My experience of the book differed considerably from my expectations of the book based on the description provided, my own needs, and why I sought out the book. Once I was able to wrestle with what this book was versus what I thought it would be, I found it pretty helpful.
As some context--I have professional training as a Marriage & Family Therapist and a thanatologist. I'm finishing up my PhD in Counseling Psychology (all but dissertation). My modalities of choice include both Narrative Therapy and trauma informed CBT. During the pandemic, I was operating in multiple roles: clinician, supervisor, educator, and student. In many ways, I was probably the ideal audience for the book.
What I was expecting was a very clinical text with specific research-informed interventions on managing your own grief and loss when working with individual clients.
Instead, I got a text that blended narrative techniques, meditation exercises, reflections, and writings from various folks both within and outside of the field. It reminded me of one of my favorite new-age-esque meditation books that I never recommend to others because it didn't age well but I've also never found anything that did as much for self-discovery. Once I got over what I expected the book to be and what it was, I found I really enjoyed it. It spoke to the parts of the therapeutic process that often show up in the room but are absent from clinical discussion. The authors were sensitive and caring and used their combined voices well throughout the text!
Things I liked:
* The structure! 10 chapters that follow the same structure with a visualization steeped in narrative metaphor, reflections from the writers and their own self-of-the-therapist journeys, bits of writings connected to the topic from others, lots of validation, and then how to take it into different areas (self of the therapist, supervision, education, grief + love). This structure made it easy to both follow along and consume a chapter at a time with relative ease (which is great with busy clinical days). I didn't have to worry about going back to catch up or worrying about where to pause.
* The animal connections. This might be a bit too "out there" for me to be able to recommend to some of my colleagues, but as a person that works often with human/animal relationships, these metaphors and narratives worked well for me.
* I have seen very few books that directly acknowledge self-of-the-therapist work and did not realize how much I was craving this until the book delivered.
* They covered a wide range of topics of grief across systemic levels! I loved this immensely because it is often hard to be grieving something broad and not have support or words for it. In particular, the chapter about grieving aspects of the profession hit home.
* Very specifically, there was some reflection on how billing is the same regardless of the emotional energy and the grief connected to that. I hadn't reflected too strongly on that prior and this was very helpful.
Things I liked less:
* My experience with fanfiction has not been as positive as the authors. This could be my baggage, but in chatting with a few other narrative therapists, I heard similar experiences (which is possibly just confirmation bias on my end) so if you are not "deep into the fandom" of something, some of the suggestions might come across as....hmm. Dismissive isn't quite the right word. But there's a layer of depth for fanfiction writers that's often assumed within fanfiction that isn't always assumed outside.
As an example, I both loved and felt a strong reaction to one of the authors discussing a reframe with a difficult client with a strong religious belief and values that differed and marginalized the author. The author was able to reframe this as "the jesus fandom" (not a direct quote, I might have it wrong!). This was so clever and also left a little gut feeling of "oh, that feels not-so-good in a cultural kind of way."
* Community care VS self-care was mentioned but I would have loved to see more specific guides, suggestions, or reflections. While grief is an individual experience, with mentions of community care, I guess I wanted, well, more community. That might be beyond the scope of the book so take this review with a grain of salt; my reaction was more "this was mentioned and then not really explored."
A reflection that I don't know where else to put connected to this book:
* I actually picked the book up due to an experience with disenfranchised grief that wasn't showing up in clinical spaces so much as it was non-clinical spaces. Being a therapist and grieving is weird. My experience has been many folks assume I should "get over it" or "grieve better" because I have all of these tools. Some folks have actually told me directly they provide less support because "therapists don't need it."
A supervisor had shared that it can be hard to have a normal (difficult) human experience as a therapist because it is often seen as a professional failing. His context was talking about parenting but I felt it with grief.
The book didn't quite help with that. It DID help with situations like having a client come in for eco-anxiety and both of us looking out the windows and laughing because it was dark at 12pm noon from wildfire smoke and knowing we both felt that grief but not knowing how to verbalize it. It helped for mourning winters that are not as cold as they used to be. It helped for mourning early stages of my career and what it could have been (telehealth, I was told, was not a reasonable accommodation--and then boom! covid! now it's the norm). It helped for journaling and reflecting a lot on aspects of having both privileged identities and marginalized ones.
Who I'd recommend this book to:
I cannot recommend this book to all of my colleagues, but it's one that I can definitely see passing on to those that work with a wide range of modalities--particularly under the constructivist/post-modern umbrella-- and those clinicians that are struggling with large and ambiguous loss when it comes into the room. I also passed it on to two supervisors--one a colleague, one a superior--and hope they enjoy it as much as I did.