Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Queer Oz: L. Frank Baum's Trans Tales and Other Astounding Adventures in Sex and Gender

Rate this book
Regardless of his own sexual orientation, L. Frank Baum’s fictions revel in queer, trans, and other transgressive themes. Baum’s life in the late 1800s and early 1900s coincided with the rise of sexology in the Western world, as a cascade of studies heightened awareness of the complexity of human sexuality. His years of productivity also coincided with the rise of children’s literature as a unique field of artistic creation. Best known for his Oz series, Baum produced a staggering number of children’s and juvenile book series under male and female pseudonyms, including the Boy Fortune Hunters series, the Aunt Jane’s Nieces series, and the Mary Louise series, along with many miscellaneous tales for young readers.

Baum envisioned his fantasy works as progressive fictions, aspiring to create in the Oz series “a modernized fairy tale, in which the wonderment and joy are retained and the heartaches and nightmares are left out.” In line with these progressive aspirations, his works are often sexually progressive as well, with surprisingly queer and trans touches that reject the standard fairy-tale narrative path toward love and marriage. From Ozma of Oz’s backstory as a boy named Tip to the genderless character Chick the Cherub, from the homosocial adventures of his Boy Fortune Hunters to the determined rejection of romance for Aunt Jane’s Nieces, Queer L. Frank Baum's Trans Tales and Other Astounding Adventures in Sex and Gender shows how Baum utilized the freedoms of children’s literature, in its carnivalesque celebration of a world turned upside-down, to reimagine the meanings of gender and sexuality in early twentieth-century America and to re-envision them for the future.

234 pages, Paperback

Published April 21, 2023

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Tison Pugh

45 books13 followers
Tison Pugh is Associate Professor in the Department of English at the University of Central Florida. He is the author of Queering Medieval Genres and Sexuality and Its Queer Discontents in Middle English Literature and has published on children’s literature in such journals as Children’s Literature, The Lion and the Unicorn, and Marvels and Tales.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
3 (13%)
4 stars
5 (22%)
3 stars
3 (13%)
2 stars
6 (27%)
1 star
5 (22%)
Displaying 1 - 7 of 7 reviews
Profile Image for Manic Booksy Dreamgirl.
450 reviews22 followers
December 29, 2023
The truism "If you can't put it simply you don't know it well enough" comes screaming to mind attempting to read this.

Horrendously overwritten. Often when you actually parse through the sentances you find theres nothing of substance being said, just an assemblege of big words strung together for impact.

Really dissapointing.
Profile Image for Cera.
508 reviews3 followers
January 4, 2025
It's hard to take something so pretentious seriously when it uses the word gaydar four times in as many sentences just in the opening. This was a slog. And rather than use the source material as a lens of the times to genuinely support the premise, they twist every word and name that can be construed as gay currently into a modern interpretation of how those words and names might be perceived now.

Something as simple as Tippetarius, Tip for short, "connotes phallic
images". 💁‍♀️🤦‍♀️ To whom?

"Tip's adventures than to his sex as
the story unfolds until the surprising revelation that the witch Mombi trans- formed an infant girl into this young boy. Tip initially resists retransitioning from boy to girl- "Why, Im no Princess Ozma-I'm not a girl! ... I don't want to be a girl"--but she eventually accepts her female identity and regal duty to rule as a queen instead of as a king."

"Ozma's magical transition
demonstrates the ease with
which genders and sexes are
swapped in Oz."

"But she's a girl now, and the sweetest, loveliest girl in all the world. "Zeb is awed by her beauty: "Here [Zeb| found Dorothy seated
beside a young girl so marvelously beautiful that the boy stopped suddenly with a gasp of admiration". As discussed in the following chapter, Baum frequently refrains from portraying heteroerotic attraction and so this moment is no-
table not merely for Zeb's admiration of Ozma's beauty but for his utter embrace of her trans identity. Apparently pansexual in his orientation. male identity and regal duty to rule as a queen instead of as a king."

Entirely missing the very fact, Ozma is being "embraced" as her original gender, not her transgender identity. Not to mention the "ease" with which genders are swapped in Ozma and Tip's case, the author acknowledges and then completely ignores both instances of gender swapping being entirely nonconsensual!

And don't get me started on every stereotype the author used to reframe L Frank Baum as anything other than how he presented himself. In 2023 I didn't know interest in musical theater and being an author of a book on window dressings was something we used to deduce sexual orientation, and certainly not in something published as and by someone so "educated".
Profile Image for Bobby Fort.
6 reviews1 follower
July 24, 2025
Tison Pugh’s Queer Oz is an ambitious academic work that analyzes the Oz books—and other writings by L. Frank Baum—through a queer theoretical lens. Pugh’s central argument is that Baum’s fantastical worlds contain underlying themes of gender fluidity, queer desire, and nontraditional relationships, even if these elements aren’t overtly acknowledged in the text or authorial intent.

But this is also where the book invites scrutiny. For readers skeptical of critical readings that seem to project contemporary identities and ideologies onto historical works, Queer Oz may feel like it stretches the source material. Characters like Tip/Ozma, or the same-sex friendships of Scarecrow and Tin Man, are reinterpreted in ways that arguably say more about modern frameworks than about Baum’s actual storytelling intent.

That’s not to say Pugh is unaware of this. He does take care to position his arguments within the context of Baum’s time, avoiding direct claims that Baum was intentionally writing “queer narratives.” Still, the interpretive leaps can sometimes feel like they rely heavily on inference, metaphor, and symbolic association rather than textual evidence. If you come to the book wondering whether this is an exercise in “seeing what you want to see,” there will be moments where that skepticism feels warranted.

