READ THE COMPLETE REBELLION MANGA! With Madoka Kaname’s sacrifice, the hopeless cycle that once bound every magical girl to a terrible fate was broken at last. Or was it…? All does not seem right with the world, and as Homura pulls at the loose threads of the girls’ new reality, is it possible that an even darker destiny looms ahead?
A group collaboration consisting of director Akiyuki Shinbou, writer Gen Urobuchi, the original character designer Ume Aoki, and the producer Atsuhiro Iwakami.
Suffice it to say that Madoka Magica: The Rebellion Story is one of the most controversial and divisive anime films in existence, turning the angsty-but-uplifting series into an impenetrable movie with an ending that actively infuriated most Madoka fans. The plot, such as it is, involves Magical Girl Homura appearing in an idyllic version of the world where she's friends with Madoka and Co., which naturally leads Homura to become suspicious that something's going on. For anyone desiring a deep dive into the plot, characters and themes, I wrote a detailed analysis of Rebellion for another site. As before, the movie's impeccable style - the trademark Shinbou-Inu Curry animation, with its combination of collage-art Witch's labyrinths, surreal imagery and mind-blowing action scenes - aren't easily replicated in print, though Hanokage gives it an excellent try. Having smoothed out the earlier wrinkles in her art style, her action scenes pop (even Mami and Homura's Matrix-esque gunfight, which I didn't expect to transfer well from screen-to-page, is well-handled) and her character designs more in line with the series. Gen Urobuchi's overwrought, philosophically dense script is well-adapted, and might even benefit from this format as reading rather than watching makes it easier to chew over the twists, character monologues and plot developments. Even so, the manga's sour ending isn't any easier to swallow on page than screen, except in hopefully serving as the set up to future installments.
I LOVED this. I watched the movie in 2014 and I loved it! I was concerned that the fight scenes wouldn't transfer well from screen to paper but I was wrong. They were done seamlessly!
so homura akemi right. you go insane for losing her for good considering you’ve devoted decades to her so uhmmmm your despair is so strong you construct a false universe where all your friends r happy and together and your girl is there too. hwoever this universe collapses when you find out none of them are real and oh no! the evil alien in control of the exploitative wish system is using ur delusions as a trap to try and capture and experiment on your girl who is now God/concept! so what do u do?
you lure her in, turn into the DEVIL to her GOD and you RIP her from her divinity so she can be safely kept in a gilded cage of her hs years along w her friends, whose souls you’ve also trapped. then you watch her from afar and make sure she’s happy always even if she now views you as the enemy because you hate yourself and you love her. anyways you are peak lesbian homura akemi. where’s my sequel sequel movie
I enjoyed this book and the movie equally, finding the changes interesting in both, each edition gives a slightly different context to the story while keeping them close enough that it feels like the same story/universe. The only thing I didn't like about the book, and thought the movie did better, was that the art in the fight scenes was very cluttered and difficult to make out what was happening at times(this didnt take away from the story, just the visuals)
I stand by my opinions of this and the omnibus of the og series too. Honestly, I love this, but translating Madoka over to manga format is a bit of a task! The pacing is super quick, and honestly it omits or adds details.
But it's still good! I will always stand by Madoka <3
I really wish I liked this more because I adored the first part but unfortunately the ending just wasn’t it for me. I feel like it made sense but it wasn’t pulled off properly which kinda ruined the book for me as a result. But hey this is what fan fiction’s for, right?
Just watch the movie. The book has the same content, and honestly, it's not nearly as good. The story feels convoluted, and confusing, even though I watched the movie before I ever read this.