Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Unrepentant Renaissance: From Petrarch to Shakespeare to Milton

Rate this book
Who during the Renaissance could have dissented from the values of reason and restraint, patience and humility, rejection of the worldly and the physical? These widely articulated values were part of the inherited Christian tradition and were reinforced by key elements in the Renaissance, especially the revival of Stoicism and Platonism. This book is devoted to those who did dissent from them. Richard Strier reveals that many long-recognized major texts did question the most traditional values and uncovers a Renaissance far more bumptious and affirmative than much recent scholarship has allowed.
The Unrepentant Renaissance counters the prevalent view of the period as dominated by the regulation of bodies and passions, aiming to reclaim the Renaissance as an era happily churning with surprising, worldly, and self-assertive energies. Reviving the perspective of Jacob Burckhardt and Nietzsche, Strier provides fresh and uninhibited readings of texts by Petrarch, More, Shakespeare, Ignatius Loyola, Montaigne, Descartes, and Milton. Strier's lively argument will stir debate throughout the field of Renaissance studies.

328 pages, Hardcover

First published September 1, 2011

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Richard Strier

9 books1 follower

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
10 (55%)
4 stars
6 (33%)
3 stars
0 (0%)
2 stars
2 (11%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 13 of 13 reviews
Profile Image for Aurelio  Guerra.
330 reviews34 followers
May 19, 2023
4 hour read.
I struggled a bit with the relevance of the topics of some of the chapters, so I had to go back and make sure I didn't miss the point. Mostly I didn't. Despite the fact that literature follows the Horatian platitude of the dulce et utile, we know it's usually a ruse or a mask. Medieval authors often wallow in vice-laden stories, but always, so those authors cautiously say, as cautionary tales. Renaissance authors must have been more constrained than their medieval precursors since they were forced, ideologically at least, by the mores of the times as well as by the imperative to convey some elevated classic-like life lesson.
But, fortunately, the Unrepentant Renaissance is unrepentant in that sense. This book doesn't want to teach us that the renaissance writers often callously praised anti-virtues; instead, it deals with some of these literary amorality topics, themes, motifs as slices of human desires and experiences.
Stylistically, I really enjoyed the slick manner in which Strier debated with other critics, but I did find it at times bothersome that, unapologetically perhaps, he always had to have the upper hand.
Profile Image for Marie D..
3 reviews
June 19, 2026
Strier’s insistence on rescuing the flesh, and blood realities of the Renaissance from the clinical grip of New Historicism feels incredibly refreshing. For years, academic circles have treated early modern texts as mere byproducts of power structures and political anxieties, completely stripping away the human element. By focusing on joy, physical pleasure, and genuine theological rebellion, this book restores a sense of agency to the authors of the period. I found his reading of Donne particularly striking because it challenges the standard assumption that all Renaissance wit was laced with underlying existential dread. Instead, Strier forces us to confront a culture that was genuinely comfortable with its own contradictions. It completely upends the way we introduce this era to undergraduate students who are used to a much more rigid, puritanical framework. This is a massive course correction for early modern studies that has been long overdue.
Profile Image for Jorge.
9 reviews
June 19, 2026
What stands out most in The Unrepentant Renaissance is the sheer bravery of Strier's intellectual stance against the prevailing critical orthodoxy. He takes on giants like Burckhardt and greenblatt without falling into the trap of cheap contrarianism, relying instead on meticulous textual evidence. The chapter dealing with 'Shakespeare against Morality' is bound to cause a stir because it refuses to sanitize the messy ethics of the plays. He shows that characters like Falstaff aren't just moral warnings; they represent a vibrant, unapologetic celebration of life that the texts themselves endorse. Reading this made me realize how much modern criticism has tried to force a Victorian moral code onto an era that was far more radical. It’s an essential reminder that literature doesn't always exist to teach us a lesson or uphold state power. Sometimes, it exists to revel in the sheer, unrepentant chaos of being alive.
Profile Image for Roland Mark.
4 reviews
June 19, 2026
I appreciate how Strier handles the delicate intersection of religion and secularism without relying on the tired old narrative of a sudden, clean break from the medieval mind. He demonstrates that the 'unrepentant' nature of the era wasn't about atheism, but rather a profound reevaluation of what it meant to live a holy life in a physical world. His analysis of devotion and desire in George Herbert’s poetry completely reframed my understanding of the period's spiritual landscape. The writing is dense but incredibly rewarding, demanding that you slow down and trace the lineage of every single philosophical claim. It acts as a perfect counterweight to the overly cynical readings that have dominated the field for the last three decades. You can tell this book is the product of a lifetime of deep, affectionate engagement with these texts. It challenges you to love the literature as much as you analyze it.
6 reviews
June 19, 2026
The core strength of this work lies in its refusal to accept the neat, tidy historical categorizations that we've been relying on for convenience. Strier breaks down the false binary between the sacred and the profane, showing how deeply intertwined they were in the Renaissance imagination. His chapter on the virtues of pride and self assertion completely blew open my understanding of Milton’s complex moral universe. We are so used to reading Paradise Lost through a lens of absolute humility that we miss the profound humanism lurking beneath the surface. Strier writes with a clarity that is hard to find in contemporary academic publishing, avoiding jargon in favor of precise, devastating arguments. It’s a book that clearly aims to change the direction of an entire field, not just add to the noise. Anyone serious about understanding the intellectual history of Europe needs to spend time with this text.
