“Dream Awake” by Jane C R Reid engages with the fertile crossroads of romance and fantasy, inviting readers into a liminal world where dream and waking life blur and the promise of transformation hangs tantalizingly in the air. Serafim, a young woman caught between emotional abandonment in the waking world and the seductive pull of Bridgton Valley, a dreamlike, fantastical realm that offers escape. As romance, rivalry, and longing intertwine, the novel traces her attempts to make sense of love and identity when reality itself feels negotiable. Reid leans into mythic potential even as the narrative remains anchored in very human heartbreak and rivalry.
Reid’s prose has an assured, literate cadence that often feels more attentive to emotional nuance than many in the genre achieve, and her atmospheric descriptions of the fantastical world hint at a richness that could be the novel’s greatest inheritance. Yet the book’s ambitions are undercut by protagonists who lack compelling interior force. Serafim, the ostensible main character, drifts through events rather than shaping them. Her passivity blunts the stakes of her journey, leaving the book’s psychological shifts oddly weightless. Likewise, Isolde, drawn as an antagonist, is sketched with such unmodulated cruelty that her motivations feel implausible even within the story’s heightened reality. Even her internal dialogue is entirely sociopathic, a caricature of the “evil sister” trope.
The romantic dynamics show a similar impatience. Relationships veer so swiftly between obsession and abandonment that it’s hard to track the emotional logic. The fantastic setting of Bridgton Valley, so promising in Reid’s early pages, remains curiously peripheral, more a backdrop than a meaningful part of the narrative. The ending tries to reconcile these disparate elements, but it didn’t work for me. It felt too convenient and didactical.
For readers who savor lyrical writing and dreamlike conceits, “Dream Awake” offers plenty to enjoy. Those seeking fully embodied characters and narrative gravity might go unfulfilled. Ultimately, this is an accomplished debut with clear strengths and limitations, a novel whose aesthetic intrigue doesn’t quite cohere with its character work.