When you think legal thriller, John Grisham and Scott Turow, just pop into your mind. They have cornered the market in thrilling legal cases. James Barretto is angling to join this august twosome and for the most part succeeds, except for a couple of minor quibbles.
Barretto's hero is Jack Marino, once and esteemed member of the District Attorney's office until he is beaten severely after a victory. After the beating, Marino loses himself and is ultimately fired by his boss, who, now that Marino has not snapped back to his old self, is put out to pasture. Marino, who is married to Abby Thorn, the scion of a wealthy lawyer family is now just barely holding himself together, practicing corporate and civil law.
But fate has intervened. His old mentor suggests that he take up a murder case as a defense lawyer representing David Lamb, a man charged with murdering a Tommy Regan, a friend of his when they both worked at The Treasure Chest, a strip joint run by Nolan.
Marino takes the case to the consternation of his wife, who eventually leaves him, but finds immediately that the odds are stacked against him. Nolan, was granted immunity for his testimony. Marino's ex-colleague Brad Sears, who is the prosecutor, has disappeared evidence of a possible exculpatory witness and Judge Stone, the presiding judge in the case, hates Marino for past interactions. Moreover the jury foreman turns out to be the son of cop.
Aided by his brother Matt and an old girlfriend, Marino tries to put together a strong defense for Lamb, who is heading straight for the slaughter - as the prosecutor makes the case into a death penalty case.
Barretto ably puts on a thrilling trial. Marino is a master litigator and uses all of his abilities to defend Lamb.
But Barretto really stacks the story against him. As mentioned I had a couple of issues -- the character names --I mean seemed to telegraph things. Lamb, the poor person on trial for murder, Stone, the iron judge who will not bend one inch in the face of Marinos arguments, Sears the fiery prosecutor, Summer, Marino's beautiful ex girlfriend, and Thorn, Marino's thorny wife. I mean one name is coincidence but the rest -- Barretto should do a better job.
In addition, while no criminal defense lawyer, Stone's rulings from the bench seem unbelievably prejudicial to Lamb. Likely that's intentional, but none go the defendant's way.
Finally, without giving away anything, some of the story is not settled in the court room but somewhere else, where there is fighting, cops, and reporters. I guess that is the part that is the thriller part, but I find these kind of denouements a little overripe.
Nonetheless the action packed ending had several surprises and the story was fresh and convincing.
This is an excellent read, which I blew through in a nonce, and if you like Grisham and Turow, the masters of this genre, Barretto has the chops to join their company one day. He clearly knows the field.
Be on the lookout for his next book.