We return to the world of the Cascone sisters with this Deadtime Stories. One of them happens to be a ghostwriter for this week's Animorphs we'll get into when I review that, so I had to pop in one before we get there. This time the randomizer picked book 8, which had a reprint. I could not get acess to the OG print which on one hand is fine as this cover is way better. But the reprints make the font bigger for some reason so the books could appear long. That affected my reading, I'd get through it quicker if it was shorter which it is.
It was the basis for the first episode of the TV show but I'll talk about that when I re-watch it for a twitter thread at some point. Let's focus on the book. It's good! Easily the best one of these I've read since Appleheads. It d0esn't quite top that one but it comes close. Protagonist Amanda Peterson lives next door to cranky old Miss Barnes. There are various rumors about her, that she's a witch who does bad spells to people she doesn't like.
One day she and her friends discover a doll buried in Amanda's backyard, but they find out that it was on a part that once belonged to Barnes meaning it was buried on her property. Then they starts seeing messages saying "I want my baby back" and other odd things happen. Is Mrs. Barnes a witch that wants this doll back or is something else going on?
So I will say that for an adult, this one is fairly predictable. I've been reading too many of these, because early 0n I knew where it was going. I got some details wrong as more unfolded, but I was mostly on the money in a general way. It's not too bad but it isn't super surprising if you've read enough of these.
Writing wise it's on the basic end with some clunky short sentence stuff, but also some decent atmosphere and at least one vocab word, making them perfect for Animorphs. Amanda is fairly bland as a protagonist, we just jump right into without getting to know her super well. She is likable and you feel for her plight as it goes on though.
The parents are actually decent so they aren't in it much, and instead this friend Jarrad plays the annoying disbeliever role. The scares are tame here which can make it a bit slow at first, and it does feel a tad padded. That said, that mostly works given where this goes. Spoilers, there isn't exactly a big bad in this one.
I grew t0 like the dynamic between the friends. They prove to care about each other as they get all in this together but give each other shit, with some amusing exchanges. Jarrad gets some cool moments and even a nice bit to counteract the disbeliever stuff. There's a sister that isn't too annoying and is at least kinda important.
While it is a bit obvious, I did get into the mystery as things start to unfold. Where it goes works well and it gets decently emotional. The climax works and was pretty nice. It's no The Peephole or The Howler but it is up there as far as emotion goes is.
This is a lot less silly than the others I've read, it's more serious and emotion based. Not super scary although the backstory is a bit dark. I appreciate this, it seems like they were willing to get more serious and it does work well for me. It's not amazing and perfect but it is pretty solid.
Overall, it's a good one. After Cyber Scare was a bit lacking, this was a welcome surprise. If you want a good example of a solid ghost story with em0tion to it, this is a good one to check out. See ya Thursday for more of a Cascone's work.
Side note, Chucky Child's Play gets name dropped but they spell it "Chuckie", huh.