Light-hearted romances have an Achilles heel - perhaps many, but at least this one - their main character usually has to be kind of a goober. There's a reason, though.
The story has to have conflict. If absolutely nothing stands in the way of the hero and heroine falling in love, then it's boring and over quickly. But, the conflict can't be too big or too dramatic. If it's too serious, then it stops being a light-hearted romance and gets more into the drama category. So what we end up with is minor conflicts keeping the two main characters apart. Which usually means that at some point in the story, at least one of the main characters is acting like a goober. As in, this problem is not actually a big deal, but the character needs to REACT as though it's a big deal to keep the plot going forward instead of ending the story. As in, "I love to draw but I am shy about showing anyone my art, and you walked in and saw the sketchbook open on my bed and looked at it, and now I CAN NEVER TRUST YOU AGAIN!"
It's absurd, but I accept that it's absurd. Well-adjusted people don't really react like that to minor conflicts, but I accept it for the sake of the genre. I have read several of the books in the Christmas House series, enjoyed them, and didn't have anything negative to say about any of them, other than the characters occasionally act like goobers.
But this book. THIS book...
I just couldn't with Olivia. She drove me off-the-wall batty. I actually didn't even finish it, which is REALLY rare for me. I will struggle-read through a book I hate just so that it doesn't best me, but I called it quits at about 75% of the way through this one. The conflict until that point had been acceptable - he wanted something superficial but accidentally fell in love; she has trust issues, particularly with him, but has forgiven and is trying to move on. She was more of a goober than he was, but still within acceptable limits.
And then this doctor - this surgeon hero, who by her own standards is intelligent, charming, kind, generous, caring, successful, financially secure, and OH so handsome - this doctor literally saves a patient's life for the second time, and she is furious. Absolutely furious with him, calls it quits, tells him off, because he had the audacity to save the life of her mother's ex-husband who had been abusive. It was a betrayal of HER trust. The doctor should have let him DIE, obviously, even though the doctor didn't know his patient had any connection to the family. But even if he had known, he STILL should have let him die.
That kind of ridiculous selfishness rocketed straight out of "goober" range and launched itself into 4-letter-word territory. I was so appalled that I stopped reading right then and there and didn't look back.
I gave it 2 stars instead of 1 because I liked the main guy a lot and I thought he was kind of endearing.