Profile Image for Diane N.
4 reviews1 follower
June 19, 2026
There is an intellectual rigor here that forces you to constantly look up your own assumptions about early modern humanism. Strier builds a compelling case that Renaissance thinkers were far more invested in celebrating human capacity than modern critics give them credit for. His critique of the way we overemphasize subversion and containment in Shakespearean drama is incredibly sharp and well-argued. Instead of seeing power everywhere, Strier allows us to see art, passion, and genuine philosophical debate. The book functions beautifully as both a historical critique and a masterclass in close reading. I spent hours wrestling with his footnotes because they contain an entirely separate, vibrant dialogue with contemporary scholarship. It is rare to find a book that manages to be this deeply polemical while remaining so utterly respectful of the primary sources.
Profile Image for Renee  Carpenter.
7 reviews
June 19, 2026
As someone who has always felt a bit alienated by the cold, structuralist approaches to early modern literature, Strier’s book feels like an absolute lifeline. He defends the idea that Renaissance writers were capable of genuine free thought, free expression, and unmitigated joy. His examination of the ways in which classical paganism was integrated into Christian frameworks reveals a culture that was remarkably flexible and daring. The section on Shakespearean comedy reminded me why I fell in love with this period in the first place, he sheer, unadulterated wit and the refusal to apologize for human frailty. Strier doesn't shy away from the difficult parts of his thesis, addressing counter arguments with a fairness that only a seasoned scholar could manage. It’s a beautifully constructed argument that values human experience over theoretical models.
Profile Image for Barbara L..
8 reviews1 follower
June 19, 2026
What makes this volume so compelling is how Strier uses the literature itself to challenge the heavy handed historical frameworks that have dominated academia. He proves that the writers of the Renaissance were often far ahead of the philosophers, constructing complex ethical systems through their poetry and plays. His reading of the skepticism in the late plays of Shakespeare is particularly brilliant, suggesting a profound comfort with uncertainty rather than a tragic despair. The book avoids the dry, sterile tone of much contemporary criticism, vibrating instead with a genuine passion for the subject matter. It’s a monumental achievement that balances sweeping historical claims with breathtakingly precise textual analysis. It completely changes the conversation about what early modern humanism actually looked like.
Profile Image for Nina E..
3 reviews
June 19, 2026
Strier provides a marvelous corrective to the dark, pessimistic view of the Renaissance that has become standard in modern classrooms. By pulling back the curtain on the era's capacity for celebration, self love, and intellectual freedom, he reshapes the narrative entirely. The way he tracks the evolution of moral philosophy through lyric poetry is nothing short of brilliant. I particularly enjoyed how he tackled the concept of repentance, showing that refusing to repent wasn't always a sin, but sometimes a radical act of integrity. The book demands a lot from its reader, requiring a familiarity with both theological disputes and literary aesthetics, but the payoff is immense. It leaves you with a profound respect for the sheer intellectual ambition of the early modern world.
Profile Image for Betty H.
7 reviews
June 19, 2026
This book is a masterclass in historical contextualization that refuses to let theory get in the way of the actual text. Strier’s close readings are incredibly nuanced, revealing layers of meaning that standard historicist approaches completely glaze over. His work on the philosophical underpinnings of Renaissance drama shows that these writers were active participants in shaping moral philosophy, not just passive mirrors of their society. I found myself reconsidering everything I thought I knew about the relationship between Protestantism and the arts. Strier's voice is authoritative yet deeply engaging, making complex academic debates feel urgent and alive. It is the kind of book that you immediately want to discuss with colleagues because every chapter sparks a new debate.
6 reviews1 follower
June 19, 2026
Strier’s argument for an 'unrepentant' Renaissance serves as a powerful reminder that history is never quite as settled as we think it is. He exposes the blind spots of modern critical movements that are too quick to project our own current anxieties onto the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries. His analysis of the era's attitude toward the physical body and worldly ambition is incredibly well-documented and persuasive. The book is especially strong when it deals with the subtle shifts in language that signify a changing worldview. It’s an intellectual workout in the best possible way, forcing you to slow down and re read passages to fully grasp the weight of the evidence. Strier has written a book that will undoubtedly influence the next generation of Renaissance scholarship.
55 reviews3 followers
October 19, 2020
'The Unrepentant Renaissance' is an exemplary work of literary criticism. Combining scholarly rigour and originality with subtle touches of humour and insightful readings of canonical and sometimes difficult texts, Richard Strier's book is a well-written and eminently readable account of the Renaissance that successfully opposes some predominant lines of scholarship but which depend on assumptions that sometimes go unchallenged. The book includes carefully arranged and extensive footnotes that deftly elucidate the main arguments and offer a valuable survey of current research on the field. For me, its highlights include its discussions of Petrarch, Thomas More, Milton, Shakespeare's sonnets and the Reformation. This is 21st century literary criticism at its best and will leave the reader feeling completely unrepentant.
Displaying 1 - 13 of 13 reviews