Fighting Fair tells the story of a marriage reaching its breaking point and the pivotal night that supposedly saves an estranged couple from divorce. Natalie and Shane once shared a passionate, committed relationship, but Shane's relentless focus on his career has pushed Natalie to seriously consider ending things. In a last-ditch effort, Natalie schedules a couples counseling session, which Shane arrives at late and dismisses their issues casually. However, after Shane makes partner at his investment firm a few days later, he suddenly realizes how empty his marriage has become and how dangerously close he is to losing Natalie for good.
Given my two-star rating, it's clear this story didn't fully convince me. It starts strong with the counseling session, vividly showcasing the contrast between their happier past and their current bitterness and resentment. Natalie and Shane's deep-rooted problems become especially clear when Shane, celebrating his promotion alone, realizes he doesn't even know his wife's whereabouts. Spotting Natalie through a bar window talking to another man, Shane jumps to conclusions and confronts her.
From this point forward, the narrative quickly unravels. The carefully built angst and emotional tension abruptly dissolve into a tedious and improbable sex game. Natalie's willingness to engage felt completely out of character. Moments earlier, she was barely speaking to Shane and couldn’t hide her bitterness toward him. Shane's playful suggestion after accusing her of cheating felt particularly jarring and unrealistic. The ensuing sex scene came across as an extended, lukewarm apology for Shane's years of neglect, and afterward, their problems seemingly vanish without genuine emotional resolution.
Ultimately, Fighting Fair felt shallow to me, relying on sex rather than substantial emotional reconciliation. I've encountered this issue before with Anne Calhoun’s work, where physical intimacy overshadows deeper emotions. It’s simply not my preference, and this story reinforced that. Two stars.