That said, for readers interested in how literature can be reexamined through different cultural lenses, or how queerness can be traced even in spaces where it was historically unspoken, Queer Oz offers thoughtful—if sometimes speculative—analysis. Just be prepared for a level of interpretation that may feel more reflective of the critic than the creator.
Profile Image for Bonsai.
116 reviews
July 14, 2024
2.75, rounded up. What an absolute SLOG. Usually I love reading criticism of classic children's literature. Ditto queer studies, so this seemed like a perfect mashup. Nope.

The writing itself is borderline indecipherable at times. Over and over I had to pause to mentally translate Scholarly English into Plain English — academic writing at its most irritating.

Sure, a book like this, published by a university press, is bound to include some specialized jargon...and that's all the more reason not to throw in unnecessary show-off words like adumbrate, cathexis, and contumely.

And the sentence structure — good lord. If a person with a degree in linguistics who reads 3-5 books a week and has taken a master's level course in children's lit can't make it from one end of a sentence to the other without doubling back in confusion, something's outta whack.

In short, this author took a subject I was genuinely interested in and excited to explore and turned it into an exercise in pure frustration. A bummer, because I was also intrigued by Pugh's books on Disney fairy tales and TV sitcoms. But after wrestling my way through Queer Oz, I'm not sure I want to repeat the experience.

Unsolicited advice to Tison Pugh: For the love of Pete, don't try to sound impressive at the expense of BASIC COMPREHENSION.
750 reviews1 follower
September 26, 2024
Wanted to like this, hated the big jargon heavy academic language
1 review1 follower
February 2, 2024
Thorough and well written. The academic style writing can be a but dense at times, but if you don't mind having your vocabulary skills tested it's worth it.
55 reviews
May 21, 2026
Queer Oz: L. Frank Baum's Trans Tales and Other Astounding Adventures in Sex and Gender is possibly the worst piece of academia I have ever read in my life, and I mean that without exaggerating at all.

The best part of this book was the introduction, where several interesting ideas were acknowledged, vaguely. He made some interesting points about Baum's penchant for pun names. Unlike others I did not find this book to contain dense prose, just insubstantial arguments.

I am confused why Pugh felt the need to spend large amounts of this book decrying Baum's views on race. Yes they were abysmal, but Pugh never connects his analyses on racialized depictions to what he is observing about Baum's queer depictions. Instead, it's almost as if a modern liberal worldview in all things is assumed on Baum's part because of the queer reading Pugh's doing, and he is attempting to apologize for a not-liberal presentation of race. It's irrelevant and sloppy.

A bigger issue is the ahistorical approach Pugh takes. Despite acknowledging in his introduction that some of his timeline does not map out correctly, he continues with little proof. It seems he has read a good many primary sources, but contextualized none of the contents therein in the time and place they were written. For example, Pugh writes, "Nerle cries in anticipation, 'Soon shall I be content, for these darts will doubtless pierce every part of my body' (Yew, ch. 10), the queer imagery of St. Sebastian’s martyrdom is recalled, in which, in most images, a handsome, near-naked man is penetrated by a hail of arrows." (Pugh 87). In this given segment he does not connect his quote to the analyses at all. Does every single instance of being shot with arrows in art/literature evoke St. Sebastian? That seems like a tall order. No other reason is suggested connecting the two, however, and no more is said on the subject. Pugh does not answer any of the following: why the imagery might be there, other reasons for the connection, why Baum would code Nerle as queer, Baum's potential familiarity with depictions of St. Sebastian in art, if historically he had ever seen one of these paintings, or even if Baum was Christian (the answer to the final being no).

Pugh also frequently muses on Baum's sexuality, due to the prominence of queer subtext in his work. While I do not think you can figure out someone's sexuality based on the fiction they write, he does offer some evidence. Said evidence has to do with Baum's love of theater and previous jobs he worked such as window dressing. This is little more than an application of textbook gay stereotypes to a deceased person. Ones occupation is not sufficient evidence for their sexuality, and that should be unacceptable in an academic text.

I could go on and on--his baseless assumption that ki-ki relates to queer slang despite his own misreading of its pronunciation, his assumption that cannibalism is automatically queer coded, etc, but this review is already long enough.

The last part I will dwell on, however, is the section that upset me the most: chapter 7, which focuses on the Aunt Jane's Nieces series. Coming off the heels of chapter 6 which looked at Baum's Boy Fortune Hunters series, chapter 7 looks at his series written for young women from the same time. Pugh admittedly does contextualize the Boy Fortune Hunters series within the genre of pulp boy adventurer novels that were standard fare for boys at the turn of the century. However, he places Aunt Jane's Nieces alongside fairy tales in terms of genre. He completely ignores the popular books aimed at women of the day, many of which featured young heroines finding their places in the world and family structure. While not as action-oriented as boy adventurer stories, logically Aunt Jane's Nieces peers in the literary world should be Anne of Green Gables, A Little Princess, the Secret Garden, Little Women, and more. To ignore genre, era, and intended audience, and analyze a story for girls alongside fairy tales is not only ahistorical, it is (unconsciously) misogynistic. There was a literary tradition for young women alive and well at the time Baum wrote his series, and it was a popular form he intended to cash in on. It would be one thing if Baum offered women fairy tales where he offered boys adventure; instead he offered them both fairy tales under his own name and used pseudonyms specifically to market his work to gendered demographics and genres. Women read more than fairy tales, and if Pugh did a modicum of research he would contextualize these novels correctly. Following that, I feel that Pugh's generic ignorance leads him to flawed analysis of the books' contents.

My apologies for being harsh, but do not read this book. It is poorly written, devoid of factual content, unaware of its own misogynistic biases, and abysmally researched. I have no idea how this was published. As a subject, academia on ever evolving queer depictions in Oz over the last 125 years would be a fascinating, and I anxiously await more writing on this topic from other authors.
Displaying 1 - 7 of 7 reviews