I received an early review copy of the audiobook of this via NetGalley. This review is my own, and I was not asked or pressured to give an overly positive or negative review.
First, the technical, the audiobook is very good, but the reading speed is a bit on the slower side, so I sped it up a bit to more of the speed that I enjoy from an audiobook.
Now the book:
I appreciated the position being taken by the author. The skills of parenthood are not "innate". They are learned. Further, studies have proven that early involvement is critical to creating bonds with children and for both parents to establish themselves as equal parent. Equal parenting looks like a recognition of the power of communication and helping your significant other with parenting. The book focuses largely on what a father can do to be equal. That might mean taking off work early to pick up a child, and phone calls from the school not always going to the mother. Most importantly, the concept of equal parenting helps a child develop and ensures the relationship between parents.
Points that I appreciated:
1. If we expect little from a father, they will likely meet our expectations and little more. We should expect them in the delivery room, at prenatal and postnatal appointments. More than that picking up kids from school, dropping them off, and having to leave work are all not “super dad” functions, that is just being a parent.
2. Why do we think that only a mother should stay up all night with a child, what is so important at work that a new father cannot be tired the next day at work outside the home? I was extremely guilty of this, and looking back on the younger years of my 3 kids (the youngest is 13 at the time of this writing) I missed critical time bonding and learning how to be a parent when I should have been getting in more “practice.”
3. Waking up in the middle of the night is something that can quickly shift from parent to parent, depending on who has the perceived primary responsibility. How many times have you heard the story about frustration because my “husband slept right through the baby crying” The book argues there are studies that prove once a routine is established by parents, a body and mind quickly adapt, which is why the other parent sleeps through it.
4. Government systems need to be updated for new family types and should not just have a single parent (specifically the mother) as the only caregiver tracked by the government or medical systems. Of note, the author is in the UK so your portion of the world may vary. Even issues such as surrogacy are not well structured to ensure the health and safety of children.
5. We need the media to stop portraying dads as hands-off and bumbling. These go a long way to help create a culture of equal parenting. Along with media, we
6. If you get parental leave, TAKE IT. If you supervise others, ENCOURAGE or REQUIRE them to take it (if feasible). That time is precious; you need it.
7. A new child can be a traumatic experience for the father as well. Before anyone yells at me about not giving birth, you are totally right, and the book argues this is not to take away from new birth mothers' trauma or stress. This is, however, a huge life change and can have lasting impacts on fathers as well. healthcare needs to start addressing these issues, and fathers need to step back and ask for help.
The final points that I want to praise in the book are these. It takes clear communication from parents to ensure that parenting is equal, though tasks do NOT have to be split 50/50, but can also be split via what comes naturally. It will take cultural shifts to require men to step up and take parental leave moving forward.
Identifying my personal bias in this review: I am a conservative, religious male, and this book was written by a same-sex couple man, so I had a few disagreements with the author's opinion, but he is more than fair, and it is clear his primary concern is how to be a better parent. He is the absolute right person to write this book, he has been dealing with mom versus dad questions during his entire parenting experience. I wish I had read this before my children were born so I could have a better discussion with my wife about what she needed and wanted.
I look forward to the day when men are given and expect to be more active in their children's lives. Studies continue to show that helps with the development of a young person.
Now for the negative:
1. There are a lot of solutions listed in this book that maybe a country has implemented, and it works. The argument that Government should institute more paid leave, or better subsidize child care is good, but there is no assessment of what that would look like in taxes or other forms to fund those programs. It is a minor gripe and is not the main point of the book. Instead, his book argues that especially if those programs exist, it is PROVEN to be in your family’s and child’s best interest.
2. The book spends an overly long time focusing on non-traditional family issues; see my personal views above. The author is speaking from his viewpoint. I think some of the discussions would have been as easily made with data and studies from all family perspectives and lost none of its impacts. One specific example was the story about a single trans-man parent that seemed to counter-argue with itself, that birth certificates not showing that a mother was then a father and later could choose to detransition back to a mother was confusing. Maybe the parent should explain that to their children rather than trying to get government paperwork to be updated based on the transitioning of a parent after the fact. The author's view is understandable, and this book will still be very useful to all parents, more so to those in "non-traditional" setups, which is very common.
I hope you enjoyed this review it is one of the longest ones I have written. Since I listened to the audiobook, I MAY have gotten a few of the points above slightly wrong; that could be me misremembering something. If you want to negative comment on my more traditional views, feel free, but I am not passing off this review as anything but my own opinion, and I will not respond or engage.
This book has many good things to teach and can help especially soon-to-be fathers start thinking more about how to be the parent they want to be and taking steps to accomplish that.