhaps the antithesis of what readers have come to expect in the FBI Agents who are presented in the bulk of serial killer novels. Pender is older, overweight, homely, and has the unenviable distinction of being credited as the worst dressed FBI Agent in the bureau. The character development of Pender is adequate in that we learn enough about Edgar to marvel at his independent mind set, admire his tenacity for never doubting his own instincts about the missing women over the period of a decade, and to admire his sense of empathy and his commitment to pursuing the truth that lie at the end of the road. That said, Pender's back story and character development are comparatively much better handled by the author in his sequel When She Was Bad.
This inaugural novel which introduces the dogged, highly intelligent underdog FBI Special Agent Pender is much more about the hunted than the hunter. The engine that drives the plot line, keeps the reader's attention riveted, and maintains a relentless momentum toward an explosive conclusion stems almost entirely from the interplay between court-appointed psychiatrist Irene Cogan and an apprehended violent criminal who Irene has been hired to meet and evaluate. The prisoner who calls himself "Max" is of course the dominant alter who controls a host of weaker identities. Irene is a recognized expert in the specialized field of DID (formerly known as MPD or Multiple Personality Disorder). It is her confrontation with the narcissistic sociopathic master manipulator alter Max that keeps us fascinated. This is especially true when she is abducted by this monster and her very survival depends upon her clinical expertise and her intuition. In a principal way it is Irene rather that the tenacious Pender on "Casey's" trail who is the primary protagonist of the novel. Her clinical approach to her captivity kept me entertained, in the way that black humor often does in an inappropriate situation. However, I did not find myself liking Irene 100% of the time, and her scientific decision at the conclusion of the book (which flew in the face of caring about others, or even herself for that matter) really rattled my cage. The takeaway from the Epilogue was totally predictable.
In summary, Nasaw created a well researched novel that featured a likable, colorful, and original FBI Agent, an ingenious and creative serial killer who was fascinating as often as he was chillingly sadistic, violent, and cunning, and a pragmatic psychiatrist who learned the meaning of the admonition "Be careful of what you wish for, you just might get it".
The sequel in this instance (When She Was Bad) allowed the reader to get to know Pender better, doubled the fun of dealing with "multiples", and was just overall a more exciting and memorable reading experience. That is my rationale for awarding four stars and not five stars.