Marylu Tyndall is certainly an incredibly gifted writer and storyteller! My husband and I eagerly looked forward to reading a little more of this book every evening before bed!
The characters really came to life, especially that of Mr. Heaton. I loved how vulnerable he was on the inside, how brave and strong he was on the outside, and how he learned to surrender his heart & life to Jesus!
What I didn’t like about this story, however, was Cassandra’s character that seemed repetitive of other female characters in Tyndall’s novels: proud, stubborn, headstrong, hypocritical and foolish! More than this, I cringed each time reference was made to God being in control of everything that ever happens here. God gave dominion and authority over the affairs of the earth to mankind. It isn’t God’s will for loving parents to die in a fire, or for innocent children to be orphaned, etc. Not everything that happens on the earth is God’s will- but this is the false impression Tyndall drives throughout many of her books. People often make rotten choices that are followed by unpleasant consequences- and that isn’t God’s fault. If we love God, and are called according to His purpose, whatever happens He can work out for our good somehow according to Romans 8:28 of course- but the characters in Tyndall’s book weren’t Christians during most of the book. On one hand they resented, blamed and resisted God because they believed the very doctrine Tyndall continually crams down the reader’s throat throughout the book: that for some mysterious purpose unknown to us, God just “allows” devastating circumstances to happen in our lives. 😬 Never does she acknowledge the responsibility to appropriate the promises of God by faith 👉regarding the authority of the believer👈 …or the fact that although God “is able to do exceeding abundantly above all that we ask or think”, it is “according to the power that worketh in us.”
Ephesians 3:20 KJV
This was still a page turning love story, and the history was vivid- but the behavior of Cassandra, especially in the last few chapters was irritating, unrealistic and stupid! If she would’ve conducted herself more maturely, the whole story could’ve had Cassandra as a shining example worth following instead of a predictable, self centered, impulsive brat who acts out of her immediate emotions like a number of other annoying females in Tyndale’s novels, and yet still gets to miraculously live happily ever after. Tyndall does a fantastic job of illustrating the perfect picture of masculinity in her male figures, but needs to work on creating a female character that depicts Godly femininity, discretion and restraint. The love story between Luke & Cassandra would’ve contained so much more depth if Cassie’s character had been more respectful, patient and discreet.
Sigh. Ultimately, my husband and I still couldn’t hardly put the book down. Tyndale has a gift. I just hope she can get her theology straightened out, and can come up with a more exemplary female character by the time I try reading another one of her stories! 🙄