Mary Haywood is in the throes of a bitter custody battle with her soon-to-be ex, George. A controlling and vindictive man, he and his family sadly have the means to run her ragged in court. On top of that, Mary is feeling isolated and alone without any true friends of her own. Until she meets the gorgeous and easy to get along with Willa at a neighborhood playground with her own son in tow, that is. The first woman who Mary has felt she can actually be herself around, she’s quickly enamored.
Before Mary knows it, she and Willa have become closer than close. Until one alcohol-fueled evening when Mary divulges some of her most deeply held secrets. The next thing she knows, her supposed best friend stops answering her calls and vanishes into thin air. Days turn into weeks and weeks into months. Despite never giving up on there being some sort of explanation, it seems Willa has ghosted her just like some guy from Tinder.
After months of contentious and heated discussions, Mary believes that George just might have turned the corner and agreed to a custody arrangement that will work for them both. Now determined to start over, she chooses a small town north of the city where she can create a new, stable life for her and her son. While visiting the area prior to her move, however, Mary swears she sees Willa. A woman who swears her name is Annie.
Not twenty-four hours later, Mary discovers George dead of an apparent murder. As the police investigation starts in earnest, it’s clear that Mary is the one and only suspect. Forced to rely on the only person in town that she knows, she calls Willa for help. But the more that she learns, the more Mary starts to doubt the innocence of her former friend. Could she have had something to do with George’s death? And is Willa her confidante or her nemesis? The only hope Mary has of clearing her name is by finding out the truth—no matter the cost.
Holy cow! A startling tale of female friendship, the power of wealth, and the expectations men sometimes have of the women in their lives, Keep Your Friends Close not only delivered a killer storyline, but provided profound insights into societal norms. While not exactly a pulse-pounding ride from beginning to end, this divine slow burn thriller kept me on edge as secrets and lies were revealed through a perfectly timed plot. Far from the first novel by Konen that I’ve read, I was blown away yet again by her masterful skill at crafting characters and drama alike.
From the start, I was captivated by both Mary and Willa, but for very different reasons. I instantly connected with Mary as she desperately tried to get away from her overbearing husband, but it was Willa who had me entirely within her thrall. The more I read, the more I questioned what her motives really were. A delightful conundrum, her secrets drew me in deep as they were kept not just from Mary but us as well. Add in the scores of morally gray characters that ran the gamut from a manipulative con artist to a cutthroat soon-to-be ex, and I was utterly sold hook, line, and sinker.
As for the storyline, it was simply sublime. Addictive and unputdownable, the format itself only added to its perfection. Told in three parts that shifted from dual timelines to that as well as dual POVs, the story was recast more times than I could count as one stunning twist after another was delivered at the perfect time and the perfect place. But it was the plot charging drama and ever ratcheting tension that kept me flying through the pages. Quite frankly, it was such a masterful slow burn of a whodunnit that it’ll likely singe your fingertips.
The only piece that somewhat missed the mark was the requirement to suspend all disbelief. Well, that and the mildly over-the-top climax. Just the same, it barely got my notice as I inhaled chapter after chapter, each deliciously short and with many a cliffhanger. So I guess in the end these two were just teeny, tiny imperfections in the grand scheme of things.
All in all, I was completely blown away by Konen yet again. With a thoroughly Hitchcockian plot that took my expectations and threw them out the window, there wasn’t a chance of me guessing the ending. And surprise, surprise, but that finale was everything I wanted and more. Wholly bingeable as well as a thoroughly brilliant popcorn thriller, it was packed full of finger-tingling dread and foreboding. All I know is, this should be your next must read novel of suspense. Take it from me, but this was Konen at her best. Rating of 4.5 stars.
Thank you to Leah Konen and G.P. Putnam’s Sons for my complimentary copy. All opinions are my own.
PUB DAY: February 20, 2024
Scroll down for my potentially plot spoiling trigger list.
Trigger warning: divorce, custody dispute, con artist, loss of a spouse, mention of: gaslighting, infidelity